Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Missouri

Cake and cookie shops

You don't see a reason to choose between a cake and a cookie when you can have both.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 1
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 2
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 3
View all

Small bakery with warm, cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. Fresh cookies and pastries bake throughout the day, filling the air with rich, inviting scents. Known for beautiful, flavorful cookies that combine soft texture with perfect bake.

Cookie cake stands out with a rich, sweet flavor that captivates. A variety of decorated sugar cookies like cinnamon chai and sugar cookie with pumpkin buttercream offer diverse tastes and textures.

Cookies here combine beautiful decoration with superb taste. Custom designs match exact requests without sacrificing flavor, and treats like chocolate chip and sugar cookies consistently impress.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best chocolate chip cookie I've ever had."

"I tried the s'mores heart cake and it stole my heart."

"These sugar cookies are adorable and delicious."

Good to know

1

Vanilla Sugar offers a happy hour deal on cookies.

2

The bakery bakes cookies and pastries in smaller increments throughout the day to keep everything fresh.

3

This practice ensures they donโ€™t run out of popular items shortly after opening.

02
Cake House Design image 1

Bakery offers a festive atmosphere with beautiful decorations and a welcoming vibe. Freshly baked aromas fill the space, creating a cozy feeling. A dessert bar showcases a variety of sweet treats, including standout cupcakes, cake pops, and custom cakes with detailed designs.

Cakes come with impressive presentation and consistently high quality. Custom designs include cookie dough filled vanilla cakes and themed creations like Strawberry Mini Mouse cakes.

Chocolate Kona coffee cookies offer a fudgy texture and balanced sweetness. The cookie cake looks visually stunning and tastes delicious, with frosting that pairs well with the cookies.

People are saying

"This bakery has the most creative and best tasting goodies."

"Their cakes are beautiful and taste amazing."

"I'm still salivating over the salted caramel cake."

Good to know

1

The Bake House handles events from weddings to birthday cakes and grazing tables.

2

They provide desserts for special occasions like welcome parties.

3

Cake House Design offers cake slices and entire cakes for purchase.

03
Pint Size Bakery & Coffee image 1

Bright space filled with beautiful plants and cute wallpaper creates a pleasant vibe. Bakery offers local ingredients and highly praised pastries like salted caramel croissants and oatmeal cream pies. Strictly take-out with minimal seating, it draws lines for specialty items on weekends.

Custom cakes come with vintage icing and script options and often receive rave reviews for taste and presentation. Birthday and wedding cakes are delicious and well priced, with German chocolate cake noted as a standout.

Oatmeal cookie sandwiches stand out with their chewy texture and creamy filling, making them a popular choice for special occasions. Chocolate chunk cookies offer a phenomenal taste and a perfect bite balance between chew and firmness.

People are saying

"I found the scones to be buttery, flaky, and tender."

"My wedding cake was perfect and well done."

"You have to try their oatmeal cookie sandwiches; they're a true stunner."

Good to know

1

Freshly baked salted caramel croissants are available every Saturday at 9:30 AM.

2

Expect a long line for salted caramel croissants on Saturdays.

3

Only two croissants are given per party on Saturdays.

04
The Cakery image 1

Quaint shop with spotless design and a delicious aroma fills the air. Energy feels warm and inviting, suited for special occasions like weddings. Offers customizable cakes and convenient rentals, standing out for elegant, flavorful creations.

Wedding cakes feature stunning designs that bring Pinterest boards to life and offer flexible communication for last-minute changes. Cakes for birthdays and baptisms come out delicious and beautifully crafted.

Lavender cookie stands out as a unique option. Cookies and cookie cakes come in many varieties and are available for walk-in purchase or special orders.

People are saying

"This cake is incredibly moist and flavorful."

"I highly recommend their bakery for your wedding cake."

"I found the cookie cake to be amazing."

Good to know

1

You can order and pay online to see all the varieties and decorations.

2

The curbside pickup was fast.

3

They offer many basic and premium options for fillings, frostings, and cake flavors.

05
Sugaree Baking Company image 1

Quaint bakery with a friendly atmosphere and holiday decorations that add charm. Offers a large variety of baked goods including exceptional cinnamon rolls and pies. Known for delicious cakes and savory quiches, attracting a loyal local crowd.

Cakes come in amazing flavors like 3 chocolate and carrot, with beautiful decorating and thick layers of frosting and filling. Cheesecakes and cookies are also available alongside the cakes.

Salted chocolate chunk cookies stand out with perfect texture and rich flavor. A variety of cookies like sugar cookies and toffee blondies offer delightful options, often presented on cookie platters.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and delicious."

"I thought their pies were the best I had ever tasted."

"I thought the salted chocolate chunk cookies were the best."

Good to know

1

Sugaree Baking Company is open on Sundays.

2

Pick up orders are easy and convenient.

3

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

06
Bebe's Bake ShoppePERMANENTLY CLOSED image 1

Bright, clean space with affordable prices and frequent menu changes offers about a dozen cookie flavors. Atmosphere feels welcoming with a focus on creative baked goods like the gooey butter cookie. Shop maintains a very clean environment and attracts those seeking tasty, varied treats.

Soft and fluffy caramel cake stands out with a rich texture. Cupcakes, cookies, and brownies also offer a variety of sweet options, though the caramel topping leans on the sweeter side.

Gooey butter cookie stands out as a phenomenal treat. Red Velvet and butter cookies offer beautiful, flavorful options with excellent quality.

People are saying

"The caramel cake here is especially soft and fluffy."

"I found the gooey butter cookie delicious and perfect."

"The cookies from this bakery are delicious."

Good to know

1

Bebeโ€™s Bake Shoppe offered a rotating selection of baked goods each week.

2

Prices for baked goods were reasonable and affordable.

3

The shop featured around 12 different cookie flavors.

07
Harter Bakery image 1

Bakery offers homemade taste with reasonably priced cakes and pastries. Atmosphere carries a heavenly smell that draws in regulars and families. Known for best donuts and richly filled custard pastries, it suits special occasions and everyday treats alike.

Cakes here have a rich, delicious taste that guests often rave about. Custom orders include themed designs like jungle animals, and options like the Strawberry Supreme stand out.

Cookies come in cute and delicious varieties with reasonable prices around $2 each. They are often described as addictive and one of a kind.

People are saying

"The cake here tastes amazing and is worth the price."

"These cookies are so cute and delicious!"

"I found the donuts here to be great."

Good to know

1

Harter Bakery offers custom cakes with personalized messages at no extra charge.

2

Prices are very reasonable for homemade baked goods.

3

They provide premade cake designs that are popular for special occasions.

08
Helfer's Pastries image 1

Traditional bakery counter and organized display case create a classic bakery atmosphere with a warm, welcoming vibe. The place draws a steady crowd looking for high-quality cakes and pastries, especially known for its gooey butter cake and custom birthday cakes.

Gooey butter cake stands out as a favorite, known for its rich and delicious flavor. Wedding cakes arrive beautiful and fresh, with options like butter cream white cake and coconut cake also highly praised.

Cookies offer a chewy and crunchy texture thanks to cornflakes in the grandma cookies. Decorated sugar cookies and sprinkles butter cookies are popular, with iced and frosted cookies also tasting great.

People are saying

"I loved the gooey butter cake and the deep crumb coffee cake."

"Their iced cookies were extremely good and a childhood favorite."

"This bakery made my custom cake come to life and it tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

Credit card payments are accepted, but there may be surcharges.

2

Parking is available, including handicap spots.

3

Fresh pastries are best in the morning; arrive early for the best selection.

09
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Freshly baked cookies fill the air with a heavenly aroma that welcomes everyone inside. Bright, well-lit and fashionable space feels warm and inviting, often bustling with people enjoying a variety of weekly cookie flavors. Cleanliness and a trendy vibe set this cookie shop apart from others.

Tree leches cake stands out with its rich flavor. Cookies have creative names like Beetlejuice cake and pink sugar. Cakes and cheesecakes offer solid options but vary in appeal.

Cookies come fully cooked and taste consistently delicious. The lemon cheesecake cookie stands out as a distinctive flavor. Ordering is fast and the cookies maintain a high quality every time.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be always delicious."

"It's so kid friendly; my kids love the cookies here."

"I found the cakes and cookies here to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Crumbl offers a new variety of cookies each week.

2

The store is always clean and well-lit.

3

Parking is readily available at this location.

10
Federhofer's Bakery image 1

Old school bakery with traditional atmosphere and heavenly smells fills the space. Display cases show rows of tempting treats like cookies, cakes, and pastries. Known for butter crรจme frosting cakes and fresh baked goodies, it feels like stepping back in time.

Cakes come with butter crรจme frosting and custom decorations that stand out. The gooey butter cake and German Chocolate Cake are consistently delicious and popular for birthdays and celebrations.

Decorated cookies serve as a family tradition for holidays and special occasions. Iced cookies and birthday cake flavors consistently please, while butter cookies bring a nostalgic touch from childhood.

People are saying

"Their cookies and petit fours are delicious."

"I ordered a custom cake that was moist, flavorful, and not overly sweet."

"These decorated cookies are a family tradition for holidays and special occasions."

Good to know

1

Expect quick service even during busy hours.

2

The bakery often sells out of popular items, especially before holidays.

3

Prices are very fair for fresh baked goods.

11
Lydia's image 1
Bakery

Bright, open bakery with an open garage door wall and whimsical decor creates a comfortable, fun atmosphere. Live music and entertainment add energy, while seating areas include a small patio and spots for pets. Desserts and cocktails draw a diverse crowd seeking a unique sweet and drink experience.

Cakes here are stunning and delicious with flawless decoration. They come out better than example photos and offer rich, moist flavors that impress guests consistently.

Custom sugar cookies fit themed events like baby showers. A great variety of cookies and other baked goods come in many flavors.

People are saying

"The coffee here has such a cute, inviting vibe."

"This cake was decorated flawlessly and tasted amazing."

"The cookies here are thoughtfully crafted and delicious."

Good to know

1

High tea at Lydia's requires reservations.

2

Lydia's hosts monthly events including high tea.

3

Lydia's was open late, which was a real bonus.

12
Sweet Spot Cake Shoppe image 1

Old school bakery style fills the space with a sweet aroma of cakes and cookies. Atmosphere feels charming and inviting, with beautifully decorated cakes that draw attention. Customers come for customized cakes that match exact themes and tastes, often praising the quality and design.

Custom cakes come with precise designs and flavors tailored to preferences. Gooey Butter Cake and classic vanilla and chocolate options hold up well even after freezing, maintaining amazing flavor and consistency.

Soft and chewy cookie cakes stand out, especially for birthdays. Cookies look beautiful and taste good, though some icing shows minor flaws. Holiday cookies arrive fresh but may be made in advance.

People are saying

"The custom cakes here are always amazing and beautifully designed."

"These cupcakes are amazing and beautiful."

"The cakes and cookies here are beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers customized cakes for various occasions.

2

Prices are affordable compared to other bakeries in the area.

3

The ordering process for wedding cakes is easy and seamless.

13
Missouri Baking Co image 1

Bakery with a nostalgic yesteryear feel and warm, inviting atmosphere where customers often know each other by first names. It offers authentic Italian pastries and cookies with a reputation for outstanding baked sweets. Cash-only policy adds to its old-school charm.

Chocolate cake stands out with its rich flavor. Butter cake and gooey butter cake offer superb texture and taste. Custard filled cakes add variety for events.

Authentic Italian cookies stand out here, especially amaretto cookies and cannolis. Butter cake and a variety of cookies also show strong quality.

People are saying

"The bakery staff were so friendly and helpful."

"I thought the Italian cookies tasted like a hug from Nonna."

"I thought their chocolate cake was the best in town."

Good to know

1

They only accept cash, and debit transactions cost an additional $1.50 with exact change required.

2

The bakery has a few parking spots, which is a luxury for businesses on the Hill.

3

There is no seating inside, so plan to take your treats to go.

14
Arber Cafe image 1
Restaurant

Small corner cafe with tall ceilings and beautiful plants creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere that feels like a peaceful escape. Space is clean and thoughtfully arranged, perfect for relaxing or working. Music and TV add to the laid-back vibe, attracting a mix of authentic, friendly people.

Complimentary slices of cake often accompany visits, showing a kind gesture from the staff. The strawberry European Roll Cake features a light texture with a balanced mix of dough, strawberries, and whipped cream.

Freshly made cookies come free at the start of meals. The Albanian kiss is a cookie sandwich with chocolate and coconut. Staff sometimes offer Albanian cookies as a treat.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and thoughtfully prepared."

"They brought us a complimentary slice of delicious cake."

"This cookie is delicious and filling."

Good to know

1

Expect an hour wait for Saturday brunch due to high demand.

2

The prices are reasonable, with a good lunch costing under $10.

3

The menu features a variety of Albanian and Italian dishes.

15
Vitale's Bakery image 1

Enormous bakery with authentic Italian charm and a warm, cozy atmosphere that invites lingering. Offers a huge selection of baked goods including notable Italian breads and desserts. Smells evoke nostalgia and the vibe feels like stepping into an old-school Italian bakery.

Cakes here come in extremely rich varieties like German chocolate, fit for a king, alongside fluffy and light options such as tiramisu. They offer fruitier choices that balance richness, with clear guidance on storage and serving.

Cookies melt in your mouth and come in great variety alongside pastries and bread. Staff offer warm greetings and the cookies consistently satisfy without complaints.

People are saying

"This Italian bakery has classic, delicious pastries and melt-in-your-mouth cookies."

"I loved the variety of Italian cookies here."

"This tiramisu cake is so fluffy and light."

Good to know

1

A pound of cookies costs $18.

2

A box of cookies is $18.

3

A cannoli costs almost $4.

16
Rosciglione Bakery image 1

Small family-owned bakery with Italian heritage and generations of tradition offers a huge selection of baked goods including made-to-order cream cannolis. Atmosphere feels like a hidden gem with a local, authentic vibe. Customers find cakes and pastries moist and flavorful, with some items selling out early.

Cakes come with beautiful decorations and make a spectacular presentation. Options include carrot cake, cannoli cream cake, and fudge cake with good flavor.

Assorted cookies come in large quantities, often sold by the pound. Presentation includes small cakes alongside cookies. Some batches show signs of being stale.

People are saying

"The cannoli here are made to order and look magnificent."

"The cake here looked amazing and tasted even better."

"The cakes and cookies here are the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Items tend to sell out early, so arrive early to avoid disappointment.

2

The bakery offers a huge selection of Italian baked goods.

3

Rosciglione Bakery is family-owned for more than 5 generations.

17
Crave Cookies image 1
Cookie shop

Open workspace reveals cookie-making process in a bright, clean, and modern setting. Energy feels cheerful with staff who clearly enjoy their work. Massive, gourmet cookies change weekly, offering a unique variety that stands out from typical cookie shops.

Cookie cakes stand out here, including a giant cookie cake option. Birthday cakes come in cookie form, alongside other treats like flavored sodas and loaded drinks.

Cookies come in giant size and are made fresh every day. The chocolate chip cookies stand out for their quality and taste.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were fantastic and amazing."

"These chocolate chip cookies are big, moist, and flavorful."

"I found the cookies fantastic and perfect for sharing."

Good to know

1

Crave Cookies offers a rotating menu with new flavors introduced weekly.

2

The price is $18 for four large cookies, which is a good deal for their size.

3

They have a special 'semi-sweet day' event every Thursday.

18
801 Chophouse image 1
Fine dining restaurant

Rich wood decor and warm, dim lighting create an atmosphere reminiscent of a 1920s supper club. The space feels elegant and classic, with cozy booths offering privacy amid generally lively noise levels. Steaks and cocktails stand out as key features in a setting that balances tradition with a refined vibe.

Carrot cake stands out with its rich flavor and moist texture. Desserts consistently impress with their excellent quality.

Warm brown butter chocolate chip cookies come with just the right amount of salt. They serve as a delightful finish to the meal and stand out as a highly recommended dessert.

People are saying

"The Wagyu here is cooked to perfection, the best I've ever had."

"The steaks here are cooked to perfection and extremely flavorful."

"These chocolate chip cookies are the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for private events and large parties.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

During Clayton Restaurant Week, special menus are available for a limited time.

19
Creative Sweet Treats image 1

Bakery offers fresh pastries and high-quality cakes that often become the centerpiece of celebrations. Ordering online is straightforward, with beautiful packaging enhancing the experience. Some challenges with shipping and delivery timing occur, but the bakery maintains a personal, family-owned feel that adds value.

Cakes come in varied flavors like coconut, pineapple upside down, and raspberry chocolate. Orders arrive fresh and on time, with options for cold packs and next day shipping to keep them perfect.

Chocolate chip and red velvet cookies come perfectly baked with crispy edges and soft, chewy centers. Ordering online is easy, and cookies arrive fresh and beautifully packaged.

People are saying

"These cupcakes were a hit; everyone loved them."

"This cake was unbelievably tasty and the star of the party."

"I've never had a chocolate chip cookie this good."

Good to know

1

Expect potential delays if ordering close to holidays due to shipping issues.

2

The bakery's website does not clearly indicate holiday closures.

3

Shipping can take longer than expected, especially during peak times.

Discover more

Missouri

Area guide
Loading Map...