Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Grilled cheese spots in New Jersey

A simple, toasted grilled cheese sandwich served in a familiar American diner style.

Based on 813 Opinions
+810
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Anderson Market image 1
Anderson Market image 2
Anderson Market image 3
View all

Upscale market space blends bright lighting with a calm, airy atmosphere and friendly vendors. It hosts a vibrant food hall vibe featuring local gourmet options and an art gallery. Acoustic music and a mix of indoor and outdoor areas create a welcoming spot for gathering or relaxing.

Grilled cheese sandwiches stand out with high quality sourdough bread and rich flavors like the Uncle Nino and Not So Plain Jaine. Nashville hot chicken offers a balanced heat level paired with maple syrup for a unique taste.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come on sourdough bread with options like the Uncle Nino and Not So Plain Jaine. They taste high quality and delicious but feel more like a snack than a full sandwich.

People are saying

"This grocery store has a warm, welcoming atmosphere with bright lighting."

"The market's thoughtful assortment of products feels like a community spot."

"The American Food, especially the grilled cheese, is delicious."

Good to know

1

Anderson Market offers a variety of local food vendors and specialty shops under one roof.

2

There is a good amount of seating available for those wanting to work or relax.

3

The butcher counter has a great selection and is open on Sundays.

02
Damasco Cafe image 1

Space features floral interior design and vintage-inspired decor that evoke a Mediterranean garden. Atmosphere stays warm and inviting with calming music and lighting, creating a cozy refuge. Families frequent the cafe for its dedicated kids play area with sensory boards and pretend play stations.

Grilled cheese stands out with options like turkey bacon, pastrami, and zaatar. The sandwiches are very good and often paired with ice cream.

Grilled cheese comes with turkey bacon, pastrami, or zaatar, offering a variety of flavors. The grilled cheese is consistently very good and pairs well with other menu items.

People are saying

"The staff at this cafe are so welcoming and attentive."

"The Syrian ice cream here is excellent and genuinely different."

"I loved the grilled cheese with pastrami; it was perfectly melted and tasty."

Good to know

1

Damasco Cafe hosts private events like birthday parties and bridal showers.

2

Live music featuring classic Oud happens every Friday evening.

3

The cafe is kid-friendly with a play corner for children.

03
Turquoise Bakery & Cafe image 1

Bright, clean space with modern decor and plenty of windows creates an inviting atmosphere. Energy stays calm and serene, though seating can feel a bit cold and less cozy. Crowd tends to be steady, drawn by homemade baked goods and healthy lunch options.

Grilled cheese stands out as a highlight, described as heaven. The menu includes hearty options like the Cobb Salad and banana pudding, alongside specials such as tomato soup and caprese pesto sandwiches.

Grilled cheese stands out as a heavenly choice here, often paired with tomato soup for a classic combo. It appears alongside other sandwiches like the caprese pesto, showing up regularly on orders.

People are saying

"The banana bread latte was the best I ever tasted."

"I thought the American food here was delicious and tasty."

"I thought the grilled cheese was delicious and tasty."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

2

Parking can be busy, so plan to arrive early.

3

The bakery items are made fresh in-house daily.

04
Next Door Provisions image 1

Cozy restaurant filled with abundant greenery and fresh decor creates a warm, homey atmosphere. Bright, sunlit space offers a serene vibe with plants and comics enhancing the inviting setting. Guests enjoy a relaxed experience with free parking and a welcoming, comfortable environment.

Patty melt and brisket mafaldine stand out as key dishes. Biscuits and gravy also feature prominently on the menu.

Grilled cheese stands out with first-rate quality and a satisfying, rich flavor. It pairs well alongside other hearty mains like spicy chicken ramen and biscuits & gravy.

People are saying

"This Filipino brunch is creative, beautifully presented, and absolutely delicious."

"The American Food here is creative and exploding with flavor."

"I found the grilled cheese here to be delicious and creative."

Good to know

1

Parking is available onsite for guests.

2

The restaurant has a BYOB policy, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

3

The Kamayan Dinner event offers a unique dining experience.

05
Van Hook Cheese & Grocery image 1

Cheese shop offers a rotating selection of artisan cheeses and curated pantry goods including hot sauces, snacks, and condiments. Beautifully arranged displays create an inviting atmosphere for exploring unique grilled cheese sandwiches and assembling charcuterie boards. The space attracts those seeking quality local products and thoughtful gift options.

Grilled cheese sandwiches stand out with fabulous bread, cheese, and toppings. They take some time to prepare but deliver an excellent, delicious experience worth the wait.

French Onion grilled cheese stands out with its rich flavor. Bread, cheese, and toppings combine for fabulous grilled cheese sandwiches that often require a short wait but deliver excellent taste.

People are saying

"I ordered a beautiful charcuterie platter that was the biggest hit at my event."

"I thought their grilled cheese was the best I have ever had."

"I thought the grilled cheese sandwiches were the best in the USA."

Good to know

1

Sandwiches cost between $7 and $9 and are big and filling.

2

The selection of cheeses rotates frequently, providing new options each visit.

3

They offer gluten-free crackers and a variety of jams.

06
White Owl Tavern image 1

Tastefully remodeled space features beautiful wood flooring, neon signs, and unique owl decor. Atmosphere feels inviting and lively with live music and retro tunes. Comfortable seating includes a 16-seat bar with tables offering outlets, creating a convenient and social environment.

Honey buffalo wings taste grilled and stand out alongside Unami Grilled Cheese and Asian Zing spare ribs. Nachos, burgers, and truffle fries add variety to the American menu.

Umami Grilled Cheese stands out with rich flavors. The menu also features ribeye cheesesteak and birria grilled cheese, both packed with savory fillings.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, elevated, and comforting."

"The American food here is fantastic, especially the juicy salmon."

"The umami grilled cheese is the best thing on the menu."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited, so be prepared to find street parking.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for special events like Mother's Day brunch.

3

The menu features a variety of impressive dishes.

07
The Sandwicheria Eatery - Peruvian Street Food image 1

Small, warm space with dim lighting and a large flat-screen TV creates a cozy, casual vibe. Seating is plentiful and arranged efficiently for dining in. Modern Peruvian design and artisanal touches set it apart from typical Latin American eateries.

Grilled cheese stands out with a unique flavor not commonly found elsewhere. Pulled pork offers a rich, tasteful experience alongside other American staples like carne asada and papas bravas.

Grilled cheese here offers a unique flavor unlike typical versions. It pairs well with dishes like pulled pork and carne asada.

People are saying

"I found the lomo saltado sandwich to be very flavorful."

"The food here is authentic Peruvian street fare, perfect for date spots."

"I loved the American food; the grilled cheese was delicious."

Good to know

1

There is a public parking lot behind the eatery on Prospect.

2

The eatery offers bowls with cilantro rice and your choice of meats or vegetables.

3

Several vegetarian options are available on the menu.

08
TFS Burger Works image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Garage-style setting creates an energetic, lively space with a strong Americana vibe. Crowd enjoys well-balanced smash burgers and crispy fried chicken sandwiches. Menu focuses mainly on burgers and hot dogs with fresh cut fries as a popular side.

Spicy fried chicken sandwich stands out with bold flavor. The grilled cheese features a crispy cheese crust and gooey, melted cheeses. Classic items like cheeseburgers, hand-cut fries, milkshakes, and hot dogs meet expectations.

A grilled cheese here features a crispy crust of cheese on the outside of the bread. It combines different cheeses that melt perfectly, making each bite crispy, gooey, and cheesy.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be perfectly balanced and well-constructed."

"The American Food here is so cheesy, crispy, and gooey."

"The grilled cheese is perfectly gooey and crispy."

Good to know

1

The menu features a variety of burgers and hot dogs.

2

Expect to pay around $40 for a meal with drinks for two.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean and tidy environment.

09
Groundworks Cafe & Lounge image 1

Coffee shop offers rustic decor with wooden accents and ample seating in a cozy but spacious setting. Atmosphere stays relaxing and welcoming, suitable for studying or casual hangouts. Lounge area includes kid-friendly games and a large TV, adding to its community feel.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come with bacon and pair well with tomato soup. The combo hits the spot alongside a cafe con Leche.

Grilled cheese comes with bacon and pairs well with tomato soup or cafe con Leche. The sandwich is made to perfection and tastes yummy.

People are saying

"It's a cozy spot to relax and grab a nice coffee."

"The American Food, especially the grilled cheese, hit the spot."

"I loved the grilled cheese with tomato soup."

Good to know

1

Groundworks Cafe & Lounge is open until midnight, making it a late-night option.

2

Expect to pay around $17 for a large frozen yogurt.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is recommended for some vendors.

10
C'est Cheese image 1
Cheese shop

Small shop offers 70 artisanal cheeses from American farms and international sources alongside imported meats and gourmet groceries. Warm, cozy atmosphere feels like a European market with a women-owned personal touch. Custom cheese boards and unique products create a gastronomic adventure for cheese lovers.

Grilled cheese sandwiches stand out with wagyu pastrami, prosciutto fig jam, and mortadella pesto options. The menu offers unique, delicious choices crafted by an exceptional chef.

Unique grilled cheese sandwiches feature wagyu pastrami, prosciutto fig jam, and mortadella with pesto. The menu offers a variety of delicious options crafted by an exceptional chef.

People are saying

"Tina's passion and expertise make her Grilled Cheese incredible."

"Tina's charcuterie board was beautiful, tasty, and expertly guided."

"Tina's passion and expertise make the American Food experience incredible."

Good to know

1

The shop offers about 70 artisanal cheeses from small American farms and international sources.

2

Custom cheese boards, jams, and kitchen accessories are available for purchase.

3

The store is family-owned and supports local businesses by selling their products.

11
La La Lobster Cape May image 1
Seafood restaurant

Walk-up seafood spot with small outdoor seating and beach casual vibe. Sunlit tables offer a welcoming atmosphere with a breeze on warm days. 80s rock music plays softly, creating a fun and relaxed energy.

Lobster rolls feature generous amounts of lobster meat with great flavor and no skimping. Quick counter service delivers tasty lobster rolls and fries at a reasonable price near the beach.

Lobster grilled cheese stands out with rich seafood flavors. Kids enjoy a simple grilled cheese option on the menu alongside other favorites like mac and cheese.

People are saying

"I had the best lobster roll I ever had."

"The American Food here is packed full of lobster and delicious."

"I loved the lobster grilled cheese with warm butter."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is a walk-up spot with minimal outdoor seating.

2

Lobster rolls cost $22, including chips and a pickle.

3

An extra 2 ounces of lobster meat can be added for $7.

12
Harper's Cafe image 1

Cafe offers a friendly and accepting atmosphere with chill music and amazing artwork. Spacious seating and games at each table create a relaxed, inviting space. It serves as a safe space for LGBTQ individuals and encourages conversation.

Truffle grilled cheese stands out with extra bacon as a popular choice. The menu also features club sandwiches, lattes, pancakes, biscuits, and various baked goods.

Truffle grilled cheese stands out with its rich flavor and crispy bread. Extra bacon adds a smoky touch, making it a hearty choice.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was amazing."

"The American Food here, like the club sandwich, is delicious."

"I loved the delicious food and service."

Good to know

1

Finding parking can be difficult, so pay attention to the signs.

2

They offer oat milk and almond milk as dairy-free options.

3

Expect a lively atmosphere during weekend events.

13
Sandwichitos image 1
Sandwich shop

Small, cozy sandwich shop with an open kitchen and original artwork on white tile walls creates a warm atmosphere. Seating is limited and compact, with a mix of indoor tables and outdoor spots offering a breeze. The vibe feels friendly and comfortable, reflecting passion in every detail.

Philly cheesesteak sandwich comes packed with meat, cheese, and flavor. Large portions of tater tots make one order enough for two people.

4 cheese grilled cheese stands out with rich, melty layers. The French Cuban offers a unique twist, combining classic grilled cheese with bold flavors. Both sandwiches deliver strong, satisfying tastes.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were amazing and delicious."

"Their American food, especially the cheesesteaks, is awesome."

"The grilled cheese here is off the charts delicious."

Good to know

1

Sandwichitos operates on a first come, first serve basis, so arrive early to avoid disappointment.

2

Getting there early is wise if you plan to dine in, as seats are limited.

3

Expect to pay around $20 for a sandwich, which some may find overpriced.

14
The Grind Coffee Cafe image 1

Cozy coffee shop with charming decor and indoor and outdoor seating creates a calm atmosphere. Friendly staff contribute to a welcoming vibe that suits both socializing and quiet work. The space balances a beautiful bistro feel with comfortable, sturdy furniture outside.

Creamy grilled cheese comes with a side of white truffle fries. The juicy cheeseburger cooks to perfection.

Creamy grilled cheese stands out with its rich texture. It pairs well with white truffle fries for a flavorful combo.

People are saying

"The coffee here is really good and delicious."

"The American Food here felt like visiting an attentive family member's house."

"I had the creamy grilled cheese, and it was so good."

Good to know

1

Expect a small hot coffee to cost $2.75 and a small iced coffee to cost $6.

2

The cafe is about a 10-minute drive from Casola Farms and Delicious Orchards.

3

The cafe is good for a quick breakfast, as it is fast and affordable.

15
Shore Good Eats image 1

Tiny cafe with a beachy aesthetic and warm, inviting atmosphere offers a cheeky shore vibe. The space feels cozy despite occasional discomfort from temperature. Regulars enjoy unique spins on classic dishes and a variety of flavorful options.

Brisket stands out with its perfect tenderness. Desserts like Apple Pie Egg Rolls and S'Mores Egg Rolls offer a unique twist. The Short Rib Grilled Cheese and corn beef quesadilla add creative spins to classic American dishes.

Unique spins on classics stand out, like the Short Rib Grilled Cheese and the French Onion Grilled Cheese with Swiss, provolone, and caramelized onions. The grilled cheese options offer rich, hearty flavors that mix traditional and creative elements.

People are saying

"The food for the party was beyond fantastic; everyone raved about it."

"You have to try the breakfast sandwiches; they're wonderfully delicious."

"I was addicted to their French onion grilled cheese."

Good to know

1

Shore Good Eats offers catering for events of all sizes, including corporate gatherings.

2

The food truck is available for hire for private events and parties.

3

They provide setup and delivery services for catered events.

16
Life After Restaurant & Lounge image 1

Space blends urban sophistication with hip-hop nostalgia, featuring music-themed decor and artwork celebrating culture. Atmosphere feels classy and warm, with a live DJ playing R&B and hip-hop that creates a welcoming vibe. Outdoor cigar lounge and photo spots add unique touches to the experience.

Jumbo lump crab cakes come pan-seared with a tangy remoulade and heirloom tomato salad. The menu also features jerk chicken with string beans and coconut rice, plus chicken and cornbread waffles and shrimp and grits.

Oxtail grilled cheese stands out with its rich flavor and tender meat. It pairs well with other dishes but shines on its own.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and beautifully presented."

"The oxtail grilled cheese is so delicious."

"I really enjoyed the oxtail grilled cheese."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals are available daily from 4-7pm with discounted appetizers.

2

Karaoke brunch happens every Sunday, featuring live music and a fun atmosphere.

3

Comedy night takes place every Thursday at 8pm with a two-drink minimum.

17
Summer and Autumn Brunch Cafe image 1

Small brunch spot with tight indoor seating and outdoor tables offers a fun, selfie-worthy aesthetic. Atmosphere varies from loud music that fills the space to moments of enjoyable worship tunes. The place fills quickly, making reservations advisable.

Cheeseburgers with bacon and french fries stand out with rich flavors. Grilled cheese paired with tomato soup offers classic comfort food. Cajun syrup adds a spicy kick to chicken and waffles.

Grilled cheese comes with tomato soup that adds a comforting, spicy kick. The sandwich itself is simple but tasty, making it a solid choice for a cozy meal.

People are saying

"The Brunch here is fresh, delicious, and packed with flavor."

"The American Food, like the cheeseburger, is delicious and flavorful."

"The grilled cheese with tomato soup is pure comfort food."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the cafe fills up quickly.

2

The cafe has a parking lot across the street for convenience.

3

Expect a wait during busy weekends due to limited seating.

18
Mile Square Cafe image 1

Cafe offers a warm, vibrant atmosphere with a focus on Instagram-worthy aesthetics and a family-like environment. It attracts a hip, trendy crowd seeking quality quick eats and specialty coffee. The space feels cozy yet lively, blending unique menu items with a visually appealing setup.

Breakfast burrito and fried chicken sandwich come out tasty and satisfying. The birria grilled cheese offers a large, flavorful portion that stands out alongside sweet options like apple pie pancakes.

Birria grilled cheese stands out with a rich, mouthwatering flavor. The chorizo grilled cheese comes with a dip, and portions are notably large.

People are saying

"The breakfast burrito was packed with flavor and unforgettable."

"The American Food breakfast burrito was tasty and delicious."

"I had the birria grilled cheese that made my mouth water."

Good to know

1

The Italian focaccia sandwich costs $15.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for a table during peak hours.

3

Parking can be difficult around the cafe.

19
The Hamilton Inn image 1
American restaurant

Bright, airy space with cozy neighborhood feel and outdoor seating featuring an Airstream bar and string lights. Atmosphere suits casual brunches and relaxed gatherings with a quiet, easy vibe on most evenings. Perfect spot for people-watching and enjoying simple, well-prepared meals.

Cornbread French toast stands out with its moist, soft, and sweet texture. The short rib grilled cheese features tender, flavorful meat and just the right amount of melted cheese on crispy toast.

Short rib grilled cheese features tender, flavorful meat with the right amount of melted cheese on crispy toast. The sandwich size is moderate, making it a satisfying portion without being too large.

People are saying

"Bartolo makes great cocktails for brunch."

"The American Food here, especially the short rib grilled cheese, is so tasty."

"The short rib grilled cheese had tender, flavorful meat and crispy toast."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-off wine on certain days.

2

Blue Point oysters are on special on Wednesdays.

3

Reservations are recommended due to high weekend demand.

20
Grilled Cheese at the Melt Factory image 1

Small sandwich shop with only five or six tables offers late-night hours until 3AM, attracting a crowd after bars close. Atmosphere varies from quiet when empty to packed and lively late at night. Menu features varied grilled cheese combinations and allows customization for dietary preferences.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come out giant and full of cheese and meat, especially the roast beef version. The sandwiches pair well with tomato soup and serve as a fast and delicious late-night option.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come in lots of varieties with tasty combinations like roast beef packed with cheese and meat. They serve them fast and late at night, making them a solid choice for a late snack.

People are saying

"I love getting grilled cheese late night after the bar."

"I found the food to be amazing and the portions were great."

"This American food is the perfect late-night indulgence after the bars close."

Good to know

1

You can alter any sandwich to your dietary preference.

2

Expect a wait due to its popularity on weekends.

3

They are open till 3AM, catering to late-night crowds.

21
LeGrand Coffee House image 1

Coffee shop offers modern décor with large windows and ample seating inside and outside. Atmosphere feels relaxing and spacious, suitable for solo time or socializing. Background music and free WiFi create a comfortable, inviting environment.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come with options like bacon and pair well with soup. The menu also includes a Cinnabon Latte that complements the savory dishes.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come with bacon and pair well with soup. The menu includes classic grilled cheese options served alongside drinks like the Cinnabon Latte.

People are saying

"The iced vanilla latte was heavenly and freaking fire."

"I loved their grilled cheese and soup."

"I enjoyed their grilled cheese with bacon."

Good to know

1

Parking is available and free at LeGrand Coffee House.

2

The menu features a variety of seasonal flavors and unique combinations.

3

Expect limited pastry options as they sell out quickly each day.

22
Crave Cafe image 1
Restaurant

Stylish space with vibrant murals and meticulous design creates an upscale atmosphere suited for adults seeking a refined dining experience. The environment feels welcoming and special, often hosting celebrations and lively brunches. Dim lighting in the main dining area adds to the intimate vibe.

Eggs Benedict comes with perfectly cooked eggs and rich Hollandaise sauce. The short rib grilled cheese stands out with its tender meat and strong flavor.

Short rib grilled cheese stands out with its rich flavor and tender meat. It changes expectations for how short rib can be prepared in a sandwich.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and great."

"The short rib grilled cheese is unbelievably delicious."

"The American Food here, especially the Eggs Benedict, is cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak brunch hours, especially on Sundays.

3

Parking can be limited; arrive early to secure a spot.

23
Westside Saloon image 1
Sports bar

Small, rustic bar with 50’s knotty pine paneling and an old school large oval bar creates a friendly, waterfront neighborhood vibe. Crowded and lively, it offers casual indoor and shaded outdoor seating with live music enhancing the atmosphere.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come with options like crab cake for a twist. Crab cakes and pork roll egg and cheese stand out. Most dishes, including asparagus and tomato-based plates, are priced at market value.

Grilled cheese includes a version with crab cake that stands out. Most dishes, except cheeseburgers and grilled cheese, follow market pricing.

People are saying

"The food here is excellent and truly amazing."

"I loved the American Food, especially the grilled cheese and crab cakes."

"I enjoyed the grilled cheese with crab cake."

Good to know

1

The menu features many items at market price, which can vary daily.

2

Credit cards are accepted, but check for any minimum purchase requirements.

3

Expect a casual atmosphere; no strict dress code enforced.

24
M by MOKAFÉ image 1
Restaurant

Spacious restaurant with modern decor and lush olive trees creates a bright, welcoming atmosphere. Music leans toward techno and EDM, supporting a lively yet cozy vibe. Seating options suit both small groups and pairs, with ample outlets and free Wi-Fi enhancing comfort.

Grilled cheese and tomato soup stand out as classic comfort foods here. Shakshuka and truffle buffalo wings add a creative twist to the American menu.

Grilled cheese comes with authentic real cheese and pairs with incredibly tasty tomato soup. The combo costs around $12 and feels like a classic comfort meal.

People are saying

"The brunch French toast and pancakes were so soft and delicious."

"The American Food, especially the grilled cheese and tomato soup, is so tasty."

"You have to try the grilled cheese with tomato soup; it's a must-have."

Good to know

1

M by MOKAFÉ is open until 8pm.

2

There is an 18% gratuity included in the bill.

3

They plan to have weekly and monthly specials.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...