Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New Jersey

Cool bookstores

A bookstore is only worth your time if it has a distinct personality that sets it apart from the chains.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Wolfe & Kron Books image 1
Wolfe & Kron Books image 2
Wolfe & Kron Books image 3
View all

Compact space resembles a mystical medieval library with a gorgeous blue ceiling and exposed brick walls. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, filled with carefully curated books and local art items like pins and postcards. Visitors find a unique, diverse selection including rare titles and local zines.

Small and cozy space creates a magical atmosphere for books. Inventory is deep and varied, with a strong focus on queer authors. The bookstore actively supports the local community and offers both used and new titles.

A cool mix of new and used titles fills the shelves. The selection feels extremely well chosen and fits a niche vibe.

People are saying

"I found this bookstore to be an absolute gem."

"This local spot is so welcoming and inclusive."

"This bookstore is seriously cool, with a gorgeous, mystical medieval library vibe."

Good to know

1

Wolfe & Kron Books has a unique selection of books, including LGBTQIA+ titles.

2

The bookstore hosts local events and author signings regularly.

3

Parking is easy and convenient near the bookstore.

02
A&S Comics image 1
Comic book store

Comic book store with 3D statues and large collections of superheroes and villains creates an old school atmosphere. Shelves hold tons of Marvel and DC back issues, including rare Spider-Man and silver age key comics. Space divides between figures and comics, offering complete series bundles for collectors and readers.

Offers a wide selection of comic books that makes it a go-to spot for comic enthusiasts. The store has a friendly vibe that makes visits enjoyable and keeps people coming back.

Cool decor creates a unique vibe. The owner and staff are down to earth and friendly, making it a nice escape from daily routine.

People are saying

"It's a cool spot with a really good variety of books."

"This bookstore has a huge selection of comics and complete series."

Good to know

1

A&S Comics has a large selection of Marvel and DC back issues.

2

They offer bundles of comic books, including entire series.

3

Parking at A&S Comics is easy and convenient.

03
The Toy & Comic Spot image 1
Comic book store

Comic book store filled with vintage toys and nostalgic collectibles from the 80s and 90s creates a friendly, welcoming atmosphere. The space offers an extensive selection of comics and action figures that invite long browsing sessions. Regulars find it a dependable spot for both modern and retro items.

A comic book store offers a solid selection of key issues and vintage toys. It serves as a notable spot for the local community with a strong reputation in the area.

Many cool toys, comics, and collectibles fill the shelves. Staff are friendly and add to the cool vibe.

People are saying

"I found the best vintage toys and comics here."

"The owners and staff are super cool and really friendly."

"This bookstore owner is so knowledgeable and fair."

Good to know

1

The store hosts collectible shows every month, perfect for enthusiasts.

2

Payment methods include credit cards and cash; check for specific vendor policies.

3

Parking is available nearby, but it can get crowded during events.

04
Expired Robot image 1
Comic book store

Comic shop offers wide selection of new and vintage comics, manga, and trading cards. Space feels small but well-stocked, with affordable prices including several dollar comic bins. Atmosphere suits family-friendly and beginner collectors, focusing on variety without overpricing.

Offers a classic comic book shop vibe with a strong focus on comic books. Provides a cool atmosphere for comic enthusiasts.

Comic book stores here have a very cool vibe. Spots like Wicked add to the unique atmosphere.

People are saying

"This comic book store has a really great selection."

"I described the store as awesome."

Good to know

1

The store has a great selection of new and vintage comics.

2

Expect to find a variety of manga and trading cards available.

3

Prices are reasonable, with several dollar comic bins for budget shoppers.

05
Montclair Book Center image 1

Bookstore spans three floors with labyrinthine layout and shelves reaching the ceiling, creating a vintage, old-fashioned vibe. Atmosphere feels calm and timeless, welcoming those who enjoy browsing without rush. Space doubles as a community gathering place with a unique mix of books and vinyl records.

Shelves reach the ceiling with a vast selection that feels like you can find anything. The space is old-fashioned, charming, and clearly made for book lovers.

Vinyl section features records from well-known and lesser-known artists. Book store offers a unique and engaging selection.

People are saying

"This bookstore's selection felt endless, packed with hard-to-find titles."

"It's a vintage treasure trove packed with gems and old-school shelves."

"I found so many interesting books and neat finds here."

Good to know

1

Street parking is difficult, but a paid garage is nearby.

2

The store has a daily clearance rack offering 3 books for $1.

3

The bookstore offers both new and used books.

06
Fortress of Solitude image 1
Comic book store

Small, intimate space with a vintage feel offers a calm and cozy atmosphere for browsing. New comics display on tables rather than shelves adds to the unique setup. Selection includes back issues, indie comics, and collectibles, especially Godzilla items, catering to both newcomers and seasoned readers.

Huge selection of back issues, variants, and figures fills the shelves. Everything wanted from other comic shops exists here.

Strong sense of unique vibe makes this spot stand out. Many find the shop's atmosphere refreshingly cool and memorable.

People are saying

"This comic book store is the best I've ever been to."

"I thought this hometown store was a pretty cool place."

Good to know

1

The store has a huge selection of back issues and indie comics.

2

Prices are reasonable for both new and old comics.

3

Expect a variety of collectibles, especially Godzilla items.

07
Indigo - Short Hills image 1

Large bookstore with spacious layout and inviting children's area offers a peaceful, pleasant atmosphere. Displays feature a wide selection of books, toys, and lifestyle goods for all ages. The space includes comfortable seating and diverse sections for games, clothing, and gifts.

Huge space with seating creates a welcoming spot for both kids and adults. The bookstore offers more than books, including kitchen supplies, toys, and jewelry, making it a unique place to spend time.

Offers a wide variety of cool items beyond books, including kitchen supplies, toys, and jewelry. Stands out as a really cool bookstore with diverse selections.

People are saying

"This bookstore has a huge selection of books and other cool items."

"It's a fun, magical place with a huge selection of kids' books and toys."

"It's a cool bookstore with lots of interesting items."

Good to know

1

The store has a huge selection of books and great gift ideas for all ages.

2

Expect a cozy shopping environment with unique items beyond just books.

3

The bathrooms require asking staff for a code to access.

08
Fat Moose Comics image 1
Comic book store

Comic book store with creative displays and a diverse selection of new and back issues, including an insane selection of Indie titles. Atmosphere stays cool and inviting, drawing in those interested in comics and collectibles. Pricing remains reasonable, supporting a steady flow of enthusiasts.

Classic setup with a strong focus on old school comics. Offers a memorable experience for comic book fans.

Lots to look at with an awesome selection of comics and collectibles. The shop has a good atmosphere and a cool vibe throughout.

People are saying

"They have an awesome selection of comics and other cool stuff."

"The bookstore staff were really friendly and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

The store has a vast selection of indie titles not found in other shops.

2

Prices are reasonable, making it a budget-friendly option for comic lovers.

3

Expect a mix of new comics and back issues available for browsing.

09
The Paranormal Museum- Paranormal Books & Curiosities image 1

Spacious museum with eerie artifacts and a paranormal bookstore creates an immersive, authentic haunted atmosphere. Visitors experience engaging tours filled with spooky stories and local history. Busy streets outside contrast with the museum's captivating, respectful vibe.

A free bookstore sits alongside a paranormal museum and gift shop. It offers a variety of items that draw interest from those exploring ghosts and legends.

Filled with cool occult and paranormal books, the shop offers a mix of spooky stories and real local history. The paranormal museum features cool artifacts in every room and the tour highlights several neat items.

People are saying

"The ghost stories and history woven together were really interesting."

"I found the tour really cool, with lots of neat stuff."

"I loved the bookstore and the amazing museum add-on."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for museum tours at least one week in advance.

2

Expect to pay $120 for a private tour at the Paranormal Museum.

3

The ghost tours feature lantern-led walks through historic downtown areas.

10
Comic Relief of Toms River image 1

Comic book store offers extensive selection of comics and vintage toys with organized layout and reasonable prices. Atmosphere feels lively with bins to dig through for bargains. Collection spans decades, including modern series and classic collectibles.

A classic comic book store with decades of history offers a strong selection of comics. It stands out as one of the best comic book shops in the area, maintaining a solid reputation.

Many cool collectibles fill the shelves, making it a treasure trove for fans. The overall vibe feels all-around cool and inviting.

People are saying

"I loved the selection of vintage toys and comics here."

"The staff here is so helpful and great with kids."

"I found the store to be a cool place with many collectibles."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a large selection of vintage toys and collectibles.

2

Expect to find hundreds of comics from every decade, including DC and Marvel.

3

Prices on vintage items are very reasonable, making it a great spot for collectors.

11
Jay & Silent Bob's Secret Stash image 1

Comic book store doubles as a Kevin Smith memorabilia hub with walls lined by signed items and movie props. Atmosphere stays chill and cool, attracting fans of the filmmaker's work more than general comic readers. Outdoor covered displays let visitors browse even when closed.

A fully-stocked comic book shop with new issues, back issues, and signed comics from DC, Marvel, and Dark Horse. Large selection includes rare finds and memorabilia.

Displays include View Askewverse memorabilia and a large collection of movie props. The spot draws fans with its Kevin Smith film connections and cool movie-related items.

People are saying

"This comic book store is a mecca for Kevin Smith fans."

"This place is so cool with all the movie memorabilia and props."

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful with kids."

Good to know

1

The store mainly features merchandise related to Kevin Smith's films.

2

Expect to find a variety of signed memorabilia and collectibles.

3

Prices can be high, so budget accordingly if you plan to buy.

12
The Little Point Bookshop image 1

Cozy bookstore with an eclectic mix of seating and a coffee bar in the back creates a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. The space feels vibrant and immersive, inviting visitors to unwind with books and coffee. Family-friendly environment supports local businesses and fosters a sense of community.

A huge variety and selection of books fills the shelves, with many titles you won't find at larger stores. The space offers a cozy atmosphere with comfortable spots to read and a coffee bar in the back, plus regular events like book clubs and author talks that bring the community together.

A cool little book shop with a coffee bar in the back creates a relaxed vibe. Other interesting cool items add to the unique feel.

People are saying

"It's a charming, cozy reading spot with a coffee bar."

"The bookstore's barista crafts flawless lattes with infectious positivity."

"I thought the place seemed cool, like a little book shop with a coffee bar."

Good to know

1

The bookstore hosts events like Book Club and Live Music Jams regularly.

2

Reservations are not required for events, but arrive early for best seating.

3

The coffee bar offers a selection of drinks to enjoy while browsing.

13
Barnes & Noble image 1
Book store

Huge bookstore with bright, open layout and many hidden nooks for reading. Large, clean cafe area offers plenty of seating including private spots. Atmosphere is generally quiet and inviting, though lighting can be intense for sensitive eyes.

A huge bookstore with a huge selection of books and a bright, inviting space. It features a nice cafe area and plenty of hidden nooks and seating for reading.

Super cool decor and very cool displays stand out here. The building feels less cool compared to the previous location.

People are saying

"It's a beautiful, big Reading Spot with a huge selection."

"This bookstore is huge with a wonderful selection."

"The displays and decor here are really cool."

Good to know

1

The children's Lego event occurs every Saturday at 10am.

2

A children's author signing happens monthly; check the schedule for details.

3

Parking is available, but it can fill up quickly on weekends.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...