Simple pizza shop with impeccably clean space and few tables for sit-down meals. Atmosphere stays warm and friendly, welcoming even for takeout. Known for outstanding thin crust pizza and affordable prices.
Outstanding thin crust pizza comes with a fantastic sauce especially on the margarita pizza. The pizza consistently impresses with its amazing flavor and generous sauce.
Calzones come out in about 10 minutes and taste really good and delicious. They pair well with the pizza and offer a satisfying meal option.
"Their Italian food, especially the pizza, is the best ever."
"I thought the pizza here was amazing."
"I really enjoyed the delicious calzones here."
Good to know
McHugh's offers free delivery for orders over a certain amount.
The large pizza costs $16, making it an affordable option.
Expect your pizza and calzone to be ready in about 10 minutes.
Cozy pizza spot with large slices and classic New Jersey tomato pie style. The atmosphere is friendly and busy, offering quick pick-up and reasonable prices. Pasta and Alfredo sauce stand out alongside the pizza, making it a well-rounded local favorite.
Pizza features a simple classic style with standout New Jersey tomato pie and Sicilian styles. It consistently ranks as the best in town and remains a go-to spot for authentic Italian pizza.
Very large calzones serve as a filling meal for two. They stand out among other items like pizza and pasta for their generous size and satisfying portions.
Good to know
The lunch specials offer good value for a quick meal.
A good slice of pizza costs $2.50.
They sell pizza by the slice or as a whole pie.
Italian pizzeria with a homey, relaxed atmosphere and friendly vibe. The space feels simple and welcoming, with shaded outdoor tables. Pizza features thin, crunchy crusts and authentic Brooklyn-style flavors that appeal to all ages.
Pizza features a perfect crust, delicious sauce, and arrives piping hot. Varieties include Margherita, vodka mushroom, and deep dish pepperoni and sausage, all crispy and flavorful.
Calzones come out crispy and fresh, with a delicious flavor that stands out.
Good to know
Cash payments are preferred; credit cards may not be accepted.
Parking costs $25 nearby, so plan accordingly.
The restaurant has limited seating, which can lead to longer wait times.
Italian restaurant offers cozy romantic atmosphere with dim lighting and a homey vibe. It stays open late, attracting those seeking a relaxed spot for pizza and pasta. The interior feels modern and renovated, creating a welcoming space for casual dining.
Crunchy crust and melty golden mozzarella top a thin, crispy pizza with fresh, locally sourced toppings like artisanal pepperoni and basil. Every ingredient tastes incredibly fresh, creating a well-seasoned slice that sets a high standard for pizza.
Massive calzones feature a golden, crunchy crust with a perfect flour dusting for a rustic look. Fillings include thin pepperoni and creamy ricotta or sausage with peppers and onions, balancing crispy and soft textures well.
Good to know
The restaurant is open until 4am, making it a late-night option.
Expect high prices, with lasagna costing $22 without sides.
There is no available parking nearby, so plan accordingly.
Pizza restaurant offers quiet, friendly atmosphere with a clean, organized space. Menu features fresh, high-quality pizza reminiscent of Italy and notable chicken parm sub. Prices tend to be on the higher side.
Pizza features a perfect crust with amazingly fresh tomatoes and cheese. The selection is great, with consistently fresh and delicious pies delivered hot and on time.
Extremely flavorful calzones stand out alongside excellent cheesesteak and pizza options. The calzones deliver rich taste and pair well with appetizers and soups.
Good to know
The delivery speed is fast and reliable.
Deliveries are always on time.
The place is clean and well-organized.
Small space with limited seating and a warm, homey vibe reminiscent of an old-school Italian neighborhood. Atmosphere feels welcoming and casual, suited for relaxed lunches or pizza dinners. Known for exceptional pizza and a friendly, inviting energy.
Authentic Jersey pizza comes out crispy and delicious, ready when you arrive. It offers excellent quality with a taste that brings back childhood memories and stays reasonably priced.
Calzones come in a few varieties, including a chicken calzone option. The menu pairs calzones with other Italian favorites like pasta and salads.
Good to know
The restaurant has limited seating, so arrive early to secure a table.
Most menu items are not available during lunch hours.
Parking is easy and accessible near the restaurant.
Pizza restaurant offers spacious seating for large groups with family-owned atmosphere that feels welcoming. Thin crust pizzas stand out with fresh, high-quality ingredients and homemade sauce. Music plays softly, creating a casual and comfortable vibe.
Thin crust pizza stands out with its fresh and delicious taste. The Margherita slice is a delicious option, and the pizza consistently delivers amazing quality.
Calzones vary widely here, with some being exceptional and others soggy and mushy. Dough often blends into the filling, making texture inconsistent.
Good to know
Signing up for rewards gives a 15% discount on orders.
The restaurant is suitable for large groups needing to be fed.
Ordering for pickup is quick and efficient.
Building reflects 50's style with nostalgic Americana decor featuring outsider and folk art. Atmosphere stays lively and authentic, evoking an old American movie scene with a quirky, fun vibe. Regulars enjoy classic Jersey pizza in a setting that honors tradition while welcoming updates.
Thin, crispy crust and perfectly balanced cheese define the pizza here. Fresh basil tops the pies, and calzones come out unexpectedly delicious with a good undercrust and moderate cheese amount.
Huge baked calzones and mini deep-fried calzones stand out here. The ricotta & ham fried calzone and deep-fried versions come with sauce and hold a strong reputation for quality and flavor.
Good to know
On Fridays, they host a comedy night from 9 pm to 11 pm.
Open mic events occur every Friday evening.
The restaurant is open until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Large dining area offers comfortable seating with homey, local vibe and welcoming atmosphere. Busy spot with exceptional staff and BYO policy. Lighting tends to be bright, sometimes feeling sterile rather than cozy.
Sicilian pizza stands out with its taste and texture. The ricotta pizza also offers a very good option. Overall, pizzas here are consistently delicious and excellent.
Cheese calzones stand out with rich cheese filling and a satisfying texture. Some calzones lean toward being overly bready and cheesy but lack strong flavor.
Good to know
Casa D'Amici is a BYO restaurant, allowing customers to bring their own alcohol.
The restaurant has limited seating due to damage from a drunk driver.
They offer a food allergy menu for customers with dietary restrictions.
Traditional pizza place with an old school vibe and large, comfortable seating fills with the aroma of freshly baked pizza. Atmosphere stays quiet during the day, creating a calm dining experience. Walls display pictures that add character but lack a clear theme.
Pizza features a crust that holds up well and an incredibly rich sauce with plenty of it. Prices are reasonable, with a $12.99 pizza offering good value compared to typical $17 large pizzas.
Deep fried calzones stand out with a crispy texture. A large selection includes calzones, slices, and garlic knots. Calzones come unheated unless requested otherwise.
Good to know
The price for two big slices is $7, a good deal.
Takeout pizza pie special is $9.99.
Dine-in and takeout prices are now the same at $12.99.
Italian movies play softly in a quaint space with both inside and outside seating, creating a warm family atmosphere. Brick and carousel ovens bake top-shelf pizza that stands out in the area. The place is BYOB and offers a pleasant, homey vibe reminiscent of North Jersey and Brooklyn.
Pizza comes out hot and fresh with a great crisp to the crust and fresh cheese. The margherita pizza has a perfect balance of taste and texture.
Calzones have a delicious dough flavor and come with fillings like meatballs. Some crusts can be burnt, and sizes vary compared to other places.
Good to know
Manzano's is BYOB, so bring your favorite drinks.
Expect longer wait times on weekends, especially after 7 PM.
Takeout is available if you want to avoid the busy dining room.
Cozy spot with a nostalgic diner vibe and clean atmosphere. Music plays softly, creating a relaxed mood. Offers creative pizza toppings and a variety of options that attract a diverse crowd.
Pizza features a special dough that stands out. Options include chicken Caesar and chicken Chipotle pizzas, all fresh and affordable.
Huge size calzones cost about 12 dollars and often come with leaking fillings. Some calzones are delicious, while others are not edible.
Good to know
Mama's Gourmet Pizza offers a great variety of pizza options.
Pricing is fair for the quality and quantity of food.
The restaurant is kid-friendly and welcomes families.
Small, old school Italian restaurant with a cozy, quaint atmosphere and casual local favorite vibe. Seating is limited and cramped, with outdoor tables available. Known for authentic pizza and pasta, it offers quick service and a relaxed setting.
Delicious, authentic pizza comes with good-sized portions and quick delivery. Pizza-by-the-slice offers a great way to enjoy the top quality pies on site.
Calzones here come with thin slices of Italian sausage but very little filling overall. They contain only mozzarella and pepperoni, with no ricotta, and the size is smaller than expected.
Good to know
Delivery typically takes about 30 minutes, but can vary based on demand.
The restaurant is open until 11 PM on weekends, making it a late-night option.
Expect to pay around $21 for a medium pizza, which may be higher than average.
Small space offers a hometown feel with limited seating and a quiet dining experience. Menu includes stuffed crust pizza and large portions that provide good value. Atmosphere stays calm, attracting those seeking hearty, straightforward meals rather than a bustling restaurant vibe.
Pizza features a stuffed crust with a crust thickness similar to Pietro's. Toppings include fried chicken slices with sweet sauce, honey mustard chicken, sausage, and mushroom, all paired with flavorful sauce and excellent cheese.
Fried calzones have an awesome sweetness in the breading and a delicious filling. The fried ham calzone cooks in the same oil as seafood, which affects its flavor.
Good to know
Bring cash as some payment methods may incur a service fee.
Expect large portion sizes that provide good value for the price.
Half and half pizza combinations are available for more variety.