Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New Jersey

Consignment shops

Consignment shopping that offers a curated selection of quality finds instead of a cluttered rack of discarded trends.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Revive Consignment / Somerville, NJ image 1
Revive Consignment / Somerville, NJ image 2
Revive Consignment / Somerville, NJ image 3
View all

Bright, open space offers a friendly atmosphere with designer handbags and shoes for women's consignment. Clean, organized layout features high-quality items at affordable prices. Comfortable seating and frequent new inventory make shopping easy and enjoyable.

Many designer handbags, shoes, and clothing fill the shelves. The shop stays very clean and offers a great selection for women's consignment.

People are saying

"The staff here are the sweetest people ever when helping with women's clothing."

"You'll find hidden gems with the sweetest, most helpful owners."

"I found this consignment shop to be the best I've ever visited."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $10-20 for most jeans and tops.

2

New merchandise is displayed frequently, ensuring variety.

3

All items are posted online for easy browsing and purchasing.

02
Cottontails Children's Consignment image 1

Shop features a well-curated selection of kids' and maternity items at affordable prices. Space is clean and organized, making shopping calm and easy. Families find trusted brands and a pleasant consignment experience here.

Offers a quality selection of kids' items with a pleasant shopping experience every visit. Stands out as a nice consignment store for children's goods.

People are saying

"I found this consignment store to be the nicest around."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of well-curated items in great condition.

2

Expect affordable prices on quality brands throughout the store.

3

The maternity section has a variety of clothing options available.

03
The Garb Collection image 1

Sections look like individual closets, making shopping easy and fun. Shoppers find gently used, stylish clothing and vintage gems at great prices. Teens and young adults love the chance to earn over $1,000 through consignment here.

Offers a selection of gently used, stylish clothing and vintage pieces. Supports consignment sales with opportunities to earn over $1,000. Caters especially to teen and young adult thrift shoppers.

People are saying

"Setting up my closet here was actually fun and seamless."

"I found this thrift store to be super organized with amazing pieces."

"I found awesome, stylish clothes and accessories at this consignment store."

Good to know

1

The store offers a fully stocked two-dollar rack accessible to everyone.

2

Items are organized by consigner or seller for easy browsing.

3

Many items in the store are new with tags, ensuring quality.

04
Rebel Supply Co. image 1
Clothing store

Eclectic store offers screaming bargains on vintage and modern consignment clothes, including a plus-size section. Warm, community vibe shines through lively events like local shows and dance parties. Unique gifts add charm to the carefully curated space.

Offers screaming bargains on vintage and contemporary consignment clothing. Features a plus-size consignment section and unique novelty items with a carefully selected inventory.

People are saying

"This consignment shop feels like home with its amazing staff."

"You'll find unique pieces and genuine hospitality here."

"I found the most eclectic pieces styled in ways I hadn't considered."

Good to know

1

Rebel Supply Co. offers a wide selection of unique vintage clothing and gifts.

2

The store features a plus-size consignment section, which is rare in thrift shops.

3

Expect a friendly atmosphere with a welcoming owner who knows the community.

05
Daffodil Consignment image 1

Bright, airy space with fashion-forward displays offers a lively, organized vibe. Quality designer items and sparkling jewelry shine in a friendly, helpful setting. Late hours make it a fun spot with good earnings for sellers.

Offers a wide range of quality merchandise including designer items and sparkling jewelry. The store has a friendly atmosphere with helpful staff and provides good earnings for sellers.

People are saying

"I found beautiful jewelry and clothes at this consignment shop."

"The owner of this Footwear Store made me feel like I made a new best friend."

"You'll feel the love at this jewelry store from the moment you walk in."

Good to know

1

The store has a wonderful collection of clothing, handbags, shoes, and jewelry.

2

The prices are fair for high-quality merchandise.

3

The selection is curated and priced below market value.

06
New Start Consignments image 1
Consignment shop

Shop offers a carefully curated selection of jewelry, bags, and shoes in excellent condition. Space feels clean and organized with fun music playing. Prices stay fair and reasonable, making it a super awesome selection among New Jersey consignment stores.

Small size meets super awesome selection in this consignment store. It stands out among various secondhand shops visited across New Jersey.

People are saying

"The owner's passion for his work makes this consignment shop amazing."

"The owner of this jewelry store is so charming and fun!"

Good to know

1

There is a convenient parking lot on the side of the store.

2

The store is organized and offers quality new and preowned merchandise.

3

The jewelry, bags, and shoes are in excellent condition.

07
The RealReal image 1
Consignment shop

Beautifully curated consignment shop offers hidden slide-out racks and personal styling services for a chill, bright atmosphere. Staff like Abdur and Appy provide friendly support and help with transactions. Luxury items here boast consistent quality and authenticity.

Consignment here involves a simple process with staff like Abdur and Appy who offer helpful and friendly support. They assist with transactions and suggest pieces from the sales floor for events.

People are saying

"The staff made the luxurious experience feel approachable and enjoyable."

"The consignment process here is super easy and the staff is so friendly."

Good to know

1

Parking is available at the Summit location.

2

The RealReal offers a selection of luxury items for buying and selling.

3

The quality and authenticity of items are consistently high.

08
conSHINEment image 1
Consignment shop

Shop features a curated selection of vintage and trendy clothes at affordable prices. Friendly staff create a chill atmosphere with loud, good music. Fitting rooms are simple but functional, making shopping relaxed and easy.

A curated secondhand and consignment store offers a really good assortment of items with a nice array of brands and prices. The service is very professional, focusing on current trends and classic pieces.

People are saying

"I found a large variety of quality women's clothing in great condition."

"The vintage here has the friendliest staff and best customer service."

"I found the brands and clothes at this consignment store to be of great quality."

Good to know

1

Expect a good assortment of items with a nice array of brands and prices.

2

Prices are generally affordable, but some items may be priced high for thrift.

3

There is no fitting room or return policy, so check sizes carefully.

09
Pearl St. Consignment and Custom Clothes image 1

Small consignment shop shines with high-end consignments and a trendy retro vibe. Offers alternative fashion like Punk and Goth styles. Features adorable fitting rooms and easy parking nearby.

Small thrift and consignment store offers many amazing pieces including high-end consignments. One of a kind shop with a cool selection of used and consignment clothing.

People are saying

"I found unique vintage and alternative fashion pieces at this thrift store."

"I found so many unique and fashionable goodies at this consignment shop."

"I found unique and curated vintage clothing and accessories here."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy with several spots available next to the store.

2

Prices on used and custom clothing are affordable and reasonable.

3

Expect a fast turnover of unique items; buy quickly if you see something you like.

10
Soled Out Jersey City image 1

Retail consignment shop boasts extensive sneaker inventory and competitive pricing. Manager offers consignment options without buyouts. Laid-back vibe makes browsing easy for sneaker and streetwear fans seeking authentic rare shoes.

Offers designer items for consignment with competitive prices compared to mall stores. Manager provides consignment options but does not do buyouts.

People are saying

"The staff at this footwear store are super friendly and helpful."

"I found the consignment prices here to be the best."

Good to know

1

They are 100% authentic.

2

The store has no return or refund policy.

3

The process to sell and buy is super easy.

11
Back on the Racks image 1
Consignment shop

Large consignment shop offers color-coordinated racks and helpful staff for easy shopping and selling. Enjoy stylish clothing and home decor in a positive, energetic space with lovely dressing rooms and convenient furniture pickup.

Large selection of clothing defines the consignment offerings here. Helpful staff assist both on the sales floor and with consignment, making the process smooth and approachable.

People are saying

"The women's clothing staff are so helpful and kind."

"The hosts' professionalism and enthusiasm made shopping here unique and fun."

"The consignment staff's kindness and patience made my visit so much better."

Good to know

1

The clothes are organized by color for easy browsing.

2

Prices are generally excellent, offering good value for quality items.

3

Expect a limited selection of furniture and home decor.

12
Squan Dry Goods image 1
Consignment shop

Small exterior hides a spacious interior with a lattice layout that separates clothing types. Known for quality items and a well-curated selection, it offers a wide variety of brand-name styles. Frequent new arrivals keep inventory fresh and seasonally relevant.

Offers a well-curated selection with a strong reputation among consignment shops. Known for its quality items and thoughtful presentation.

People are saying

"I found so many nice clothes, shoes, and accessories here."

"I found high-end shoes and handbags at a fraction of the price."

"This consignment shop is so well-organized with incredible finds."

Good to know

1

Squan Dry Goods offers a wide variety of high-end used clothing and accessories.

2

Consigning items is simple; sellers receive 50% of the sale price as store credit or cash.

3

The store is well-organized, making shopping a pleasant experience.

13
Bo's Attic image 1
Consignment shop

Shop features luxury purses and upscale finds in a well curated space. Atmosphere stays pleasant and inviting, free from thrift odors. Expert consignment management ensures high-quality items at affordable prices.

Luxury purses appear regularly on consignment here, making it a spot for upscale finds. The shop stands out as not your average thrift and has a reliable consignment expert managing the selection.

People are saying

"The owner Bo is the sweetest lady, making the consignment shopping pleasant."

Good to know

1

The store has been expanded and rearranged for better shopping.

2

Items are of better quality than expected from a thrift shop.

3

Prices are very fair for the quality of items.

14
Ladies Room Consignment Boutique image 1

Shop offers beautiful selection of clothes, shoes, and accessories at bargain prices. Atmosphere invites browsing and finding good steals regularly. Some caution advised when consigning items here.

Many good steals appear regularly in the selection. Some reviews suggest caution before consigning items here.

People are saying

"The owner was so sweet and helpful with my consignment experience with consignment."

Good to know

1

Prices are generally lower than retail, making it a great place for bargains.

2

The shop features a wide selection of clothes, shoes, and accessories.

3

Consigning items may require careful consideration based on reviews.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...