Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cookie and seafood in New Jersey

Made for those who have eclectic cravings and want to pair a high-quality cookie with a seafood-focused meal.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Nostimo Mediterranean Greek Restaurant image 1
Nostimo Mediterranean Greek Restaurant image 2
Nostimo Mediterranean Greek Restaurant image 3
View all

Small space offers a cozy, intimate atmosphere with authentic Greek flavors. Outdoor seating provides a relaxing, comfortable spot with sun and heating options. Friendly vibe feels like dining with family, enhanced by warm, attentive service.

Complimentary cookies arrive with the bill, often including almond and Greek powdered varieties. These treats come free at the end of the meal.

Fresh fish and well prepared seafood stand out here. Shrimp dishes like the Shrimp kataifi starter and shrimp platter are popular choices, alongside calamari and Thalassenas appetizers.

People are saying

"I found the Greek food here to be fresh and delicious."

"The grilled shrimp and octopus were delicious."

"They brought out complimentary cookies at the end of the meal."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your own wine.

2

Prices are reasonable, and portions are large.

3

On weeknights through Thursday, they offer a 10% reduction in prices.

02
Red Horse Steakhouse by David Burke - Rumson, NJ image 1

Steakhouse offers a loud, energetic atmosphere with live music enhancing the experience. Decor features quaint, classy touches like blown glass artwork and candlelight. The space attracts those seeking a vibrant, upscale dining environment.

Sugar cookie ice cream sandwiches with toasted marshmallow stand out as a nostalgic treat elevated to gourmet levels. The cookies are delicious and pair well with creamy ice cream.

Fresh seafood stands out with dishes like pork chops paired with clams and scallops. Shrimp and avocado cocktail also features alongside rich sides like French Onion Soup Mashed potatoes.

People are saying

"Dinner in the dark is an unforgettable sensory revelation."

"The sugar cookie ice cream sandwich was a nostalgic, gourmet treat."

"The lobster ravioli and shrimp seafood were the star of the show."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all day on Tuesdays with special promotions.

2

Trivia night features movie trivia every Tuesday at 8pm.

3

Steak night is on Wednesdays with special menu items.

03
La Lupa image 1
Restaurant

Tiny space with cramped seating and dark walls creates an intimate but tight atmosphere. Loud music and close tables make conversation challenging, yet the vibe feels cozy and inviting. BYOB policy and hip hop music add a casual, personal touch to the dining experience.

Warmed chocolate cookie cake with gelato stands out as a rich dessert. Chocolate chip cookies offer a nice end to the meal alongside other sweets like brownies.

Seafood stands out with top notch lobster and a lobster pasta that ranks highly. Other seafood dishes complement the menu alongside amazing pizzas and pastas.

People are saying

"The steak here is fantastic, truly unmatched."

"The warmed chocolate cookie cake with gelato was amazing."

"The seafood here, especially the lobster, was top notch."

Good to know

1

La Lupa is BYOB, so bring your own wine or drinks.

2

Getting a reservation at La Lupa is a must due to limited seating.

3

Appetizers are priced similarly to entrees at other restaurants.

04
Tavern 73 image 1
American restaurant

American sports bar with a wrap-around veranda and an airy interior featuring vines and a hanging garden overhead. Atmosphere is friendly and lively, often noisy with many TVs showing sporting events and games on screens. Offers a banquet room for parties and a sizable bar area for drinks.

Skillet cookie sundae stands out as a phenomenal dessert option. Chocolate chip cookie appears often, including in a skillet version that pairs well with other desserts like Nutella mousse cake.

Fish and chips come with crispy fries and tartar sauce. The coconut shrimp appetizer cooks quickly and stays tender. Shrimp tacos and mussels in white sauce add variety to the seafood options.

People are saying

"The food at these dinner spots is amazing, hot, and fresh."

"You have to try the fish tacos; I can't wait to go back."

"The chocolate chip cookie skillet was recommended."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs on Fridays starting at 5:30 pm.

2

The restaurant is suitable for family events and gatherings.

3

Parking is available on-site for guests.

05
Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace image 1

Marketplace combines old school vibes with a boutique Italian atmosphere featuring live classic music and upstairs serene dining. Displays are colorful and organized, evoking a vintage 1950s grocery feel. Shoppers often enjoy a calm, elegant environment with a touch of Italy throughout.

Pignoli cookies stand out with their rich pine nut flavor. Heated tents offer cookies and coffee while waiting. Gluten-free options made in Italy taste delicious.

Fresh seafood includes live lobsters, jumbo fried shrimp, crab cakes, and several types of seafood salads. The seafood department offers scratch-made dishes like shrimp scampi and fruiti de mare salad, all consistently fresh and flavorful.

People are saying

"The fresh seafood here is top-notch and wonderful."

"Their bakery sells all types of Italian cookies, cakes, breads, and pastries."

"I found the pignoli cookies to be delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

Hot food and some sandwiches are 50% off after 7:30 PM.

2

On Fridays, two pizza pies are available for $22 after 7:30 PM.

3

Live performances occur on weekends from 1 to 4 PM.

06
Wing Bar image 1
Chicken wings restaurant

Small, narrow space fills with loud music and lively energy, creating a welcoming atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating. Crowded bar seats host people playing games and cheering, while staff bring contagious vibes that keep the mood upbeat. Known for fresh wings and a tight, casual environment, it serves as a neighborhood spot for late-night food and drinks.

Dessert cookies come warmed up to perfection and have a homemade feel. Brownies share the same warm, comforting quality.

Shrimp specials stand out with $1 shrimp Wednesdays and a popular Thursday deal. Fried shrimp often come with Thai chili sauce, pairing well with other fried items like golden chicken and wings.

People are saying

"The bartenders here are so sweet and kind!"

"The seafood here is great, and the servers are so upbeat and attentive."

"The wings here are great, the best in the area."

Good to know

1

Wing Bar offers a $1 wing special every Wednesday night.

2

Happy hour features drink specials from 4-7pm on weekdays.

3

Karaoke takes place every Thursday night with no cover charge.

07
MoonShine Modern Supper Club image 1
New American restaurant

Modern design with a private upstairs loft creates a classy, intimate setting. Music ranges from laid-back to lively, supporting a versatile vibe suitable for couples or groups. Comfortable outdoor space and a beautiful bar add to the overall experience.

Warm cookie dough stands out with gelato and sparkler candles. Chocolate chip cookies and peanut butter mousse also feature as incredible desserts.

Shrimp dishes stand out with shrimp and grits served alongside collard greens and a fresh shrimp cocktail. Calamari also appears as a solid seafood option.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious."

"You have to try the warm cookie dough with gelato."

"You have to try the shrimp and grits; it's so good!"

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for private events to ensure availability.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Brunch is served from 12 to 4pm on weekends.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...