Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New Jersey

Cookies and cream ice cream

Made for those who have a specific devotion to cookies and cream and will seek out the most dedicated ice cream makers to find it.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Boza Creamery image 1
Boza Creamery image 2
Boza Creamery image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Small, clean space with modern design and a fresh baked cookie scent creates a zen vibe. Coffee bar sits to one side, ice cream service to the other, with a tasting station speeding up busy times. Outdoor seating is limited but peaceful, and the shop stays lively late into the night.

Homemade ice cream here is creamy and has a great base. It stays open late, until 11PM, offering some of the best ice cream in the area.

Every bite of the cookies and cream ice cream contains Oreo pieces. The flavor is consistently delicious and spot on with classic cookies and cream taste.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so fresh and delicious."

"You have to try these homemade ice cream hidden gems; they let you sample every flavor."

"I thought the Cookies and Cream flavor was amazing."

Good to know

1

Boza Creamery is open until 11PM, making it a late-night option.

2

There is plenty of parking available near the shop.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but check for any promotions before visiting.

02
Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream image 1

Small ice cream shop with natural light and benches inside and outside offers a quiet, welcoming atmosphere. Unique Asian-inspired flavors like Lychee, Taro, and Ube stand out alongside rich, creamy homemade ice cream. Sampling is allowed, and seating can get cramped during busy times.

Black sesame, green tea matcha, and homemade Thai tea stand out as unique ice cream flavors. The ice cream quality is consistently phenomenal with options like ice cream cakes available.

Cookies and cream ice cream offers a creamy texture with the right level of sweet. It pairs well with coffee and stands out as a solid Oreo-flavored option.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are so unique and delicious."

"The milk tea and lychee flavors were spot on."

"I love that the Cookies and Cream ice cream is homemade."

Good to know

1

There is free parking at Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream.

2

They offered unique flavors such as Lychee, Taro, and Ube.

3

The pricing is very affordable, making it a great after-dinner treat.

03
Dasโ€™ Creamery MooTown image 1

Cozy ice cream shop with friendly staff and fun decor creates a welcoming atmosphere. Offers a wide variety of unique flavors, including many vegan options. Spacious layout with ample parking supports a relaxed visit.

Apple orchard and chocolate cake stand out as popular flavors. The ice cream offers a variety of options and tastes authentic and delicious.

Coffee flavor stands out in the Colombian cookies and cream. It blends rich coffee notes with creamy sweetness.

People are saying

"The ice cream servers here are so nice and helpful."

"I loved the amazing variety of unique flavors they offered."

"The Colombian Cookies and Cream flavor had an incredible coffee taste."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy and available nearby.

2

The shop is new and very clean.

3

Expect high prices; a small soft serve with sprinkles costs over $7.

04
Maroons Creamery - Hand Crafted Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop offers wide variety of flavors with options for sampling and includes sugar-free and eggless choices. Interior is modern and clean with limited indoor seating and some outdoor options. Atmosphere feels welcoming and cozy despite occasional heat and lack of music.

Unique, hand crafted flavors like ube and strawberry-ube soft serve stand out. The ice cream tastes very natural and tasty with an amazing selection to try.

Soft serve includes a Cookies and Cream flavor that stands out. The ice cream version of this flavor is also very good. Other recommended flavors nearby include pistachio and fudge.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is rich, creamy, and full of flavor."

"The Thai tea here is exceptionally delicious and intriguing."

"The Cookies and Cream ice cream here is amazing and very tasty."

Good to know

1

Seating is limited, so plan accordingly during busy hours.

2

Expect to find unique flavors like strawberry lychee and black sesame.

3

There was a $1.25 charge for the cone that was not disclosed beforehand.

05
MilkShake Factory Florham Park image 1

Bright, modern space blends nostalgic charm with a clean, inviting design. Energy feels upbeat and welcoming, drawing families and chocolate lovers alike. Offers wide milkshake variety, homemade chocolates, and allergen-friendly options in a fun, family-focused atmosphere.

Vanilla ice cream with cookie crumbles stands out in the Cookie Jar milkshake. The shop offers a cozy, bright, modern vibe with fantastic ice cream and chocolate options.

Milkshakes come packed with cookie pieces and blend smoothly. The mint cookies and cream flavor works well even in non-dairy versions, and the chocolate bark with cookies and cream is a tasty treat.

People are saying

"These milkshakes are delicious and full of flavor."

"The Cookies and Cream milkshake was loaded with cookie pieces and perfectly blended."

"The ice cream staff here are so friendly and happy."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a huge variety of milkshakes and chocolates.

2

They provide gluten-free and dairy-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Free samples of chocolate barks are available for customers to try.

06
Bun N Done image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Small burger joint offers best smash burgers with fresh beef and crispy chicken tenders. Space feels clean and cozy with a family-friendly vibe. Music sometimes includes profanity, contrasting the otherwise welcoming atmosphere.

Soft serve ice cream comes creamy and rich, not watered down like at other spots. Complimentary servings sometimes appear alongside milkshakes and churros.

The Cookies and Cream Milkshake stands out as a popular choice here. It pairs well with other items like dulce de leche churros and Cajun fries.

People are saying

"I thought their burgers were the best I had in the US."

"I thought the ice cream here was delicious and amazing."

"You have to try their Cookies and Cream milkshake; it's very great."

Good to know

1

Bun N Done is a halal restaurant with Zabiha certification.

2

They have parking available in the back and on the side.

3

Bun N Done offers vegetarian options alongside their main menu.

07
Stack Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Cozy shop with a retro-style ambiance and the smell of fresh baked cookies fills the air. Customers create custom ice cream sandwiches from a variety of unique flavors and cookies. No seating is available, encouraging quick visits in a clean, updated space.

Ice cream here is consistently really good with a variety of flavors. Staff are patient and helpful, especially when making custom ice cream sandwiches.

The cookies and cream flavor stands out with a balanced sweetness that is not overpowering. Pairing it with Cookie Monster ice cream or using it in ice cream sandwiches with M&Ms cookies creates a unique and enjoyable twist.

People are saying

"Jill's service made my ice cream experience super pleasant."

"Jill made a delicious cookie sandwich; it was amazing."

"I loved the cookies and cream flavor; it wasn't too sweet."

Good to know

1

Stack Creamery offers a variety of ice cream flavors and cookie options.

2

Prices for cookies are $11.99 for 6, but may vary.

3

Generous portions make it easy to get full from a single order.

08
Chip City image 1
Dessert shop

Warm aroma of freshly baked cookies fills a small, cute shop with limited seating and welcoming decor. Music complements a fun, charming vibe that attracts late-night snack seekers. Offers a wide variety of cookie flavors, including standout dairy-free and vegan options.

Sea salt caramel and strawberry shortcake stand out among the ice cream flavors. Cookies often come paired with ice cream, like the Brookie with cookies and cream ice cream.

Mint Cookies & Cream cookies have a delicious mint flavor and a rich cookies and cream texture. The cookies consistently impress with their balanced sweetness and satisfying crunch.

People are saying

"These cookies are huge, soft, and delicious."

"The staff here is so friendly and kind."

"The Cookies and Cream cookie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Chip City is open until 1 am on weekends for late-night cookie cravings.

2

They offer a buy-one-get-one-free deal on Uber Eats, totaling $10 including delivery.

3

Parking near Chip City can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...