Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Pie and deli spots in New Jersey

You want your pie from a deli, and you expect the selection to be as authentic as the setting.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Drew's Market image 1
Drew's Market image 2
Drew's Market image 3
View all
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store with a classic neighborhood market feel offers an excellent selection of fresh food including a prime butcher and deli. The atmosphere is reliable and inviting, attracting locals and visitors alike with quality products and fair prices.

Made-to-order pot pies include a chicken parm pot pie with pulled chicken and a holiday pot pie. The Thanksgiving Pie features turkey and sides, offering a hearty dinner option.

Fresh, high-quality meats and deli items stand out here. The place serves prime butcher and deli products with an Italian deli focus.

People are saying

"The market's prepared foods and sandwiches are delicious and fresh."

"The staff here makes this lunch spot feel like home."

"You have to try the chicken parm pot pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Drew's Market offers a wide selection of fresh food and Italian specialties.

2

Catering services are available for events, including graduation parties.

3

Prices at Drew's Market are affordable and competitive.

02
Twin Pond Farm Country Market image 1

Large market combines garden area and indoor deli with a friendly atmosphere. Offers locally grown produce, a wide variety of plants, and activities for children including hay rides. Food options include fresh pies, cider donuts, and breakfast sandwiches made on torpedo rolls.

Freshness stands out in the pies here, with options like Dutch Apple Pie and Fruits of the Forest berry pie. The pies consistently taste delicious and come highly praised for their quality.

Large indoor deli offers full-sized Italian Hoagies priced around $18. The market includes a garden area and a farm store alongside the deli.

People are saying

"I thought the pies were awesome and tasty."

"It's amazing for the kids."

"I was confused by the multiple options for an Italian Hoagie at the deli."

Good to know

1

The market closes at 6 pm.

2

Parking is easy at the market.

3

They offer many activities for children, including a hay ride.

03
Giancarlo's Bakery image 1

Old school Italian bakery with crowded interior and outdoor seating offers a variety of baked breads, meat pastries, and entrees. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and no-nonsense, attracting those seeking authentic Italian flavors. The place is known for top-quality pastries and cakes with a neighborhood vibe.

Lemon meringue pie stands out as a highlight. The bakery offers an excellent selection of pies including apple pie that surpasses typical grocery store versions.

Top quality Italian deli products stand out here. The deli section offers a nice variety alongside pastries and frozen dinners that maintain consistent quality.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be delicious and beautifully done."

"I loved their baked goods and pastries; the crumb buns were wonderful."

"I found they had an excellent selection of pies and cakes."

Good to know

1

Giancarlo's Bakery offers a variety of baked goods, including cakes, pies, and pastries.

2

Most items are baked in-house, ensuring freshness and quality.

3

The bakery has a deli section with sandwiches, wraps, and breakfast options.

04
Big Rocs Deli image 1

Clean, modern deli with cafeteria-style seating and arcade games creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Conversations fill the space, making it loud and lively. Decor includes art displays and a large flat panel TV for entertainment.

Bean pies stand out here, made fresh daily and priced around six dollars. They pair well with sandwiches and salads, offering a delicious, homemade taste.

Huge deli sandwiches feature turkey, roast beef, and Swiss with a clean, warm setting. The mini pastrami with Russian and slaw and Tuna Fish recall classic flavors with an upscale vibe.

People are saying

"The food here is really good and smoked to perfection."

"The deli sandwiches here are huge and delicious."

"I found the bean pie here to be very good."

Good to know

1

All toppings are free with your sandwich order.

2

They charge extra for coleslaw and Russian dressing, at $1.50 each.

3

One sandwich could feed two people.

05
Pinho's Bakery image 1

Bakery offers a large covered patio and a few indoor tables with sunlit glass roof creating a calming atmosphere. Shelves display fresh-made breads and a wide variety of confectionery and desserts. The vibe feels like a warm, community-focused family joint with a sense of culture and comfort.

Many pies like apple crumble, peach tart, and custard are available. The selection includes mini desserts and other baked goods.

An inviting atmosphere feels more like a welcoming home than a traditional deli. The deli side offers classic sandwiches and breakfast platters elevated to an art form with great quality deli items and fresh baked goods.

People are saying

"I found this bakery to be the best I could go to."

"I loved their peach tart pies and other sweet treats."

"You have to try the Natas at this Deli; they're the best."

Good to know

1

They make fresh egg tarts every hour, perfect for a quick treat.

2

Complimentary parking is available, but it is limited.

3

Pinho's Bakery offers a wide selection of baked goods, including pastries and sandwiches.

06
Hinck's Turkey Farm image 1

Dining room combines old antique look with cozy, home-like atmosphere and patriotic charm. Large space offers both indoor table seating and outdoor picnic tables. Self-service deli features freshly made turkey dishes and traditional farm sweets.

Pot pies stand out with their legendary reputation and make a solid dinner choice. The Strawberry Rhubarb pie offers a sweet, traditional finish alongside other farm-style desserts like honey.

Fantastic deli-style counter service offers both hot and cold food. Fresh deli sandwiches, cold cuts, salads, and bread fill the self-service deli section, along with deli desserts.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious turkey dinner with stuffing and gravy."

"You have to try the homemade pies; they're delicious."

"The deli's home-cooked sides and fresh sandwiches are delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required six weeks in advance for holiday dinners.

2

Expect long lines and wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Credit card payments incur an extra 3% fee, so consider cash for larger orders.

07
Forked River German Butcher Shop image 1

Old-school butcher shop with a huge selection of fresh meats, prepared foods, and bakery items creates a busy but efficient atmosphere. Customers come from far away for quality cuts and ready-to-eat meals. The space combines traditional charm with a well-organized layout.

Chicken pot pies come in a large size and are served hot. They have a baked crust and are often described as delicious, though some find them bland and suggest adding thyme for more flavor.

Offers an incredible selection of prepared foods, deli meats, cheeses, and sides. Includes a deli and baked goods with wholesome German deli vibes. Prices run slightly higher but match the quality and serving sizes.

People are saying

"This Lunch Spot has delicious, ready-to-go meals and fresh salads."

"I found a wonderful variety of desserts here."

"The deli has a huge selection of fresh meats, cheeses, and prepared foods."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a huge variety of meats, breads, pastries, and prepared foods.

2

They have a bakery with fresh breads and desserts available daily.

3

Quality food is offered at fair prices, proportional to serving sizes.

08
Stew Leonard's Farm Fresh Food & Wine image 1

Maze-like layout guides shoppers through every department, creating a unique flow. Animatronics like singing avocados and dancing cows add a playful, family-friendly vibe. Integrated wine and liquor section blends seamlessly with fresh food offerings, enhancing the lively atmosphere.

Fresh pies come in full or half sizes, with the clerk willing to split pies to offer different flavors. Pecan pie stands out as a consistent choice, paired often with cheese popcorn.

Deli offers a wide variety of fresh turkey that tastes like it came straight off the bird. Grab chicken sandwiches ready to go from the warmer for a quick bite.

People are saying

"This grocery store felt like a theme park with lively animations."

"I loved the delicious pies, especially the coconut custard."

"The chicken sandwiches from the Deli were so good."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide variety of fresh produce, meats, and baked goods.

2

Parking is ample and easily accessible for shoppers.

3

Prepared foods may not look fresh after 6pm.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...