Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New Jersey's best

Everything bagels and muffins

You want a bakery that can handle a savory everything bagel just as well as a sweet muffin.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Island Heights Bagelry image 1
Island Heights Bagelry image 2
Island Heights Bagelry image 3
View all

Spacious bagel shop with clean, modern decor and comfortable seating creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. The vibe suits both quick bites and remote work sessions. Bagels are fresh and authentic, drawing a crowd that appreciates quality and care.

Muffins come fluffy and moist with a good amount of rich chocolate chips. The double chocolate muffin stands out as a flavorful option often shared as a sample.

Everything bagels come with cream cheese or used as sandwich bread for items like Pastrami and Club sandwiches. Options include toasted or not toasted, paired with toppings like nova and capers or breakfast items.

People are saying

"The bagels here are served by such friendly and welcoming staff."

"Their French toast muffin was light, fluffy, and perfectly sweet."

"The Everything Bagel here is perfectly crispy and chewy."

Good to know

1

Ample parking space is available at the shop.

2

They offer a wide selection of bagels and sandwiches.

3

Prices are reasonable, with sandwiches averaging around $10.

02
Hot & Toasty Bagels LLC image 1

Bagel shop with fresh, high-quality bagels and a busy, welcoming atmosphere. Space feels cute with clean tables but can get crowded and awkward due to layout. Popular spot known for family-friendly vibe and long lines.

Corn muffins come toasted with butter and taste very fresh. Muffins pair well with breakfast sandwiches like bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel.

Everything bagels come with a very flavorful mix of toppings. Options include whole wheat and plain, often enjoyed with butter and coffee. Buying a dozen is common.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"I found the everything bagel so flavorful and delicious."

"The muffins here are so yummy and fresh."

Good to know

1

Order ahead to avoid long wait times.

2

Prices of items are not displayed clearly.

3

They offer soy and almond milk in addition to regular milk.

03
Poppy Bagels & More image 1

Bright, clean bakery with plenty of seating and a local feel offers a unique vibe and killer presentation. Music plays consistently, creating a lively atmosphere. Bagels stand out as perfectly baked and high-quality, attracting a steady flow of customers throughout the day.

Blueberry and poppy seed muffins come out tasty and fresh. Muffins share the spotlight with homemade poptarts that look just as good.

Everything bagels come with a great amount of seasoning that stands out. Options include toasted with chive cream cheese or topped with egg whites, sausage, and pepperjack cheese.

People are saying

"These bagels are probably the best I've had outside of North Jersey."

"The bagels here are always fresh and delicious."

"This Everything Bagel is the closest New Jersey bagel I found."

Good to know

1

Call ahead for faster ordering, especially during busy hours.

2

Expect wait times of over 15 minutes for a dozen bagels.

3

Prices for bagels are generally affordable, around $10 each.

04
Gabe’s Bagels image 1

Bagel shop combines old deli feel with a clean, cozy atmosphere and a self-serve coffee bar. Bright environment features a transparent kitchen and friendly energy from staff. Bagels are fresh and flavorful, often selling out early due to popularity.

Freshly made muffins include an Oreo muffin that stands out. Staff sometimes offer a free muffin for birthdays. Muffins pair well with other baked goods like bagels.

The everything bagel comes with cream cheese and lox or can be paired with sausage and cheese. It offers a classic flavor that many find tasteful and phenomenal, though opinions vary.

People are saying

"I thought these were the best bagels I've ever had."

"The fresh, flavorful muffins here are the best I ever had."

"The Everything Bagel here is so welcoming and friendly."

Good to know

1

They often run out of popular bagels like cinnamon raisin by 10:30am on Sundays.

2

Expect higher prices; they charge significantly more than nearby bagel shops.

3

The shop has cleanliness issues that may affect your experience.

05
Jersey Joe's Bagels & Deli image 1

Small shop with cozy, homely interior and clean, cheerful atmosphere. Friendly energy fills the space, drawing a steady flow of locals who appreciate fresh, top-quality bagels and sandwiches. The vibe reflects a quintessential small-town deli loved for its welcoming feel and great food.

Many varieties of muffins are available alongside bagels and beverages. Muffins come freshly made and pair well with other pastries and sandwiches.

Egg everything bagels come with olive cream cheese and have a decent size. They rank among the top three in freshness and taste.

People are saying

"I thought their bagels were the best in the area."

"I ate the whole Everything Bagel plain, it was so good."

"I thought the bagels were delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

Prices for bagels and sandwiches are very reasonable.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere during weekend mornings.

06
Henry's Bagel Cafe image 1

Bright, spacious bagel shop with clean, modern interior and plenty of seating. Atmosphere feels warm and cozy, welcoming a steady flow of locals. Known for fresh, high-quality bagels and a friendly, family-run vibe.

Homemade muffins come in different flavors, including a corn muffin. They pair well with homemade soups and breakfast items like omelettes and bagels.

Everything bagels come with varied toppings like lox and cream cheese or bacon and egg cheddar. They have a light seed coverage and serve as a base for items like chicken salad and home fries.

People are saying

"I found their bagels to be the best in town."

"I loved the delicious homemade muffins."

"I found the Everything Bagel to be delicious and healthy."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers online ordering for easy pickup.

2

Expect a busy atmosphere during weekend mornings.

3

Parking is convenient and available nearby.

07
Bagel Co. image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop offers a super clean and bright interior with a simple, chill vibe and background Bachata and Reggaeton music. The atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, attracting those looking for fresh, flavorful breakfast sandwiches and a variety of bagel toppings.

Blueberry muffins come fresh and can be served toasted. Extra charges apply for additional requests with muffins.

Everything bagels come with a balanced mix of toppings that is not too heavy. Options include toasted with veggie cream cheese, whole wheat with peanut butter, and sandwiches with egg, cheese, or bacon.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the best I ever had."

"The Everything Bagel is fresh, hot, and delicious."

"They even offered toasted muffins."

Good to know

1

The facility is super clean.

2

The prices at Bagel Co. are fair and affordable.

3

There are many spreads available for bagels.

08
The Bagel Store image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop run by three grandmothers offers fresh, flavorful bagels and affordable prices. The atmosphere is casual with quick service through a walk-up window. Options include muffins and crumb cake alongside classic deli items.

Muffins come made in house with a crispy top and moist bottom. The butter corn muffin stands out, and muffins arrive in a cute box.

Everything bagels come with a rich mix of toppings that add bold flavor. Sandwiches like bacon, sausage, egg, and cheese or BLT with chipotle mayo use the bagel as a toasted, hearty base. On Saturdays, everything bagels have lighter toppings than usual.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be fresh and delicious."

"The Everything Bagel is made in house, crispy on top, and moist below."

"The muffins are made in-house, crispy on top and moist."

Good to know

1

Ordering online is quick and easy through their website.

2

Expect to wait at least an hour for your order.

3

Prices are affordable, with a deal for 5 bagels and cream cheese for $10.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...