Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New Jersey

Italian grocery stores

Made for those who prefer to source authentic Italian ingredients directly from the grocery store shelves.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated July 2026
01
il Mercato Holmdel image 1
il Mercato Holmdel image 2
il Mercato Holmdel image 3
View all
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store combines modern design with an old market feel in a clean, charming space. Atmosphere stays friendly and relaxed, with a small picnic area for casual dining. It draws a steady crowd seeking quality and freshness in a neat, updated setting.

Fresh bread and house-made mozzarella stand out alongside the CPV sandwich with chicken cutlet, prosciutto, and vodka sauce. Pasta dishes like eggplant pasta and cold deli pastas offer solid Italian flavors, while catering includes items like crab stuffed mushrooms and pasta purses.

Offers a modern restaurant vibe with an old market feel. Features a great Italian deli and market selection.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

"I thought their Italian food was amazing, especially the pasta."

"This grocery store's Italian sandwiches and stuffed breads are delicious."

Good to know

1

Il Mercato offers an extensive catering menu for events like Sunday football and holidays.

2

Prices are very reasonable for the quality of food offered.

3

The portion size of sandwiches is great for the price.

02
Angelo's Italian Market image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store offers homemade sandwiches with perfectly sliced cold cuts and high-quality fresh mozzarella. Atmosphere feels like a family-owned deli with a focus on premium products and convenient parking.

Sandwiches feature fresh mozzarella and Italian bread of good quality, with options like meatballs, chicken parmigiana, and a chicken cutlet sub with balsamic and bruschetta instead of roasted red peppers. Pasta salads exist but have hard, not al dente pasta.

Freshly prepared foods stand out with incredible quality and amazing subs. Specialty groceries fill the shelves, and the staff keeps the vibe friendly and welcoming.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing and delicious."

"I thought their Italian food made the best sandwiches."

"I believe this Italian market is the best in the area."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the back of the market for easy access.

2

They charge separately for bags, so consider bringing your own.

3

Everything in the market is homemade, ensuring fresh quality.

03
Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace image 1

Gigantic supermarket with Italian music and live singers creates a lively, festive atmosphere. Spacious, bright layout features artistic food displays and a variety of specialty counters like bakery, pizzeria, and sushi bar. Crowded and busy, it offers an immersive Italian market experience with fresh aromas and free samples.

Fresh made pasta and ravioli stand out with their quality. The store offers a wide variety of Italian staples like ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic rolls, plus sauces, soups, and pastries.

Offers a superb Italian market experience with a wide selection of groceries and specialty trays. Staff provide great customer service in a vibrant, welcoming environment.

People are saying

"This Italian grocery store has amazing prepared foods and specialty items."

"I loved the bakery and the fresh mozzarella here."

"Their fresh pasta and marinara sauce are delicious."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays and Fridays, enjoy 2 pizzas for $22.

2

After 7:30 PM, hot and cold subs and hot bar items are half price.

3

Fish fry specials on Wednesdays and Fridays include fish and chips and fried calamari.

04
IL Porcellino Italian Market image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store offers authentic imported meats and cheeses with a friendly, homey atmosphere. Generous portions and freshly made pastas and desserts create a taste of Italy. Sandwiches, especially cheesesteaks and pork, stand out for their high quality and large size.

Freshly made pastas and desserts sit alongside a wide deli case with high quality Prosciutto and Mortadella. Sandwiches like chicken parmesan and Italian varieties come on crusty bread with crispy, tender chicken and rich sauce. Cannolis feature a crispy shell and creamy filling with balanced sweetness.

Offers a wide selection of authentic Italian products including imported meats, cheeses, and pasta. Features a clean market with a deli case serving hot and cold sandwiches and options for family-style meals and catering.

People are saying

"These hidden gems are award-winning heaven, truly mouthwatering."

"These Italian Food sandwiches are packed and taste incredible."

"The pizza steak at this Grocery Store is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer a variety of hot and cold sandwiches made to order.

2

Catering services are available for events with options for 10-12 people.

3

The deli case features items like stuffed artichokes, mortadella, and cannolis.

05
The Food Emporium image 1

Wide aisles and full accessible features create an open, convenient shopping environment. Cleanliness and organization stand out throughout the store, supporting a calm and efficient pace. High-quality deli and fresh produce attract shoppers seeking premium meats, bakery items, and specialty platters.

Fresh mozzarella stands out alongside eggplant bowtie pasta salad, a clear favorite. Sides like String Beans Almondine and Eggplant Rollatini come in generous portions and taste great.

Modern grocery store offers a wide variety of products with good quality and clean aisles. Prices stay lower than local Italian markets while keeping the same taste.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the eggplant parm and pasta, was fresh and delicious."

"This grocery store's fresh mozzarella is a standout."

"The food for the party was amazing, everyone raved about it."

Good to know

1

The store is clean and well organized, making shopping easy.

2

Parking is available and convenient for customers.

3

They offer a variety of high-quality fresh produce and bakery items.

06
Durazzos Italian Market image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store offers an immersive cultural experience with warm aromas of freshly baked bread, cheeses, and cured meats. Shelves hold a phenomenal selection of authentic Italian goods, while deli counters serve loaded sandwiches praised for their quality and flavor. Family-run atmosphere creates a homey vibe that feels welcoming and genuine.

Fresh mozzarella and jumbo mozzarella sticks stand out, with the sticks recommended in pairs. Italian cold cuts like prosciutto and provolone come with a delicately fried egg on toasted bread. Pasta selections pair well with fresh baked Italian bread, and the tiramisu is soaked in rum.

Offers an authentic Italian experience with a wide selection of aged cheeses, cured meats, and freshly baked goods. Functions as a one-stop shop for butcher, produce, groceries, and sandwiches, run by a family that values quality and tradition.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"This Italian grocery store offers an authentic experience with amazing imported foods."

"I found the most authentic Italian food and deli selections here."

Good to know

1

The market offers a wide selection of authentic Italian goods.

2

Fresh mozzarella is available, but check for proper storage.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is recommended for smaller purchases.

07
Violante's Meat Market image 1
Butcher shop deli

Butcher shop deli combines freshly baked bread, prime meats, and homemade prepared dishes in a modern, clean space. The atmosphere feels like an authentic Italian market with a strong family tradition. Customers find a diverse selection of bakery items and quality cuts of meat all under one roof.

Chicken trays, roast beef, and homemade sausage stand out alongside pastas. The tomato and mozzarella salad and a chicken cutlet sandwich with red peppers and mozzarella add fresh, classic Italian flavors. Mortadella, rice balls, and cheese are also available for takeout.

Specialty market offers quality meats, a deli, bakery, and imported packaged goods. Service stands out as exceptional for meat enthusiasts.

People are saying

"You have to try the sandwiches at this deli; they're loaded with flavor."

"The Bakery staff are so welcoming and helpful, they make you feel like family."

"The Italian food here is fantastic, truly delicious."

Good to know

1

Violante's offers daily sandwich specials and take-out dinner packages for four.

2

Expect to pay around $10 for a small sub, which is considered worth it.

3

Violante's is known for its superior cuts of meat compared to grocery stores.

08
D'Angelo Italian Market of Freehold image 1

Italian grocery store offers an impressive selection of authentic Italian products and fresh prepared foods. The atmosphere is quiet and friendly, attracting regulars who appreciate quality and care. Sandwiches and homemade mozzarella stand out as distinctive, flavorful highlights.

Homemade mozzarella stands out with rich flavor. Chicken Parmesan comes with a full plate of spaghetti and a chicken wing. Sandwiches like the Freddieโ€™s Finest and Alexandra hero feature mozzarella cheese and flavorful sauces. Cannoli desserts arrive in beautifully presented trays and are a favorite finish to meals.

Offers a great selection of Italian products including specialty foods like cookies, sauces, meats, sausage, and chicken cutlets. Operates as a local family owned market with extremely generous portions.

People are saying

"This grocery store has amazing sandwiches and authentic Italian goods."

"They delivered our Super Bowl spread right on time."

"The Italian Food cannoli tray was beautifully decorated and loved by guests."

Good to know

1

D'Angelo's offers a BBQ package for 20 people that can feed over 40.

2

Catering orders include paper plates and utensils only with the party package.

3

The food quality is consistently praised by customers.

09
Lenny's Silverton Market image 1

Huge deli and old school butcher shop combine with a small bakery to create a family-friendly atmosphere. Clean, well-organized space features a train display overhead and offers an insane meat selection alongside fresh salads and sandwiches. Friendly interactions give the market a neighborhood feel that stands out in the area.

Cold cuts stand out with tender texture and fresh mozzarella paired with roasted peppers in oil and vinegar. The freezer holds a huge assortment of raviolis, pasta combos, and homemade sauces. Italian sausage and imported pasta add to the authentic selection.

Offers a unique mix of butcher shop, bakery, and market with a wide selection of grocery items. Known for high-quality meats like beef, sausage, chicken, and hot dogs, plus fresh-made sandwiches and reasonable prices.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are huge and packed with flavor."

"This grocery store has amazing, fresh meat that's always tender."

"Their Italian subs are overstuffed with fresh-sliced goodies."

Good to know

1

Lenny's Silverton Market offers unique items not found elsewhere.

2

The market is known for its quality meats and fresh baked goods.

3

Expect a narrow parking lot, which can be challenging during busy times.

10
J&S Pork Store image 1
Italian restaurant

Old-school Italian deli vibe fills the space with a homely atmosphere and family-like energy. The place feels like a bodega with a chaotic but welcoming flow from ordering to payment. Italian specialties and fresh semolina sandwiches stand out as key features.

Fresh Italian cuisine shines with excellent mortadella, incredible fresh mozzarella, and homemade ricotta. Dishes like chicken parmesan and eggplant parmesan stand out, alongside Italian groceries and braciole.

Italian groceries stand out with homemade ricotta and mozzarella. The store also offers a great Italian deli selection including braciole.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the fresh mozzarella, is so good."

"I thought the sandwiches here were amazing and overstuffed."

"The prepared foods at this grocery store are so fresh and beautiful."

Good to know

1

The Tripe is part of a Wednesday special.

2

Parking is available in the back of the store.

3

They sell homemade ricotta and mozzarella.

11
Jerry's Gourmet and More image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Old school Italian market with an authentic deli vibe and quirky charm. Offers an extensive cheese room with samples and a wide selection of European gourmet foods. Busy atmosphere with long waits during peak times.

Offers a wide variety of Italian specialty products like coffees, chocolates, cheeses, and imported pastas. Includes prepared soups, salads, pasta dishes, and gourmet items such as cheese, seasonings, and desserts.

Offers a wide selection of Italian groceries and wines. Features authentic Italian market items alongside eclectic foods and meats from both sides of the Atlantic.

People are saying

"I loved the amazing selection of European and Italian foods here."

"You'll find amazing Italian food, especially the cheeses and cured meats."

"This Italian grocery store is like finding hidden gems from Italy."

Good to know

1

They always host tastings at Jerry's Gourmet and More.

2

The store offers a wide variety of Italian specialty products, including cheeses and imported pastas.

3

Expect long wait times during lunch hours due to high customer volume.

12
Cafasso's Fairway Market image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Narrow aisles create a claustrophobic feel despite an authentic hometown vibe. High-quality Italian specialty foods and fresh produce define the selection, with a strong focus on cheeses, meats, and seafood. Prices tend to be on the higher side, reflecting the gourmet market atmosphere.

Fresh mozzarella and authentic Italian prosciuttos stand out here. The deli offers classic lasagna, tiramisu, and a variety of antipasti alongside prepared dishes like pasta, veal, and grilled shrimp.

Offers a wide variety of fresh produce, top-notch meats, and a plethora of cheese. Staff treat you like a friend and the market has an authentic hometown vibe.

People are saying

"This grocery store has an amazing selection of fresh produce and top-notch meats."

"I found the fresh mozzarella and other Italian foods here to be the best."

"The prepared foods at this Market are extensive and beautifully presented."

Good to know

1

Cafasso's Fairway Market offers a wide selection of fresh produce and meats.

2

There is only one handicap parking spot available at the back of the market.

3

Expect a sticky floor and narrow aisles during busy shopping times.

13
Monmouth Market image 1
Grocery store

Fresh mozzarella is made in the middle of the store, creating a hands-on food experience. Shelves hold semolina bread and sub sandwiches known for quality. Pricing includes a cash discount, and the atmosphere is clean and local-focused.

Fresh mozzarella gets made right in the middle of the store and pairs well with roasted peppers. Fresh cold cuts and pasta salads add variety, with mozzarella sticks standing out as a popular choice.

Offers a very clean shopping environment with a selection of semolina bread noted for quality. Prices tend to be a bit high but the store carries nice items worth over $50 in purchases.

People are saying

"I found the prepared food here to be excellent."

"I loved the fresh mozzarella and semolina bread at this grocery store."

"The fresh mozzarella here is amazing with roasted peppers."

Good to know

1

Expect to find a cash discount available for purchases.

2

The mozzarella is half price on Mondays.

3

Payment by cash can save you money compared to card payments.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...