Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New Jersey

Ice cream cakes

You know that an ice cream cake is the only acceptable way to mark a special occasion.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Caputo’s Homemade Ice Cream image 1
Caputo’s Homemade Ice Cream image 2
Caputo’s Homemade Ice Cream image 3
View all

Ice cream shop offers an endless variety of homemade flavors including gluten-free and vegan options. Friendly atmosphere with inviting decor and music from a DJ creates a welcoming vibe. Prices remain reasonable despite high quality and rich, creamy texture.

Homemade ice cream offers a wide selection of flavors including dairy-free and no sugar added options. The ice cream cakes are also popular and well made.

Custom half-sheet ice cream cakes come in solid sizes. The cakes have a homemade quality and taste good.

People are saying

"The homemade ice cream here is insanely creamy and super flavorful."

"The ice cream cake here is delicious and beautifully decorated."

"This ice cream cake was really good and delicious."

Good to know

1

Caputo’s offers an incredible variety of homemade ice cream flavors.

2

They have gluten-free and vegan options available.

3

Prices at Caputo’s are very reasonable for homemade ice cream.

02
The Towne Scoop image 1
Ice cream shop

Small town ice cream shop with a hometown vibe and simple, cute design. Offers soft serve and custom ice cream cakes with a variety of flavors and toppings. Atmosphere feels personal, often managed by the owner, creating a friendly, local experience.

Offers a wide variety of flavors including standout options like salted caramel and chocolate peanut butter. Known for ice cream cakes and soft serve that taste fresh and homemade.

Ice cream cakes come in traditional and custom-made flavors with options to add extra crunchies in the middle. They work well for birthdays and holidays, offering a delicious treat.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is fantastic and delicious."

"Their ice cream cakes are delicious and beautifully designed."

"The ice cream cakes here are delicious and guests raved about them."

Good to know

1

The Towne Scoop offers traditional and custom-made ice cream flavors.

2

Prices at The Towne Scoop are reasonable for ice cream.

3

The takeout window is managed by the owner or manager.

03
Carvel image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers great variety of flavors and creamy soft serve with generous toppings. Interior feels dated, but outdoor seating is clean and spacious with plenty of parking. Prices stay affordable, and wait times remain short even when busy.

Soft serve ice cream stands out with creamy texture and variety of flavors like strawberry and pumpkin pie. Dairy-free options made with Oatly cater to vegans, and ice cream cakes offer a tasty alternative.

Ice cream cakes feature smooth texture and professional writing on top. The overall quality of the ice cream and cakes is consistently very good.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so creamy and delicious."

"The ice-cream cakes here are delicious and the kids loved it."

"I thought the ice cream cake was very good."

Good to know

1

Most of the time, the waiting time at Carvel is not very long.

2

Carvel offered good deals on Wednesdays.

3

They had plenty of parking and outdoor tables.

04
Piece of Cake - Gourmet Gelatos, Ice Creams & Sorbets image 1

Shop sits tucked behind a house, accessible by a path and marked by a red lit sign. Atmosphere is quiet and focused on takeout, with no seating available. Known for fresh, high-quality gelato and sorbets, it draws people seeking unique flavors and homemade desserts.

Freshness stands out with fresh fruit sorbets and quality gelatos. Ice cream cakes and unique flavors like Peanut Butter and tiramisu offer rich variety.

Top-tier variety ice cream cakes draw family approval. The cakes combine rich flavors and textures that make them a consistent hit.

People are saying

"I found the homemade ice cream to be incredibly delicious."

"Their ice cream and desserts are homemade with superb ingredients."

"My family loved the ice cream cake."

Good to know

1

This place only accepts cash payments.

2

You can't eat inside; it's a to-go only shop.

3

No pre-ordering is necessary; you can pick up items directly.

05
Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream image 1

Small ice cream shop with natural light and benches inside and outside offers a quiet, welcoming atmosphere. Unique Asian-inspired flavors like Lychee, Taro, and Ube stand out alongside rich, creamy homemade ice cream. Sampling is allowed, and seating can get cramped during busy times.

Black sesame, green tea matcha, and homemade Thai tea stand out as unique ice cream flavors. The ice cream quality is consistently phenomenal with options like ice cream cakes available.

Offers 12-inch ice cream cakes with cute designs that taste as good as they look. Cakes suit gatherings and special occasions.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are so unique and delicious."

"The milk tea and lychee flavors were spot on."

"The ice cream flavors here are amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

There is free parking at Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream.

2

They offered unique flavors such as Lychee, Taro, and Ube.

3

The pricing is very affordable, making it a great after-dinner treat.

06
Cold Stone Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with a huge outdoor seating area and a clean, well-organized space creates a welcoming atmosphere. The vibe is busy and lively, supported by friendly staff and a pleasant scent inside. It draws a great crowd enjoying top-quality, flavorful ice cream and impressive ice cream cakes.

Signature ice cream creations offer fantastic flavor and great value compared to supermarket pints. Friendly, patient staff craft ice cream exactly how you want, and the ice cream cakes impress both kids and adults.

Ice cream cakes come in a huge variety and are made fresh daily. They impress both kids and adults with their delicious and top notch quality.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was fantastic and amazing."

"Their ice cream cakes are truly outstanding and delicious."

"The ice cream here is so delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Portion sizes may be smaller than other locations, so consider ordering extra.

3

The shop maintains a clean and welcoming environment for families.

07
Nasto's Ice Cream Co. — Old World Desserts image 1

Old school ice cream shop with old world charm and sidewalk tables offers a variety of fresh, unique flavors with a creamy, rich texture. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, supported by a community that values tradition and quality.

Homemade ice cream features strong natural flavors and a rich aroma that welcomes you immediately. Quality stays consistently top-notch with a variety of delicious options.

Layers of vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry combine with a nutty chocolate syrup center in the ice cream cakes. Prices stay reasonable while flavor and consistency remain delicious and consistent.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was just amazing."

"The owners' care makes this ice cream shop feel so welcoming."

"Their ice cream cakes are amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is only available on the street, so plan accordingly.

2

They allow customers to sample flavors before choosing, which is helpful for undecided visitors.

3

Credit card payments incur an extra charge, so bring cash if possible.

08
Scoops Ice Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Old-fashioned ice cream shop offers broad flavor selection with both hard and soft serve options. Comfortable seating includes outdoor areas with plentiful parking nearby. Atmosphere feels friendly and relaxed, attracting families and locals alike.

In-house made ice cream offers a creamy texture with balanced sweetness. The selection includes soft serve vegan hazelnut, ice cream cakes with no dry filler, pies, and sandwiches, all at fair prices.

Ice cream cakes come with two flavor choices and feature no dry cake filler, made entirely of ice cream. Decorations are beautiful, and the texture includes extra crunchies for added bite.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream here was delicious."

"It's so kid friendly, my kids loved the ice cream and choices."

"I thought the ice cream cake tasted so fresh and was perfect."

Good to know

1

Scoops Ice Creamery offers a variety of custards and other desserts.

2

Non-dairy options are available for customers with dietary restrictions.

3

Parking is plentiful on site.

09
Shivers Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers large portions with generous toppings and a wide variety of flavors including unique options. Atmosphere is fun and inclusive, creating a positive and humorous vibe. Pricing remains affordable despite inflation, making it a popular spot for quality ice cream and cakes.

Homemade ice cream comes in large portions that offer great value for the price. Staff show expertise in flavors and provide friendly, knowledgeable service.

A wide variety of ready-to-go ice cream cakes is always available. The selection includes soft serve, toppings, and milkshakes alongside the cakes.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is delicious and amazing."

"The ice cream shop's flavors, like SpongeBob, were delicious and brought back happy memories."

"I found the ice cream cake here to be my favorite."

Good to know

1

Shivers Ice Cream offers a wide variety of soft serve, toppings, milkshakes, and ice cream cakes.

2

Everything is big here, and they don't cheap out on sprinkles or toppings.

3

Since it’s located inside a plaza, parking is very convenient.

10
Twist Ice Cream Shop image 1
Ice cream shop

Small ice cream shop with quirky pricing and a local landmark feel. Atmosphere is clean and cute, attracting families and ice cream lovers. Known for custom ice cream cakes and a unique dog bakery corner.

Custom ice cream cakes feature amazing decoration and come both ready-made and made to order. The ice cream itself is consistently delicious and refreshing, with options like malt shakes made from hard ice cream.

Custom ice cream cakes feature detailed decorations like the Aerosmith logo and taste delicious. Both made-to-order and ready-made options offer great flavor and add a special touch to any occasion.

People are saying

"The custom ice cream cakes here are beautifully decorated and delicious."

"I was blown away by the creativity of the custom ice cream cake decorator."

"Emilia's excellent service restored my hope in the industry."

Good to know

1

Twists offers a quirky pricing system that can be fun to figure out.

2

Two small Sundays and two medium Sundays cost less than $30.

3

Twists has been a local landmark in Ramtown for many years.

11
Colonia Dairy Maid image 1
Ice cream shop

Tiny ice cream shop with retro exterior and colorful decor creates a nostalgic vibe. Outdoor seating includes benches and picnic tables that fill quickly, reflecting its neighborhood charm. Known for homemade ice cream with many flavors, it operates as a takeout-only spot with an onsite ATM.

Creamy texture and balanced sweetness define the ice cream here. The shop offers hard ice cream, bubblegum flavor, and ice cream cakes like Salted Caramel Pretzel that stand out.

Ice cream cakes come with extra fudge inside and are custom-made in various sizes. Staff answer questions patiently and prices stay reasonable.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best in Jersey."

"The staff's friendly service made getting my ice cream cake easy."

"It's so Kid Friendly; my kids loved the ice cream flavors."

Good to know

1

This is takeout only with no seating inside.

2

The establishment only accepts cash; an ATM is available on-site.

3

In the summer, it gets crowded, so expect to wait in line.

12
Uncle Louie G's @ The Downtown Parlor image 1

Bright, clean space with a cozy, old-school vibe creates a welcoming atmosphere. Family-friendly environment includes table games and space for parties, making it a joyful spot to hang out. Unique Italian ice flavors and amazing ice cream set it apart from other shops.

Ice cream here hits a perfect spot between soft serve and hard ice cream, offering a unique texture. Classic Italian ices and creamy flavors like Dubai Chocolate stand out for their rich taste.

Ice cream cakes here taste delicious and get positive reactions from everyone. Options include individual cups and cakes, making it easy for kids and adults to enjoy while hanging out.

People are saying

"The owner truly cares about making your ice cream experience special."

"The owner Mike is so patient and genuinely excited to make sure kids have fun."

"Mike made us feel welcome while explaining the Ice Cream Cake."

Good to know

1

The store has new owners and has been updated recently.

2

There is plenty of seating available to enjoy the ice cream.

3

The variety of flavors includes fruity ices like Cherry and Lemon, and indulgent ones like Bubble Gum.

13
Sundaes The Ice Cream Place image 1

Old school ice cream shop with homemade ice cream and a wide selection of flavors including creative and classic options. Lively atmosphere with benches outside but limited indoor seating. Known for exceptional quality and consistent service across locations.

Creamy ice cream comes in a wide selection of flavors including vegan vanilla soft serve. The menu also features ice cream cakes and pies alongside sundaes and toppings.

Great selection of vanilla chocolate and fudge with crunch ice cream cakes. Family enjoys the flavors, though prices are a bit high.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is amazing, the best I've ever had."

"The manager personally made our ice cream cake, decorating it to avoid cross-contamination."

"I really enjoyed their great ice cream cakes."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during summer, especially on weekends.

2

The small cup of ice cream costs a little over $5.

3

Large ice creams are priced at $8.60 each.

14
Mia’s ice cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers impressive variety with seasonal specialties and ice cream cakes. Atmosphere is casual with options like waffle bowls and generous cookie portions in ice cream. Prices stay reasonable compared to similar places.

Ice cream features rich and creamy flavors with an impressive variety including seasonal specialties. Cookies are generous, and prices stay reasonable compared to other shops.

Offers a good variety of ice cream cakes alongside cookies and ice cream. Ice cream cakes have a creamy texture and come in multiple flavors.

People are saying

"The ice cream staff here is so friendly and fast."

"I enjoyed the ice cream cake."

"I enjoyed the ice cream cake."

Good to know

1

Mia’s ice cream offers a good variety of ice cream, cookies, and ice cream cakes.

2

Mia’s ice cream has numerous flavors and seasonal specialties.

3

Prices at Mia’s ice cream are reasonable compared to other shops.

15
Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop image 1

Ice cream shop offers diverse flavors with both homemade hard and soft serve ice cream. Bright, fun throwback decor includes painted tables and dripping seats, creating a lively, welcoming atmosphere where kids often run around. Small outdoor seating complements the clean, friendly indoor space.

Soft serve stands out with its rich and creamy texture, not filled with air like others. The ice cream offers a wide variety of flavors, including unique options like pumpkin twist and coffee with Heath bits.

Beautiful ice cream cakes come in a large selection, including a cookie ice cream cake option. Some find the cakes just okay and not worth the price compared to other menus.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best around."

"They have so many delicious cookie and ice cream flavors."

"I chose an amazing cookie ice cream cake for a birthday."

Good to know

1

Coney Waffle offers a large selection of hard and soft serve ice cream.

2

There are many dairy-free flavors available at Coney Waffle.

3

The shop has a drive-thru for convenient service.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...