Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Italian pepperoni pizza in New Jersey

You want the craft of an Italian kitchen focused entirely on the execution of a pepperoni pizza.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Amadeo Pizzeria image 1
Amadeo Pizzeria image 2
Amadeo Pizzeria image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Brick oven defines the kitchen, creating a cozy, charming ambiance inside with a renovated, clean space. Outdoor seating and a beautiful backyard area offer a relaxed spot for gatherings. The atmosphere feels pleasant and family-oriented, with background music enhancing the vibe.

Pizza features a perfectly crispy crust, rich sauce, and fresh mozzarella. Pasta options like alfredo with chicken, cheese ravioli, and sausage pasta offer strong flavors. Calamari, burrata salad, and delicious cannolis add variety to the menu.

Hot vodka and hot honey add unique twists to the pepperoni pizza here. Classic pepperoni pizzas come with a satisfying, straightforward flavor.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and delicious."

"The pizza here is cooked to perfection with a crisp crust."

"This Grandma's pie is crispy, thin, and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

Amadeo Pizzeria is a BYOB establishment, so bring your favorite drinks.

2

The pizzeria offers a convenient parking lot across the street.

3

Expect generous portions for the price you pay.

02
Pizzeria 'Lucci image 1
Pizza restaurant

Bright, minimalistic space offers a laid-back vibe with a killer soundtrack that energizes the atmosphere. The dining area feels inviting and comfortable, suitable for families and date nights alike. High-quality ingredients define the flavorful, thin crust pizza served only as whole pies.

New Haven style pizza stands out with a rich marinara sauce that avoids acidity. Dishes like spicy penne vodka, meatballs, and fresh salads complement the pizza offerings.

Large Pepperoni Pizza features onions that add a unique twist. The pizza pairs well with meatball subs and a side of meatballs.

People are saying

"I considered this the best pizza I've ever eaten."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, has a super delicious crust."

"I thought the pepperoni pizza was incredible."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria only serves whole pies, not by the slice.

2

Stracciatella Saturdays feature special menu items available only on that day.

3

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

03
Tony's Pizza Pasta Grill image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, stylish pizza restaurant with about 15 tables and outdoor seating offers a family-friendly atmosphere with a chill vibe. The space feels warm and stuffy due to lack of air conditioning. Guests enjoy a cozy setting that supports community promotions.

True Italian cuisine shines through with pesto pizza, bruschetta, and chicken parmigiana. Pasta dishes like lasagna, linguine with clam sauce, and lobster ravioli offer consistent, great flavors.

Big slices of pepperoni top the pizza, making it stand out. The cheese and pepperoni combination delivers a delicious flavor that works well together.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta and pizza, was incredible."

"The pasta dishes here are incredible, just like Mom used to make."

"I thought the pepperoni pizza was super good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a buy one get one free dinner deal.

2

Dinner costs $22 for two chicken Parmesan meals with a side.

3

A delivery charge of $3 applies to all orders.

04
King's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant image 1

Bright space with modern decor featuring cinema artwork and LED lighting creates an energetic, welcoming vibe. Friendly atmosphere pairs well with good music and comfortable seating. Regulars enjoy a lively spot that balances classic pizzeria style with fresh, inviting energy.

Pasta dishes stand out with consistent quality and great flavor, including seafood pasta and lasagne. New items like chicken parm pizza and vodka penne pizza add variety alongside favorites like Bruschetta and Sweet Red Chili Chicken.

Pepperoni pizza pie comes with a crispy crust and generous slices of pepperoni. It stands out as a solid choice alongside other dishes like shrimp parmesan and chicken wings.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best in town."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, was delicious."

"I thought the pepperoni pizza tasted fresh and hot."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $5 per slice.

2

Credit cards are accepted, but check for any minimum order requirements.

3

There was plenty of free parking.

05
Burke's Tavern image 1
New American restaurant

Cozy restaurant with a New York bar vibe and a European feel offers a casual, lowkey atmosphere with warm lighting and no TVs. The space feels like a time capsule, featuring a vegetable and herb garden in the back. Music plays softly, creating a perfect background for quiet conversation and romantic dates.

Artisan pizzas come with a heated marinara sauce topped with parmesan. Handmade pastas and entrees like branzino add variety alongside wings, steak, and pizza.

Pepperoni pizza stands out with its rich flavor and satisfying taste. It pairs well with other dishes like pork sausage pappardelle and complements a variety of drinks.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and unique."

"The homemade pasta here is delicious and amazing."

"I thought the pepperoni pizza was one of the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Burke's Tavern is within walking distance from Newark Penn Station and Prudential Center.

2

Parking at Burke's Tavern can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

3

The chef accepts modifications to any dish for dietary restrictions.

06
Pizza Boys image 1
Pizza delivery

Pizza delivery spot with modernized interior and cute seating for quick bites offers customizable menu and easy app ordering. Atmosphere feels personable and clean, suited for grabbing a slice after work. Known for top-notch pizza quality and varied options including wings and garlic knots.

Hot honey pepperoni pizza and penne vodka with chicken stand out on the menu. The pesto bar pie competes closely with other well-known options. Pizza comes in half special, half plain varieties alongside sandwiches and pasta.

Hot honey and vodka sauce combine with pepperoni for a sweet and spicy flavor. The pizza tends to be greasy, especially on the pepperoni.

People are saying

"The hot honey and vodka sauce pepperoni pizza was amazing."

"The bar pie here is so thin, I could eat a whole one."

"The delivery was super quick and always hot."

Good to know

1

The app-based ordering process is easy to use.

2

The pizza is customizable with a lot of variety.

3

Prices are fair for the quality of pizza offered.

07
Sizzle n' Slice image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious restaurant with chalk art walls and comfortable seating creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. The vibe feels like home, with a friendly and relaxed energy. It stands out for offering halal Italian pizza with unique, flavorful pies.

Pasta options include Fettuccine Alfredo and a spicy vodka sauce with pesto. Pizza varieties feature beef pepperoni with hot honey and vodka-sauce inspired slices. The menu also offers a chicken parm burrata sub with vodka sauce.

Deluxe pepperoni pizza stands out with its hot honey topping adding a sweet kick. The pizza costs around 26 dollars and pairs well with wings assortments.

People are saying

"I found the halal pizza here to be the best."

"The owner and staff were so kind, recommending their favorite Italian food."

"You have to try their pepperoni pizza with hot honey."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a promotion where you can win a free pizza with a shot.

2

All pizza options are halal, making it suitable for dietary restrictions.

3

Prices are affordable, especially for college students.

08
Albatross image 1
Miniature golf course

Huge facility with intricate themed decor and a modern grey aesthetic creates an upscale yet fun atmosphere. Energy stays lively and comfortable with high-tech mini golf and a phenomenal DJ providing constant entertainment. Multiple activities and photo spots keep the pace engaging and social.

Mozzarella sticks come with a delicious marinara sauce. The Pepperoni Pizza offers a spicy kick with hot honey. Other dishes include Brussels sprouts and bone-in chicken.

Primo pepperoni pizza has a perfectly crispy crust and a balanced spice level. It comes loaded with flavor and can be paired with hot honey for a spicy kick.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, especially when bowling."

"The Primo pepperoni pizza is one of the best I've ever had."

"I suggest requesting Jordan for excellent Italian food recommendations."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted online; you must reserve a slot upon arrival.

2

Expect long wait times on weekends due to high demand and no reservations.

3

The mini golf experience costs $22 per person for 9 holes.

09
Avenue Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small indoor space opens to a patio-like setting with outdoor tables. Cozy atmosphere carries a late-night energy with a focus on unique pizza flavors and specialty wings. Crowd includes those seeking thin, crispy pizza and a satisfying meal beyond typical options.

Penne alla vodka stands out with its rich flavor and creamy sauce. Appetizers like fried ravioli and wings add a tasty start to the meal.

Garlic knot pepperoni pizza stands out with a flavorful twist. The pepperoni pizza offers a great taste and pairs well with other items like wings and egg rolls.

People are saying

"I thought their pizza was the best around, seriously delicious."

"The Penne alla Vodka here is phenomenal."

"I thought the pepperoni pizza was great."

Good to know

1

Parking at Avenue Pizza can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

2

Avenue Pizza is open late for late-night cravings.

3

They only have outdoor seating, which may be uncomfortable in cold weather.

10
Eli's Pizza Pasta Ristorante image 1

Small, old school Italian restaurant with a cozy, quaint atmosphere and casual local favorite vibe. Seating is limited and cramped, with outdoor tables available. Known for authentic pizza and pasta, it offers quick service and a relaxed setting.

Pasta and pizzas come extremely fresh and delicious with an authentic Italian taste. Dishes like Fettuccine Alfredo with perfectly cooked chicken and Penne alla Vodka with chicken stand out for their flavor and quality.

Small 10-inch pizzas feature excellent quality cheese. Pepperoni pizzas have plenty of pepperoni and a phenomenal flavor.

People are saying

"The pizza here has the best cheese and a perfectly crisp crust."

"I found the pasta here to be the best I've ever had."

"The pepperoni pizza here has phenomenal flavor."

Good to know

1

Delivery typically takes about 30 minutes, but can vary based on demand.

2

The restaurant is open until 11 PM on weekends, making it a late-night option.

3

Expect to pay around $21 for a medium pizza, which may be higher than average.

11
Gianna's Pizza & Catering image 1

Pizza restaurant offers outdoor seating and a few indoor tables in a simple setup. Atmosphere is casual with no air conditioning, leading to warmth inside on hot days. Known for New York style pizza with crispy crust and fresh toppings, it allows customers to bring their own alcohol.

Pizza, pasta, and eggplant parmigiana stand out here. Garlic knots, mozzarella sticks with marinara, and a veggie panini add solid variety.

Medium size pepperoni pizza features thin sauce coverage and a generous amount of pepperoni. The overall flavor leans toward simple and straightforward without extra toppings.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always made to perfection."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, was amazing."

"I thought the pepperoni pizza was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Outdoor seating is available when the weather is nice.

2

Customers are allowed to bring their own alcohol.

3

Daily specials are offered for families or office staff.

12
Villa Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza restaurant with only 2-3 tables offers a nostalgic, old school ambiance featuring traditional ovens and menu. Atmosphere feels friendly and peaceful but can be quiet and dingy inside. Known for halal meat and late-night hours until 2:30-3 AM.

Penne vodka and cheese pizza offers a unique twist with penne pasta blending into gooey cheese. Mozzarella sticks feature delicious mozzarella cheese, and pasta dishes maintain a good pasta to sauce ratio.

Medium pepperoni pizza costs $16 and comes in slices or whole pies. Large size is available alongside other dishes like the Godfather Philly cheese steak and chicken Parmesan.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was on another level."

"I definitely recommend their pepperoni pizza and slices."

Good to know

1

Villa Pizza is open daily until 2:30 AM.

2

Limited seating is available with only two tables.

3

Street parking and a parking lot are conveniently available.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...