Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New Jersey

Markets with pie

Made for those who browse market stalls specifically to hunt down a fresh-baked pie.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Drew's Market image 1
Drew's Market image 2
Drew's Market image 3
View all
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store with a classic neighborhood market feel offers an excellent selection of fresh food including a prime butcher and deli. The atmosphere is reliable and inviting, attracting locals and visitors alike with quality products and fair prices.

Fresh meats and deli items stand out with top quality and fair prices. Made-to-order sandwiches and prepared pot pies offer tasty options. The market maintains great customer service and cleanliness.

Made-to-order pot pies include a chicken parm pot pie with pulled chicken and a holiday pot pie. The Thanksgiving Pie features turkey and sides, offering a hearty dinner option.

People are saying

"The market's prepared foods and sandwiches are delicious and fresh."

"The staff here makes this lunch spot feel like home."

"You have to try the chicken parm pot pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Drew's Market offers a wide selection of fresh food and Italian specialties.

2

Catering services are available for events, including graduation parties.

3

Prices at Drew's Market are affordable and competitive.

02
Joe's Farm Market image 1

Colorful market space offers wide selection of plants and flowers alongside fresh fruits and vegetables. Atmosphere carries scents of home-baked pies and fresh strawberries, creating a welcoming vibe. Visitors find legendary homemade pies and local produce stand out among offerings.

Anitaโ€™s pies stand out as a highlight here. The market offers a huge flower selection and apple cider donuts that draw many visitors.

Pies feature a perfectly flaky and buttery crust made from scratch. Fillings blend the freshest blueberries and peaches with natural sweetness and flavor. The balance of fruit and crust creates a delightful treat.

People are saying

"You have to try Anita's pies from this Grocery Store; they're spectacular."

"You have to try this Local Spot's flaky, buttery pie crust."

"Anita's pies at the Market have a perfectly flaky crust."

Good to know

1

They accept cash or credit cards for payment.

2

The market has a large selection of fresh fruits and vegetables.

3

Anita's pies are a popular item and worth trying.

03
Twin Pond Farm Country Market image 1

Large market combines garden area and indoor deli with a friendly atmosphere. Offers locally grown produce, a wide variety of plants, and activities for children including hay rides. Food options include fresh pies, cider donuts, and breakfast sandwiches made on torpedo rolls.

Large space includes a garden area and an indoor deli. The market stays clean and offers good service with a variety of quality items, though some prices run higher.

Freshness stands out in the pies here, with options like Dutch Apple Pie and Fruits of the Forest berry pie. The pies consistently taste delicious and come highly praised for their quality.

People are saying

"I thought the pies were awesome and tasty."

"It's amazing for the kids."

"The market's produce is so fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

The market closes at 6 pm.

2

Parking is easy at the market.

3

They offer many activities for children, including a hay ride.

04
Schieferstein Farm image 1
Produce market

Family-owned market offers fresh local produce, seasonal fruits, and homemade pies with a boutique tucked in the back. Atmosphere feels authentic and inviting, with a focus on quality and community. Customers find a variety of plants, baked goods, and specialty items like honey and jams.

Local farm market offers a bountiful selection with standout areas for pumpkins and mums. Plants and flowers maintain high quality throughout.

Fruit pies stand out with flaky crusts and balanced flavors. Options include apple, peach, strawberry rhubarb, raspberry, and pumpkin pies, all freshly baked and ready to order.

People are saying

"I made marinara sauce from these Jersey tomatoes."

"The apple pie here is perfectly balanced and flaky."

"The Market has amazing apples going strong into December."

Good to know

1

Expect to find high-quality plants and flowers at the market.

2

Local fresh produce is available at great prices.

3

The farm offers delicious baked goods alongside fresh produce.

05
Angelo's Farm Market image 1
Farmers' market

Small, family-owned market offers fresh, locally-sourced produce and homemade pies with a standout blueberry pie known for its buttery crust and balanced sweetness. Prices stay reasonable, and healthy, large plants are available. The atmosphere is casual, with occasional long waits during festivals.

Offers fresh, locally-sourced produce like blueberries, peaches, and Jersey tomatoes. Features homemade baked goods with pies as a standout item. Prices stay reasonable in a smaller, family-owned market setting.

Blueberry pie features a perfect balance of sweetness and tartness with plump, juicy berries in every bite. Veggie pies come frozen and ready to bake at home following clear instructions.

People are saying

"This market's blueberry pie is a must-try, perfectly sweet and tart."

"I found their blueberry pie to be a must-try."

"I found the fresh produce here to be amazingly good."

Good to know

1

They offer reasonable prices on produce, plants, and pies.

2

Fresh produce starts coming out around June 10th each year.

3

Expect long wait times during festivals and busy weekends.

06
Stew Leonard's Farm Fresh Food & Wine image 1

Maze-like layout guides shoppers through every department, creating a unique flow. Animatronics like singing avocados and dancing cows add a playful, family-friendly vibe. Integrated wine and liquor section blends seamlessly with fresh food offerings, enhancing the lively atmosphere.

Family-friendly atmosphere with fresh produce and meats fills the aisles. Unique features include cheesy animatronics and exclusive wines not found in other markets.

Fresh pies come in full or half sizes, with the clerk willing to split pies to offer different flavors. Pecan pie stands out as a consistent choice, paired often with cheese popcorn.

People are saying

"This grocery store felt like a theme park with lively animations."

"This market's wacky, windy aisles have talking characters and animatronics."

"I loved the delicious pies, especially the coconut custard."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide variety of fresh produce, meats, and baked goods.

2

Parking is ample and easily accessible for shoppers.

3

Prepared foods may not look fresh after 6pm.

07
Fattal's image 1
Supermarket

Supermarket combines spacious layout with luxurious dining rooms and a cozy seating area for meals. Atmosphere feels family-oriented and welcoming, encouraging wandering and discovery. Offers a wide selection of Middle Eastern groceries and fresh bakery items with attention to quality and detail.

Extremely clean meat market with helpful staff. Offers quality and quantity and carries everything found in a Middle Eastern market.

Spinach pies stand out with fresh, vibrant flavors. Meat pies include a unique pomegranate twist, and hummus with zaatar pies add a savory touch.

People are saying

"I found this Middle Eastern grocery store had everything I could imagine."

"I found Fattal's to be the best Middle Eastern market."

"Their spinach pies are the best."

Good to know

1

Fattal's offers a wide variety of Middle Eastern groceries, including fresh produce and meats.

2

Parking is ample and easy at Fattal's, making it convenient for shoppers.

3

Prices at Fattal's are generally higher than other local grocery stores.

08
Spike's Fish Market & Restaurant image 1

Small seafood market restaurant with a cozy, retro vibe and a laidback shore atmosphere. Guests pick meals from a refrigerated case featuring the freshest catch, reflecting a nearly 100-year-old fishing shack style. The space feels quaint and bustling, offering a friendly, family-like setting.

Freshest seafood fills the market with a great selection of super fresh items. The spot combines an authentic old school seafood market vibe with a pleasant counter person handling sales and payments.

Homemade pies stand out with the coconut mousse pie being especially incredible and delicious. The pies serve as a strong dessert option after dinner.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and so fresh."

"The seafood market here has incredibly fresh items."

"I believed the pie I tried was the best pie I had ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to ensure seating, especially during busy times.

2

The restaurant is a bring-your-own-bottle establishment; no alcohol is served.

3

Expect the place to be packed at times, especially during peak hours.

09
Farms View Roadstand image 1

Farm features hayrides, petting zoo, and u-pick strawberries with a garden nursery area. Atmosphere is cozy and friendly, with charming entrance through a field and picnic tables near parking. Produce includes fresh, sweet strawberries and homemade pies, creating a wholesome outdoor experience.

Fresh local produce fills the market, including Jersey Fresh fruits and vegetables and farm-fresh eggs. Homegrown goods like local honey, homemade sauces, and jams add variety alongside garden tools and decor.

Fresh pies stand out with a delicious crust and balanced filling, avoiding overly sweet apple jam. The apple pie and Key Lime Pie capture classic flavors with a homemade touch.

People are saying

"I loved their fresh, homemade pies, especially the crust."

"The fun activities here are picking sweet, ripe strawberries straight from the vine."

"The strawberries at this Market are so sweet and fresh."

Good to know

1

It costs $5 per person for entrance to the strawberry farm.

2

Parking is ample, except around Halloween.

3

The port-a-johns are the only public restrooms available.

10
Battleview Orchards image 1

Country-style store offers fresh baked goods and seasonal fruit picking in a picturesque orchard setting. Atmosphere feels cozy and family-friendly with inviting smells of cinnamon and donuts. Visitors often enjoy apple cider donuts and fresh cider amid a clean, welcoming environment.

Fresh produce and locally made products fill the market store. It offers a nice-sized selection including bakery items and is handicapped accessible.

Very Berry Pie stands out with its limited availability and rich flavor. A variety of fruit pies like peach and raspberry offer fresh, delicious options alongside apple cider donuts and other baked treats.

People are saying

"You have to try the fresh apple cider donuts and cider."

"I found the pies here to be so delicious."

"You have to try the warm apple cider donuts from the market."

Good to know

1

Cash is required for donuts and drinks; no card payments accepted.

2

There is no ATM on the premises for cash withdrawals.

3

The orchards are not accessible for visitors with special needs.

11
Dearborn Market image 1
Grocery store

Old school grocery store with a beautifully designed garden and greenhouse area. Offers an abundant selection of fresh produce, quality meats, seafood, and cheeses. Maintains a small-town, local-store vibe despite changes in ownership.

Fresh produce, baked goods, and prepared meals fill the market with a great selection. The clean layout includes an outstanding bakery and a beautifully designed nursery and garden supply section.

Homemade pies include a lemon krumb pie and a heat and serve chicken pot pie. Prices match the quality, but pies like pumpkin spoil quickly and some items can cause stomach issues.

People are saying

"The prepared food here is delicious and reasonably priced."

"I found the market had great fresh produce and seafood."

"I enjoyed the homemade pies; they were delicious."

Good to know

1

Dearborn Market closes at 8 pm daily.

2

Expect higher prices compared to typical grocery stores.

3

ShopRite coupons are not accepted at Dearborn Market.

12
Sun High Orchards image 1

Farm offers cozy market, fresh produce, and family-friendly activities like a petting zoo and hayrides. Atmosphere shifts from quiet and quaint to lively and crowded during peak times. Visitors enjoy homemade apple cider donuts and fresh ice cream amid scenic views and picnic areas.

Fresh homemade apple donuts stand out alongside a large selection of desserts. The market offers a great array of fresh vegetables and cozy jars of jams, butters, and spreads.

Fresh baked pies stand out here, especially the apple pie. A variety of fresh baked breads and pies are available alongside fresh cider.

People are saying

"I loved the warm apple cider and donuts here."

"The market has delicious fresh desserts and baked goods."

"I found the apple pie delicious."

Good to know

1

The entry fee is $4 per person on weekends and $2 on weekdays.

2

They accept cash only for entry; debit cards are accepted for purchases.

3

Parking is available but can be challenging to find.

13
Norz Hill Farm & Market, LLC image 1

Rustic farm setting offers huge pumpkin patch and corn maze with tractor-led hayrides and a petting zoo. Atmosphere is family-friendly and intimate, with vintage tractors and sensory play areas for children. Market sells fresh produce, homemade pies, and full-fat milk, creating a hands-on farm experience.

Fresh vegetables and fruits fill the farm market. Many lovely pumpkins are available, with vintage stationary tractors and sensory bins behind the main market.

Raspberry pies stand out as a favorite, noted for their flavor. Seasonal pies join jams and pickles available for purchase at the market's close.

People are saying

"It's really Kid Friendly, especially the holiday lights hayride."

"You'll love the magical holiday lights and personalized gifts at these Date Spots."

"I loved picking sunflowers at the market and riding the hayride."

Good to know

1

They charge $10 per child and $5 for non-participants.

2

The farm offers fall activities like pumpkin picking, a corn maze, and hayrides.

3

The hayride features lights, music, and a chance to meet Santa.

14
Ort Farms image 1

Huge farm set in an incredibly scenic valley offers family-friendly activities like hayrides, corn maze, and petting zoo. Atmosphere blends festival vibe with relaxing, well-maintained grounds and live music. Facilities include a beautiful store and safe walking paths between fields.

Fresh local produce and baked goods stand out at the farmers market. The roadside market offers a beautiful setup with a nice selection, and the whole area is dog-friendly.

Fresh pies stand out here, especially apple and blueberry pies. The selection includes Thanksgiving pies and other baked goods like donuts.

People are saying

"It's so Kid Friendly with a pumpkin patch and apple picking."

"The corn maze and pumpkin patch are so much fun!"

"I loved their delicious apple pie."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines, especially for the monster truck event, with waits over 1.5 hours.

2

Parking fills up quickly; arrive early to secure a spot.

3

Admission for two adults, including all activities, is $50.

15
Alstede Farms image 1

Enormous farm with miles of orchards and sprawling fields offers a lively atmosphere with live music and various kid-friendly activities like pony rides and a petting zoo. The space includes a well-organized party area and a market featuring fresh produce and baked goods. Crowds gather here, creating a busy and energetic vibe amid vibrant greenery.

Freshly grown vegetables and local market items fill the clean produce market. Visitors can pick their own produce and buy items like carrots and romaine hearts.

Pies here have a perfect crust and fruit fillings with a balanced sweet and tart texture. The pumpkin pie stands out for its flavor and does not spike sugar levels as expected.

People are saying

"It's so kid friendly, my little ones loved the farm animals."

"The live music here creates a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere."

"The pumpkin pie here is amazing and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Entry fee is $30 per person, including children.

2

Expect to pay around $200 for a family of four for entry and activities.

3

Bring water as the grounds are large with little shade.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...