Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New Jersey's best

Oysters and sandwiches

You want a sandwich and a plate of oysters. You do not see why you should have to compromise on either.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Krewe image 1
Krewe image 2
Krewe image 3
View all
Cajun restaurant

Cozy BYOB Cajun kitchen with intimate space and quaint Mardi Gras decorations creates a relaxed, unpretentious vibe. Live jazz music on Sundays adds to the authentic atmosphere. The setting feels like a downtown boutique restaurant with a warm, inviting energy.

Sandwiches come on the softest bread and pack a lot of flavor. Options include a roast beef debris, a vegan bรกnh mรฌ, and a steak po' boy similar to a French dip.

Chargrilled oysters stand out with bursting flavor and a rich, smoky taste. They pair well with dishes like jambalaya and cornbread, matching the quality of classic New Orleans seafood.

People are saying

"The American Food, especially the jambalaya, had exquisite, traditional flavor."

"The roast beef debris sandwich is packed with flavor on the softest bread."

"You have to try the chargrilled oysters; they're bursting with flavor."

Good to know

1

Krewe is BYOB, so bring your favorite drinks.

2

Parking at Krewe is scarce and can be challenging to find.

3

Make sure to make a reservation, especially on weekends.

02
Scale Fish Market image 1
Seafood market

Small town, family-run seafood market with a cozy atmosphere and friendly vibe. Outdoor seating under adorable umbrellas adds charm to the space. Consistently offers fresh, high-quality seafood and a comfortable, controlled environment.

Crab Cake Sandwich features 80% fresh crab meat with a lightly crispy crust and soft brioche buns. Fish sandwiches like the blackened fish and shrimp Pโ€™O boy offer scrumptious, flavorful options for a weekend lunch.

Freshness stands out with oysters from both east and west coasts. Thursdays feature a great oyster deal with dollar oysters. Fried oysters come full of flavor alongside consistently fresh seafood.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, especially the oysters."

"The oysters here are amazing and so fresh."

"The blackened fish sandwich was perfectly seasoned and bursting with flavor."

Good to know

1

Bring your own bottle as the place is BYOB.

2

Taco Tuesday features special tacos, while Wednesday offers fish and chips.

3

Enjoy dollar oysters every Thursday as part of the weekly special.

03
Po Boy Riche image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers authentic New Orleans vibe with lively music and well-designed decor. Atmosphere feels clean and welcoming, blending chill energy with vibrant sounds. Guests enjoy classic Louisiana flavors and a genuine cultural experience.

Roast beef and chicken sandwiches stand out for their taste, though the roast beef portion is a bit small for the price. Sandwiches come with sides like Cajun fries, making for a solid meal option.

Shrimp and Oyster Po Boys stand out with a solid combo of flavors. The oysters and fries often exceed expectations, and gluten-free options like catfish nuggets with oysters are available.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the po' boys and beignets, is delicious."

"The oyster po boy was crispy, flavorful, and delicious."

"I found the sandwiches surprisingly tasty."

Good to know

1

Customers can bring their own alcohol to enjoy with meals.

2

A meal with a sandwich, soda, and side costs around $26-28.

3

The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness throughout.

04
Tim's Po-Boys and Wings image 1
Poโ€™ boys restaurant

Small, cozy space with New Orleans style decor and a laid-back, welcoming vibe. Quiet atmosphere with great background music enhances the personal feel. Known for authentic Cajun flavors and generous portions, it attracts those craving Southern-style seafood.

Po' boy sandwiches come in shrimp and chicken varieties with mixed reviews on the shrimp. The sandwiches have a traditional style and pair well with sides like sweet potato fries.

Fried oysters come out perfectly crispy and packed in a generous po' boy sandwich. The combo of bread, sauce, and veggies complements the oysters well.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and great."

"The gumbo here is authentic with the right amount of heat."

"The po' boy sandwiches here are all delicious."

Good to know

1

The place closes at 7:30 PM, not 8 PM as initially thought.

2

The regular size of the wings is 6 for $10.

3

Portions are large, often leaving leftovers for lunch.

05
Fleming's Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar image 1

High ceilings and contemporary decor create a bright, elegant space with an open kitchen and a four-sided bar. Live music, including piano and saxophone, adds lively energy though volume varies. The atmosphere blends upscale steakhouse ambiance with fancy, clean design and a mix of seating options.

Sliced filet mignon stands out with its tender texture and rich flavor. The bread complements the meat, enhancing the overall taste.

Oysters come out excellent and fresh. They pair well with the caesar salad served as an appetizer.

People are saying

"The filet mignon steaks were outstanding and masterfully prepared."

"Danny made our celebration special and was so attentive."

"Nick knew the oysters inside and out and offered excellent recommendations."

Good to know

1

The Bar Social Hour is from 3-6pm every day.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers during social hour.

3

Reservations are recommended for special events and busy weekends.

06
Mabel image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant combines rustic feel with modern elegance in a well-designed space featuring a lively bar scene and a cozy rooftop patio. Atmosphere ranges from lively and noisy during events to more relaxed at other times. Cocktails receive consistent praise for being exceptional and well-balanced.

Mushroom sandwich stands out as a solid choice. Other options include a tuna salad sandwich and a Cuban sandwich, all served fresh and tasty.

Freshness stands out with the seafood tower featuring some of the freshest oysters. Oysters come in tiny sizes and can be overpriced, but they pair well with caviar and cocktails on the patio.

People are saying

"The food at this bar is incredible, especially the pasta and fries."

"I loved the turkey and avocado BLT sandwich with its huge side salad."

"I had some of the freshest oysters I've ever eaten."

Good to know

1

Reservations are definitely needed, especially during busy hours.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with great food and drink specials.

3

The 'girl dinner' promotion on Wednesdays includes a martini, salad, fries, and chicken tenders for $40.

07
Pete's Fish Market image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market offers fresh fish and a wide selection of seafood including wild fish, oysters, and lobster. Atmosphere is straightforward with employees smoking inside, yet the store remains clean and odor-free. It serves as a convenient spot for seafood lovers seeking quality without traveling far.

Fish sandwiches stand out with freshly cooked and fried fish options. Whiting and shrimp sandwiches come with sides like potato salad and seafood salad.

Very fresh oysters come with an amazing taste and texture. Fried oysters are perfectly done and maintain their freshness.

People are saying

"This fish market has the freshest fish and amazing sandwiches."

"I loved their fried fish sandwiches."

"I ordered very fresh oysters with amazing taste."

Good to know

1

Pete's Fish Market offers a wide selection of fresh fish daily.

2

Prices at Pete's Fish Market are competitive compared to nearby markets.

3

You can call a day ahead for special fish requests.

08
Park Seafood Clam Bar image 1
Seafood restaurant

Outdoor dining at picnic tables surrounds an open kitchen with views of the ocean. The atmosphere feels lively but can be less than friendly. Seafood is fresh and affordable, with standout dishes like crab cakes and clam chowder.

Seafood sandwiches stand out with crab cake sandwiches, lobster rolls, and a grouper sandwich. These come with sides like homemade cole slaw and chips, offering a solid and tasty meal option.

Freshness stands out with raw oysters and clams served at the bar. The raw bar consistently offers amazing shellfish.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, I could eat it all day."

"The raw bar oysters here are always fresh and amazing."

"The crab cake sandwich is a delicious and solid choice."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers outdoor dining only.

2

Expect competitive prices for clams compared to other boardwalk spots.

3

The menu features a good variety of seafood despite its small size.

09
Blue Anchor image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers breathtaking waterfront views of Manhattan with a comfortable, local feel. Atmosphere balances refined and trendy vibes, making it a relaxing spot for dining or hanging out. Outdoor patio overlooks park and waterfront, enhancing the overall experience.

Steak sandwich and chicken sandwich appear alongside seafood options like salmon burger and cold lobster roll. Sandwiches feature seafood and meat varieties with simple, fresh ingredients.

Fresh Kumamoto oysters stand out here. Oysters come at an affordable price, especially during happy hour with drinks.

People are saying

"The food and cocktails here are amazing for Date Spots."

"The oysters here are fresh, delicious, and affordable."

"The service here is great, and everyone enjoyed their meals."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 to 7pm on weekdays with good options.

2

A 20% service charge is automatically added to all dining bills.

3

The restaurant is child-friendly with a kidsโ€™ menu and activities.

10
Greene Hook Bar & Kitchen image 1

Bar offers spacious indoor and outdoor seating with board games and shuffleboard for entertainment. Atmosphere ranges from cozy and chill to rowdy and lively, supporting easy conversation and socializing. Crowd leans toward a casual, "broey" vibe with plenty of sports TVs and a welcoming setup.

Little chicken sandwich and little burger stand out for their seasoning and juiciness. The steak sandwich and Reuben sandwich offer solid flavors, though the Reuben's pork can be a bit well done.

Happy hour offers $2 oysters that taste fresh and provide strong value.

People are saying

"The happy hour oysters are a great value at $2 each."

"I found the sandwiches here to be tasty and well-seasoned."

"You have to try the $2 oysters during happy hour."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6 pm on weekdays with drink and appetizer deals.

2

The venue is not kid-friendly, especially during happy hour.

3

Expect a casual atmosphere, but it can get crowded during game days.

11
Keyport Fishery image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market with an old school setup and freshly caught fish fills the air with a strong aroma. Busy and often crowded, it offers cash-only transactions and a simple menu focused on fried fish. Outdoor benches by the water provide a peaceful view of the bay for enjoying take-out seafood.

Fried seafood sandwiches stand out here, especially the soft shell crab and belly clam options. The flounder and crab cake sandwiches come crispy and fresh, making them popular choices.

Freshness stands out with tiny but tasty oysters served raw or fried. Options include shrimp and scallop platters alongside oysters, all consistently scrumptious and well-priced.

People are saying

"I found the fish here to be the best and freshest I've ever had."

"The lobster sandwich had whole fried lobster on a toasted bun."

"The oysters here are always so fresh and tasty."

Good to know

1

Keyport Fishery only accepts cash payments; an ATM is available inside.

2

Keyport Fishery does not offer dine-in options; takeout is available.

3

Expect limited parking and long lines during peak hours.

12
The Hamilton Inn image 1
American restaurant

Bright, airy space with cozy neighborhood feel and outdoor seating featuring an Airstream bar and string lights. Atmosphere suits casual brunches and relaxed gatherings with a quiet, easy vibe on most evenings. Perfect spot for people-watching and enjoying simple, well-prepared meals.

Pastrami sandwich stands out with its bold flavor and a pinch of spice that excites the taste buds. The vodka chicken parm sandwich offers a rich, satisfying taste, while the short rib grilled cheese provides a perfect portion for a meal.

Blue Point oysters come super fresh and often feature in a Wednesday night special. They serve as a popular, delicious appetizer to start the meal.

People are saying

"Bartolo makes great cocktails for brunch."

"The short rib grilled cheese sandwich had tender, flavorful meat."

"The oysters here are super fresh."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-off wine on certain days.

2

Blue Point oysters are on special on Wednesdays.

3

Reservations are recommended due to high weekend demand.

13
The Robinson Ale House - Long Branch image 1

Open space combines with a laid-back vibe and loud energy on busy nights. Outdoor seating welcomes dogs, adding to a casual atmosphere. The setting blends sports bar elements with a relaxed, social environment.

Crab cake and crispy Cod fish sandwiches stand out with solid preparation and flavor. The Fried Chicken Sandwich sometimes misses the bacon that should be included.

Oysters come on half shell and range from mediocre to enjoyable. They stand out as the only good thing on the menu for some.

People are saying

"The bar team here is always exceptional and attentive."

"The oysters on half shell were enjoyable."

"The crispy Cod fish sandwich was delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great deals on drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm daily.

2

Live music performances occur every Friday and Saturday night.

3

Parking is metered and can be difficult to find on weekends.

14
Capโ€™t Loui - Edison, NJ image 1

Seafood restaurant offers a spacious, modern interior with clean, well-themed decor. The atmosphere feels inviting and lively, especially on busy nights. Unique amenities like handwashing stations with hair ties and mouthwash enhance the dining experience.

Po Boy sandwiches stand out with fresh shrimp and fish options. They come with Cajun fries or sweet potato fries on the side.

Oysters come fresh and sweet with a creamy texture and low brininess. Every Tuesday offers a $1 oyster deal that draws a crowd.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and full of flavor."

"The oysters here are incredibly fresh and delicious."

"The Po Boy sandwiches were fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

$1 oysters are available every Tuesday.

2

Enjoy free 1/2 lb snow crab legs during the grand opening.

3

Unlimited garlic noodles are offered with the snow crab legs.

15
Jacks Surf & Turf- Seafood & Steak image 1

Nautical-themed decor creates a bright, casual space with two floors and outside seating. Music ranges from live performances to a well-curated oldies playlist, adding to the chill vibes. The atmosphere stays pleasant and lowkey, avoiding any upscale or stuffy feel.

Blackened Grouper stands out with bold flavor. The crab cake sandwich offers a classic seafood taste. Lobster in the sandwich has a dense, meatball-like texture.

Fried oysters come out plump, juicy, and perfectly crispy. Grilled lemon butter oysters offer a simple, rich flavor. Raw oysters taste fresh and delicious.

People are saying

"The lobster rolls are warm, buttery, and loaded with fresh lobster."

"You have to try this sandwich; it's worth the trip."

"The fried oysters were plump, juicy, and perfectly crispy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

2

Parking is available in the lot at the back and on the street.

3

Expect high prices, with some dishes costing over $20.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...