Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New Jersey's best

Pubs with pie

A pub that serves a proper pie understands that comfort food is the foundation of a good night out.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Danaher's Pub image 1
Danaher's Pub image 2
Danaher's Pub image 3
View all
Irish restaurant

Irish pub with free pool and darts in a dedicated space and professionally poured Guinness matching Dublin standards. Cozy booths and tables create a family-friendly atmosphere that can get loud near the bar. TVs show football matches, adding to the lively vibe.

Scratch kitchen delivers unusually good Irish dishes with a North Jersey twist. Staff provide friendly, cheerful service in a kid-friendly pub setting.

Shepherd's pie stands out with hearty fillings and rich flavors. The Chicken Pot Pie offers a classic, comforting taste with a flaky crust.

People are saying

"The pub grub here is fantastic, especially the bar pie."

"The darts and pool here are a huge plus."

"The shepherd's pie and chicken pot pie were excellent."

Good to know

1

Trivia night occurs every Wednesday and can get very crowded.

2

Reservations are recommended for larger groups, especially on trivia nights.

3

The pub is kid-friendly, making it suitable for family outings.

02
Lazy Lanigans image 1

Irish pub atmosphere fills the space with authentic music and a welcoming vibe. Large TVs and live sports create an energetic backdrop, while outdoor seating and games like pool and darts add casual fun. The crowd is friendly, making it a solid spot for drinks and socializing.

Authentic Irish pub atmosphere fills the space with a classic vibe. It offers a solid, old pub experience perfect for stopping in for a drink.

Shepherd's pie stands out with a hearty filling and a comforting crust. The menu also offers a shepherd's pot pie as an appetizer option.

People are saying

"The bartenders here are so friendly and funny, especially Kyle."

"The pub food here was fresh and delicious."

"I was surprised that I liked the shepherd's pie."

Good to know

1

There is parking lot and roadside parking available.

2

Drinks are priced well.

3

The menu is extensive, offering something for everyone.

03
Dowling's Irish Pub & Restaurant image 1

Spacious Irish pub with a neighborhood pub feel and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Live band plays soulful renditions of classic songs while multiple TVs cater to sports fans. Renovated space includes a banquet room, creating a comfortable spot for gatherings.

Bustling social spot with a neighborhood pub feel and friendly service. Offers hearty pub-style food like Irish Nachos and Ruben Rolls in a lively atmosphere.

Shepherd's pie comes with a rich filling and pairs well with an ice cold Kilkenny beer. Irish cream pie serves as a sweet finish, especially with Baileys Irish cream coffee.

People are saying

"The pub food, like the fish and chips, was off the charts."

"The beer here is always ice cold."

"I loved the Shepherd's Pie; it had the right ratio of meat and potato."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Bingo night is hosted weekly, providing a fun social atmosphere.

3

The pub offers gluten-free beer and food options for dietary needs.

04
O'Donnell's Pour House image 1

Irish pub offers lively atmosphere with live bands and outdoor seating under a big pavilion. The space feels welcoming and casual, with patrons often joining in sing-alongs and cheering during sports events. Decor includes county flags that add a cultural touch.

Offers a classic Irish pub atmosphere with a solid selection of drinks. Food complements the pub vibe with great dishes that match the setting.

Peanut butter pie stands out with its fabulous flavor. Shepherd's pie features braised short rib under mashed potatoes, offering a twist on the traditional version.

People are saying

"The food here is really fresh and perfectly prepared."

"I thought the pie here was great."

"This pub has great food and a nice Caesar salad."

Good to know

1

Outdoor seating is available at O'Donnell's Pour House.

2

The establishment is 21+ after 5pm, so no children allowed.

3

Expect a 45-minute wait if the kitchen is backed up.

05
Grace O'Malley's Whiskey Chapel image 1

Classic Irish pub with cozy atmosphere and chill vibe offers big screens for sports and outdoor seating. Crowd enjoys watching football games while relaxing with well-poured Guinness and other drinks. Place feels welcoming and less loud than nearby spots.

Classic Irish pub vibe with a cozy atmosphere and solid, welcoming feel. Offers a decent beer selection and always features important sports games on TV.

Shepherd's Pie serves as a decent winter option but comes in a smaller portion than expected for the price. The Chicken Pot Pie stands out as a solid choice among the pies offered.

People are saying

"It's a classic Irish pub with a solid, welcoming atmosphere."

"I was blown away by the traditional Irish dishes."

"They had a huge whiskey list, including a separate menu."

Good to know

1

The service and kitchen are open until late, allowing dining close to 11 PM.

2

Drink prices are great, especially for the area.

3

Outdoor dining is available, perfect for nice weather.

06
Thatcher McGhee's Denville image 1

Irish pub offers a large interior with two dining areas and outdoor seating. Atmosphere ranges from loud, energetic music to quieter rooms with tables for relaxed conversation. Crowd enjoys classic Irish drinks like Guinness and Irish cider alongside hearty food options.

A proper Irish pub with traditional Irish fare and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. It serves as a friendly neighborhood spot with a great vibe for drinks.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with a portion size that satisfies and a taste reminiscent of England. The Chicken Pot Pie also earns praise for its flavor and is a favorite among diners.

People are saying

"The bar has a great beer selection and authentic Irish food."

"This Irish pub is really great and welcoming."

"The Shepherd's Pie was excellent, with a great meat and potato topping."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Wednesday at 8pm.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Parking can be difficult to find during busy afternoons.

07
Mannion's Pub & Restaurant image 1

Dark wood and ornate design shape the bar's Irish pub atmosphere with live music and well poured Guinness enhancing the experience. The vibe balances laid-back energy with friendly crowds, making it suitable for both socializing and family gatherings.

A laid back Irish pub vibe fills the space with friendly staff and live music. The menu features a pub sampler that stands out for dinner.

Shepherd's pie features a heavy mashed potato topping with less filling underneath. It tends to be dry due to the imbalance between potato and meat.

People are saying

"The food here is a step above typical pub fare."

"You've got to try the pub sampler; it's a must-try."

"I picked up the shepherds pie and it was good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

2

Expect a wait time of 30-45 minutes during peak hours on weekends.

3

Live music occurs every Friday and Saturday night, starting at 9pm.

08
The Auld Shebeen Pub image 1

Irish pub with authentic imported decor creates a cozy, homey atmosphere that feels like stepping into Ireland. Quiet spaces like the snug in the back corner offer privacy and comfort for lunch or reading. Fresh Guinness and well-crafted cocktails complement the warm, inviting vibe.

The pub offers an authentic Irish atmosphere with imported decor and a vibe that feels like Ireland. Staff provide excellent service and bartenders deliver a great liquor selection with mixology skills.

Cottage pie and chicken pot pie stand out here. The pot pie has a flaky, light crust and tastes great, while the cottage pie gets consistent praise.

People are saying

"The pub staff here is so friendly and professional."

"The chicken pot pie has an awesome flaky crust."

"It felt like an authentic Irish pub with imported decor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on busy nights like St. Patrickโ€™s Day due to long wait times.

2

The pub offers a variety of vegan and vegetarian options on the menu.

3

The restaurant is conveniently located inside the Marriott hotel for easy access.

09
Muldoon's image 1
Irish pub

Small, traditional Irish pub with classic pub atmosphere and a friendly local crowd. The space feels unassuming and cozy, often crowded at the bar with a chilled out vibe. Food and drink offerings include standout items like fish and chips and lemon drop martinis, contributing to a cultured, slow-moving environment.

Feels like a traditional Irish pub with a small, local vibe. Offers an elevated specials menu and seats about 15-20 at the bar plus 5 high tops.

Guinness pie stands out with a rich beef filling. Chicken pot pie offers a hearty, classic option. Both pies come with a flaky crust and savory flavors.

People are saying

"This local spot has great food and spectacular service."

"The pub food, like burgers and fish and chips, is really good."

"You have to try the Guinness Pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but it's best to arrive early on weekends.

2

The kitchen closes at 9:30 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Parking is available nearby, making it easy to access the restaurant.

10
Pitney Pub image 1

Pub offers indoor and outdoor seating with live music and multiple TVs for sports coverage. Atmosphere stays friendly and inviting with background music that keeps noise moderate. Menu features large portions and affordable prices, with standout items like wings, pizza, and unique specials.

A cute little local pub with a buzzing atmosphere and friendly, attentive staff. Offers great pub fare like wings and pizza, plus smooth, rich espresso martinis and affordable draft beer.

Chicken pot pie stands out with rich, savory filling. Specials include a lobster pot pie. Dessert options feature key lime pie and peanut butter cheesecake.

People are saying

"The bar food here is really good, especially the wings."

"I thought the pub food, especially the wings and pizza, was amazing."

"I found the pot pie absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a busy atmosphere during major events like the Kentucky Derby.

2

The parking lot is often full, so arrive early to find a spot.

3

Happy hour specials are available, making drinks more affordable.

11
Anglesea Pub image 1
Irish pub

Irish pub with live Irish music and a large outdoor deck featuring a bar and plenty of seating. The atmosphere is lively and noisy, filled with energetic crowds enjoying authentic Irish vibes and classic tunes from the late 70s and early 80s.

Irish pub vibes come through strong with an authentic atmosphere and a great selection of drinks. Food includes phenomenal burgers and amazing chicken wings, complemented by live bands and a new deck for outdoor enjoyment.

Shepherd's Pie features a paprika-red color and has very few potatoes. Chicken pot pie comes across as very delicious.

People are saying

"The food here is great, especially the wings and perogies."

"The food at this pub is outstanding."

"Sean's Shepherd's Pie was good."

Good to know

1

The pub accepts only cash but has ATMs available.

2

Visitors should plan accordingly due to potential wait times.

3

Tuesdays are wing night with a special of 10 wings for $10.

12
Dublin House image 1
Irish restaurant

Old house design creates a warm, inviting atmosphere with an upscale yet homey vibe. Large bar area offers plenty of seating and TVs tuned for rugby matches. Outdoor patio and live music add to the lively energy on weekends.

Offers a proper pub atmosphere with a clean and inviting space. Serves standard pub fare that fits well with the Irish-style bar vibe.

Chicken pot pie stands out as tasty and delicious. The shepherd's pie is filling and well-made. The pie sampler offers a variety of flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the burgers and fries."

"The pub food here is excellent, especially the soft pretzel."

"You have to try the chicken pot pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is paid, and you will get ticketed if you don't pay.

2

The bar closes at 1:30am, which is earlier than many places.

3

The kitchen may close early, so check before planning a late meal.

13
Cattle 'n Clover image 1

Huge bar space combines live music and multiple pool tables to create a lively, energetic atmosphere. Booths and tables offer seating, though some are tight and small. Outdoor areas add a comfortable energy for relaxed socializing.

Irish pub offers a good beer list and great food with friendly staff. Pool tables and live entertainment add to the fun atmosphere, while a DJ plays loud dance music.

Chicken pot pie stands out with rich, savory filling and flaky crust. The shepherd's pie impresses with hearty layers and robust flavor, often called one of the best dishes here.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the authentic Irish fare."

"This chicken pot pie is fresh and filled with chicken and vegetables."

"The Pub's shepherd's pie is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The bar is open until 3:00 a.m. on weekends.

2

The kitchen is open until at least midnight for late-night diners.

3

Some items on the online menu may not be available at the restaurant.

14
Huddy's Inn image 1
Restaurant

Colonial tavern with historic charm and an intimate dining room offers both indoor and outdoor seating, including a covered patio and outdoor stage for live bands. Atmosphere ranges from cozy and quaint to lively with sports bars featuring multiple TVs. The setting combines traditional decor with a casual, social vibe.

American pub style food stands out with a solid menu featuring pub staples and a variety of other dishes. The pub area gets a bit loud but offers above average fare beyond typical pub options.

Chicken pot pie features a creamy soup filling with a few small vegetables. Some pies arrive cold, and occasionally the dish is removed from the bill.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and enjoyable."

"The pub food here is done very well, especially the burgers."

"I loved the homemade chicken pot pie."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 9 PM, even though the restaurant closes at 11 PM.

2

Huddy's Inn offers daily specials that change regularly.

3

Parking can be challenging during peak hours due to high demand.

15
Dublin Pub image 1

Small bar with a wrap-around design and close tables creates a crowded but lively setting. Regular live Irish music fills the space, giving an upscale Irish pub vibe that feels bright and fresh after renovation. The atmosphere is fun and energetic, though very loud, making conversation difficult.

Offers a traditional Irish pub experience with authentic decor and a cozy, updated atmosphere. Serves a great selection of beers on tap, including Kane beers, alongside fresh, traditional Irish food and notable sandwiches like Reuben and Hot Pastrami.

Hot and delicious pies stand out here. The Shepherd's Pie features juicy seasoned ground beef, carrots, onions, and peas topped with creamy mashed potatoes. The Chicken Pot Pie also comes hot and tasty.

People are saying

"The American food, like the pot pie and shepherd's pie, is delicious."

"It felt like stepping into an authentic Irish pub with great drinks."

"The Shepherd's Pie was hot, delicious, and the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The pub is located steps from the Mayo, making it a perfect date day destination.

2

The parking situation is like city parking, with no dedicated parking lot.

3

They charge $2 for 'rocks' (ice), $1 for a mixer, and $13 for vodka.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...