Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Caldwell

Seafood restaurants

You are looking for a seafood dinner where the quality of the catch is the only thing that matters.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
KUROBUTA - White Charcoal Grille image 1
KUROBUTA - White Charcoal Grille image 2
KUROBUTA - White Charcoal Grille image 3
View all

Elegant interior blends with a cozy, vibrant atmosphere and a stunning outdoor patio that invites dining and live music. Guests enjoy a private party room and a beautiful garden setting perfect for socializing. The space balances charm and sophistication with a welcoming vibe.

Amazing food shines from appetizers to skewers, with flavors that are consistently absolutely delicious. The cozy ambiance complements the dining experience well.

Shrimp ceviche delivers a unique kick not found in other ceviches. Grilled fish and fried oysters stand out for their flavor, alongside excellent sashimi crudo and karaage.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and beautifully presented."

"The outdoor seating area is very pretty and has lots of open space."

"The pork dishes here are surprisingly good, especially the skewers."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, which is a unique feature.

2

They offer a winter deal every Wednesday with special prices.

3

Brunch events start on September 8, featuring special menu items.

02
Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe image 1

Small, casual seafood restaurant with an on-site fresh seafood market and cozy atmosphere. Busy and popular, especially in the evenings, with only 11 tables requiring reservations. Offers wild fish consistently and accommodates dietary needs like gluten-free.

Food arrives quickly and stays very fresh. Highlights include coconut shrimp, lobster ravioli, and oysters with consistently excellent quality and service.

Seafood here is consistently fresh and flavorful. Dishes like black magic oysters, coconut shrimp, and lobster ravioli stand out for their taste and quality.

People are saying

"I found the seafood here to be incredibly fresh and delicious."

"You have to try the seafood here; the tuna is amazing."

"The food here is fresh and delicious, especially the seafood."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating with only 11 tables available.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, with a liquor store located next door.

3

Parking is available with entry from the rear parking lot.

03
Casa Nostra Italian Bistro image 1

Small, intimate restaurant with a cozy interior and quiet atmosphere. Guests enjoy a warm ambiance with pillow-cushioned bench seating and a world-class mural outside. The place feels comfortable for relaxed conversation and offers a BYOB setting.

Food here is authentic Italian, always fresh, and packed with classic flavors that feel homemade. Every dish tastes satisfying and true to its roots.

Seafood dishes feature fresh fish with well-balanced sauces. Large portions come with items like Shrimp Risotto, Lobster Ravioli, and a mixed seafood platter highlighting grilled octopus.

People are saying

"The Date Spots here have outstanding, classic, and delicious Italian food."

"The seafood here is really fresh with nice sauces."

"I found the food to be delicious and expertly prepared."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to dine at this restaurant.

2

Parking can be challenging, especially with new construction nearby.

3

This place is BYOB, so bring your favorite drinks.

04
Fat Fish Taco image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small space with coastal atmosphere and thematic, cozy decor creates a quaint, inviting vibe. Noise levels can be high, adding to a lively energy. Menu focuses on fresh ingredients and creative specials, drawing a family-friendly crowd seeking flavorful Mexican dishes.

Food here is consistently fresh and made to order, with a focus on healthy and high-quality ingredients. The menu offers eclectic Mexican dishes that stand out for their excellent taste and freshness.

Fish tacos stand out with fresh, flavorful fillings like spicy shrimp and fried fish. The Bang Bang shrimp offers a sweet kick with juicy pineapple, and the chicken and shrimp bowls bring bold, satisfying tastes.

People are saying

"I thought the seafood tacos were amazing and the best I've ever had."

"The nachos here are amazing and stacked high."

"The food here is amazing and tasted so fresh."

Good to know

1

The place is BYOB, so you can bring your own beverages.

2

The $8.50 tacos are huge; two are usually enough for one person.

3

The restaurant offers seasonal specials that showcase the chef's creativity.

05
Benji's Taqueria Mexican Grill 2 image 1

Colorful and cozy interior creates a welcoming atmosphere with authentic Mexican flavors and generous portions. The place draws people looking for fresh, well-seasoned dishes like al pastor and birria tacos. It offers a friendly, mom-and-pop vibe that stands out from typical fast-casual Mexican spots.

Mexican food here is authentic and consistently amazing in quality. The dishes are delicious enough to overlook occasional order mix-ups.

Shrimp stands out with generous portions and fresh flavor, especially in the shrimp ceviche and fajita plate. Fish tacos come in several styles like blackened mahi and beer battered, often paired with chipotle mayo.

People are saying

"The birria tacos here are packed with tender, flavorful brisket."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"You'll love the shrimp and fish tacos with chipotle mayo."

Good to know

1

The burritos cost $15 each.

2

Portions are generous compared to nearby restaurants.

3

Delivery starts at 11pm, even if scheduled for earlier.

06
Stephanie's Italian Restaurant image 1

Open kitchen fills the cozy space with wonderful smells and creates a homey feeling. Outdoor dining area offers a beautiful setting, while the room feels quaint and elegant. Tables fill every available space, attracting a neighborhood-friendly crowd that enjoys a lively atmosphere.

Food features authentic Italian flavors served fast and hot with a comforting, home-style vibe. Outdoor dining adds a relaxed touch to the experience.

Zuppa de Pesce features a huge portion of fresh seafood in a light marinara sauce over papperadelle. Shrimp Parmesan and Rigatoni ala Siciliana also highlight the seafood variety available.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and plentiful."

"The Italian food here is truly authentic, perfect for Date Spots."

"Michelle provided the best service, making it a 5-star experience."

Good to know

1

Making reservations is suggested to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your favorite drinks.

3

There is plenty of parking in the back and on the street.

07
Divina Ristorante image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant with crowded tables and a moderate to high noise level depending on the crowd. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting with a BYOB policy that adds to the relaxed vibe. The place often fills up, creating a lively and bustling environment.

Exceptional quality and delicious Italian food stand out here. The menu offers a variety of dishes that consistently deliver a great dining experience.

Seafood dishes include seafood fra diavolo with three jumbo shrimp and many baby shrimp in a good sauce. Zuppa de clams also stands out, while shrimp scampi has little sauce and no garlic pieces.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is the best I've ever had."

"The dinner spots here have amazing fresh bread and tasty appetizers."

"The food here is delicious and expertly prepared."

Good to know

1

Divina Ristorante is BYOB, so bring your favorite wine.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant can accommodate large groups, up to 18 people.

08
Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria image 1

Small, classic Italian restaurant with brick walls and soft yellow lighting creates a cozy, intimate setting. Atmosphere turns noisy and crowded quickly, especially at peak times, with tables placed close together. Known for thin crust pizza with excellent flavor and crunch, offering a genuine Italian vibe.

Authentic Italian food shines here with a focus on thin crust pizza that is crispy and topped with a savory sauce. Large portions arrive on time, paired with attentive service that creates a welcoming atmosphere.

Shrimp dishes stand out with spicy French-style sauce and long hots as appetizers. Clams casino feature large bacon chunks, while clams oreganato offer a flavorful option.

People are saying

"I loved the thin crust pizza; it had a satisfying crunch."

"I thought the pizza here was great and one of the best I've ever had."

"I loved the crispy thin crust pizza with no flop."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect wait times of 30-60 minutes during peak dinner hours.

3

The restaurant allows BYOB, so bring your own drinks.

09
Sabor Peru image 1
Peruvian restaurant

Small, quaint space with different themed rooms creates a home-like atmosphere filled with cultural artifacts and warm colors. The vibe is intimate and romantic, suited for calm gatherings or date nights. Artistic decor and a welcoming energy make it feel like dining in a personal home.

Food features fresh ingredients and generous portions with authentic Peruvian flavors. Presentation and taste combine for a consistently delicious experience.

Seafood options include garlic shrimp, crispy Jalea, and fish in broth. Some dishes like seafood rice and fish cracklings lack expected flavors or sides.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the fresh ceviche."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"The seafood here is fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Sabor Peru is BYOB, allowing customers to bring their own liquor.

2

The entries cost $20-$25, which is reasonable.

3

Street parking can be tough at certain times.

Discover more

Caldwell, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...