Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Dinner spots in Cape May

A dinner spot that treats the evening meal like an event rather than just a quick way to refuel.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Il Riccio Cape May image 1
Il Riccio Cape May image 2
Il Riccio Cape May image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Small, intimate Italian restaurant with modern chic decor and Mediterranean coastal vibes creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Space feels like a stylish coastal getaway with thoughtful details and elegant simplicity. Energy is relaxed yet elegant, offering an authentic Italian dining experience.

Italian food stands out with magnificent service and a memorable atmosphere. Dining here offers consistently great food and a top-tier experience.

Dinner here turns into a memorable experience with more than just food on the plate. The atmosphere and flavors combine for an amazing dinner that stands out.

People are saying

"The food here is exceptional, made with high-quality ingredients."

"The Date Spots here are so welcoming and attentive."

"The dinner spots here have amazing, fresh food, especially the octopus."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to limited seating.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your favorite wine.

3

Expect a wait time of 30-60 minutes during peak dinner hours.

02
La La Lobster Cape May image 1
Seafood restaurant

Walk-up seafood spot with small outdoor seating and beach casual vibe. Sunlit tables offer a welcoming atmosphere with a breeze on warm days. 80s rock music plays softly, creating a fun and relaxed energy.

Food comes out fresh and fast with staff going out of their way to handle food allergies safely. Service is wonderful and the dishes are consistently amazing.

Casual dinners feature lobster, shrimp, and grilled cheese options. The spot suits groups well and invites repeat visits.

People are saying

"I had the best lobster roll I ever had."

"The food here is overflowing with generous, tender lobster."

"The lobster mac n cheese is perfectly creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is a walk-up spot with minimal outdoor seating.

2

Lobster rolls cost $22, including chips and a pickle.

3

An extra 2 ounces of lobster meat can be added for $7.

03
Virginia Hotel & Cottages image 1

Restored 1879 landmark hotel offers Victorian style with cozy cottages and intimate nooks. Atmosphere blends low key elegance with lively piano music and occasional crowd noise at night. Outdoor seating and porch areas provide relaxed spots for drinks and breakfast.

Upscale dining offers impressive and consistently great food. Breakfast and dinner feature exceptional dishes with award-winning cocktails complementing the meals.

Dinner features outstanding gourmet dishes paired with attentive service. The setting supports a quality dining experience on site.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are outstanding, thanks to amazing staff."

"The dinner here was outstanding and gourmet."

"The food here was always great and tasty."

Good to know

1

The hotel offers valet parking for guests.

2

Dining options are limited to charcuterie or oysters during midday.

3

Expect high prices for drinks at the bar, ranging from $18 to $25.

04
Carroll Villa Hotel image 1

Old Victorian villa blends historic charm with modern amenities and boutique style. Cozy lounge with fireplace and live music at the bar create a warm, inviting atmosphere. Location offers easy walking access to shops, restaurants, and beach, though parking is limited.

Food here stands out for its exceptional quality and great taste. Breakfast and other meals at the restaurant consistently deliver top notch flavors.

Cozy lounge area offers a spot to enjoy a drink by the fireplace before dinner or coffee while waiting for a table. Dinner serves very good dishes, complementing an excellent breakfast experience.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the delicious breakfast and drinks."

"The food here is delicious and excellent."

"The dinner here is delicious, just like breakfast."

Good to know

1

Parking can be an issue; designated parking is a good walk from the hotel.

2

The hotel is one block from the beach and a five-minute walk to Washington Street Mall.

3

The hotel offers a golf cart service to and from the parking lot.

05
Montreal Beach Resort image 1

Resort hotel offers beautiful ocean views and rooftop bar with lively music. Atmosphere varies from quiet and cozy in rooms to loud and energetic near the bar and beach. Amenities include complimentary beach access and convenient shuttle and golf cart services.

Food here features delicious dishes and excellent drinks served in a welcoming spot right off the patio deck. The menu offers legit good food that consistently satisfies.

Dinner happens at a spot with friendly staff including bartenders and waiters. Outdoor seating offers an ocean view that pairs well with drinks before the meal.

People are saying

"The hotel staff are so welcoming and helpful."

"The food here was really good and delicious."

"The dinner at Harry's restaurant was fabulous."

Good to know

1

Happy hour at Harry's runs from 4-7 PM daily with half-price appetizers.

2

Live music is featured at the bar every night from 5 to 8 PM.

3

Octoberfest vendors and shops are available during the holiday season.

06
Boiler Room at Congress Hall image 1

Basement space with exposed brick and neon lights creates a grimy, underground vibe. Live bands play funk, boogie, and rock โ€˜nโ€™ roll, filling the room with loud, energetic music. Crowds gather for dancing and drinks in a tucked-away cellar setting.

Food features excellent flavors and attentive service with staff who are highly aware and responsive. The dining experience in the basement offers a unique atmosphere paired with well-crafted dishes.

Thanksgiving dinner here gets special attention with staff ensuring everything is perfect. The setting can be challenging for restless toddlers at the table.

People are saying

"The pizza here is crispy, chewy, and saucy."

"The brick oven pizza here is crispy, chewy, and saucy."

"Sandy made sure everything was perfect for our dinner."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended for seating.

2

The bar's last call is at 12:30 am, so plan accordingly.

3

Expect a limited menu focused primarily on pizza and light fare.

07
The Inn of Cape May image 1

Victorian architecture blends with cozy yet posh decor and a historic, quaint atmosphere. Outdoor spaces offer ocean views and rocking chairs for relaxing, while evenings bring live music and cocktails in the garden. The setting is serene and peaceful, ideal for quiet, romantic stays near the beach.

Excellent food stands out here, often noted as a highlight. The service and staff complement the dining experience well.

Dinner here features a relaxed atmosphere with a bar for drinks and consistent service across multiple visits. Breakfast is also available daily with room vouchers, adding convenience for overnight guests.

People are saying

"This charming old hotel is beautiful and historic."

"The food here is great."

"The live music on the porch makes for great dinner spots."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available daily from 4-6pm with discounted drinks.

2

Breakfast is served until 11:30am on weekdays and 11am on weekends.

3

Reservations are recommended for special events like breakfast with Santa.

08
Grand Hotel of Cape May image 1

Resort hotel offers large indoor and outdoor pools with a salt water indoor pool and hot tub. Rooms provide ocean views but can be noisy with sounds from neighboring areas. Setting across from the beach features roof decks and balconies with beautiful views.

Food comes out cooked to perfection with an excellent range during Sunday brunch. Service matches the outstanding quality of the dishes.

Dinner offers a lively atmosphere with a great menu focused on steaks. The bartenders serve top-notch drinks in a consistently high-end setting.

People are saying

"The staff here made our wedding day seamless and unforgettable."

"The food here was absolutely incredible."

"The dinner steaks and short ribs were awesome."

Good to know

1

The hotel is located right on Beach Avenue, just across the street from the beach.

2

Happy hour at the hotel offers discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

Expect noise from events if staying above the event rooms.

09
Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant image 1

Pizza restaurant with old, unkempt decor and a run-down interior offers a take-out focused atmosphere rather than sit-down dining. The vibe is quick and casual, attracting those seeking affordable, well-regarded pizza similar to New York style. It lacks tourist ambiance and is best for fast, convenient meals.

Food arrives promptly, especially pizzas and entrees. The menu features pizza and French fries, known local favorites, with options that are both great and affordable.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be really good."

"The pizza and French fries here are spot on."

"The pizza here has a crispy crust and isn't overly topped."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required for dining but may be recommended during peak hours.

2

Takeout and delivery options are available for those who prefer to eat at home.

3

No public restrooms are available for customers, so plan accordingly.

10
La Mer Beachfront Resort image 1

Oceanfront setting offers white sandy beach and gorgeous views with balconies overlooking the water. Pool area buzzes with lively energy from families and features poolside drink service. Rooms stay quiet despite nearby activity, creating a calm retreat within an upscale, festive atmosphere.

Excellent cuisine shines through at the Pier House restaurant with a pleasant atmosphere. Beachside dining offers reasonable prices along with chairs, towels, and umbrellas provided daily.

Onsite restaurant offers pleasant dinners with great service. Both breakfast and dinner maintain consistent quality.

People are saying

"The beachfront property and pool were so clean and well-maintained."

"The dinner spots here are great, with attentive staff bringing food and drinks."

"The food here is really good and delicious."

Good to know

1

Room prices can reach up to $1,300 per night.

2

Expect construction noise and dust during your stay.

3

The pool is currently unavailable for guests.

Discover more

Cape May, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...