Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Mays Landing

Sandwiches

A sandwich that is worth the trip because it is made with care instead of just being fast.

Based on 505 Opinions
+502
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mia's cafe image 1
Mia's cafe image 2
Mia's cafe image 3
View all
Family restaurant

Quaint family restaurant offers cozy indoor seating and a shady patio with string lights overlooking a historic street. Atmosphere feels friendly and community-oriented, suited for quiet breakfasts or casual gatherings. Small number of tables adds to its intimate charm.

Food comes out perfectly prepared with a variety that includes Mexican dishes, breakfast, and sushi. Portions are fantastic and plentiful, and the quality stays consistent.

Simple sandwiches like bacon, egg, and cheese and turkey club come out quickly. Options include croissant breakfast sandwiches and a pancake sandwich, alongside authentic Spanish sandwiches.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be wonderful and delicious."

"The breakfast here is delicious and perfectly prepared."

"I got the bacon, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich."

Good to know

1

Mia's cafe offers seating both inside and outside.

2

The full menu is served all day.

3

Parking is difficult; avoid the barbershop/apartment lot across the street.

02
Sugar Hill Sub & Deli image 1

Old school sub shop with quintessential Jersey vibe and walls covered in chips and snacks creates a friendly, easy-going atmosphere. Crowded and lively, it draws a family-friendly crowd looking for high-quality, large sandwiches.

Food here is consistently excellent with fabulous subs and great flavors. Service varies but the food quality stands out every time.

Sandwiches feature perfectly chopped meat and evenly distributed cheese on a fresh roll. Options like the Italian Stallion with sweet peppers and the Reuben stand out for their size and flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic and worth trying."

"I thought the sandwiches here were incredible."

"Their homemade salads, like potato and tuna, were great."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and easy to find.

2

Expect a busy atmosphere during lunch and dinner hours.

3

The cheesesteak costs $12 and is generously portioned.

03
Brick House Pub & Grille image 1

Small pub offers an intimate, family-friendly atmosphere with loud music and great energy. Regulars gather around a pool table that moves often, creating a casual vibe. The space feels cozy and encourages involvement, especially during karaoke.

Food features amazing wings and burgers with generous portions. Fries stand out as best quality and meal prices match the food quality.

Tender and juicy chicken stands out in the chicken cheese steak sandwich. The Reuben and Cuban sandwiches offer rich, satisfying flavors. Chicken cutlet sandwich adds a classic touch to the lineup.

People are saying

"I was a regular during packed karaoke nights."

"The food here was great."

"This Reuben sandwich is delicious, practically melting in your mouth."

Good to know

1

Karaoke sessions happen every Wednesday night, starting at 8pm.

2

Expect a busy atmosphere during karaoke nights, so arrive early for a good spot.

3

The pub serves food until 10pm on weekdays, but check for weekend hours.

04
Mays Landing Diner image 1

Spacious diner with classic nostalgic vibe and family-friendly atmosphere offers a huge menu featuring large portions. Seating is comfortable with ample room and easy access. The environment feels clean and inviting with a small town charm.

Food comes with fast service and consistently great quality. The dishes taste higher quality than typical diners.

Open-faced roast beef sandwich comes with a large amount of roast beef. Chicken avocado sandwich is filling and popular. Lox bagel sandwiches feature hand-sliced lox, cream cheese, capers, lettuce, tomato, and green peppers. Triple Decker and club sandwiches are also available.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and served in big portions."

"The Diner's food was delicious and satisfying."

"The chicken avocado sandwich was filling and a favorite."

Good to know

1

There is ample parking available at the diner.

2

The diner has a huge menu with many options to choose from.

3

The establishment is very clean and well-maintained.

05
Rogers Bistro image 1
Italian restaurant

Family-run Italian restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere with homemade, made-to-order dishes and gourmet variety beyond typical pizza menus. Bright and clean setting hosts generous portions and beautiful presentation, attracting locals seeking quality and affordability.

Food here stands out for its freshness and quality. Presentation matches taste, making every dish feel amazing and well-prepared.

Roasted pork sandwich comes with onion rings. Price increased from $9.50 to $26.50 under new ownership. Sandwich pairs with sides like onion rings for a full meal.

People are saying

"The homemade pasta here is delicious and cooked perfectly al dente."

"The food here is amazing and always top-notch."

"The sandwich here is way more expensive now."

Good to know

1

Delivery is available but limited to a 3-mile radius.

2

Expect a 25-minute wait for pizzas during busy times.

3

The menu features a variety of gourmet dinners alongside pizzas.

06
Pantry 1 Food Mart image 1
Convenience store

Clean space with a fantastic smell of cooking chicken sets a welcoming tone. Shelves offer a large assortment of snacks, drinks, and household items, including unique flavors not found elsewhere. Staff maintain the store well and support the community by ordering items on request.

Early morning options include coffee, tacos, fried chicken, and wedges. Fresh food comes in a variety of flavors not found elsewhere, always prepared on demand and priced affordably.

Breakfast sandwiches come in a variety of options and taste good. Preparation time can be long, sometimes up to 40 minutes. Quality stays consistent across meals, including sandwiches at lunch.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"The coffee staff here are awesome and always greet you with a smile."

"I found the breakfast sandwiches really tasty."

Good to know

1

The store has a great selection of vapes, snacks, drinks, and tobacco products.

2

You can order food online through the website or call in to order.

3

The prices are reasonable compared to other local options.

07
Jersey Mike's Subs image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers fresh, soft bread that stands out as a key feature. Atmosphere stays clean and the place handles busy periods with some wait times. Cold subs receive praise for good meat portions and consistent quality.

Food comes out fresh every time with consistently good quality and kind service.

Chicken cheesesteak and tuna sandwiches stand out as flavorful options. Sandwiches get built fresh on-site but sometimes show a burnt grill flavor and get wrapped on unclean surfaces. Ordering through the app often leads to mistakes, especially with multiple sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is solid and spectacular."

"I loved that chicken cheesesteak and tuna sandwich."

"I loved my cheesesteak with extra provolone cheese."

Good to know

1

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Online ordering may lead to inaccuracies; consider ordering in person.

3

The restaurant offers discounts for workplace deliveries with a card.

Discover more

Mays Landing, Hamilton

Area guide
Loading Map...