Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Saddle Brook

Sandwiches

A sandwich that holds its own as a full meal rather than just being a quick, forgettable snack.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Gigi's Cafe image 1
Gigi's Cafe image 2
Gigi's Cafe image 3
View all

Earthy and modern decor with reclaimed wood walls, moss accents, and oversized hanging plants creates a calming, picture-worthy atmosphere. Soft music and sunlight through large windows add warmth and natural energy. The space feels cozy and welcoming, attracting those who appreciate thoughtful design and a relaxed vibe.

Food features fresh ingredients and a unique flavor profile, especially in the chicken sandwich. Coffee pairs well with the dishes, and the overall taste is consistently savoring and satisfying.

Pernil sandwich stands out with moist meat and toasted bread. The Cuban sandwich features fermented red onions adding a sour but tasty twist. Sandwiches come out perfectly made with unique, savory flavors like the Gigi Chicken Sandwich.

People are saying

"The coffee here is amazing; the staff is always super nice."

"The food here is delicious and amazing."

"I loved the El Cubano sandwich, it reminded me of Miami Lakes."

Good to know

1

The parking at Gigi's Cafe is limited.

2

The cafe has plenty of seating available.

3

Gigi's Cafe offers great breakfast and lunch options.

02
Nick's Sandwich Shop image 1

Old school Italian deli style defines the space with a clean, comfortable dining area and family-run atmosphere. Music and The Simpsons playing create a friendly, upbeat vibe that lifts moods. Sandwiches stand out for fresh bread and perfect meat-to-bread ratio, especially chicken cutlet and Philly cheesesteak.

Food here is consistently delicious and often exceptional. Every meal delivers amazing flavors with reliable quality.

Sandwiches feature fresh meat and are packed with flavor. Options like the Philly Cheese steak and the #1 with ham, salami, and provolone stand out for their taste and quality.

People are saying

"The staff here are the warmest, friendliest people I've met."

"I ate one of the best Italian sandwiches I've ever had."

"The food here is crazy good, especially the subs."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking available in the back.

2

A 10% fee applies for credit card payments without prior notice.

3

Food is prepared quickly, making it great for a fast meal.

03
Marioโ€™s pizza & Pasta image 1

Small restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with calm music and a family-friendly vibe. Space feels warm and welcoming, suitable for casual meals or intimate gatherings. The setting blends elegance with comfort in a compact layout.

Italian dishes feature amazing quality and very delicious flavors. Service is consistently excellent and complements the food well.

Lomo steak sandwich stands out with rich flavor and tender meat. The chicken cutlet wrap and buffalo chicken sandwich also offer solid, tasty options.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza had a perfect, light crust."

"I found the food here to be authentic and delicious."

"You have to try the Lomito Steak sandwich; it's super fire."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your favorite drinks.

2

Each empanada costs $3.75.

3

Mario's offers a variety of Argentine dishes beyond pizza.

04
Brother's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy pizzeria with a comfortable atmosphere and clean environment invites relaxed dining without feeling rushed. Regulars enjoy consistent quality and affordable toppings, making it a favored spot for hearty Italian dishes and standout chicken parmesan.

Food features great taste and amazing quality with awesome prices. The owner and delivery driver ensure excellent service alongside delicious meals.

Chicken parm sandwiches stand out with options like the drunken knot in vodka sauce and the garlic knot parmesan chicken sandwich. Sandwiches come on either a garlic knot or a sub roll.

People are saying

"I thought the chicken parmesan with vodka sauce was the best I had ever tasted."

"I thought the food here was great, especially the pizza."

"I had the drunken knot, the best chicken parm vodka sauce sandwich."

Good to know

1

The price is $6 for two slices and a small drink.

2

Toppings for the whole pie are only $2-$3.

3

The restaurant offers a halal menu.

05
Saddle Brook Diner image 1

Retro-style diner with 50s Americana murals and a toy train circling the dining area creates a lively, nostalgic atmosphere. Loud acoustics fill the space with classic rock and roll tunes, making it energetic and vibrant. The vibe feels cozy and homey, welcoming guests like family.

Food here stays consistently fresh and delicious with an extensive menu offering a wide variety of choices.

Egg sandwiches stand out with options like Taylor ham egg and cheese and the western egg sandwich. The menu also features a crispy waffle and chicken sandwich with fresh ingredients, plus notable choices like the hot turkey, Cuban, and Reuben sandwiches.

People are saying

"The diner food here is hearty, satisfying, and always served hot."

"I found the food here to be delicious and hearty."

"The sandwiches here are like full-sized sandwiches, so generous."

Good to know

1

Saddle Brook Diner is open 24 hours for late-night dining.

2

Expect long wait times on Christmas Eve, over an hour for a table.

3

Parking can be difficult to find due to the diner's popularity.

06
Tribos Peri Peri - Saddle Brook image 1

Restaurant offers a clean, colorful interior with plenty of seating and a modern vibe. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, with a casual energy that suits bold, spicy flavors. Staff provide thoughtful touches like free sides for children and prayer rugs, enhancing the inclusive environment.

Food here is consistently amazing and fantastic, with a focus on halal options. Service is attentive and friendly, enhancing the dining experience.

Crispy chicken sandwiches stand out with grilled chicken served on burger buns. Adding veggies changes the flavor by reducing sauce and altering the taste.

People are saying

"I thought the food tasted great, especially the chicken."

"They're so kind and patient with kids, it's really kid friendly."

"I loved their delicious, crispy chicken sandwich."

Good to know

1

All dishes are halal.

2

You order first at the counter and they will bring you out the food when it's ready.

3

Peri Peri sauce can be mind numbingly spicy; hot and very hot options are available.

07
Midland Bagels & Grill image 1

Fast-paced bakery with a clean atmosphere and limited seating offers fresh, crunchy bagels with a soft interior. The place has a somewhat automated vibe and often features hot everything bagels on weekends.

Food features soft bagels with a nice chew and well-made sandwiches. The overall quality is usually good to amazing.

Breakfast sandwiches come on fresh bagels that are soft with a nice chew. Options like the Taylor ham and egg sandwich or ham, egg, and cheese with tomato sauce are well-portioned and freshly made.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the fresh, hot bagel sandwiches."

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"I thought these bagels were the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited; consider using side streets or nearby lots.

2

The shop gets very busy in the morning, especially on weekends.

3

Online ordering is often unavailable, so plan to order in person.

08
Bagel Run image 1
Bagel shop

Family-owned bagel shop offers fresh, fluffy bagels with a crispy outside and doughy middle. The atmosphere is busy and welcoming, filled with school kids, church goers, and hard workers. Lines move quickly, and generous portions come at good prices.

Food comes out fast thanks to the grill lady's speed. Dishes have good flavor and are fairly priced.

Breakfast sandwiches feature a good balance of Taylor Ham, egg, and cheese with a slightly charred flavor. Construction holds well, making the sandwiches above average and enjoyable.

People are saying

"I found the best bagels in North Jersey here."

"The staff here are super friendly and fast with your sandwich."

"I found their bagels to be very, very good and fresh."

Good to know

1

Bagel Run offers gluten-free bagels, but availability may vary.

2

Expect quick service; lines move fast during peak hours.

3

Prices are reasonable, with generous portion sizes.

Discover more

Saddle Brook, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...