Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Sandwich spots in Sayreville

A sandwich that actually holds together instead of falling apart the moment you take a bite.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Al's Grill & breakfast image 1
Al's Grill & breakfast image 2
Al's Grill & breakfast image 3
View all
Breakfast restaurant

Family-owned diner with freshly renovated space offers a cozy atmosphere and affordable prices. Friendly staff serve an extensive menu featuring comfort food and breakfast favorites. The place feels like a local hotspot for casual dining and takeout.

Food comes out fresh and flavorful with generous portions. Homemade beverages add to the comfort food vibe, making meals consistently good and satisfying.

Grilled chicken stands out as a tasty option. Breakfast sandwiches come highly recommended. Sandwiches come with fries that complement them well.

People are saying

"The food here is really good and fresh."

"The empanadas and waffles here make for a delicious breakfast."

"The breakfast sandwiches here are deeeelish and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The diner offers affordable prices for breakfast and brunch.

2

Takeout is available for those on the go.

3

Delivery service is offered in the nearby area.

02
Big Wally's Subs image 1
Sandwich shop

Small, crowded sub shop with takeout-only service and cash-only payments creates a hectic but friendly atmosphere. Family-run vibe shines through lively banter and old school subs with generous portions. Limited seating and basic interior keep focus on high-quality sandwiches rather than ambiance.

Food arrives exactly on time, keeping it fresh and ready to eat. Portions come in a large amount and the price is reasonable, making it a solid choice for delicatessen fare.

Subs come in great size with flavorful chicken and fresh ingredients. Specialty sandwiches like the Reuben and club are well made and tasty.

People are saying

"You get a huge amount of food for a really good price."

"I believed their sandwiches were the best in the county."

"It's a classic, authentic old school Jersey deli experience."

Good to know

1

Big Wally's Subs is a cash-only establishment.

2

It is best to call in an order ahead of time to avoid waiting.

3

Big Wally's Subs offers takeout only.

03
Margarita's Deli image 1

Deli offers affordable prices and generous portions with a steady crowd drawn by breakfast sandwiches known for their quality. Atmosphere feels like a local spot with a casual vibe, and only cash payments are accepted.

Food tastes consistently fresh and impeccable with great prices. Breakfast stands out as especially amazing and satisfying.

Monster sandwich stands out with its size and fresh preparation. Breakfast sandwiches come made to order with crispy bacon and a special quality that makes them memorable.

People are saying

"I thought the breakfast sandwiches were the best around."

"The food here offers great value for the quality."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was the best around."

Good to know

1

The deli accepts only cash payments.

2

Prices are very affordable for the quality offered.

3

Expect a busy lunch hour with a steady crowd.

04
Shahzadโ€™s Halal Food image 1

Small, cozy halal restaurant with an outdoor setup that evokes a New York vibe and a Jamaican influence. Atmosphere feels family-owned and welcoming, with lively, positive energy especially during late nights. Comfortable seating complements the friendly, intimate space.

Food here stands out for its freshly made dishes and incredible flavor. The chicken and rice ranks among the best halal meals in the area, offering a taste unlike any other.

Falafel sandwiches come with fluffy hot falafels, extra sauce, and fresh salad. Chicken sandwiches get toasted perfectly and can be customized exactly as requested. Staff consistently understand sandwich preferences well.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and always delicious."

"This is a great late night spot for good food."

"I thought their sandwiches were the best."

Good to know

1

Shahzadโ€™s Halal Food is open until 3 AM, which is convenient for late-night diners.

2

There is hardly any wait time during peak hours.

3

As a truck driver, I appreciated that they allow bobtail parking.

05
The Bar - Pizza Napoletana image 1

Large bar with friendly bartenders and plenty of TVs creates a lively setting. DJ spins house music with high-quality sound, making the atmosphere loud and energetic. Crowd enjoys authentic pizza and top-shelf cocktails in a clean, classy space with cool lighting.

Italian comfort food shines with chicken parmesan that stands out for its quality. Great pizza and bar food pair well with amazing drinks and stellar service.

Italian American favorites include a phenomenal Italian beef sandwich and a chicken parmesan sandwich. The menu also offers a chicken sandwich alongside short rib bites and burgers.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing and delicious."

"You've got to try the cocktails; they make them with top-shelf spirits."

"I found the Italian beef sandwich phenomenal."

Good to know

1

The bar hosts a Love Island watch party every Thursday night.

2

NFL Sundays feature all games broadcasted live at the bar.

3

Pizza is only served on weekends, so plan accordingly.

06
Lima Latin Peruvian Cuisine image 1
Peruvian restaurant

Cozy classic gothic space with vibrant Peruvian decor and Latin American music creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. The place feels authentic and neat, often lively and loud during visits. It stands out for family-style dining and a BYOB option.

Fresh and delicious food stands out with consistently great flavors. The menu offers authentic Peruvian dishes served with outstanding service in a pleasant atmosphere.

Steak sandwich stands out with rich flavor and satisfying taste. Chicken sandwich pairs well with salsa verde for added zest. Chicharrรณn sandwich often comes dry with minimal salsa criolla and lacks flavor.

People are saying

"The Peruvian food here is authentic and bursting with flavor."

"The ceviche here is bursting with flavor and so refreshing."

"I ate the most delicious steak sandwich I have ever eaten."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required on weekends to secure a table.

2

The restaurant has a BYOB policy, so bring your favorite drinks.

3

Expect wait times of up to 90 minutes for takeout orders.

07
Charleys Cheesesteaks and Wings image 1
Cheesesteak restaurant

Cheesesteak restaurant offers cozy yet classy vibe with friendly atmosphere and spotless cleanliness. Wings and cheesesteaks range from crispy and juicy to occasionally overcooked, with variety of sauces adding interest. Prices reflect quality, and fresh ingredients stand out in the food.

Food arrives freshly made and hot, served with a smile and brought to the table. The french fries stand out as some of the best among fast food, and every dish is seasoned with care and cooked with purpose.

Big sandwiches come with light bread and great provolone cheese. Chicken cheesesteak has melting cheese and fillings range from light to sufficiently stuffed.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always fresh."

"The cheesesteaks from the Drive Thru were pretty good."

"This cheesesteak sandwich is a big quality sandwich with great provolone."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

2

Expect a short wait time for food during lunch hours.

3

Prices are affordable compared to similar establishments.

08
Addy's Barbeque Sayreville image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Cozy halal barbecue spot with a warm, inviting atmosphere and a loft-style interior. Friendly, relaxed vibe feels like dining at someone's home with top-notch barbecue and unique Indian-inspired aromas. Known for amazing brisket and phenomenal mac and cheese that stand out in the local scene.

Food here stands out for its amazing quality and top notch flavor. The great selection offers consistently excellent dishes with reliable, friendly service.

Burnt end sandwiches come in huge portions and taste delicious. Chicken sandwiches, including BBQ and crispy styles, offer great value and satisfy with their size and flavor.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

"The beef ribs are smoky, tender, and fall right off the bone."

"The burnt ends sandwich was huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

All food served is zabiha halal.

2

They only sell whole pounds of meat and do not offer pork.

3

Half the menu is often unavailable to order.

09
Santino's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy dining room offers an old Italian vibe with a homey, warm atmosphere. Small space with limited seating creates an intimate setting. Pizzas feature Brooklyn-style slices that are hearty and flavorful.

Food here stays consistently fresh and high-quality. Italian dishes come in a casual, cozy setting with fine dining flavors.

Boars Head cold cuts create solid sandwiches here. Some sandwiches like the chicken parm can arrive cold. Entrees and wraps also match the quality of the pizza.

People are saying

"The pizza here is delicious with a perfectly crispy crust."

"This pizza is delicious and packed with flavor."

"I found the pizza here outstanding and hearty."

Good to know

1

Santino's Pizza is a BYOB restaurant.

2

The restaurant has limited seating, with only 8 or 9 tables.

3

Parking in the plaza is limited, which could be a challenge.

10
Shah's Halal Food image 1
Halal restaurant

Spacious halal restaurant with a clean, well-designed interior offers generous portions and flavorful sauces like a notable white sauce and hot sauce. The atmosphere suits quick lunches and late-night meals, attracting those seeking reliable, tasty options. Pricing tends to be higher than typical halal carts, reflecting its affordable yet quality-focused approach.

Food comes out hot and fresh with amazing flavor and explosive taste. Portions are decent and prices reasonable, with fast service and consistently good quality.

Chicken sandwich stands out with good flavor and is a favorite choice. Other options include lamb platter and chicken gyro, but the sandwich gets the most attention.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and always full of flavor."

"I thought the gyro platter had generous portions and was delicious."

"I loved their chicken sandwich; it's my favorite item."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers online ordering for takeout.

2

Expect to pay around $15.99 plus tax for a meal.

3

Portion sizes are generous for the price.

11
South Side 35 Diner image 1

Bright, clean diner with a classic aesthetic and varied seating options including booths and bar seats. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming with classic rock and pop music playing, creating a friendly and cozy vibe. Decor changes seasonally, adding a fresh touch to the inviting space.

Food here is consistently delicious with generous portions. Service complements the excellent quality of the meals.

Large portions stand out, especially the Crispy Chicken Sandwich and pastrami/corned beef special. Sandwich prices start around $9, with options like egg sandwiches that can be dry and toast that tends to be dark and crunchy.

People are saying

"The diner food was delicious, plentiful, and fairly priced."

"The food here is delicious and plentiful."

"This sandwich is huge, definitely enough for two meals."

Good to know

1

The diner is very clean and well-maintained.

2

Parking is ample and easily accessible from the highway.

3

Prices are slightly higher compared to other diners in the area.

12
Deli Plus image 1

Cozy deli with fresh daily bagels and Boar's Head meat offers a varied sandwich menu and ample parking. Tables and chairs provide space to eat in, while prices lean slightly high but remain reasonable compared to nearby options. Early visits may find only leftover bagels available.

Food here is generally good to very good with decent flavors. Some items like the breakfast sandwich feel pricey for the portion, and delivery orders sometimes include unwanted extras.

Breakfast sandwiches come with freshly made ingredients and include options like pork roll and egg and cheese. The menu offers a variety of sandwiches and wraps, though prices can be a bit high for portion size.

People are saying

"I loved their breakfast sandwiches, always made fresh."

"I enjoyed their great breakfast sandwiches."

"I thought the food here was usually good."

Good to know

1

There is ample parking available at the deli.

2

The menu features numerous choices of sandwiches and sides.

3

Deli Plus has a blackboard special that changes regularly.

Discover more

Sayreville, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...