Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Food and bars in Oak Island

A bar that feels like a local neighborhood staple rather than a place that treats you like a stranger.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Talina image 1
Talina image 2
Talina image 3
View all
Restaurant

Restaurant offers authentic Italian countryside decor with handcrafted cocktails and fresh homemade pasta. Atmosphere feels warm and cozy, transporting diners to Italy. Reservations are needed on busy nights due to popularity.

Authentic Italian dishes deliver true flavors from Italy with generous portions. The food quality pairs well with a warm, welcoming atmosphere for a complete dining experience.

A great cocktail bar vibe sets this spot apart, making it ideal for a night out or a date. Seating at the bar is immediate, and the cocktails are consistently fantastic.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and full of flavor."

"The pasta here is fresh, homemade, and delicious."

"The bartenders here craft the most amazing cocktails."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required on weekends due to high demand.

2

The kitchen closes an hour before the posted closing time.

3

Off-street parking is available in the back.

02
Mary Carroll’s image 1
Bar & grill

Classic Irish pub atmosphere fills the space with lively energy and occasional live music. Young crowds gather in the backyard area and around tables for a fun, social vibe centered on sports and nightlife.

Food offers great comfort and fantastic bar options at fair prices. Dishes are consistently delicious and worth ordering for takeout.

Classic Irish pub atmosphere shines through with authentic ownership by an Irish person. Food goes beyond typical bar fare, and the spot offers a quaint dive bar vibe with occasional live music.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and great."

"It's a great local pub with a real Irish atmosphere."

"I found this Irish pub had a real authentic atmosphere."

Good to know

1

Mary Carroll's is a kid-friendly pub, making it suitable for families.

2

Dan, the bartender, was voted Bartender of the Year, ensuring quality service.

3

The pub is run by an Irish owner, providing an authentic experience.

03
The Villager image 1

Extensive beer wall and craft beer selection set a distinctive tone. Cozy, old school atmosphere with a lively vibe that shifts to a party on weekends. Music is always on point with a large variety, attracting a cool mix of ages.

Food arrives on time thanks to attentive staff like Stephen, Anthony, and Dylan. The dishes serve up excellent quality consistently.

Offers a full bar with a tremendously large menu of craft beers. Serves top quality and creative Bistro/pub food alongside drinks.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be delicious."

"The food here is seriously delicious and always on point."

"The bar staff are super friendly and attentive."

Good to know

1

Happy hour starts at 4 PM on Tuesdays with special offerings.

2

The bar hosts live music until 10 PM on weekends.

3

Oyster events with Blue Point oysters and Casa Amigos tequila are hosted regularly.

04
Post Office Café image 1
American restaurant

Historic building hosts a spacious, modern interior with a private room featuring a fireplace and bar. Atmosphere stays friendly and relaxed, enhanced by live music and multiple TVs showing sports. Separate areas accommodate celebrations comfortably, including a soft play zone for kids.

Food here features careful preparation and pairs well with the pleasant ambience. Service complements the meal, making the whole experience smooth and enjoyable.

Large bar area features TVs everywhere for entertainment. Bartenders provide attentive service and politely handle unfamiliar drinks by looking them up.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the short ribs."

"The staff here made my party feel so special and accommodating."

"The bar staff were so friendly and attentive."

Good to know

1

The café offers a private room for events, ideal for celebrations.

2

Event planning is straightforward, with helpful staff to assist you.

3

Happy hour prices are available, but check your bill to ensure they are applied.

05
THE JAMES image 1
Restaurant

Renovated old Carriage House with beautiful interior, wrap-around staircase, and high ceilings creates a swanky, cozy atmosphere. Valet parking and an outdoor patio add convenience and charm. Upstairs space is stunning but noisy, with some seating reserved for VIPs.

Excellent food pairs with attentive staff and a great ambiance. The entire dining experience feels carefully crafted and satisfying.

A fully stocked mimosa bar keeps drinks flowing throughout events. The bar features a talented mixologist and offers impeccable service downstairs after events.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and perfectly portioned."

"The service for date spots is so attentive and delightful."

"The bar's espresso martini is a must-try."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 to 6pm with $5 draft beers and cocktails.

2

Food specials are available during happy hour.

3

Parking availability is limited due to reserved spots for owners.

06
Lily's Babylon image 1
American restaurant

Large bar with live music and an Irish flair creates a lively atmosphere. Music ranges from easy listening early to louder, crowded band performances later. Casual, friendly vibe draws people for drinks, dancing, and socializing.

Food here is consistently amazing and excellent. The menu pairs well with a cold beer and leaves guests satisfied.

Sports bar vibe with an Irish flair during the day. Offers wings and comfort food with quality that surprises for a pub. Seating is quick even when busy.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing and delicious."

"You have to check out the character brunch, my daughter loved seeing Bluey!"

"The bar food here is better than most, especially the burgers."

Good to know

1

Valet parking is available for guests at the venue.

2

Happy hour lunch offers half-price plates on select days.

3

The venue hosts themed brunch events, including character brunches.

07
The Local image 1

Open layout with train station décor and live music creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Noise levels rise high, making conversation difficult during busy times. Drinks and food offer variety, with some standout items like pierogi appetizers and refreshing cocktails.

Food arrives extremely fresh and hot with very good presentation. The menu includes a Lobster Roll Day deal offering great value alongside consistently delicious dishes.

A neighborhood sports bar with a friendly vibe where bartender Nick offers attentive service despite being busy. The bar serves both Bistro and Pub style food alongside drinks.

People are saying

"The staff at this Local Spot are so friendly and attentive."

"The food here is delicious and great."

"The bartender Nick made us feel like family at the bar."

Good to know

1

Wednesday is Lobster Roll Day, featuring three types of rolls and fries for $25.

2

Monday night bingo starts at 7pm but may end early for sports events.

3

Reservations are not required but recommended for busy nights.

Discover more

Oak Island, Babylon

Area guide
Loading Map...