Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cookies and cream bakeries in New York

You are looking for a bakery that treats cookies and cream with the same level of craft as their other goods.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Nothing Bundt Cakes image 1
Nothing Bundt Cakes image 2
Nothing Bundt Cakes image 3
View all

Bright, clean bakery with beautifully displayed cakes and a fresh, inviting atmosphere. Cakes are moist and rich, offering gluten-free options that stand out among similar shops. The space feels well-organized and cared for, attracting those seeking quality treats for gifts or gatherings.

Cookies and cream flavor appears in several items like bundt cakes and mini cakes. The bundt cake version features Oreo pieces, and mini cakes highlight a rich, creamy texture.

Freshness stands out with a beautiful bakery setting. The place feels inviting and earns consistent praise for its quality.

People are saying

"These cakes are so moist and delicious, I've never had better."

"The cakes at this bakery are delicious, moist, and fluffy."

"The Cookies and Cream mini cake tasted divine."

Good to know

1

This cake costs $56 and can feed more than 10 people.

2

Card payments are accepted, making transactions easy.

3

The cakes can be stored at room temperature for up to two days.

02
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop shines with moist cookies and cream cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie. Spotless bakery offers high-quality baked goods in a cozy, pink interior with soft jazz. Perfect for quick treats at two small tables.

Cookies and cream cupcake stands out for being moist and sweet. It ranks as a favorite flavor among several options tried.

Spotless and consistently amazing, this bakery offers a clean environment and high-quality baked goods. It stands out as a favorite spot known for its exceptional quality and reliable excellence.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"I considered this the best bakery in the city."

"The Cookies and Cream cupcake is light, soft, and tastes amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

03
Cookies and Cream Pastry Shop image 1

Small pastry shop offers a cozy atmosphere with cute outdoor seating and a warm vibe. Pastries are high quality and reasonably priced, with standout items like rich muffins and custom cakes. The space feels inviting for casual visits with friends or family.

Cookies and cream and carrot cake cookies stand out among several treats. Small local spot offers a friendly vibe and a variety of items beyond just mini cakes.

Affordable pricing and reliable service stand out here. Many choose this bakery for its consistent quality and easy cake ordering.

People are saying

"Their pastries are fresh, delicious, and have great flavor profiles."

"This bakery's cookies and pastries are fresh, light, and delicious."

"I loved the cookies and cream cake."

Good to know

1

Reservations for custom cakes require at least two weeks' notice.

2

Pricing for cakes, cupcakes, and cookies is very reasonable.

3

Customer service can vary; visiting early may improve your experience.

04
Smallcakes Scarsdale image 1

Cozy bakery with a boutique atmosphere and fresh-baked aroma creates a welcoming, family-friendly vibe. A DJ often plays great music, adding a fun and inviting energy to the space. Cupcakes feature unique, delicious flavors with eye-catching designs.

Cupcakes come in a cookies and cream flavor that stands out. Cookies and Cream cookies feature Oreo crumble for added texture and taste.

Fun and inviting atmosphere makes the bakery stand out. It hosts events and offers consistently quality baked goods in a cute setting.

People are saying

"I learned so much decorating my own cake at the class."

"This bakery has delicious cupcakes with mouth-watering decoration."

"The Cookies and Cream cookie with Oreo crumble was so good."

Good to know

1

Cupcakes After Dark offers a fun class for various events.

2

Expect limited parking availability, especially during busy hours.

3

Special flavors of the month are available, so call ahead to check.

05
Funny Face Bakery image 1

Small bakery with colorful, charming decor and creative, Instagramable cookies creates a cozy, adorable vibe. The air carries a pleasant, inviting aroma that complements the artistic presentation. Cookies are known for being decadent and delicious, often considered among the best available.

Cookies and cream treats feature a very sugary marshmallow taste and come in baked goods like cookies. Staff help with orders, and options include cookies and cream cookies alongside other flavors like s'mores and funfetti.

Cookies come out warm, showing a thoughtful touch not common in bakeries. The bakery offers Instagramable decor and affordable sweet treats perfect for any occasion.

People are saying

"I found the cookies to be amazing and delicious."

"Christian's warm welcome made the bakery feel amazing."

"I tried the cookies and cream, and it was very good."

Good to know

1

The establishment does not allow dogs inside, even service dogs, unless proof is provided.

2

The business closes at 8 PM.

3

Two of the regular cookies were already sold out on a rainy Thursday afternoon.

06
Spirals image 1
Bakery

Tiny bakery with adorable decor and warm, inviting atmosphere. Offers unique rotating flavors of cinnamon rolls, including sweet and savory options. Friendly staff create a cozy, welcoming vibe despite the small space.

Cookies and cream rolls come with a gooey texture and a sweet, rich flavor. Spirals offers these alongside other rolls, making it a notable choice for this flavor.

Rotating flavors of cinnamon rolls stand out here, with each batch fresh and visually appealing. The bakery combines adorable decor with friendly service, making it a welcoming spot for sweet treats.

People are saying

"I thought the cinnamon rolls were the best I'd ever had."

"This bakery's cinnamon rolls are huge, moist, and incredibly tasty."

"The Cookies and Cream flavor is gooey and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line on Saturday mornings, but it clears up by noon.

2

Cinnamon rolls are priced around $10 each, which some find excessive.

3

The bakery offers both sweet and savory rolls, including unique monthly flavors.

07
Schmackary's image 1

Small, clean bakery with freshly baked cookie aroma filling the air. Cozy, fun-spirited vibe with limited seating and heated outdoor tables. Offers unique cookie flavors and ice cream treats in a charming, compact space.

Cookies and cream stands out with its rich, creamy texture and crunchy cookie bits. The cookies and cream cookie also offers a yummy twist on the classic flavor.

Cookies here feel like Broadway baked into a cookie, dramatic and unforgettable. The bakery has a cute vibe and the smell from the street draws people in.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"This bakery's cookies can fix your mood and make you believe in happiness."

"The Cookies and Cream flavor was a standout."

Good to know

1

The ice cream shop has a 2 for 1 cookie sale.

2

New flavors come out regularly, check for updates.

3

Cookies may be given away at a discount right before closing.

08
Eileen's Special Cheesecake image 1

Small bakery with limited seating and a busy, cramped atmosphere. Customers often stand at a counter or bar area to enjoy cheesecakes, which are widely regarded as high-quality and flavorful. The space feels cozy but not suited for lingering or groups.

Cookies and cream cheesecake stands out as a best seller with a delicious flavor profile. It appears consistently among popular choices alongside salted caramel.

Offers every imaginable kind of mini cheesecakes with a focus on special cheesecakes. Bakery also operates as a restaurant, providing a variety of cheesecake options.

People are saying

"I found the cheesecake here to be divine and melt-in-your-mouth delicious."

"This bakery's cheesecakes are delicious, creamy, and perfectly balanced."

"The Cookies and Cream cheesecake is so creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

The shop is small and has no seating, so you will probably have to take your order to go.

2

Each cheesecake is freshly homemade on-site.

3

The prices are very expensive for non-New Yorkers in relation to the size.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...