Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New York

Banana pudding and Italian food

You want an Italian dinner that finishes with a classic banana pudding, and you expect both to be handled with care.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
SoulRibbean image 1
SoulRibbean image 2
SoulRibbean image 3
View all
Restaurant

Caribbean food spot with authentic dishes and rich cultural variety serves from a window setup. Atmosphere feels like a community staple with consistent quality that draws repeat orders. Menu includes standout items like oxtail, roti, and banana pudding.

Very fresh and creamy texture stands out in the banana pudding. Kids enjoy it a lot, and its appealing look often draws orders.

Rasta pasta shows up in many orders, sometimes paired with jerk chicken wings or oxtails. Portions vary, with some servings small and greasy, and flavors range from rich and flavorful to bland and microwaved.

People are saying

"The Oxtail here is fall-off-the-bone tender and flavorful."

"The Rasta pasta here is so flavorful and amazing."

"I tried the banana pudding; it was the best food I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is reasonably priced with generous portions.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

3

Reservations are recommended during peak hours.

02
Electric Beets image 1
Vegan restaurant

Cozy shop with beautiful interior and an art-drenched atmosphere creates a vibrant, positive vibe. Good music plays softly, enhancing the chill and fresh energy. Limited seating encourages a grab-and-go experience with many offerings made in-house and packaged in biodegradable containers.

Banana pudding stands out as a guiltless treat with a notably good taste. It pairs well with other fresh options like soups and wraps.

Lasagna stands out with a gluten free and vegan version that draws a lot of praise. The dishes focus on fresh, plant-based ingredients with options like the crunchy peanut salad and sesame noodles.

People are saying

"The vegetarian food here is outstanding, especially the mushroom sausage."

"The Italian food, especially the lasagna, is a must-try."

"The banana pudding here is my absolute favorite guiltless treat."

Good to know

1

The deli mostly functions as a grab-and-go but has limited seating inside and outside.

2

The food is always labeled depending on dietary restrictions.

3

Everything in the store is refined sugar free.

03
Busy Bee Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Cozy coffee shop with unique decor and bright, ample seating creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Jazz music and a charming backyard offer a relaxed vibe, perfect for quiet moments or casual gatherings. The space combines free wifi and beautiful design, making it ideal for both work and leisure.

Banana pudding comes as a dessert option alongside other sweets like lemon cake. It pairs well with drinks such as the strawberry matcha freddo. The menu also features banana waffles for banana lovers.

Chicken Alfredo stands out with a rich sauce and tender meat. Pasta dishes come across as really delicious. Tiramisu offers an interesting flavor different from traditional mascarpone but remains pleasant.

People are saying

"It's a nice, cozy little place to sit back and relax."

"I loved the homemade banana pudding with fresh vanilla wafers."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is really delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Finding residential street parking can be difficult during business hours.

3

There is construction outside, but the Google map times are accurate and they are open.

04
Angie's Soul House image 1
Soul food restaurant

Small space fills with crowds and lively energy, creating a family reunion vibe with soul music like Outkast and Wu-Tang playing. Staff share smiles and enjoy each other's company, adding to the welcoming atmosphere. Lines often merge with the waiting area, reflecting steady popularity.

Rich flavor and strong sweetness define the banana pudding here. It stands out as an amazing dessert that draws attention.

Rasta pasta stands out with its balanced heat and light creaminess. Sides like the tuna mac salad complement the meal well.

People are saying

"I found the soul food here to be the best on Long Island."

"This banana pudding is addictive; I might want to come back for more."

"The Italian food here is pretty good, with some heat."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult; arrive early to secure a spot.

2

No phone orders are accepted; you must order in person.

3

Expect long wait times if you don't order online ahead of time.

05
Cadence image 1
Restaurant

Intimate setting with plant-based Southern cuisine and friendly chefs seated along the kitchen counter. The atmosphere combines elegant decor with great music, creating a plush yet unpretentious vibe. Private rooms and heated outdoor spaces offer comfortable options beyond the main dining area.

Banana pudding comes with coconut whipped cream and stands out as a highlight of the meal.

Fried lasagna stands out with its perfectly crispy texture and a secret sauce that adds depth. Lasagne and oyster mushroom waffles offer an amazing mix of textures and flavors.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the cornbread, is outstanding."

"You have to try the fried lasagna; it's the best I ever had."

"I loved the banana pudding with real banana pieces."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required; no walk-ins are allowed.

2

You need to book more than a week in advance to get a table.

3

In January 2025, Cadence will be replacing the whole menu.

06
Nonnas of the World image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space with eclectic, whimsical decor feels like entering a grandmother's home. Friendly nonnas from around the world cook and mingle, creating a warm, personal atmosphere. Outdoor seating is minimal and basic, contrasting with the lively indoor vibe.

Banana pudding stands out as a phenomenal dessert here, often described as one of the best ever tasted. It has a rich, creamy texture that makes it easy to devour quickly.

Lasagna stands out with rich tomato sauce and layers of pastry. Meatballs and focaccia with red onion and pickled vegetables also feature prominently alongside fresh salads, fish, beef, and desserts.

People are saying

"The food here is absolutely amazing."

"The Italian Food, especially the lasagna and meatballs, is top notch."

"I've never had such a delicious, creamy, fresh Banana Pudding."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner at 5:30 or 7:30.

2

The restaurant is cash only or accepts Venmo for payment.

3

You need to call and reserve as there is no online option.

07
Willow Vegan Bistro image 1
Vegan restaurant

Mid-century modern decor with sound absorbing panels creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere despite tight table spacing. The space features huge windows that add natural light, balancing the compact layout. Music and lighting contribute to a warm, comfortable vibe where conversation is easy.

Rich, creamy texture defines the banana pudding here, making it a standout dessert. It pairs well with other dishes like the oyster mushroom calamari and Chefโ€™s Cookie Skillet for a satisfying finish.

Scallop Cacio e Pepe stands out with a nostalgic Italian flavor. Lasagne and ravioli offer classic Italian comfort, while Porcini Chick'n Marsala adds a unique twist to traditional dishes.

People are saying

"The vegetarian comfort food here is so flavorful and satisfying."

"I thought I knew good Banana Pudding until I tried theirs."

"The butternut squash ravioli is so flavorful and satisfying."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-priced drinks and finger food from 5 to 6:30 pm.

2

Sandwiches are discounted on Thursdays.

3

Reservations are recommended for weekends or busy hours.

08
Demo image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant combines cozy booth seating with a living front bar and cafe in a dark, atmospheric space. High noise level and wonderful lighting create an energetic vibe suited for intimate occasions or casual drinks. Wine program stands out, complementing a menu featuring memorable dishes like tuna head and scallops.

Melt-in-your-mouth texture defines the banana pudding here. It stands out as a memorable dessert that draws repeat orders and recipe searches.

Focaccia stands out with a moist crumb and crispy crust. Gemelli with duck confit ragu delivers a rich, savory punch that defines the meal.

People are saying

"The staff really knows their wine and makes great recommendations."

"I'd plan to return just for the banana pudding."

"The Italian food here is incredible, with unique twists on familiar dishes."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant takes both walk-ins and reservations for dining.

3

Expect to share 2-3 plates per person for a satisfying meal.

09
GG'S Fish & Chips image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small space with modern decor and a soda fountain counter creates a nostalgic feel. Loud, old school hip-hop music sets a 90's throwback vibe with family-oriented energy. Spacious outdoor seating includes heaters and a big screen, enhancing comfort and social atmosphere.

Rich and creamy texture defines the banana pudding here. It tastes delicious and holds up well for takeout.

Rasta Pasta features prominently with shrimp or fish options. Lemon wings and catfish also appear alongside these dishes.

People are saying

"The American food, especially the mac and cheese and collard greens, is amazing."

"I tried the banana pudding and it was delicious."

"I loved the rasta pasta with shrimp and mild spice."

Good to know

1

GG's delivers catfish every Thursday.

2

Get there a little early to avoid selling out.

3

Parking on their block is tough; be prepared to drive around.

10
Loco Lobster image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant with a modern fast food setup and clean, inviting atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant dining option despite limited access from inside. The vibe is relaxed and casual, welcoming guests with fresh decor and friendly energy.

Free dessert includes banana pudding that stands out for its rich, creamy texture. It earns five-star ratings alongside shrimp alfredo and delivers a flavor punch that could slap your mama.

Shrimp Alfredo pizza stands out with rich flavors. The hot lobster roll also draws attention. Chicken Alfredo offers a solid, enjoyable option.

People are saying

"I got two lobster rolls for the price of one through the app."

"The shrimp alfredo pizza and hot lobster roll are amazing Italian Food are amazing."

"I had the best Banana Pudding I ever had."

Good to know

1

Loco Lobster often offers a buy one get one free deal.

2

The parking lot is extremely slippery, posing a safety risk.

3

There is no easy access to the outdoor seating area from inside.

11
Simply Fried image 1
Restaurant

Small space with vintage car theme and Banksy-like wall art creates a chill, inviting atmosphere. Crowded seating includes bar-height stools and pipe tables, fostering a cozy vibe. Caribbean influences shape the energy, with lively music and a mix of savory and sweet menu options.

Banana pudding hits all the right places with a creamy texture and balanced sweetness. It pairs well with other dishes like oxtail Mac & cheese, making it a popular choice to order more than once.

Fried lasagna comes lightly breaded with an explosion of flavors. Rasta pasta with oxtail tends to be overcooked and lacks enough cheese.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and always fresh."

"The fried lasagna here is delicious and flavorful."

"The Banana Pudding was hitting all the right places."

Good to know

1

Street metered parking is available in front and across the street.

2

Expect a 10-40 minute wait for food during busy times.

3

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

12
C as in Charlie image 1
Korean restaurant

Tables sit close together in a warm, eclectic space filled with loud energy and interactive experiences like dessert painting. The vibe blends Korean jeong with Southern hospitality, creating a fun atmosphere suited for small groups. An open kitchen adds warmth, while music keeps the mood lively.

Banana pudding comes as a dessert that guests can draw on and enter a contest. It arrives alongside complimentary sweet tea and pairs well with dishes like mushroom bibimbap and oxtail pasta.

Ox bone cream pasta stands out with rich flavor. Seoul'sbury steak and popcorn chicken add unique twists to the menu. Baby back ribs and shrimp toast roll also feature prominently.

People are saying

"The toast roll and banana pudding dessert were my favorite dishes."

"The banana pudding here was good."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, was really delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to the crowd.

2

The restaurant offers a 22:30 dinner slot on Saturdays.

3

The place gets fun at the end of the night Thursday to Saturday nights.

13
Toss't and Press't image 1

Small restaurant offers a cozy setting with a welcoming atmosphere and community-centered vibe. Free samples and a new seating area with books create a relaxed space. Music plays softly, enhancing the inviting energy throughout.

Homemade banana pudding stands out with its rich flavor and creamy texture. The banana pudding biscuit served by staff adds a unique twist to the classic dessert.

Rasta pasta dishes come with oxtails and have a wet texture. Salmon bowl and jerk chicken options also appear alongside pasta offerings.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and so fresh."

"I loved the homemade banana pudding; I usually only eat it at home."

"I loved the Rasta Pasta with oxtail."

Good to know

1

Toss't and Press't is a carry out only restaurant.

2

Regular bowls cost about $16, with oxtail being an extra charge.

3

One bowl can easily serve two people and is very filling.

14
Virginia's image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant offers a warm, confident space with framed menus adding character and a tiny bar that feels inviting. The atmosphere is vibey and trendy, balancing music volume to create a chill and fun vibe. Outdoor terrace seating provides an additional option despite some discomfort on steep inclines.

Banana pudding stands out as a mouthwateringly amazing dessert often highlighted for its quality. It ranks among the top desserts in the city and pairs well with other sweets like chocolate lava cake.

Wild mushroom risotto stands out with its creamy texture and rich flavor. Other notable dishes include the Roasted Carrot Salad and Shrimp Cocktail with Calabrian Chili-Lime Aioli.

People are saying

"I thought Virginia's served one of the best burgers in the city."

"I could not leave without getting the mouthwateringly amazing Banana Pudding."

"The Italian Food here is delicious, especially the burger."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating with around 15 tables.

2

Virginia's charges $50 for last minute cancellations on reservations.

3

The burger costs $20, with sides like French fries adding an additional $12.

15
Cooklyn Eats BK image 1
Restaurant

Small hole-in-the-wall restaurant offers a friendly, welcoming atmosphere with pleasant vibes and good music. Seating feels stiff and uncomfortable, but the space remains aesthetically pleasing and cozy.

Banana pudding stands out with its cookie butter flavor and a texture that feels handmade and rich. It pairs well with other desserts like fried Oreos and consistently hits the mark as a sweet finish.

Jerk pasta stands out with bold, flavorful seasoning and generous portions. The Rasta pasta features a creamy garlic Parmesan sauce that complements the spicy notes well.

People are saying

"The jerk pasta here is silky-smooth and creamy."

"The banana pudding here is on a whole other level."

"You have to try the banana pudding; it's sinfully delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open until 3am for late-night dining.

2

Dine-in service is not available at this location.

3

Expect to pay $22 for a side, one protein, and a drink.

16
NY Bakery and Desserts Times Square image 1

Clean space with luxurious decor and a chocolate waterfall wall creates a striking setting. Loud music fills the air, making conversation challenging. Outdoor seating offers views of street shows and passersby, adding to the lively atmosphere.

Rich flavor and creamy texture define the banana pudding here. It consistently tastes delicious and stands out among desserts.

Tiramisu stands out with fresh pistachio and classic versions that many find amazing. The cannoli and Alfredo also get strong mentions for quality and service.

People are saying

"The desserts here are fresh and absolutely amazing."

"I found the banana pudding to be truly delicious."

"You'll find delicious Italian Food, like inventive pistachio tiramisu and sweet cannolis."

Good to know

1

There are no seats available inside the bakery, only outside seating.

2

The price of the apple turnover is $8 plus tip.

3

The bakery is located right in the middle of Times Square.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...