Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Brownies for birthday cakes

A birthday cake is a celebration, but a brownie is a non-negotiable requirement. You need a place that understands the importance of both.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 1
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 2
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 3
View all

Cozy bakery offers fudge brownies with rich chocolate and dense texture alongside custom birthday cakes featuring rainbow layers and fun themes like Minions. Friendly staff and a pleasant outdoor seating create a warm, inviting vibe perfect for relaxing or casual meetups.

Fudge Brownies stand out with rich chocolate flavor and dense texture. They join other sweet treats like Nutella pie and Oreo balls in the lineup.

Custom birthday cakes come in rainbow layers and themed designs like Minions. Coconut cakes taste just right, not too sweet. Orders complete on time with beautiful, tasty results.

People are saying

"This bakery made my daughter's birthday cake exactly as I requested."

"I thought the birthday cake was gorgeous and delicious."

"I thought the brownie here was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Visitors should get to the bakery early on weekends to try new items, as they sell out.

2

Ingredients could be modified due to allergens for special events.

3

Delivery from Crumbly is always on time.

02
Buttermilk Bakeshop image 1

Small bakery with an adorable interior and stunning decoration offers custom cakes that receive high praise for taste and appearance. The atmosphere is clean and organized, with a classic bakery scent filling the space. No seating is available, focusing on takeout and special orders.

Brownies here stand out for their creative flavors and amazing taste. The cornflake brownie gets a lot of praise for being especially good, described as a big slay.

Birthday cakes come in custom themes like Spider-Man and classic styles such as Confetti. Cakes serve groups up to 13 and are ordered repeatedly for family celebrations.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"The birthday cake is beautiful and delicious."

"This brownie is the most amazing I have ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The cake is ready at the designated pickup time.

2

The ordering and pickup process are super easy.

3

Buttermilk Bakeshop accommodates vegan and gluten-free guests by clearly marking everything.

03
Perfect Sweets in Auburndale image 1

Cozy cafe with a bright, charming interior offers a peaceful atmosphere where music plays softly. It attracts those seeking fresh, house-made pastries and exceptional coffee in a quiet neighborhood setting.

Chocolate brownies balance bitter and sweet flavors without being overly sweet. They look standard but deliver a rich, chocolatey experience that stands out from regular brownies.

Customizable birthday cakes stand out here with beautiful designs. The cakes consistently impress with their quality and appearance.

People are saying

"These cookies are pillowy, chewy, and perfectly sweet."

"I loved how custom and beautiful my birthday cake turned out."

"This brownie is a square of chocolate heaven, not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 10-20 minutes during peak hours.

2

Credit cards are accepted, along with mobile payment options.

3

Special orders for events require at least 48 hours notice.

04
Oh.Sweet.Mason [Desserts, Custom Birthday Cake & Specialty Cupcakes] image 1

Cozy and spacious bakery with a welcoming vibe and friendly staff. Custom cakes and cupcakes feature intricate fondant toppers and themed designs like sushi and casino chips. Dessert jars offer unique flavors such as biscoff cookie cheesecake and cinnamon toast crunch cheesecake.

Red velvet brownies stand out with a rich, creamy cheesecake swirl. Brownies come in jars alongside cookies and cakes, offering a unique presentation and varied flavors.

Custom birthday cakes come through even on short notice. Cakes impress with great taste and presentation.

People are saying

"I commissioned a masterpiece cake with a stunning theme."

"I loved the red velvet cheesecake brownie."

"The birthday cake here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Oh.Sweet.Mason provides desserts and sweet treats for events.

2

They offer a variety of cake and cheesecake shooters.

3

Cupcakes are available but may be pricey due to special decorations.

05
Taste Crème image 1

Bakery offers a calm and relaxing atmosphere with a cute, aesthetic design and a great seating area. Cakes and pastries are not too sweet and feature unique flavors like matcha and pandan with coconut. The place stands out for custom cake designs tailored to exact visions.

Chocolate fudge brownie croffle stands out with its rich texture. Matcha brownie offers a soft and light bite, ideal for an afternoon treat. Other options include hojicha brownie and black sesame cookie.

Custom birthday cakes come in various sizes, including a 10-foot option. Cakes often feature decorative flowers and are available for early pickup. They taste delicious and get eaten quickly.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and delicious, not too sweet."

"This birthday cake was beautifully designed and tasted amazing."

"The matcha brownie is soft and light."

Good to know

1

The online checkout does not work.

2

Each sponge cake costs $16.55.

3

The size of the cakes is small unless they are custom.

06
Saint Street Cakes image 1

Rustic, intimate bakery with cozy decor and semi-outdoor seating offers a warm, inviting atmosphere. Small cakes sell out quickly, attracting a steady flow of customers. Known for high-quality, beautifully presented cakes and standout cookies, including vegan options.

Gluten-free brownies stand out with a delicious taste and satisfying texture. Cookies and brownies both offer a high-quality bakery experience that invites repeat visits.

Morgan makes birthday cakes here and has done so for multiple years. Cakes for first birthdays are also available.

People are saying

"I thought the cakes here were out of this world."

"Their vegan cakes are beautiful and delicious, truly dessert heaven."

"I had the best vegan carrot birthday cake."

Good to know

1

The small cakes sell out quickly, so arrive early.

2

They often sell out of items even 2.5 hours after opening.

3

Visiting on weekdays helps avoid long lines.

07
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop with classic, old school design and pink, cute interior creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Soft jazz music plays while two small tables offer seating for quick treats. Known for outstanding cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake.

Brownies feature a cheesecake swirl and a rich interior fudge center. Gluten-free options exist, and the bakery offers a variety of brownies alongside cupcakes and bars.

Custom birthday cakes come with personalized messages and match exact requests. Flavors like red velvet and cookies n cream stand out as sweet and delicious options.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"I found the brownies to be rich and fudgy."

"The Birthday Cake service was so patient and helpful."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

08
Piece-A-Cake image 1

Spacious cafe filled with unique antiques and nostalgic decor inspired by historic New York scenes. Atmosphere is cozy and lively, often bustling with families and children running around. Displays showcase a wide variety of cakes and pastries, creating a sweet and inviting environment.

Brownies come in soft and rich varieties with intense flavor. Mini brownies and raspberry-filled options exist, though some can be dry and stiff or contain unexpected elements.

Custom birthday cakes feature moist Red Velvet and raspberry mousse options with detailed designs like sports logos. Staff provide helpful service and prices stay reasonable.

People are saying

"The cake here is delicious and not too sweet."

"This birthday cake was a hit at the party and raved about."

"I found the brownies outrageously delicious."

Good to know

1

Street parking is the only option available.

2

The prices for an average size coffee are around 6 or 7 dollars.

3

Ordering online is a better experience than showing up in person for breakfast.

09
Layers Bakeshop image 1

Cozy bakery with comfortable seating including couches and coffee tables invites relaxed visits. Unique flavored cupcakes and custom cakes draw attention for their variety and quality. Atmosphere feels casual and welcoming, similar to sitting in front of a familiar local spot.

Brownies come fresh and decadent with options like the White Chocolate Blondie and Nutella brownie. Slightly microwaving the Dubai chocolate brownie enhances its flavor, making it just perfect.

Quick service helps with birthday cake orders. Staff like Lilly assist in picking out cakes. This spot serves as a go-to source for birthday cakes and holiday desserts.

People are saying

"The cake here is so moist and delicious."

"Picking out a birthday cake here felt effortless and memorable."

"The brownie is just perfect, especially after microwaving it."

Good to know

1

They offer a wide variety of unique flavored ready-made cakes and treats.

2

Prices for cakes are reasonable compared to other local bakers.

3

The shop maintains a very clean environment.

10
Milk Bar image 1
Dessert shop

Industrial interior with pink theme and cute merchandise creates a bright, friendly atmosphere. Music is often loud and energizing, contributing to a lively vibe. Seating is limited and uncomfortable, with bar stools and picnic tables that don't suit groups well.

Brownies come with gooey marshmallow layers and a fluffy texture that stands out. Chocolate s'mores cheesecake brownies and soft-serve combos add variety and richness.

Moist, sweet, and nostalgic flavor defines the birthday cake here. The cake works well for parties and includes a popular birthday cake truffle variation.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be really tasty."

"I thought the birthday cake here was the best I ever had."

"I thought the brownie was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The location is very accessible as it is right on Broadway.

2

There is no place to sit at this location.

3

They charge for glasses without warning.

11
Iva’s Sweet Parlour image 1

Pastry shop offers cozy seating and elegant, stylish decor with a friendly vibe. Desserts feature beautiful presentation and include standout items like tres leches and brownies. The atmosphere feels welcoming and quaint with a high-end ambiance.

Chocolate brownie with mousse offers a rich, decadent taste. Brownies here stand out for their great flavor and pair well with hot chocolate.

Chocolate and dulce de leche birthday cakes come out delicious and well designed. Pickup is straightforward and convenient.

People are saying

"The tres leches cake here is so moist and flavorful."

"The chocolate brownie was decadent and to die for."

"The birthday cake here is great."

Good to know

1

Be wary of ordering on UberEats or Seamless as items may be forgotten.

2

The shop is open late for those looking for a sweet treat.

3

There is limited seating in the shop, so plan accordingly.

12
Billy's Bakery image 1

Old-fashioned bakery with nostalgic vintage decor and cozy farmhouse-style tables creates a welcoming, charming atmosphere. Small seating area supports a community-oriented vibe with inviting product displays. The place feels like a classic American bakery with a touch of movie-like charm.

Fudge brownies come in a balanced sweetness and are not overly chocolaty. Slices cost around $4.50, offering a delicious and affordable dessert option.

Birthday cakes come in reliable variety and consistently please crowds. Many orders happen yearly for family and work celebrations.

People are saying

"I ordered a gorgeous, custom cake that was exactly what I wanted."

"I've ordered so many birthday cakes here over the years."

"I believed they had the best brownie I had in NYC."

Good to know

1

A slice of cake costs $7, but the portion is small.

2

The price of a cupcake is $5.25.

3

Billy's offers vegan dessert options for those who cannot have regular desserts.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...