Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Birthday cake spots

A pudding that serves as a sophisticated alternative to a standard birthday cake, without losing the festive spirit.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 1
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 2
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 3
View all

Cozy space with warm, welcoming atmosphere and tasteful modern decor offers both indoor and outdoor seating. The air carries a distinctive baked goods aroma, enhancing the inviting vibe. Seasonal animatronic decorations add a playful touch to the experience.

Banana pudding stands out with its rich flavor and creamy texture. Rice pudding and banana bread pudding also offer unique twists on classic puddings.

Creative and personalized birthday cakes come with funny touches and detailed designs like volcano or unicorn themes. Cakes look amazing and taste great, even when made on short notice.

People are saying

"I got the perfect custom cake exactly as I requested."

"You have to try the banana pudding; it's amazing."

"The birthday cake looked amazing and tasted great."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers many gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Seating is limited to fewer than five people, so plan accordingly.

3

They have seasonal coffee options that change regularly.

02
Cakes by Nerwan image 1

Cake shop offers custom designs with fresh, visually stunning desserts including cupcakes, cake pops, and unique items like kunafsicles. Atmosphere feels aesthetically pleasing but lacks warmth. Pricing is notably high, reflecting an elevated, chic experience.

Banana pudding jars stand out with their rich flavor and creamy texture. Rice pudding and cake/cheesecake jars also offer smooth, satisfying options.

Birthday cakes come in unique flavors like cannoli and aperol spritz cupcakes with orange and vanilla. Custom designs are made from a single inspiration picture.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"The birthday cake here is just delicious."

"The banana pudding jars here are top tier."

Good to know

1

Cakes by Nerwan allows customers to select the design, flavor, filling, and color of the cake.

2

The best way to order cupcakes is through their website.

3

The cake was ready under a 24-hour timeline.

03
Oh.Sweet.Mason [Desserts, Custom Birthday Cake & Specialty Cupcakes] image 1

Cozy and spacious bakery with a welcoming vibe and friendly staff. Custom cakes and cupcakes feature intricate fondant toppers and themed designs like sushi and casino chips. Dessert jars offer unique flavors such as biscoff cookie cheesecake and cinnamon toast crunch cheesecake.

Banana pudding comes in mason jars and can be customized without bananas. It features a clear taste of real banana and strawberries.

Custom birthday cakes come through even on short notice. Cakes impress with great taste and presentation.

People are saying

"I commissioned a masterpiece cake with a stunning theme."

"I thought the banana pudding was amazing and perfectly chilled."

"The birthday cake here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Oh.Sweet.Mason provides desserts and sweet treats for events.

2

They offer a variety of cake and cheesecake shooters.

3

Cupcakes are available but may be pricey due to special decorations.

04
Bakelicious By Chef Manny Inc image 1

Bakery offers a cozy, family-owned atmosphere filled with the aroma of freshly baked goods and spotless, detailed decor. The space feels warm and inviting, reflecting pride and dedication in every aspect. It draws a diverse crowd seeking authentic, flavorful pastries and cakes.

Banana pudding stands out with its amazing flavor and exceptional quality. It draws repeat visits for its rich taste.

Custom birthday cakes feature detailed decorations and strong flavor that impress many. Cakes often match specific images or themes, like a Marshmello design or crema de leche flavor.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be so moist and delicious."

"This birthday cake was beautiful and delicious!"

"I tried their banana pudding; it was amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery takes custom orders for cakes.

2

The tres leches cake costs $5.

3

The establishment is very clean.

05
Butterly Bakeshop image 1

Narrow space with cozy modern decor and a chained yellow bike outside sets a charming scene. Warm atmosphere fills the air with the aroma of freshly baked goods. Known for moist cupcakes and rich banana pudding, it offers limited indoor seating and caters mainly to non-vegan, non-allergic customers.

Banana pudding stands out with its rich vanilla flavor, perfect fluffy texture, and balanced sweetness that is less sugary than Magnolia's. Nutella cookie and chocolate mousse cake also offer delicious dessert options.

Birthday cakes come out fresh, delicious, and attractive even with short notice. They rank among the yummiest in the city and have been a reliable choice for multiple years.

People are saying

"They recreated my custom cake design perfectly."

"I thought the banana pudding was the best I had ever tasted."

"They recreated my custom Birthday Cake design perfectly."

Good to know

1

The bakery is closed on Mondays.

2

The bakery offers great vegan and gluten-free options.

3

There is not much indoor seating available as the space is very narrow.

06
Leidylicious Cakes image 1

Small bakery with a retro pink and sky blue aesthetic creates a clean, charming, and cozy atmosphere. The space feels welcoming and full of personality, with limited seating for those who want to stay. Cupcakes and macarons stand out as the most delicious and distinctive treats offered.

Banana pudding stands out with a sweet, satisfying flavor that often surprises. The chocolate pudding cupcake offers a moist, rich texture that complements the other desserts well.

Birthday cakes here stand out for their beautiful design and delicious taste. Custom orders come from a woman-owned business and can be arranged even at the last minute.

People are saying

"They truly made my cake vision come to life."

"I found the banana pudding here to be amazing."

"I ordered a birthday cake that was beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of cupcakes and desserts including macarons and sugar cookies.

2

Prices are comparable to other bakeries in the area.

3

People with nut allergies should be cautious when visiting.

07
AshleysSweetTreatsInc. image 1

Pastel colors and cute, inviting decor create a sweet, friendly atmosphere with pleasant music and a heavenly scent. The bakery draws a crowd with beautifully decorated cupcakes and amazing banana pudding. It stays clean and accessible, offering a cozy space that sometimes expands for private events and lessons.

Banana pudding here is consistently delicious and served in jars or cups. The recipe is perfected and never misses, making it a standout dessert.

Custom birthday cakes match the provided pictures exactly. Multiple orders show consistent quality and attention to detail. The cakes have a personalized design and reliable visual accuracy.

People are saying

"These cupcakes are so moist and delicious, I'm always satisfied."

"This bakery's custom cakes and cupcakes are beautiful and delicious."

"I dreamed of their banana pudding; it was out of this world."

Good to know

1

The bakery is open every day except Monday.

2

Cupcakes are priced at $2 on Tuesdays.

3

A minimum purchase of two cupcakes is required.

08
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop with classic, old school design and pink, cute interior creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Soft jazz music plays while two small tables offer seating for quick treats. Known for outstanding cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake.

Creamy banana pudding stands out with rich flavor and smooth texture. The strawberry shortcake pudding offers a very creamy, sweet experience. Both puddings consistently impress with their deliciousness.

Custom birthday cakes come with personalized messages and match exact requests. Flavors like red velvet and cookies n cream stand out as sweet and delicious options.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"Their banana pudding is the best I've ever had."

"The Birthday Cake service was so patient and helpful."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

09
Huascar & Co. Bakeshop image 1

Tiny bakery with a beautifully decorated interior and outdoor cafe area offers a comforting atmosphere filled with the delicious smell of fresh baking. Customers enjoy unique gluten-free treats and exquisite cupcakes with bold flavors in a cozy, tucked-away setting.

Classic flan and banana pudding with salted caramel stand out as delicious puddings here. Tiramisu and spiked tres leches also appear on the menu for future tasting.

Custom birthday cakes and themed cupcakes come with detailed designs like mermaids. The bakery handles special orders with care and creativity.

People are saying

"These cupcakes are beautiful, delicious, and fresh."

"I found the puddings here to be delicious."

"The Birthday Cake was a stunning centerpiece and tasted delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery provides dependable delivery of delicious products.

2

The bakery offers desserts to go, including passion fruit cheesecake and tres leches cake.

3

The alfajores come individually packaged, making them great for gifts.

10
Ivaโ€™s Sweet Parlour image 1

Pastry shop offers cozy seating and elegant, stylish decor with a friendly vibe. Desserts feature beautiful presentation and include standout items like tres leches and brownies. The atmosphere feels welcoming and quaint with a high-end ambiance.

Banana pudding stands out as a favorite, praised for its flavor and recommended often. The coconut bread pudding also appears, noted for its quality and ingredient transparency, especially regarding dietary concerns.

Chocolate and dulce de leche birthday cakes come out delicious and well designed. Pickup is straightforward and convenient.

People are saying

"The tres leches cake here is so moist and flavorful."

"I definitely recommend the banana pudding."

"The birthday cake here is great."

Good to know

1

Be wary of ordering on UberEats or Seamless as items may be forgotten.

2

The shop is open late for those looking for a sweet treat.

3

There is limited seating in the shop, so plan accordingly.

11
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Bakery offers cozy indoor seating and a quiet backyard garden with beautiful lighting for a relaxed atmosphere. Space feels crowded and noisy inside, with tables placed closely together. Outdoor area provides a calm spot to enjoy desserts and drinks away from the bustle.

Bread pudding features a crispy outside and chewy inside texture. Banana pudding offers a rich, creamy feel with a whipped texture similar to cheesecake.

Custom birthday cakes come with smooth ordering and on-time delivery. Options include vegan, lemon blueberry, Nutella chocolate, and Tres Leche flavors.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be amazing and delicious."

"This birthday cake is light and so delicious."

"The banana pudding is rich, creamy, and has a whipped texture."

Good to know

1

Mia's is open until midnight on weekends and 10 PM on weeknights.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for to-go desserts during peak hours.

3

Parking near the bakery is challenging, with limited metered spaces.

12
SHAKALAKA BAKERY image 1
Chinese bakery

Chinese bakery offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with rustic decor and soft lighting. Spacious seating includes free Wi-Fi and outlets, making it suitable for chatting or studying. The environment feels clean and comfortable with a large variety of pastries and drinks.

German-style pudding tarts stand out with their rich flavor and creamy texture. Pudding egg tarts offer a smooth, custardy filling that pairs well with the flaky crust.

Birthday cakes here are not too sweet and offer good value for money. Custom cakes include Chinese style designs and come at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautifully decorated and not too sweet."

"I always ordered my son's birthday cakes from here and loved them."

"The German puddings here are so tasty and creamy."

Good to know

1

You have to make a reservation to eat at the bakery.

2

The bakery closes at 8:30 PM.

3

Some popular pastries or sweets will be sold out before afternoon due to high demand.

13
Make My Cake image 1

Bright, clean bakery with a vibrant atmosphere and friendly team. Known for moist red velvet cakes and divine key lime pie. Offers some of the best cheesecakes and sweet potato cheesecake in the city.

Banana pudding varies here, with some batches being amazing and others watery with bad bananas. It can be dangerously good or the worst ever, showing inconsistency in quality.

Birthday cakes come with easy last-minute ordering and simple decoration options. Planning ahead works too, with inquiries accepted up to five weeks in advance.

People are saying

"I thought the red velvet cake was the best."

"This banana pudding is so good, it transported me back to the South."

"I loved the Birthday Cake; it tasted great."

Good to know

1

The price for a 6" cake is $50, which is considered very high.

2

Cupcakes are priced at $4 each, which some find overpriced.

3

The bakery does not provide proper boxes for cakes over 8 inches.

14
Doc's Cake Shop image 1

Bakery offers heavenly aromas and a cozy, welcoming vibe with Gospel music playing in the background. Large cake slices and a wide variety of southern-style cakes draw a steady crowd. Central cake displays and a wall counter without seats create a simple, focused space.

Banana pudding stands out as a favorite, often described as amazing and better than other well-known spots. Other puddings like strawberry also get mentions, but banana pudding clearly leads the way.

Birthday cakes come in various styles here, with some being delicious and suitable for special occasions like a 60th birthday. However, mistakes happen, as some cakes are done incorrectly.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be delicious and fluffy."

"I loved their banana pudding; it tasted so amazing."

"I got a birthday cake here and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

They have a $10 credit card minimum.

2

The price for a cake starts at $75.

3

You need at least a week to two weeks' notice for cake orders.

15
Sugar'd image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Caribbean restaurant with stylish gold decor and live floral arrangements creates a classy, vibrant atmosphere. Music features Afro beats, soca, and reggae played by a live DJ, setting an energetic tone suitable for dancing. Seating options include outdoor, main room, and a back lounge with a mini bar, offering varied experiences.

Warm coconut bread pudding stands out as a dessert option, often served with ice cream. It sells out quickly, showing its popularity among the choices.

Chocolate lava cake arrives with a cute presentation that makes birthdays feel special. It draws clear appreciation and adds a memorable touch to celebrations.

People are saying

"The food here is flavorful, fresh, and perfectly cooked."

"The warm coconut bread pudding with ice cream is surprisingly good."

"They made her feel special with the birthday cake."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during busy hours, especially on weekends.

2

Parking is rough, so keep that in mind when preparing to visit.

3

The location is easy to find and very close to the train.

16
Billy's Bakery image 1

Old-fashioned bakery with nostalgic vintage decor and cozy farmhouse-style tables creates a welcoming, charming atmosphere. Small seating area supports a community-oriented vibe with inviting product displays. The place feels like a classic American bakery with a touch of movie-like charm.

Banana pudding features smashed cupcakes and a banana-forward flavor. Some batches taste homemade, while others seem made from an instant mix.

Birthday cakes come in reliable variety and consistently please crowds. Many orders happen yearly for family and work celebrations.

People are saying

"I ordered a gorgeous, custom cake that was exactly what I wanted."

"Their banana pudding is the best I've ever had."

"I've ordered so many birthday cakes here over the years."

Good to know

1

A slice of cake costs $7, but the portion is small.

2

The price of a cupcake is $5.25.

3

Billy's offers vegan dessert options for those who cannot have regular desserts.

17
Martha's Country Bakery image 1

Spacious bakery with plenty of seating and an appealing design creates a welcoming environment. Evenings feature a live DJ spinning an eclectic mix of music, making the atmosphere lively and energetic. Outdoor seating adds to the relaxed vibe during quieter hours.

Banana pudding stands out with its creamy texture and use of real bananas. Other notable puddings include rice pudding and banana chocolate bread pudding, all praised for their rich flavors.

Birthday cakes come in flavors like strawberry shortcake and tres leches peach. Cakes can be ordered in advance and are consistently delicious.

People are saying

"The pastries here are amazing and generously filled for the price."

"I thought the banana pudding was fantastic."

"The birthday cakes here are so fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

On Mondays, gourmet cupcakes are on special for only $1.95 each.

2

The shop has a daily promotion with different specials each day.

3

They have a deal of the day where a different pastry or cake slice is half off.

18
Magnolia Bakery image 1

Small bakery designed for take-out only with a cozy atmosphere and sweet aromas of freshly baked goods. The space is limited, often crowded, with no seating inside but nearby outdoor options. Known for exceptional banana pudding and a variety of desserts.

Banana pudding stands out for being moist and creamy without being overly sweet. It offers a delicious, balanced flavor that many find memorable.

Birthday cakes get ordered here but often come with issues like receiving the wrong item or staff forgetting the order. Picking up a cake can turn into an unpleasant experience due to these problems.

People are saying

"Their banana pudding is smooth and flavorful."

"The caramel pecan cheesecake is creamy, sweet, and rich."

"I will be dreaming about this Birthday Cake for weeks."

Good to know

1

Magnolia Bakery is for takeout only; there is no seating available.

2

Expect long lines on weekends due to high demand for banana pudding.

3

Banana pudding is often sold out by the end of the day.

19
NY Bakery and Desserts Midtown image 1

Bright, cozy bakery with beautiful decor and a flowing chocolate fountain creates a friendly atmosphere. Seating includes a small back area and outdoor options, offering a comfortable place to enjoy a wide array of desserts. The vibe is inviting and the space feels clean and well-appointed.

Banana pudding stands out with its good pudding mixture and layering, offering a flavor many find better than Magnolia's. Chocolate pudding and cannoli come with balanced sweetness and rich taste.

Personalized birthday cakes come in jars or traditional styles here. The bakery offers a wide variety of desserts including cheesecakes and cupcakes alongside birthday cakes.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be amazing."

"I thought the banana pudding was the best I had ever tasted."

"I ordered a personalized birthday cake and it was amazing."

Good to know

1

The establishment is open 24 hours for late-night cravings.

2

Cheesecakes and desserts are available late at night.

3

No vegan options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...