Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New York

Pastry for birthday parties

A celebration deserves a table filled with delicate pastries to share with everyone.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Patsy's and Son Italian Bakery image 1
Patsy's and Son Italian Bakery image 2
Patsy's and Son Italian Bakery image 3
View all

Old school bakery with a friendly atmosphere and classic Italian pastries. Offers handmade cakes and cookies that stand out for their authentic taste and quality. Known for special occasion cakes and traditional treats like Saint Joseph's pastries.

Fresh pastries include Black and Whites and Cassata cake, plus Saint Joseph's pastries appear on the feast day. Bread, cookies, and Italian ices complement the delicious, authentic Italian pastries.

Specialty cakes like red velvet and custom cookie favors come together for birthday parties. Collaboration with staff on multiple cakes and favors supports personalized celebrations.

People are saying

"This bakery's cakes are stunning and taste incredible."

"I found their Italian pastries to be the best."

"Victoria makes my cake visions a reality for Birthday Parties."

Good to know

1

Patsy's offers a variety of pastries, cookies, and cakes.

2

Single-serving cakes are available in many flavors.

3

Metered parking is available out front.

02
Sweet Touch by Iva image 1
Wedding bakery

Rustic design and warm, inviting atmosphere create a unique setting for enjoying beautiful, custom cakes. Attention to detail and impeccable craftsmanship stand out in every dessert. The space feels like a hidden gem with a rich, thoughtful aesthetic.

Pastries come out fresh and beautifully made with consistent full flavor. Custom orders maintain high quality and impressive presentation.

Custom cakes stand out with detailed designs like a Mermaid cake. They handle last-minute orders and offer delivery for birthday parties.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and delicious."

"The cakes here are beautiful and perfect for kid-friendly parties."

"The custom cakes for Birthday Parties here are beautiful and perfectly crafted."

Good to know

1

The ordering process is easy and can be done online.

2

Delivery options are available and reasonably priced.

3

Custom cakes can be created in as little as 48 hours.

03
The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant image 1

Victorian tea party style fills the space with whimsical decor and a wall of hats for guests to wear. The atmosphere stays cozy and inviting, welcoming all ages with a relaxing vibe. A full bar offers themed cocktails alongside delicious scones and treats.

A two-tier tower arrives stacked with a huge variety of pastries alongside tea sandwiches, fruit, and scones. The pastries are consistently magnificent and pair well with clotted cream and jam.

Spaces accommodate groups around 35 people comfortably for birthday celebrations. The atmosphere supports family gatherings and offers a pleasant setting for parties.

People are saying

"The high tea here is perfection, with delicious sandwiches and scones."

"The food for Birthday Parties, especially the scones, was delicious."

"The pastries here are delightful and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for all events at The Mad Batter.

2

Drag Bingo occurs every first Saturday of the month at 7pm.

3

The venue hosts themed events like tarot reading and trivia nights.

04
Conti's Pastry Shoppe image 1

Bakery offers wide variety of Italian pastries displayed in orderly glass counters within a beautiful, vintage atmosphere with modern twist. The space feels clean and inviting, with outdoor seating and a full coffee bar adding to the experience.

Custom-made cakes and Italian pastries stand out here. Cakes like the Boston Cream and themed options such as the Nacho Libre cake are popular for events including weddings and birthdays.

Birthday parties feature custom cakes like gluten free vanilla with dulce de leche filling. Options include sheet cakes and two-tier cakes that guests enjoy.

People are saying

"They executed the custom cake design exactly to my vision."

"The pastries here are beautiful, fresh, and delicious."

"The cakes for birthday parties here are beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

You should preorder your custom cake in advance around the holidays due to high demand.

2

The bakery has a 2-day notice for placing cake orders.

3

Expect long lines on holidays like Christmas Eve due to high customer volume.

05
Taste Crรจme image 1

Bakery offers a calm and relaxing atmosphere with a cute, aesthetic design and a great seating area. Cakes and pastries are not too sweet and feature unique flavors like matcha and pandan with coconut. The place stands out for custom cake designs tailored to exact visions.

Delicious pastries stand out here with rich flavors and satisfying textures. Every pastry and dessert offers a consistently enjoyable taste experience.

Custom cakes stand out for birthday parties, crafted specifically for each celebration. Multiple orders show consistent quality and attention to detail for kids' birthdays.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and delicious, not too sweet."

"The cakes for birthday parties here taste absolutely delicious."

"The blueberry earl grey cake pastry is amazing and perfectly sweet."

Good to know

1

The online checkout does not work.

2

Each sponge cake costs $16.55.

3

The size of the cakes is small unless they are custom.

06
Buttermilk Bakeshop image 1

Bright, airy space with vintage-themed decor creates a comfortable atmosphere. Cakes and cupcakes stand out for their moist, delicious flavors and custom designs that impress guests. Mainly a baking facility, it focuses on quick service and quality treats without seating or drinks.

Pastries come out moist and delicious with prices that stay reasonable.

Birthday parties here run smoothly with kids baking activities led by the owner. The space handles groups well and creates an enjoyable, hands-on experience for children.

People are saying

"The cakes here are stunning and delicious."

"The kids loved baking and decorating cupcakes at the birthday party."

"I loved their moist and delicious pastries."

Good to know

1

The bakery makes all types of birthday and holiday cakes.

2

The ordering process is easy and convenient.

3

They deliver cupcakes for special occasions.

07
Sherry's Weakness 4 Sweetness image 1

Spacious bakery with a clean, welcoming environment and exclusive decorations for occasions. The atmosphere is warm and cute, with a focus on authentic Guyanese flavors and made-to-order desserts. Customers often praise the delicious cakes and friendly service.

Pastries here capture a taste of Guyana with every bite. They stand out for their pure perfection and consistently impress alongside the cakes and other baked goods.

Catering includes custom made cakes with flavors like chocolate and red velvet. Plenty of delicious food options let hosts avoid kitchen time during birthday parties.

People are saying

"I've ordered many amazing cakes from Sherry for birthdays and events."

"I've been ordering Sherry's amazing pastries for over ten years."

"I loved the cake at the Birthday Parties here!"

Good to know

1

You need to order your cupcakes 2 weeks in advance for your event.

2

Sherry's Weakness 4 Sweetness accommodates food allergies and sensitivities.

3

Food is ready for pickup or delivery.

08
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with rustic wooden accents and beautiful decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Comfortable seating indoors and outdoors supports relaxed visits, though loud music sometimes fills the space. Cakes and desserts stand out as memorable and excellent offerings.

Croissant-style pastries feature a flaky, buttery dough that stands out. The selection includes pain au chocolat and savory options, all displayed in an incredible assortment for dine-in or takeout.

Custom cakes with personalized designs and flavors fit birthday themes well. Consistent quality makes them a reliable choice for birthday celebrations.

People are saying

"The custom cake came out exactly how I imagined it."

"I was so pleased with how the custom cakes looked exactly like the online images."

"The cakes for birthday parties here looked incredible and tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for custom cake orders, especially for weekends.

2

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and vegan options.

3

Cakes are prepared in advance and may not be freshly baked.

09
AnnTremet Cake image 1

Small bakery with just a few tables inside and one outside offers a cozy atmosphere and stylish presentation of intricately designed cakes. The space feels minimalist with white walls and limited decor, creating a simple backdrop for the artful desserts.

Pastries here offer unique and flavorful options without being too sweet. Highlights include Black Sesame, Sakura Cheesecake, and Pandan Coconut pastries, all crafted with strict quality control and beautiful presentation.

Strawberry birthday cakes impress guests and make parties memorable. Cakes ordered online arrive fresh and become the talk of the party.

People are saying

"Annabelle was so helpful and patient with my cake questions."

"I enjoyed the afternoon tea for its great flavors and attention to detail."

"The strawberry birthday cake was gorgeous and so yummy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly advised due to limited seating.

2

The Halloween Afternoon Tea costs $52 per person and features eerie treats.

3

Christmas tea time slots fill up quickly, so book early.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...