Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New York

Birthday parties with sandwiches

Made for those who want a low-key birthday gathering built around high-quality, reliable sandwiches.

Based on 936 Opinions
+933
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The BlackSheep at Miller Place image 1
The BlackSheep at Miller Place image 2
The BlackSheep at Miller Place image 3
View all

Fusion restaurant offers warm, inviting atmosphere with a local charm and relaxed, comfortable vibe. Menu features unusual, mostly scratch-made dishes with many gluten-free and vegan options, appealing to diverse tastes. Family-friendly setting includes amenities like crayons and toys for children.

Hosts birthday parties for all ages, from toddlers to seniors. Offers personalized attention and flawless execution for celebrations.

Sandwiches feature gourmet flavors like chicken with pesto and goat cheese. Options include a fried pesto chicken sandwich, a steak sandwich, and a notable eggplant sandwich.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and plentiful."

"You have to try the pesto chicken sandwich; it's gourmet excellent."

"The food at birthday parties here is amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of gluten-free options on the menu.

2

Prices are reasonable, with a family meal costing around $72.

3

Kids' selections include vegan options, catering to diverse dietary needs.

02
Goldy's Gems image 1

Cozy bar with comfortable seating and a lounge vibe shifts into a lively club atmosphere when DJs play. Music balances well with socializing, supported by board games and darts for a laid-back feel. Lighting and decor create a warm, inviting space that suits casual gatherings and private events.

Hosts birthday parties for all ages, from a first birthday to a 60th surprise. Supports joint celebrations and surprise events with a smooth experience.

Spicy chicken sandwich stands out with real, hearty portions. Fries complement the delicious, full-sized sandwiches well.

People are saying

"The food here was really good and plentiful."

"The staff made my birthday party a hit and took all the stress off me."

"I claimed their chicken sandwich is better than Popeyes or Chick-fil-A."

Good to know

1

Goldy's Gems comfortably fits up to 65 guests for private events.

2

The venue offers a DJ package included in party bookings.

3

Booking a party at Goldy's Gems is a straightforward process.

03
The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant image 1

Victorian tea party style fills the space with whimsical decor and a wall of hats for guests to wear. The atmosphere stays cozy and inviting, welcoming all ages with a relaxing vibe. A full bar offers themed cocktails alongside delicious scones and treats.

Spaces accommodate groups around 35 people comfortably for birthday celebrations. The atmosphere supports family gatherings and offers a pleasant setting for parties.

Everyone gets a tower of sandwiches with scones and desserts. The sandwiches are excellent.

People are saying

"The high tea here is perfection, with delicious sandwiches and scones."

"The sandwiches here are a nice big size and beautifully arranged."

"The food for Birthday Parties, especially the scones, was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for all events at The Mad Batter.

2

Drag Bingo occurs every first Saturday of the month at 7pm.

3

The venue hosts themed events like tarot reading and trivia nights.

04
Farington's Cafe and Restaurant image 1

Restaurant offers an intimate atmosphere with elegant decor and cloth tablecloths creating a classy, modern vibe. Space feels homely and comfortable, though some tables sit close together. Light music plays softly, supporting a relaxed environment suited for easy conversation.

Hosts birthday parties for various ages, including first birthdays and toddler celebrations. Accommodates groups up to 21 people for brunch gatherings.

Steak and egg sandwich stands out with fluffy bread and chipotle mayo. Fish and chicken parmesan sandwiches also deliver solid flavors.

People are saying

"The staff made me feel like family during Brunch."

"The food for Birthday Parties here is always delicious."

"The steak and egg sandwich here is delicious, especially the fluffy bread."

Good to know

1

The restaurant provides accommodation for food allergies.

2

Farington's Cafe and Restaurant offers brunch for only $18.95.

3

The best bet for parking is to park on Richmond Avenue.

05
Avoca image 1

Backyard patio offers a quaint and spacious setting with beautifully renovated interior and dog-friendly amenities. Loud music, including rap during brunch, creates a lively atmosphere that suits private events and group gatherings. The space balances sunlit outdoor areas with cozy indoor seating.

The back patio offers a spacious setting that fits around 50 people comfortably. It works well for surprise parties and first birthdays, creating a lively and enjoyable atmosphere.

Fried chicken sandwich stands out with its flavorful taste and comes with crispy fries. Egg white smash sandwich pairs well with seasoned breakfast potatoes cut into wedges.

People are saying

"The food here is super good and delicious."

"The staff made our Birthday Parties feel so welcome and helpful."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was really good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as this place gets booked up quickly.

2

Happy hour prices are available until dinner time on weekdays.

3

On Taco Tuesday, three tacos are available for $10.

06
The Horny Ram image 1

Bar shines with bottomless mimosas and a lively atmosphere perfect for birthday parties. Sandwiches like the Korean steak and crispy fish offer bold flavors. Cozy southern vibe and unique decor add charm indoors and on the outdoor porch.

Large groups fit well for birthday parties here. The space suits celebrations with a lively atmosphere.

Korean steak sandwich stands out with rich flavors, paired well with honey hot wings. The crispy fish sandwich cooks to a perfect crunch, while the chicken and waffle sandwich offers a unique twist.

People are saying

"The bottomless brunch experience here is amazing and worth doing."

"I ordered the steak sandwich and it did not disappoint."

"The food for birthday parties here is amazing."

Good to know

1

The bottomless brunch allows unlimited top ups from a choice of bellinis and mimosas.

2

You can only order from the Brunch menu on Sunday from 11am - 4pm.

3

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with great deals.

07
Arcadia Bar and Kitchen image 1

Gastropub with a cozy backyard garden and quirky decor offers a quiet, chill atmosphere ideal for conversations. Lively bar area features TV screens and comedy shows, attracting a mix of locals. Outdoor seating is dog friendly and complements the welcoming vibe.

Hosts surprise parties and milestone celebrations like 16th birthdays. Staff are accommodating to different party needs.

Hot chicken sandwich stands out with strong flavor, though the chicken can be dry sometimes. The chicken Parmesan sandwich shines on garlic bread, adding a rich taste.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and perfectly seasoned."

"The food and service for Birthday Parties here are excellent."

"The chicken parm sandwich here is excellent, especially on garlic bread."

Good to know

1

The happy hour deal is awesome, offering great discounts on drinks.

2

Trivia night happens every Thursday at 8pm with a fun atmosphere.

3

Open mic comedy night is on Wednesdays, providing a lively entertainment option.

08
Tara Rose| NYC image 1
Cocktail bar

Cocktail bar offers live music and a warm, intimate atmosphere with beautiful decor and outdoor seating. Energetic vibes attract groups for drinks and private parties, with a spacious downstairs speakeasy available for reservations. Guests often enjoy personalized music control and a lively, fun environment.

The Speakeasy room hosts birthday parties with a private, intimate vibe. Groups celebrate milestones like 25th and 30th birthdays there.

Steak sandwiches come out perfectly cooked and packed with flavor. Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich also stands out among the lunch specials offered with sides and drinks.

People are saying

"The food here was delicious and perfectly fitting for an afternoon get-together."

"The bartenders here make Birthday Parties personable and fun."

"The steak sandwich is super flavorful and cooked perfectly."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 PM to 7 PM, Monday to Friday.

2

The restaurant offers $25 bottomless drinks for 1.5 hours on weekends.

3

An entree purchase is required for the bottomless brunch.

09
The Naked Pig image 1

Bar space buzzes with lively atmosphere thanks to multiple TVs and a stellar DJ. Perfect for birthday parties, it runs smoothly and keeps energy high. Food shines with pulled pork and French dip sandwiches, plus a unique Waffle Sandwich twist.

The space offers a great setting for birthday parties with everything running smoothly. Many find it a perfect spot to celebrate and enjoy the occasion.

Pulled pork and French dip sandwiches stand out for their tasty and incredible flavors. The Waffle Sandwich offers a deliciously unique twist, while the chicken club delivers a solid classic option.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the nachos, is amazing."

"I loved the pulled pork sandwich; it was amazing."

"I had the best birthday party ever."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals are available every day from 4-7pm and 10pm-close.

2

Weekend reservations are a must for boozy brunch.

3

Expect a 90-minute limit on unlimited brunch drinks.

10
The Flying Cock image 1

Bar space combines upmarket design with open outdoor seating and a fire bar centerpiece. Atmosphere stays confident and fun, energized by a fabulous music playlist and lively crowds. Tables sit close together, encouraging conversation and a social vibe.

Hosts birthday parties for groups up to 30 in the back bar with good vibes. Offers bottomless brunch options during celebrations.

Crispy chicken sandwiches stand out with tender, flavorful meat. Sandwiches often come paired with mac and cheese, adding a rich, creamy touch. Waffle sandwiches offer a unique twist on the classic.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"This chicken sandwich is tender, crispy, and packed with flavor."

"The staff went above and beyond for our Birthday Parties."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for bottomless brunch on weekends.

2

Happy hour runs daily from 4-8 PM with great deals.

3

The bottomless brunch is available only on weekends.

11
Mary's image 1

Back room features a giant disco ball and big screen, creating a lively party space. Classic antique wooden bar anchors the front, offering sports and an extensive menu. Atmosphere stays friendly and relaxed, with music and dance floor energizing the space without overpowering conversation.

Booking a reserved area for birthday parties is straightforward. The bar gets packed, creating a lively atmosphere for celebrations.

Crispy chicken sandwich comes on homemade bread and tastes delicious. It pairs well with a cold beer.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic, especially the comfort food."

"The food for Birthday Parties here is great, especially the pimento dip."

"The crispy chicken sandwich here is delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour drink pricing is available until 7 PM.

2

The establishment has a great selection of food and drinks.

3

The place can get busy, especially during peak hours.

12
Jody's Club Forest image 1
Irish restaurant

Irish restaurant combines old school charm with a spacious bar area and multiple sports TVs. Atmosphere stays relaxed and inviting, with a neighborhood feel where patrons interact like family. Music from a DJ adds energy without overpowering the comfortable vibe.

Hosts birthday parties for all ages, from baby's 1st birthdays to 21st and 40th celebrations. Offers a space suitable for both intimate and larger gatherings.

Steak sandwich stands out with strong flavor. The Gobble sandwich also ranks highly. Turkey club stays consistently good, but pastrami falls short.

People are saying

"The American food here is delicious and flavorful."

"I found the steak sandwich to be amazing."

"The staff here is so patient and accommodating for Birthday Parties."

Good to know

1

The venue is great for small events and private parties.

2

Expect a lively atmosphere during events like the St. Patrick's Day Parade.

3

The restaurant offers affordable meals, with burgers and fries priced at $8.

13
Tap Room image 1
Restaurant

Long bar with plenty of TVs creates a classic US pub setting. Atmosphere is fun and friendly, lively with occasional live music performances. Spacious seating includes an upstairs party room, making it suitable for groups and events.

Events can take over the entire 2nd floor for large groups. Cocktail packages offer a simple way to serve drinks. Staff provide attentive care during surprise parties.

Fried chicken sandwich stands out for being huge and delicious. Corned beef sandwich special and chicken a la vodka sandwiches also offer distinctive flavors among typical pub fare.

People are saying

"They have a great selection of beers on tap."

"The staff did a wonderful job making my birthday party perfect."

"The fried chicken sandwich was delicious and huge."

Good to know

1

The bottomless brunch costs $22 for two hours of unlimited mimosas, excluding flavored options.

2

Trivia night happens on Wednesdays and lasts for two hours.

3

The Thursday special includes 20 wings for $20.

14
Rivercrest image 1
Sports bar

Wide, airy space filled with many TVs showing multiple sports games creates a lively sports bar vibe. Atmosphere stays laid back and welcoming, with music and DJs on weekends adding energy. Crowd enjoys great food and drinks, including standout burgers, wings, and creative cocktails.

Management and staff provide accommodating service for birthday celebrations. A private back room is available for hosting parties.

Brisket sandwich stands out as a temporary menu item that many hope stays. Chicken sandwich and buffalo wings also get strong mentions, alongside sliders and blackened chicken sandwich.

People are saying

"You have to ask for Frankie at the bar; he's amazing."

"The staff made my birthday party unforgettable and so attentive."

"The service here is amazing and attentive."

Good to know

1

Happy hour specials are available throughout the day.

2

Trivia night happens every Tuesday with fun prizes.

3

UFC fights are regularly shown at this location.

15
Kitchen at Cobble Hill image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Mediterranean restaurant with cozy yet elevated decor and bright mid-century modern furnishings creates a warm, chic atmosphere. The space stays quiet and relaxed, especially at night, with attentive bartenders serving generous, beautifully presented cocktails. Live jazz music adds to the chill, welcoming vibe.

Space suits big family gatherings and offers a cute, customizable setup for kids' birthday parties. It works well for milestone celebrations like a 40th birthday.

Smoked salmon sandwiches and chicken sliders stand out as popular choices. The Sabich sandwich offers a unique flavor and pairs well with a veggie platter.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be absolutely delicious."

"You have to try the chicken sandwich; it's delicious."

"The food for Birthday Parties was delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant can accommodate approximately 70 attendees, including 10 children comfortably.

2

For $20, patrons can have a Michelin star worthy meal.

3

They have a BYOB wine Wednesday with no corkage fee.

16
The High Note image 1

Bar offers an intimate, candlelit tavern vibe with excellent acoustics and comfortable seating. Energy stays lively with good music and a great crowd, especially OSU fans gathering after work. Unique drinks like espresso martinis and spicy margaritas complement the atmosphere.

Offers a great venue for birthday parties with a lively atmosphere. Works well for after work drinks and special events, making celebrations easy and fun.

Spicy and flavorful Nashville hot chicken sandwich stands out with fresh toppings. The sandwich is consistently delicious and satisfying.

People are saying

"You have to try the signature drinks during Happy Hour; they're a must have."

"I threw my birthday party here and everyone had a blast."

"I found their chicken sandwich to be one of the best."

Good to know

1

Happy hour lasts until 8 PM with two dollars off many drinks.

2

The bar accepts both plastic and cash payments.

3

The kitchen is closed on Mondays.

17
Post Office Cafรฉ image 1
American restaurant

Historic building hosts a spacious, modern interior with a private room featuring a fireplace and bar. Atmosphere stays friendly and relaxed, enhanced by live music and multiple TVs showing sports. Separate areas accommodate celebrations comfortably, including a soft play zone for kids.

Private rooms host birthday parties for various ages, including 30th, 60th, and 65th celebrations. Planning can be done through phone calls and emails for surprises.

Steak sandwiches come with four pieces of tender steak and cook to order. Grilled chicken and chicken fried sandwiches offer varied tasty options with generous portions.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the short ribs."

"The steak sandwich was tender and cooked perfectly."

"The staff made our Birthday Parties a success with their attentive service."

Good to know

1

The cafรฉ offers a private room for events, ideal for celebrations.

2

Event planning is straightforward, with helpful staff to assist you.

3

Happy hour prices are available, but check your bill to ensure they are applied.

18
White Post Farms of Melville image 1

Children's farm offers spacious grounds with friendly animals including giraffes and lorikeets that visitors can feed and pet. The atmosphere is safe and welcoming, with kid-friendly activities like pony rides, playgrounds, and magic shows. Open-air aviary and tractor rides add to the engaging experience.

Well-organized operation runs birthday parties here, making events smooth and enjoyable. Parties offer a fun atmosphere suitable for toddlers and kids alike.

Pulled pork sandwiches come with melted cheese and pair well with mac salad. Fresh vegetables and a standout cole sandwich add variety.

People are saying

"It's so Kid Friendly; the animals are awake and eager for attention."

"These birthday parties are amazing and so well-organized."

"I loved the pulled pork sandwich with melted cheese."

Good to know

1

Admission is $30 in cash; no debit or credit cards accepted.

2

Parking is free and plentiful at the farm.

3

Children can feed the animals during designated times.

19
Crown Alley image 1

Small, narrow bar with dim lighting and cozy atmosphere offers secluded spaces for easy conversation. Outdoor seating includes scenic sidewalk area that complements the relaxed interior. Crowd enjoys affordable craft cocktails and top-tier Guinness in a welcoming, unpretentious setting.

Offers a wonderful experience for birthday parties with a setting that supports celebration and enjoyment.

Sandwiches come out quickly and feature options like chicken and lamb. They are properly filled and pair well with drinks during happy hour.

People are saying

"The Happy Hour service was awesome and super friendly."

"The staff made my birthday party easy and fun."

"The staff here is so nice and attentive with my sandwich order."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is every day from 4 PM to 7 PM.

2

Expect $1 oysters and $5 drafts during happy hour.

3

Get here early for happy hour as it fills up quickly.

20
The Laurels Cafe and Bar image 1

Bar features dim lighting, lively noise levels, and Irish influences with live Irish music sessions. Seating includes outdoor options and cozy booths under hanging greenery. Atmosphere blends college bar energy with a welcoming neighborhood vibe.

Side rooms accommodate groups of about 20 to 30 people for birthday parties. Booking can happen quickly, with events scheduled just days after reaching out.

Steak and grilled chicken sandwiches stand out with Tenderloin Steak, Gruyere cheese, and black garlic aioli on ciabatta bread. French fries come on the side, and the BLT uses simple white bread.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"The cocktails here kept everyone happy at the Birthday Parties."

"The steak sandwich here is fantastic."

Good to know

1

Reservations can be made easily by direct messaging their Instagram or through Resy.

2

The bottomless brunch offers great value at $39 for two entrees and bottomless drinks.

3

Happy hour runs with great prices on drinks and food.

21
Evalyn's Tap House image 1

Glass and concrete space with floor-to-ceiling windows and fairy lights creates a lively, intimate vibe. Large TVs show sports while loud club music fills the air, making conversation challenging when busy. Outdoor terrace with several tables offers a quieter spot to sit.

Birthday parties include a private section and helpful staff. Communication happens through a free party promotion with a dedicated contact for over a month.

Fried chicken stands out as a really good sandwich option. The menu focuses on pretzels, sliders, and sandwiches, including schnitzel and mushroom-topped burger sandwiches.

People are saying

"I loved the great beer selection and cold beers."

"The staff was so helpful during my birthday party."

"I found the chicken sandwich to be amazing."

Good to know

1

There is no set closing time, which can be unpredictable for planning.

2

The booth fills up quickly, so it's best to arrive early.

3

Evalynโ€™s Tap House allows large gatherings without high fees.

22
AnnTremet Cake image 1

Small bakery with just a few tables inside and one outside offers a cozy atmosphere and stylish presentation of intricately designed cakes. The space feels minimalist with white walls and limited decor, creating a simple backdrop for the artful desserts.

Strawberry birthday cakes impress guests and make parties memorable. Cakes ordered online arrive fresh and become the talk of the party.

Mini sandwiches come in tuna & corn, fig with Brie & honey, and turkey & cucumber. They appear alongside mini quiches and a variety of sweet treats like mousse cakes and macarons.

People are saying

"Annabelle was so helpful and patient with my cake questions."

"The mini sandwiches were beautifully made and tasty."

"The strawberry birthday cake was gorgeous and so yummy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly advised due to limited seating.

2

The Halloween Afternoon Tea costs $52 per person and features eerie treats.

3

Christmas tea time slots fill up quickly, so book early.

23
Gran Torino image 1
Restaurant

Large space includes multiple themed rooms, a gorgeous garden, and outdoor seating with natural air flow. Atmosphere varies from relaxing to lively with great music and control over sound. Dog-friendly with a private room option and amenities like a pool table.

Private rooms like the Velvet Room offer a fun setting for birthday parties. Reservations are available to secure space for celebrations.

Fresh ingredients make the tuna avocado sandwich stand out, especially on focaccia. The prosciutto and tuna sandwiches hit a perfect balance, while the breaded chicken sandwich shows a crafted touch beyond expectations.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are delicious and spectacular."

"I had my birthday party here and it was perfect."

"I thought the tuna sandwich was perfect and very tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is advertised at 10:00 PM, but staff may enforce it starting at 11:00 PM.

2

The venue has no rental fee, only a minimum spend for food and drinks.

3

Gran Torino is dog-friendly and offers a special dog menu.

24
Mouette image 1
Brunch restaurant

Cozy brunch spot with beautiful decor and a calming theme creates a welcoming atmosphere. Kids workshop and play area offer engaging activities, making it family-friendly. Upstairs area provides a quiet space suitable for intimate gatherings.

Events include kid's birthday parties and 21st birthday celebrations with a 2-hour time limit on party duration.

Freshness stands out with the sandwiches here. The chicken club sandwich comes with two tasty sides, and the goat cheese sandwich pairs well with an iced mocha.

People are saying

"It's a cozy, warm, and beautiful space with a charming atmosphere."

"I found the sandwich here to be very good."

"I had an amazing time at this place for a birthday party."

Good to know

1

The cafe has a time limit of 2 hours for parties.

2

Mouette is great for events, parties, or family gatherings.

3

The master class for creating gingerbread is recommended for children aged 4-5 years.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...