Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Key lime pie and bread

A bakery that takes its bread as seriously as its key lime pie.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Patisserie image 1
Patisserie image 2
Patisserie image 3
View all

Cozy interior with beautiful design creates an inviting atmosphere without exclusivity. Energy feels fun and exciting, attracting a crowd that appreciates high-quality pastries and exceptional bread. Prices lean toward the higher end, reflecting a focus on premium offerings.

Sourness stands out in the key lime pie, balanced by a layer of whipped cream on top. It tastes delicious but comes at a higher price.

Bread stands out for its exceptional quality and is often compared to offerings from Michelin-starred restaurants. The ciabatta is notably praised, though the bread comes at a high price and is sourced from The Tin Building.

People are saying

"I found the hazelnut cake so decadent."

"The croissant was so crispy and buttery, I fell in love."

"I was obsessed with the key lime pie here; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of desserts, including different pastries daily.

2

Prices for desserts are generally high, reflecting the quality and location.

3

Tea is served only in take-away cups, not dine-in.

02
Gallagherโ€™s Steakhouse NYC image 1

Steakhouse boasts an enormous dry aging room and an open kitchen that adds excitement. Key lime pie is rich and divine, earning top marks. Fresh date bread complements meals perfectly, all set in a lively jazz-filled atmosphere.

Full of flavor and divine, the key lime pie stands out with its rich taste. It consistently earns a 5 out of 5 rating.

Date bread stands out as a highlight, served fresh and often with attentive care. Bread here complements meals well, adding a memorable touch to the dining experience.

People are saying

"The porterhouse steak was flavorful and cooked to perfection."

"The bread basket was excellent, with different types and fancy butter."

"The Key Lime Pie here is perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for lunch courses on weekends.

2

Lunch course is available until 4pm on weekends.

3

Expect around $130 per person for a meal with drinks, tips not included.

03
Peter's Steakhouse image 1

Elegant yet comfortable setting with beautiful decor and live music creates a welcoming atmosphere. The space includes tables of all sizes and a private back room, accommodating various group needs. The vibe is lively on weekends and impressively busy even on weekdays.

Key Lime Pie offers a pleasant balance of tart and sweet flavors. It pairs well with coffee and holds up as a solid dessert choice.

Warm bread and rolls arrive in a basket with butter and a great smell. The bread pairs well with appetizers and comes alongside sparkling and flat water.

People are saying

"The Porterhouse steak here is cooked to perfection."

"I had the most amazing, perfectly cooked Ribeye."

"I could have eaten the entire basket of warm, delicious bread."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for busy weekend evenings.

2

Happy hour offers half-price drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

Expect a 20% auto-gratuity added to your bill for parties of six or more.

04
Au Cheval image 1
New American restaurant

Graffiti-adorned alley leads to a lively spot with a secret speakeasy downstairs. Fresh, well-toasted bread pairs perfectly with tartar. The key lime pie offers a sharp, sweet balance that cuts through richer dishes.

A perfect balance of sweet and sour defines the key lime pie. It offers a sourish balance that cuts through richer dishes, making it a standout dessert.

Bread comes fresh and tasty, served at the right temperature. It pairs well with dishes like tartar, offering well toasted slices that complement the flavors perfectly.

People are saying

"You have to try these burgers; they're perfectly cooked and juicy."

"The Key Lime Pie here is the best I've ever had."

"The burger bun was perfectly cooked and juicy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to avoid long waits, especially during peak hours.

2

The wait to get in is about 20-25 minutes depending on party size.

3

The speakeasy operates from 6-11 pm on certain days downstairs.

05
Hallock's Cider Mill image 1
Farmers' market

Farmstand shop offers fresh baked goods and a large selection of local preserves and pies. Atmosphere feels old school and soothing with a true North Fork vibe. Visitors often come for exceptional pies and cider donuts.

Key lime pie comes in several forms including a chocolate covered version kept in the freezer. The pies vary in quality from phenomenal to just OK, with some already half eaten before photos.

Freshness stands out with freshest pies and breads available. Grain bread shows a distinct quality, often paired with cheese and preserves for a delicious combo.

People are saying

"I thought the pies here were the best I ever had."

"I really would love love love their bread and pies."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was delicious and phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Free parking is available on-site for visitors.

2

Donuts cost $3 each, while apple fritters are $4.

3

The store offers a variety of locally made preserves, pies, and pickled items.

06
PARK AVE KITCHEN BY DAVID BURKE image 1

Beautiful interior with Himalayan sea salt decor and lots of windows creates a classy, charming atmosphere. The vibe feels like an old neighbor, offering a unique and welcoming experience. A grab-and-go area adds convenience for those on the run.

Dessert features a key lime pie that is mildly sour and served with fruit and raspberry sauce on the side. Portions tend to be smaller but the flavor is solid.

Cornbread and popovers come with the bread service. Crusty bread pairs well with the tomato soup topped with a thick layer of melted cheese.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and packed with flavor."

"The bread here is so tender, it falls off the bone."

"The Key Lime Pie here is delicious and not too sour."

Good to know

1

The happy hour at Park Avenue Kitchen is every day from 4pm until 7pm.

2

The menu has limited options for those with shellfish allergies.

3

The restaurant offers a creative and innovative menu during restaurant week.

07
Double Chicken Please image 1

Small, Japan-inspired bar splits into two distinct rooms: dark, refined backroom with craft cocktails and lively front room offering draft drinks and casual bites. Atmosphere feels chic and sexy, with innovative cocktails and standout chicken dishes drawing a dedicated crowd despite long waits.

The key lime pie cocktail stands out as a highlight. It pairs well with other favorites like Japanese cold noodle and beer salad.

Soft and buttery buns hold the sandwiches together with a perfectly crunchy texture. The bread stands out as an exceptional base that complements the juicy chicken and bold flavors.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are inventive and unlike anything I've tried."

"I thought the hot honey chicken sandwich was the best I ever had."

"The bread here makes any sandwich extraordinary."

Good to know

1

Reservations are definitely needed, as they sell out quickly.

2

Be prepared to wait outside for at least an hour on weekends.

3

The wait time for the coop side can be 3-4 hours.

08
THE JAMES image 1
Restaurant

Renovated old Carriage House with beautiful interior, wrap-around staircase, and high ceilings creates a swanky, cozy atmosphere. Valet parking and an outdoor patio add convenience and charm. Upstairs space is stunning but noisy, with some seating reserved for VIPs.

Presentation stands out with the key lime pie looking great and tasting yummy. It pairs well as a dessert option after dishes like tuna appetizer and pork chop.

Bread arrives hot and delicious at the table, which is a unique service approach. Some find it mouthwatering, while others think it could be better.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and perfectly portioned."

"The Key Lime Pie here is served with such attentive, appreciated service."

"The bread here arrived hot and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 to 6pm with $5 draft beers and cocktails.

2

Food specials are available during happy hour.

3

Parking availability is limited due to reserved spots for owners.

09
Keens Steakhouse image 1
Steak house

Exposed pipes line the ceiling, creating a historic chophouse vibe with old-school New York decor. The atmosphere feels classic and timeless, filled with vintage memorabilia and a sense of tradition. Guests enjoy a unique dining experience that blends rich history with hearty steakhouse energy.

A very light texture stands out in the key lime pie. It ranks among the best in the city and finishes meals with a memorable touch.

People are saying

"The atmosphere and service at this Steakhouse are professional and pleasant."

"The bread was warm and delicious with the soup."

"You have to try the Key Lime Pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required as this is a popular restaurant.

2

The portions at the steakhouse are quite big, so definitely come hungry.

3

If you mention an anniversary when reserving, they celebrate with ice cream and candles.

10
Peter Luger Steak House image 1

Classic steakhouse with old-fashioned decor and a brightly lit dining room creates a straightforward atmosphere. Energy feels comforting yet brisk, with staff moving efficiently around the room. Known for exceptional steak quality, it draws diners focused on the food rather than ambiance.

Slices come with a flavorful and delicious filling. The pie stands out as a popular dessert option alongside pecan pie and chocolate mousse.

People are saying

"This steak is tender and delicious, even when cold."

"The bread was warm and quite tasty."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash and US debit cards.

2

Securing a reservation is crucial to avoid long wait times.

3

The restaurant gets busy on Tuesday nights.

11
Hamburger America image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Vintage burger diner with retro-modern design and old school American vibe fills a small space packed with eager diners. Formica counters and sizzling flattops create a nostalgic atmosphere where the burger assembly line is visible from the counter. Outdoor seating and a bar add variety to the lively, crowded setting.

Chocolate key lime pie offers a rich twist on the classic with a creamy texture. The traditional key lime pie stands out as a dream dessert with a bright, tangy flavor.

Bread here is fresh and well-balanced, blending perfectly with the meat and toppings. The bun resembles white bread but adds a soft texture that complements every bite.

People are saying

"The American Food here is simple, delicious, and perfectly satisfying."

"I loved the fried onion burger, it was greasy in the best way."

"The bread here is pillow soft with a great crunch."

Good to know

1

You order food and pay upfront, which makes the process easy and efficient.

2

Be warned that lines can be long on certain days at George Motzโ€™s restaurant.

3

Opening time is the best time to visit to avoid crowds.

12
Red Hat on the River image 1

Bistro offers cozy indoor seating and open outdoor dining with spectacular Hudson River views from patio and rooftop lounge. Atmosphere feels inviting and trendy yet comfortable, with a relaxed vibe along the river. Seating operates on a first-come, first-served basis without reservations.

Key lime pie stands out with its superb, rich flavor and creamy texture. It pairs well with ice cream and biscoito, making it a popular dessert choice.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always fresh."

"The complimentary bread arrived quickly after a bit of a wait."

"You have to try the Key Lime Pie; it's beyond perfect."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; it's first-come, first-served.

2

From 3PM to 4PM, only bar seating and drinks are available.

3

Expect high prices for food and drinks, especially during peak hours.

13
Mable's Smokehouse & Banquet Hall image 1

Rustic space with wooden panel walls and string lights creates a homey atmosphere with bench-style seating and long share tables. Woody, smoky scents fill the air, enhancing the laid-back vibe. Large screen sports channels add a casual, lively energy to the setting.

The Key lime pie features a tasty flavor that stands out. It comes with whipped cream, though not fresh or homemade.

Corn bread comes out moist and flavorful, often paired with brisket or mac and cheese. It holds its own as a solid side with a slightly sweet touch.

People are saying

"The brisket here is melt-in-your-mouth good."

"The key lime pie was lovely and a perfect way to finish the meal."

"The brisket and corn bread were amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy Hour runs from 4-7 PM with $8 beer and $50 margarita pitchers.

2

The restaurant offers all-you-can-eat ribs for $25 on Wednesdays.

3

All-you-can-eat wings are available every Thursday.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...