Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cake and ice cream cake in New York

Somewhere that crafts an ice cream cake that actually tastes like a real cake, not just a frozen block of sugar.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Carvel image 1
Carvel image 2
Carvel image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers wide variety of flavors and generous portions with fresh daily products. Atmosphere stays busy with people drawn to excellent ice cream cakes and soft serves. Empanadas stand out as a unique favorite alongside classic treats.

Ice cream cakes stand out for their rich flavor and custom options like caramel. They deliver a classic taste that feels authentic and satisfying.

Custom ice cream cakes with options like caramel stand out here. The cakes have a real, authentic taste that draws repeat visits.

People are saying

"The sundaes and soft serves here are delicious."

"The soft serve here is delicious."

"I always looked forward to the ice cream cakes."

Good to know

1

The ice cream is made fresh daily, ensuring quality and taste.

2

Expect long lines during peak hours due to the shop's popularity.

3

Generous portion sizes make it a great value for your money.

02
Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream image 1

Small ice cream shop offers fresh Asian-inspired flavors like black sesame, lychee, and taro with homemade quality. The atmosphere is busy and popular, often drawing a crowd despite limited space. Pricing is reasonable, and ordering is straightforward with options for ice cream cakes in various sizes.

Custom ice cream cakes come in unique flavors like lychee/strawberry and black sesame/vanilla. Sizes like 6-inch serve 4-5 people, and cakes work well for birthdays and special events.

Custom ice cream cakes come in unique flavors like taro, which stands out for its taste. Cakes often surprise people expecting typical sponge cake, and they work well for events like weddings and birthdays.

People are saying

"You have to try the unique Asian-inspired ice cream flavors."

"Their taro ice cream cake is the best I ever had."

"You have to try the taro and milk tea cake flavors."

Good to know

1

You need to call them at least a day ahead to order ice-cream cakes.

2

The price of the cakes ranges from approximately $26 to $34.80.

3

This place offers unique Asian flavor inspired flavors for ice cream cakes.

03
Cinnabon Carvel image 1
Ice cream shop

Spacious and immaculately clean ice cream shop with hand-made cinnamon rolls baked daily and customizable cakes featuring unique flavors and printing. Atmosphere feels inviting and well-maintained, enhanced by fresh in-house products and a distinctive Guyanese dรฉcor. Energy is calm and accommodating, with a focus on quality and freshness.

Cakes come with customizable flavors and personalized printing, including favorite characters. Staff handle short-notice orders and add custom lettering and sprinkles.

Customized ice cream cakes come out exactly as envisioned with options to add a picture on the cake. Designs like Octonauts are made perfectly, making the experience exciting for future orders.

People are saying

"The staff here are super nice and welcoming with the cake."

"Arti was so sweet and kind to my kids."

"I thought the ice cream cake was delicious."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, they have a buy one get one free sundae deal.

2

Every day they have a different special.

3

You can customize printing on cakes ordered in advance.

04
Parm Mulberry Street image 1
Italian restaurant

Tiny Italian restaurant with limited indoor seating and a bar area alongside outdoor dining. Atmosphere feels intimate and lively, often enhanced by staff engaging guests with music. Known for friendly service and a cozy vibe despite the small space.

The ice cream cake stands out as a tasty and satisfying dessert option. It serves as a nice way to end the meal and is often brought out for special occasions like birthdays.

The ice cream cake offers a tasty and pleasant finish to the meal. It pairs well with other dishes like chicken Parm sandwiches and pizza knots.

People are saying

"I thought their Chicken Parmigiana was the best around."

"I would order the ice cream cake again; it was delicious."

"The ice cream cake was delicious and a nice way to end the meal."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is only available at the bar with great deals on drinks.

2

Expect a long wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant is known for its affordable prices, making it a good lunch option.

05
Mia's Ice Cream Kitchen image 1

Small shop with nostalgic rustic decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere that suits families well. Unique ice cream flavors include alcohol-infused options alongside treats for dogs. A wheel spin reward program adds playful energy to visits.

Ice cream cakes come in ube and cheesecake flavors and taste delicious. Staff handle special requests well and prepare cakes on time.

Offers an amazing ube and cheesecake ice cream cake that stands out. The ice cream cake consistently earns a 10 out of 10 rating for celebrations.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream was delicious and flavorful."

"I got an amazing ube and cheesecake ice cream cake."

"I thought the ice cream cake was amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

They have a weekly contest where you could win free ice cream for a year.

2

Mia's Ice Cream Kitchen offers many unique flavors to try.

3

The choices of ice creams include both alcoholic and non-alcoholic options.

06
Stuffed Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Bright, spacious ice cream shop offers unique Asian-inspired flavors and fun board games for a casual yet cozy experience. Friendly atmosphere with plenty of seating and a clean, inviting environment. Music adds to the relaxed vibe while customers enjoy wide variety of toppings and treats.

Ice cream cakes come in different sizes and flavors like black sesame and coffee or mango and almond. They balance sweetness well and offer a variety of ice cream options including cones and toppings.

Ice cream cakes come in different sizes for special occasions. Flavors like sesame and hojicha offer a unique, not too sweet option.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream here to be delicious and tasty."

"I loved the unique ice cream cake flavors like sesame and hojicha."

"The ice cream cake has great Asian-inspired flavors."

Good to know

1

You can sample as many flavors as you want before ordering.

2

They charge an extra $2 for a tiny spoon of sprinkles.

3

For custom cakes, it takes about 2 days to make.

07
Bad Roman image 1
Italian restaurant

Modern decor combines with a lively, energetic atmosphere that suits groups celebrating special occasions. Bold, Instagram-worthy cocktails and a vibrant, whimsical design create a fun vibe. Seating by windows offers views of Central Park and Columbus Circle, enhancing the experience.

Ricotta and tiramisu stand out as the only saviors on the cake menu. Desserts include lemon cheesecake and tiramisu ice cream cake.

People are saying

"The truffle pasta here is out of this world."

"The chocolate cake was genuinely the best Iโ€™ve ever had."

"You have to try the tiramisu ice cream cake."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to dine at Bad Roman.

2

I recommend making a reservation at least a day in advance to avoid waiting.

3

The restaurant is located on the third floor of a shopping center.

08
Cold Stone Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Small shop with limited seating fills up on weekends due to nearby theater. Atmosphere mixes fresh ice cream and plant-based options with a variety of flavors and custom cakes. Cleanliness varies, but energy stays lively during busy times.

Ice cream cakes come in many shapes and flavors. Customized birthday cakes get special attention from the manager, who delivers them personally.

Many flavors of classic ice creams and ice cream cakes fill the menu. Some cakes include a sponge layer inside, which changes the texture and filling ratio.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was fresh and delicious."

"Caleb did an amazing job on the cake for my son's birthday."

"The ice cream cake here tasted so good."

Good to know

1

The establishment only accepts cash payments.

2

The price for two scoops with three toppings plus a waffle cup is 11 dollars.

3

The wait time to order was 15 minutes.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...