Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Lobster rolls and cheeseburgers in New York

Deciding between a lobster roll and a cheeseburger is a struggle that only ends when both are on the table.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Revelie image 1
Revelie image 2
Revelie image 3
View all
Diner

Small diner with retro interior offers a cozy vibe perfect for casual chats. Lobster roll delivers a fresh seafood taste with simple, clean flavors. Green Chile Cheeseburger adds a spicy twist blending classic and New Mexico flavors.

The lobster roll offers a fresh seafood taste with a simple presentation. It sometimes blends in with other dishes like tuna salad but stands out for its clean flavor.

Green Chile Cheeseburger stands out with its spicy green chili topping that adds a unique twist. The cheeseburger combines classic flavors with a New Mexico-inspired kick.

People are saying

"I had one of the best burgers Iโ€™ve had in a long time."

"I found the lobster roll to be excellent, with perfect texture."

"I found the green chili cheeseburger delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect to spend around $40 per person for a normal meal.

3

The burger costs $17, with fries available for an extra $6.

02
P.J. Clarke's Third Avenue image 1
American restaurant

Historic pub offers an authentic old New York vibe with a 150-year-old bar and lively music. Lobster rolls are huge and rich, perfect with drinks. Cheeseburgers are juicy with crunch, served fast alongside good fries.

Lobster rolls come huge and rich with a satisfying flavor. They pair well with drinks and stand out as a delicious choice on the menu.

Juicy meat with a bit of crunch defines the cheeseburger here. The Cadillac cheeseburger and 1884 Cheeseburger come out quickly and consistently, paired with good fries.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were fantastic and great."

"I found the lobster roll to be amazing and a generous portion."

"I thought the cheeseburger was truly the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are advisable, especially for dinner service.

2

Expect a 20-40 minute wait during peak hours.

3

The bar area operates on a first-come, first-served basis.

03
Hundredfold image 1
Brasserie

Open kitchen and high ceilings create a light, airy vibe with modern charm. Atmosphere balances upscale and inviting with a warm, cozy feel. Outdoor seating and full bar add to the relaxed yet high-end experience.

Lobster rolls come flavorful and fresh with a notable version featuring a bump of caviar that adds extra taste. Lobster roll bites stand out among other dishes for their delicious quality.

Tender texture and delicious flavor define the cheeseburger here. It stands out among other dishes like lobster roll bites and steak au poivre.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and well-portioned."

"Sara's professional and patient service made our Lobster Roll experience exquisite."

"I ordered an amazing cheeseburger here."

Good to know

1

Reservations might become hard to get very soon due to the place's growing popularity.

2

The restaurant is located within a luxury open air shopping and dining destination.

3

The menu was a bit limited, so check it out before visiting.

04
Golden Hof - Korean Bar & Grill image 1

Spacious Korean restaurant with hanok style decor and dim lantern lighting creates a warm, vibrant atmosphere. Loud energy combines a sports bar vibe with art by Korean American artists displayed on the walls. The space includes a gastropub upstairs and an upscale steakhouse downstairs, offering a unique blend of dining experiences.

Busan Lobster Roll offers a unique twist with a small portion size. It stands out among dishes like Rose Rigatoni and buldak dumplings.

The cheeseburger stands out for its tender and juicy texture, especially the Golden Cheeseburger. It pairs well with a variety of dishes and is a recommended choice.

People are saying

"The mini pancakes here are unreal and a perfect size."

"I thought the cheeseburger tasted excellent."

"The lobster roll here is incredible."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 3 PM to 6 PM.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

3

Expect a 30-minute wait if arriving without a reservation.

05
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1

Diner offers a clean, spacious interior with music-themed decor and a vibrant atmosphere near a busy city area. The space includes outdoor seating with pet-friendly amenities and features lively background music and sports broadcasts. Strong, well-priced cocktails and bottomless mimosas add to the energetic vibe.

Generous portions of succulent lobster meat fill buttery, toasted rolls, creating a savory delight in every bite. The lobster roll offers a true taste of the sea with perfectly cooked, flavorful seafood.

Organic cheeseburgers come with a mac and cheese bun for a unique flavor. Options include a classic deluxe and a 1-pound huge cheeseburger.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, well-seasoned, and beautifully plated."

"The classic diner cheeseburger came out hot and delicious."

"The lobster roll is overflowing with tender, succulent lobster meat."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 3-7 PM with great prices on drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended for breakfast to avoid long waits.

3

Breakfast is available all day, so you can enjoy it anytime.

06
Oscar Wilde image 1
New American restaurant

Eclectic Victorian decor blends with Nomad style and Lewis Carroll themes, creating a massive yet intimate cocktail bar. Energetic music fuels dancing, while impressive holiday and Halloween decorations add whimsy. The atmosphere balances charm and vibrancy, drawing a crowd that enjoys style and character.

Lobster roll features generous meat portions and a small but satisfying size. It pairs well with crispy fries and stands out as a favorite dish alongside east coast oysters.

Cheeseburger sliders come with wings and taste good. The cheeseburger costs the same as the plain burger. A brioche bun is available with just a burger.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and flavorful."

"I found the cheeseburger delicious and well-prepared."

"I had the lobster roll and it was amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required, especially during holidays.

2

Fridays and Saturdays after 10:30 PM are the best times to visit.

3

The place is packed during happy hour.

07
Diner 24 NYC image 1

Classic diner vibe with cozy atmosphere and Sinatra tunes sets a nostalgic mood. Smash cheeseburgers are juicy and tasty, especially the double bacon and Au Poivre. Lobster roll opinions vary, some find it amazing, others say it's pricey and not great.

The lobster roll has a very mixed reputation here. Some find it amazing and worth coming for, while others describe it as nasty and expensive.

Smash cheeseburgers come juicy and tasty, with options like the double bacon and the Au Poivre double smash in creamy peppercorn cheese sauce. Some orders mix-ups happen, like missing bacon on bacon cheeseburgers.

People are saying

"The diner staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"I thought the cheeseburger was very tasty and juicy."

"I found the lobster roll to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Brunch is available any day.

2

Happy hour offers $4 beers and $7 cocktails at the bar.

3

Breakfast is served all day.

08
P.J. Clarke's On The Hudson image 1
American restaurant

Restaurant offers outdoor seating by the water with spectacular views of the river and marina. Atmosphere varies from lively and noisy indoors to relaxed and scenic on the patio. Seating options include traditional oyster bar, bar with TVs, and classic dining areas with wood and checkered tablecloths.

Lobster rolls come very fresh with a Maine Style presentation. They pair well with Sea Salt Fries and offer a satisfying, solid meal option.

Juicy cheeseburgers come in classic and creative styles like blue cheese and bacon variations. The original cheeseburger offers a savory and satisfying flavor.

People are saying

"The waterfront views of the Hudson River and Statue of Liberty are incredible."

"The Lobster Roll here has an amazing view of the Hudson River."

"The service here is awesome and attentive."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted for same day dining.

2

Happy hour is very crowded; consider visiting at another time.

3

The waterfront tables require reservations.

09
P.J. Clarke's Lincoln Square image 1
American restaurant

Old New York charm fills a spacious restaurant with both indoor and outdoor seating, offering a cozy view over Lincoln Center. Live music and a great jukebox create a lively, energetic atmosphere. Crowded tables and close seating add to a bustling vibe during busy times.

Lobster roll stands out with its excellent flavor and freshness. It earns high praise, often rated around 9.5 out of 10, and compares well to classic homemade versions.

The cheeseburger comes as the PJS 1884 option and is cooked properly. It can be ordered without bacon.

People are saying

"You have to try their cheeseburger; it's one of the best in town."

"The lobster roll was delicious with big chunks of lobster."

"This cheeseburger is one of the best in town."

Good to know

1

Brunch is available at the restaurant on weekends.

2

The venue is enjoyable during the Opera season and summer months for dancing.

3

The restaurant closes at 10:30 PM according to the bartender.

10
Paul's Daughter image 1
Seafood restaurant

Outdoor seating on the boardwalk offers ocean views and a casual, divey ambiance with picnic tables and a small bar. The atmosphere stays laid-back and lively, attracting people who enjoy relaxing by the beach. The bar features classic drinks like beer on tap and margaritas, complementing the seaside vibe.

Lobster rolls come with large portions of fresh lobster in a buttery brioche bun with mayonnaise. They taste delicious and classic, often paired with local beer.

Offers a juicy cheeseburger alongside fresh seafood and savory sausages. Some find it comfort food quality, while others consider it tasteless.

People are saying

"You get a nice view of the ocean from the outdoor seating."

"I had the best lobster roll I have ever had."

"I've never had a cheeseburger that tasted so good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant opens at 11:40 AM daily.

2

Expect a long line if you arrive just before opening.

3

Parking can take extra time, so plan accordingly.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...