Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Hotels with cookies

A hotel that treats a cookie like a welcome gift, not just a stale snack left on the pillow.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Nine Orchard image 1
Nine Orchard image 2
Nine Orchard image 3
View all

Rooms combine chic design with spacious comfort and custom sound systems, creating a home-like atmosphere. Common areas and bars offer a stylish, vibrant vibe reminiscent of the Great Gatsby era. Large windows provide fantastic city views, enhancing the overall experience.

Elegant design and a warm, chic atmosphere define this hotel. It offers a beautiful setting and an amazing atmosphere that stands out in the city.

Warm cookies arrive nightly with fresh water on bedside tables as part of the turn-down service. The attention to detail in providing these treats adds a cozy, welcoming touch.

People are saying

"The Hotel staff here are so kind and make you feel welcomed."

"The breakfast here was absolutely delicious and flavorful."

"The staff here are so friendly and helpful with everything."

Good to know

1

Nine Orchard offers a daily complimentary chilled wine hour.

2

Breakfast and dinner can be enjoyed at the corner bar.

3

The hotel is allergy aware and accommodates dietary restrictions.

02
The Fifth Avenue Hotel image 1

Hotel showcases lavish interiors with intelligent room technology and personal butler service. Atmosphere blends clubby charm with a warm, upscale vibe. Guests find it intimate and well-designed, with attentive staff and thoughtful details throughout.

Stunning architecture and lavish interiors define this hotel, paired with world-class amenities. Its great location near the subway and a house car service make getting around easy.

Personal butler service delivers welcome drinks and cookies including ginger sandwich cookies and lemon cookies. Front desk offers extra ginger cookies for take-home.

People are saying

"The hotel staff made our stay feel magical and wonderfully homely."

"The downstairs bar felt intimate and cozy, with an attentive bartender."

"They surprised us with welcome cookies and little gifts."

Good to know

1

The wine tasting takes place on the first floor every Saturday at 5pm.

2

The hotel offers free valet parking for guests.

3

Children are welcome at the hotel at all hours.

03
The Menhaden image 1

Boutique hotel offers intimate atmosphere with cozy lounge and rooftop views overlooking water and skyline. Each floor features complimentary snack and drink stations, including fresh baked cookies and coffee. Location provides easy access to town amenities and transportation options.

Rooms feature luxurious design and high-end amenities. Service is consistently excellent, creating a comfortable and thoughtful stay.

People are saying

"This hotel's galley had so many snacks and drinks!"

"The staff here makes you feel so welcome, it's perfect for date spots."

"The staff is so welcoming and helpful, they're always just a text away."

Good to know

1

The hotel is steps away from the marina, LIRR, and Hampton Jitney.

2

The Menhaden is within walking distance to all shops and restaurants.

3

The hotel offers complimentary cookies every night at 7pm.

04
The Roundtree Amagansett, a Small Luxury Hotel image 1

Sprawling grounds with beautiful gardens and cozy cottages create a serene, peaceful atmosphere. Guests enjoy evening bonfires with s'mores, outdoor showers, and complimentary bikes for local trips. The setting offers a luxurious yet welcoming vibe with thoughtful amenities like slippers and dog beds.

Small luxury hotel with a central location within walking distance to shops and restaurants. Offers pet-friendly amenities like toys, beds, and attention for dogs, plus complimentary beach passes and shuttle or bike transportation to nearby beaches.

Freshly baked cookies arrive late at night on request. Complimentary cookies come with water and coffee during check-in and beach setups.

People are saying

"The staff here are friendly and attentive, making your beach stay the best."

"The hotel staff were so friendly and helpful."

"The staff here is so nice and provides excellent service."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is included daily and served on a beautiful outdoor patio.

2

The hotel provides beach essentials like parking passes, chairs, and umbrellas.

3

Walking distance to shops, restaurants, and a farmer's market.

05
The Historic Blue Moon Hotel image 1

Hotel combines art deco charm with historic artifacts and unique artwork throughout. Rooms offer panoramic city views from balconies and blend vintage style with modern comforts. Atmosphere feels like stepping into a living museum with quiet, spacious accommodations.

Massive rooms and a Kosher restaurant attached make this hotel stand out. Staff engage in friendly conversations, and the hotel offers easy access to major sights.

Cookies come in large sizes and offer a burst of flavor without being too sweet. They pair well with a lattรฉ and include varieties like the orange-almond cookie.

People are saying

"The hotel staff made me feel like family."

"It's a unique, historic place filled with art and personality."

"David provided an exceptionally great experience."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges a $30 resort fee despite lacking resort features such as a pool, gym, or spa.

2

Guests must walk through a little Italian cafe with homemade delicious treats to get to the main desk.

3

The hotel is conveniently located near subway stations and popular neighborhoods.

06
The Northport Hotel image 1

Hotel blends old world elegance with state of the art conveniences in a beautifully restored setting. Atmosphere feels cozy and refined, with upscale decor and warm sunlight enhancing the dining experience. Rooms offer top-notch amenities and spacious comfort, supporting a relaxed and polished stay.

Rooms offer personalized service, with staff attending to special needs like extra pillows and ice. The hotel suits intimate events such as small weddings and provides a welcoming atmosphere for guests with service animals.

Fresh, delicious baked cookies arrive in rooms alongside chocolates and brownies. Guests find cookies waiting at the entrance with champagne, adding a touch of elegance.

People are saying

"The hotel staff here is so accommodating and delightful to talk to."

"This place has an elegant, charming ambiance perfect for date spots."

"The staff here are so friendly and attentive, it's amazing."

Good to know

1

Valet parking is available, but it can be slow during busy times.

2

The hotel offers free parking in their garage for guests.

3

Expect higher prices for food and drinks at the hotel restaurant.

07
Staypineapple, An Artful Hotel, Midtown New York image 1

Compact rooms offer extremely comfortable beds and quiet surroundings despite city location. The hotel features modern design with dog-friendly amenities and a welcoming atmosphere. Guests find it cozy and peaceful, with thoughtful touches like complimentary pineapple cookies and beverages.

Perfect location near Penn Station offers easy access without city noise. Rooms stay clean and the hotel provides exceptional service that stands out.

Free pineapple decorated sugar cookies sit on the lobby table daily for guests to take. Cookies come with coffee in the afternoon, adding a sweet touch to the day.

People are saying

"This hotel is so cute and clean."

"The beds here are super comfortable."

"The staff here are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The hotel is centrally located to all main sightseeing attractions in Manhattan.

2

Expect to pay an additional $25 plus taxes per night when checking out.

3

The hotel adds a $30 per night guest amenity fee at check out.

08
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Times Square South image 1

Rooms feel modern and spacious with comfortable beds and a quiet atmosphere despite being downtown. Lobby offers a 24-hour coffee and tea bar alongside a cozy seating area. Breakfast space is notably small and crowded compared to the rest of the hotel.

Rooms are very clean and the staff is amazing. The hotel sits in a great location near major tourist sites and public transit, making it easy to explore the area.

People are saying

"The breakfast here is varied and good."

"This hotel's location is excellent and close to everything."

"This central location is perfect for walking to Times Square."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is included with the stay at the hotel.

2

Breakfast is only served from 6 AM to 9 AM.

3

The hotel has easy access to Times Square and Penn Station Metro stations.

09
voco the Franklin New York by IHG image 1

Historic building blends vintage charm with modern comfort in small, clean rooms. Quiet atmosphere suits restful stays near subway access and cultural sites. Features include cozy sitting areas, an old-fashioned elevator, and a convenient coffee bar.

Rooms stay quaint and clean with well-appointed details. The hotel offers friendly service and a covered patio, all within walking distance to major stores and subway lines.

Complimentary cookies arrive with coffee at the start. The welcome cookie tastes very good.

People are saying

"The hotel staff here is so friendly and helpful."

"The complimentary coffee in the lobby and rooms was delicious."

"You get a delicious welcome cookie upon arrival."

Good to know

1

The hotel costs about $400 per night, considered a good value for NYC.

2

A $50 deposit is automatically returned to your account upon checkout.

3

The hotel is conveniently located near two subway lines.

10
The Palms Hotel Fire Island image 1

Low-key beachy vibe blends with clean, modern rooms and thoughtful amenities like bikes, beach chairs, and umbrellas. Private bay area offers a quiet spot for sunsets while being steps from lively restaurants and nightlife. Atmosphere balances relaxing privacy with easy access to local activity.

Rooms have a clean, modern style with a low-key beachy vibe. The hotel offers a true hotel experience on the island, making stays feel like a special treat.

Freshly made hot cookies arrive daily from 2 PM with champagne. Warm chocolate chip cookies greet guests on arrival, creating a welcoming vibe.

People are saying

"The Hotel staff was so friendly and accommodating."

"The staff here is so thoughtful and helpful with everything."

"This place is a hidden gem, truly amazing."

Good to know

1

Champagne happy hour runs from 2-4 PM with cookies and Tostitos chips.

2

Freshly made cookies are served daily starting at 2 PM.

3

The hotel offers complimentary bikes and beach chairs for guests.

11
SpringHill Suites by Marriott New York Manhattan Times Square image 1

Hotel offers modern design with efficient room layouts and clean, updated bathrooms. Despite proximity to a busy area, rooms provide a quiet retreat with convenient amenities like mini fridge, microwave, and Smart TV. Complimentary breakfast includes a varied buffet with make-your-own waffles and fresh-baked treats.

Steps from Times Square, the hotel offers a buffet breakfast and has friendly, helpful staff. Location suits sightseeing, shows, and dining well.

Fresh-baked cookies come with coconut almond flavor standing out. The lobby serves hot chocolate and cookies together as a treat.

People are saying

"The location is great, just steps from Times Square."

"This hotel's location is incredible, right near Times Square."

"The free cookies were delicious."

Good to know

1

The hotel is located less than a block from Times Square.

2

Expect small room sizes, making it difficult to move around.

3

Breakfast included depends on your member status.

12
Hampton Inn Manhattan-35th St/Empire State Bldg image 1

Rooms offer Empire State Building views and 24-hour coffee and tea amenities. The building feels small and cramped, with slow elevators that often cause delays. Street noise is loud in rooms facing the street, while higher floors remain quieter.

Central location puts many key spots within walking distance, including Empire State Building and Times Square. Rooms offer comfortable accommodations with friendly service and easy access to a nearby metro station.

Fresh cookies arrive daily, often handed out by a friendly grandfather who cares for the children.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is perfect, steps from the subway."

"The breakfast here is great, with plenty of food and fresh waffles."

"Luis gave the kids cookies every morning with a smile."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is best enjoyed between 6 and 7:30 AM for ample seating.

2

Waffle machines are popular; arrive by 7 AM to secure a table.

3

Expect long elevator wait times in the morning, up to 30 minutes.

13
TownePlace Suites by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square image 1

Hotel rooms offer modern design with kitchenettes and comfortable beds. Lobby features a complimentary breakfast and a cafe area open all day. Noise from nearby streets and hotel elevators creates a lively but sometimes loud atmosphere.

Location scores high with easy access to city highlights. Rooms include a kitchen, adding convenience. Staff greet guests warmly, and the hotel offers excellent value for money.

Fresh baked cookies sit in the lobby and taste excellent. Staff offer warm cookies alongside free breakfast and bottled water during the morning.

People are saying

"The breakfast staff was super nice and helpful."

"The hotel staff was super nice and helpful."

"The staff here are so accommodating and friendly."

Good to know

1

Breakfast ends at 9am on weekdays and 10am on weekends; arrive early to avoid crowds.

2

An early check-in can be accommodated upon request.

3

A metro station is just a few meters away, providing easy access to the city.

14
DoubleTree by Hilton New York Times Square South image 1

Narrow building with small rooms and comfortable beds offers a quiet retreat from constant street noise outside. A rooftop bar provides a 180ยฐ view including the Empire State Building, creating a standout feature for relaxation and drinks. Lobby areas can become congested during busy check-in times.

Located in the heart of Times Square, this hotel offers a prime location close to major tourist spots and the train station to EWR airport. The rooms are consistently clean and the hotel provides a strong price-performance ratio for city trips.

Warm chocolate chip cookies arrive at check-in, adding a sweet touch to the friendly and welcoming service. These delicious cookies come free and enhance the overall experience.

People are saying

"The hotel staff's service was outstanding and so welcoming."

"The view of the Empire State Building from my room was unbeatable."

"You get a delicious cookie when you check in!"

Good to know

1

Check-in time is at 4 PM and check-out is at 11 AM.

2

The hotel charges $65 for parking, but there is no hotel parking available.

3

The rooftop bar has a well-priced happy hour.

15
DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Nanuet image 1

Indoor pool and hot tub offer a beautiful, spacious setting for relaxation. Rooms vary from cozy to spacious, with some showing signs of age but generally clean and comfortable. The atmosphere balances peaceful comfort with occasional noise from surrounding areas and early activity.

Rooms stay clean and fresh across multiple visits. The pool area stands out as beautiful and well-maintained. Service feels welcoming and accommodating, with easy access to nearby spots.

Warm cookies greet guests at check-in, creating a welcoming start. Freshly baked treats come with bottled water and friendly service from Devin and Chloe.

People are saying

"Chloe's warm personality made me feel instantly comfortable and valued."

"They always give you warm cookies at check-in."

"The hotel's heated pool and jacuzzi are a huge hit with kids."

Good to know

1

The hotel offers ample parking for guests.

2

The bar stays open late for special events like weddings.

3

Rooms are generally clean and well-maintained.

16
DoubleTree by Hilton New York JFK Airport image 1

Refurbished rooms offer modern decor and clean comfort with pleasant jasmine scent. Free 24-hour WiFi and a free airport shuttle running every 30 to 45 minutes support convenience. Lobby space feels inviting and spacious despite occasional noise from nearby freeway and airport.

Staff arrange transportation with care, including a free shuttle to the airport. Facilities include a fitness center, business center, and a restaurant/bar downstairs.

Warm cookies arrive at check-in and with room service. Staff offer them alongside champagne and express gratitude when given cookies back.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and professional, making my stay comfortable."

"The warm chocolate chip cookie at check-in made me feel welcomed."

"The hotel staff here is so nice and professional."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges $50 per night for parking, which is considered high.

2

Shuttle service to the airport is unreliable and may take over 45 minutes.

3

There are no luggage carts or storage options available for guests.

17
DoubleTree by Hilton Long Island City New York image 1

Rooms are small with European-style design and paper-thin walls. The atmosphere balances city noise with moments of quiet, though loud sounds often carry through. On-site amenities include a functional gym and a coffee bar seating area.

Rooms stay very clean and the hotel feels quiet and up to date. Staff are incredibly attentive and offer free baggage storage before and after check-in. Parking options include free street parking nearby, though guest safety and secure parking could be improved.

Warm chocolate chip cookies greet guests at arrival. Delicious cookies come freely with requests and check-in includes a free cookie and water.

People are saying

"This hotel is modern, spotless, and incredibly clean."

"You get a warm cookie at the front desk."

"The breakfast here was delicious and better than expected."

Good to know

1

Parking is challenging; free street parking is available but limited.

2

The hotel does not offer complimentary breakfast, but there's a cafรฉ on-site.

3

The neighborhood is safe and regularly patrolled by police.

18
Arlo NoMad image 1

Minimalist rooms offer a clean, cozy atmosphere with multiple light sources to set mood. Rooftop bar provides 360ยฐ panoramic views and a relaxed space for drinks or coffee. The hotel feels safe and welcoming, with a pleasant scent in the lobby and daily room service.

Rooms like the City Queen and Sky View Queen offer comfortable stays. The hotel provides a pleasant experience with everything needed for a visit in Manhattan.

Unexpected fortune cookies arrive with a welcome note, adding a sweet touch. These cookies come alongside sparkling wine and macarons, enhancing the experience.

People are saying

"The rooms have a lovely city view, it's great for the price."

"The hotel rooms are small, with barely a foot of space between the bed and the wall."

"The fortune cookies here were delicious, making my stay enjoyable."

Good to know

1

Breakfast service starts at 07:10, and food takes 30 minutes to serve.

2

The rooftop bar may be closed for private events.

3

A $15 discount on the diner is available after 4 PM.

19
Homewood Suites by Hilton New York/Midtown Manhattan Times Square-South, NY image 1

Rooftop terrace on the 22nd floor offers quiet, panoramic views of Manhattan day and night. Spacious rooms include kitchenettes and sofa beds, suited for small groups. Lobby area feels narrow and crowded during breakfast, with limited elevators adding to congestion.

Rooms include a mini kitchen and access to a gym and rooftop views. Location offers easy walking to major attractions, subway stations, and bus stops.

Wednesdays feature an evening reception with cookies, ice cream, fruits, and cheese. Check-in includes Milano cookies and water, especially for club members.

People are saying

"The hotel staff is so friendly and helpful."

"The breakfast here has a good variety, including fresh fruit and bagels."

"I loved how they checked in daily to see if everything was okay."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served daily until 10:30 AM, with hot dishes starting at 8 AM.

2

Every Wednesday, the hotel hosts a welcoming event with soup, fruit, and desserts.

3

The hotel offers a weekly evening reception on Wednesdays with a small buffet.

20
DoubleTree by Hilton New York LaGuardia Airport image 1

Hotel offers spacious entrance hall and newly renovated rooms with great airport views. Shuttle service to airport and metro station runs prompt and convenient. Atmosphere mixes business hotel feel with some outdated furnishings.

High-quality service stands out with attentive staff who handle special situations well. The hotel offers a free shuttle to the airport and convenient location close to the airport. Event hosting for large groups and parties is supported with good facilities.

Warm cookies are offered at check-in, creating a welcoming touch.

People are saying

"The hotel staff's hospitality and friendly vibes really impressed me."

"The beds here are top-notch and really comfortable."

"You get a warm cookie when you arrive."

Good to know

1

The hotel is located 5 minutes from LaGuardia Airport (LGA).

2

The shuttle to the airport starts at 0400 in the morning every 20 minutes.

3

The breakfast buffet costs $23.00 per person.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...