Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Hotels with historical sites

Made for those who choose their accommodations based on proximity to the city's most significant historical sites.

Based on 764 Opinions
+761
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Nine Orchard image 1
Nine Orchard image 2
Nine Orchard image 3
View all

Rooms combine chic design with spacious comfort and custom sound systems, creating a home-like atmosphere. Common areas and bars offer a stylish, vibrant vibe reminiscent of the Great Gatsby era. Large windows provide fantastic city views, enhancing the overall experience.

Elegant design and a warm, chic atmosphere define this hotel. It offers a beautiful setting and an amazing atmosphere that stands out in the city.

Rich history shapes the property with careful attention to heritage preservation and detailed respect for the site's past.

People are saying

"The Hotel staff here are so kind and make you feel welcomed."

"The breakfast here was absolutely delicious and flavorful."

"This historic building is stunning and has an authentic vibe."

Good to know

1

Nine Orchard offers a daily complimentary chilled wine hour.

2

Breakfast and dinner can be enjoyed at the corner bar.

3

The hotel is allergy aware and accommodates dietary restrictions.

02
The Hotel Chelsea image 1

Building showcases beautiful restoration with original architecture and quirky touches preserved. Atmosphere blends quiet, stylish rooms with a creative, inspiring lobby bar known for exceptional cocktails. Long-term residents add an authentic, lived-in vibe to the space.

Rooms offer a unique experience with a vibe that stands out in Manhattan. Service is consistently excellent and top-notch, making stays feel truly superb.

A carefully renovated landmark building offers a strong sense of history that stands out during visits.

People are saying

"It's like staying in an art museum, full of history."

"The Hotel's art and craftsmanship are exceptional."

"The cocktails here are inventive and beautifully made."

Good to know

1

The hotel offers a daily free wine happy hour for guests.

2

Breakfast is not included in the stay, so plan accordingly.

3

The bar operates on a first come, first serve basis for all guests.

03
Come As You Are Inn LLC image 1

Inn offers spacious, comfortable rooms with historic charm and beautifully renovated bathrooms. Atmosphere is peaceful and serene, enhanced by ambient music and a quiet neighborhood. Outdoor area features a gorgeous pool and courtyard, ideal for relaxing and sunbathing.

Rooms provide comfortable accommodations with a warm atmosphere. Guests receive an excellent continental-style breakfast and coffee each morning.

A historic home with a cozy atmosphere stands out, featuring modern amenities like ensuite TVs and mini-bars. The building itself holds clear historical significance.

People are saying

"The hosts here are so wonderful and accommodating."

"The hosts Mark and Ari were so welcoming and thoughtful."

"The hosts' hospitality made the historical sites feel so welcoming."

Good to know

1

The inn is a short walk from the Sayville train station and restaurants.

2

It's about a mile from the Fire Island ferries to Cherry Grove or The Pines.

3

Expect clean and spacious en suite bedrooms with comfortable beds.

04
The Historic Blue Moon Hotel image 1

Hotel combines art deco charm with historic artifacts and unique artwork throughout. Rooms offer panoramic city views from balconies and blend vintage style with modern comforts. Atmosphere feels like stepping into a living museum with quiet, spacious accommodations.

Massive rooms and a Kosher restaurant attached make this hotel stand out. Staff engage in friendly conversations, and the hotel offers easy access to major sights.

The building shows a lot of character and a strong sense of history. An artist guides tours that highlight how much of the original history has been preserved and honored.

People are saying

"The hotel staff made me feel like family."

"It's a unique, historic place filled with art and personality."

"The staff here make you feel like family at these historical sites."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges a $30 resort fee despite lacking resort features such as a pool, gym, or spa.

2

Guests must walk through a little Italian cafe with homemade delicious treats to get to the main desk.

3

The hotel is conveniently located near subway stations and popular neighborhoods.

05
Washington Square Hotel image 1

Older style hotel with vintage charm and spacious rooms offers a mix of quiet nights and occasional street noise. Facilities include a well-equipped gym, a lounge bar, and an attached restaurant. Rooms feature clean, cozy beds and multiple windows for fresh air.

Friendly and helpful staff create a welcoming atmosphere. The hotel offers a quaint, comfortable stay in a good location near NYU.

Boutique hotels here show unique charm and history through their tiny spaces and stories of past tenants.

People are saying

"This hotel's location in Greenwich Village is unbeatable."

"It's a quiet neighborhood, safe and comfortable."

"It's a classic historical hotel near Washington Square Park."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served only on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday.

2

The hotel offers a jazz brunch on Sundays.

3

Parking is metered and limited to 2 hours in nearby zones.

06
Montauk Manor image 1

Hotel offers gorgeous views and spacious rooms with unique layouts. Grounds resemble a luxury Caribbean resort with meticulously maintained landscapes. Lobby features a fireplace creating a cozy, inviting atmosphere.

A stunning, classy, and timeless hotel with flawless amenities like tennis courts and pools. The on-site restaurant and bar add convenience, and the staff, including the manager, provide helpful support.

A historic building sits on a bluff with great sea views. The grounds and architecture reflect a rich past and offer a stunning venue.

People are saying

"This historic hotel is beautiful and the rooms are clean."

"The scenic views from the room were amazing."

"It's a beautiful historic hotel overlooking the sea."

Good to know

1

Murder Mystery weekends are popular and require advance reservations.

2

Oktoberfest events feature fireworks and are held annually.

3

Dinner service is available after obtaining a liquor license.

07
Waldorf Astoria New York image 1

Historic hotel with iconic architecture and a grand clock tower creates a luxurious and elegant atmosphere. Spacious, comfortable rooms and well-maintained facilities support a classic luxury vibe. The setting attracts a mix of guests seeking a blend of historic charm and upscale comfort.

Impressive with a rich historical background, the hotel features a gorgeous Peacock Alley restaurant and offers a prime location near key landmarks and a subway station. It provides a full range of amenities and a glamorous atmosphere.

A New York landmark since 1993, the building underwent restoration from 1982 to 1988. A brass plaque notes that some of the loveliest songs in American musical history were composed on its Steinway.

People are saying

"The staff shared cool history and made the arrival feel special."

"The staff here is so caring and makes you feel loved and valued."

"The hotel staff made me feel so welcome and special."

Good to know

1

The Waldorf Astoria is currently closed for renovations and will not reopen until further notice.

2

Sunday brunch at the establishment is legendary, but check for reopening dates.

3

The hotel has been closed for three years while undergoing extensive renovations.

08
The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel, by Hyatt image 1

Historic building showcases stunning open atrium and 5-star design with a cozy, lively atmosphere. Spacious, luxurious rooms contrast with a classy, quiet bar and a vibrant jazz basement. Complimentary chauffeured rides add a unique touch to the experience.

Stays offer a blend of luxury and comfort in a historic building with modern amenities. The hotel suits special occasions and provides a unique, well-preserved atmosphere near key city landmarks.

The building stands as a stunning piece of history with unique architecture and furnishings that span multiple decades. The atmosphere carries a rich historical charm you can feel throughout.

People are saying

"The bar's atmosphere is gorgeous, upscale, and thoughtfully designed."

"The staff here is so kind and helpful, making it a comfortable stay."

"This hotel building is gorgeous and spectacular."

Good to know

1

Breakfast for globalists is available from 7am to 12pm at the restaurant or via room service.

2

The last call for drinks is at 10:50 PM.

3

You need to book a table even for breakfast at the lounge.

09
Akwaaba Mansion image 1
Bed & breakfast

Victorian brownstone mansion offers a romantic atmosphere with historical architecture and a quiet neighborhood setting. Spacious rooms feature comfortable beds and access to a lounge stocked with snacks, coffee, and tea. The property includes a garden and common areas suited for gatherings.

Boutique charm and a feel-at-home atmosphere define this inn. The inn keeper's remarkable hospitality enhances the stay, and parking is conveniently close.

The mansion showcases rich architectural history and feels like a historical museum. The quiet neighborhood adds to the strong sense of history throughout the space.

People are saying

"The breakfast here feels like staying with family, thanks to the warm hosts."

"The hotel hosts, Randy and Monique, were so warm and welcoming!"

"The historical sites here feel like a beautiful museum."

Good to know

1

Guests should give themselves time each morning to enjoy the delicious breakfast prepared by Monique.

2

There is easy on street parking available.

3

The subway is just a few minutes' walk away, making it easy to get anywhere.

10
The Plaza image 1

Historic architecture blends with luxurious interiors featuring high ceilings and elegant finishes. Atmosphere balances refined comfort with a relaxed vibe, especially in the bar area. Spacious rooms combine classic charm and modern amenities, creating a serene escape amid a bustling city.

Rooms offer huge, luxurious space with classic decor and large bathrooms. Staff provide excellent service in an elegant, comfortable setting with a refined yet relaxed bar.

Architecture stands out with its classic design and rich history. The site features a legacy tied to many international films and holds significant historical value.

People are saying

"The hotel staff treated us like royalty."

"I enjoyed a wonderful afternoon tea experience here."

"The historical sites here are beautifully decorated in a classic New York style."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for afternoon tea, especially for special occasions.

2

Valet service costs approximately $95 and may have a wait time of over 30 minutes.

3

The tea room lunch costs $125 per person, excluding tip and tax.

11
Temple Court image 1
Fine dining restaurant

Venue showcases 19th century Manhattan architecture with an intimate, relaxed atmosphere enhanced by live jazz music during brunch. Seating can be close, creating a cozy but sometimes cramped feel. Signature cocktails like Coco's Old Fashioned add to the elegant, swanky vibe.

Historic hotels feature breathtaking design and period decor that create a unique atmosphere. Dining options include rooms with views of the atrium overlooking hotel floors.

Elegant architecture captures the essence of 19th-century Manhattan landmarks. Unique ambience reflects deep historical roots and distinctive design.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and the service is impeccable."

"The hotel's ambiance and decor feel like a classic movie."

"You'll love the beautifully restored historical building and its architecture."

Good to know

1

Jazz brunch is available on Sundays from 12-3 PM.

2

During restaurant week, a 3-course dinner is offered for $60.

3

Expect a 45-minute wait for drinks on Saturday nights around 9 PM.

12
Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District, an IHG Hotel image 1

Rooms offer spacious, modern design with views of Trinity Church and Dutch-themed furnishings. Atmosphere stays calm and quiet, away from midtown noise, with a fresh, welcoming vibe throughout. Amenities include thoughtful extras like a kettle, iron, and large bathrooms, enhancing comfort.

Excellent service and great location near subway entrances make this hotel stand out. The staff, including the manager, provide friendly and attentive care throughout the stay.

A book in the room details the area's history. It offers lessons about the neighborhood's past.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is great for subway access and food options."

"The view from the room was breathtaking, like something out of Harry Potter."

"It's steps from Wall Street and the 9/11 Memorial."

Good to know

1

Three subway stations are close by, making it easy to get around the city.

2

The price for a mid-week stay in May was steep at $423 total.

3

Breakfast is only included for Diamond Elite members, not for Platinum or Spire Elite members.

13
Bear Mountain Inn image 1

Historical lodge offers spectacular mountain and lake views with a cozy, old lodge feel and wood fireplace. Surroundings include lush forests, a zoo, and family activities like hiking and tennis. Atmosphere blends relaxing Adirondack charm with modern comforts.

Rooms offer a comfortable stay with clean, well-maintained spaces. The inn suits various trips, from family celebrations to romantic weekends, providing a peaceful setting to disconnect and enjoy nature.

A historic hotel sits right at the state park, offering a rich, old-timey feel. Inside the tower, tile plaques tell the story of a long-term park commissioner, adding to the romantic vibe and charm.

People are saying

"The Hotel grounds are beautiful with a stunning lake and mountain backdrop."

"The views here are beautiful, especially of the lake."

"It's a historical place with a lot of beauty and charm."

Good to know

1

Parking costs $10 cash for events at the venue.

2

Expect loud parties until 10 pm on weekends.

3

The venue hosts a car show every Wednesday during summer.

14
Bryant Park Hotel image 1

Rooms offer spacious layouts with unmatched views of a vibrant park featuring daily shows and attractions. The hotel serves as a cultural hub with a trendy underground bar and ties to the arts scene. Guests enjoy high-quality amenities including comfortable beds and free morning coffee with muffins.

Rooms offer an elegant design and the hotel sits right next to a great park for sitting and eating. Staff provide exceptional service and go beyond standard help, including assisting with lost items.

A beautiful landmark building houses the hotel, blending historical charm with modern design. Tours highlight the building's rich history, creating a welcoming and stylish atmosphere.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is ideal for walking everywhere."

"The staff here are so friendly and helpful, making every moment special."

"The staff's professional service made my stay extra special."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges a facility fee of $30 per night for bundled WiFi and gym access.

2

Brunch is recommended from Sunday to Sunday.

3

The hotel held our luggage past checkout so we could see a matinee on Broadway.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...