Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Fire Island Pines

Food spots

Made for those who view every meal as an essential part of their daily experience.

Based on 801 Opinions
+798
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Redefine Meals image 1
Redefine Meals image 2
Redefine Meals image 3
View all
Health food restaurant

Offers fresh meals with great value and fast service. Atmosphere is clean and welcoming, perfect for work lunches or meal prep. Food quality and service stay consistently great, making it a top choice for healthy dining.

Food here stays always fresh with a variety of great options. Service matches the food quality, making every meal consistently great.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

"I found the healthy food options here to be delicious and convenient."

"This lunch spot is perfect for quick work lunches."

Good to know

1

Redefine Meals offers a variety of healthy meal options for busy schedules.

2

Pricing is considered good value for the quality of meals provided.

3

The location is convenient for those working nearby.

02
Come As You Are Inn LLC image 1

Inn offers spacious rooms with historic charm and beautifully renovated bathrooms. Food shines with a professional NYC chef crafting quality meals. Outdoor area boasts a gorgeous pool, perfect for relaxing in a peaceful, quiet neighborhood.

Food comes from a professional chef with a background in NYC, delivering great quality and careful preparation. Hosts provide helpful suggestions for dining and nightlife, enhancing the overall food experience.

People are saying

"The hosts here are so wonderful and accommodating."

"The homemade bread here is baked fresh every morning."

"The breakfast food here is delicious and home-baked."

Good to know

1

The inn is a short walk from the Sayville train station and restaurants.

2

It's about a mile from the Fire Island ferries to Cherry Grove or The Pines.

3

Expect clean and spacious en suite bedrooms with comfortable beds.

03
Metros on Main image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers amazing food in a cozy space with shiplap wood walls. Live music adds energy without noise, creating a friendly vibe. Stylish bar serves well-crafted drinks that match the lively crowd.

Food here is consistently delicious and amazing. The dining room adds a beautiful backdrop to the excellent meals.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the meatballs."

"The bar staff here is so welcoming and remembers your name is remembered."

"The staff here is so warm and welcoming, making you feel right at home."

Good to know

1

Live music and DJ sets happen on weekends, creating a lively atmosphere.

2

Thursday night features ladies night with acoustic music from 7 to 10 PM.

3

Karaoke starts late on Thursdays, and drinks are available at the bar.

04
Sayville Athletic Club image 1

Small space with lodge vibe and animal heads creates a cozy, quirky bar. Crowd stays mild-mannered and chill, making mood peaceful and respectful. Pub food offers great flavor with strong local energy, served by regular bartenders who keep vibe casual and welcoming.

Pub food stands out with great flavor and strong local energy. Service comes from regular bartenders who keep the vibe casual and welcoming.

People are saying

"The bar's pastrami sandwich is piled high and ridiculously flavorful."

"I thought the food here was really good."

"The American Food here, especially the brisket, is excellent and smoky."

Good to know

1

The club is family-friendly, offering high chairs and a kids menu.

2

Local owners take pride in their craft and care about patrons.

3

Expect a casual atmosphere with great food and strong local energy.

05
Sayville Sandwich image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop boasts a brand new interior with a large customizable menu. Food is consistently excellent and hospitality is warm despite a cold atmosphere inside.

Food here stays consistently good with excellent quality and great taste. Hospitality complements the awesome food experience.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and excellent."

"I thought their sandwiches were the best all around."

"I found the breakfast sandwich delicious and satisfying."

Good to know

1

This deli offers a variety of sandwich options to customize your meal.

2

Prices are competitive compared to other local delis.

3

Ordering in person is recommended for the best experience.

06
The Sayville Inn image 1

Casual spot with a cozy vibe perfect for families and sports fans. Known for award-worthy fish and chips with a unique coconut crust. Enjoy local pub fare and ice cold beer in a laid back setting.

Food here is consistently delicious and spectacular with a focus on local pub fare. Service complements the meals well, making the overall dining experience very good.

People are saying

"The seafood here is award-worthy, with a hint of coconut."

"It's a laid back, family friendly place."

"The food here is delicious and everyone enjoyed it."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups, especially during weekends.

2

Expect a casual atmosphere with a relaxed dress code.

3

Parking is available nearby, but it can fill up quickly during peak hours.

07
Loughlin Vineyard image 1

Rustic winery features cozy log cabin and fantastic quality food. Enjoy live music and scenic vineyard views in a family-friendly, low-key setting. Perfect for tasting flights, picnics, and relaxing with children and pets.

Food here is consistently great and very good with a fantastic quality that stands out.

People are saying

"Brittany's passion for wine made our day."

"This place is amazing for Date Spots, they even opened early for us."

"The food here was fantastic and very good."

Good to know

1

Visitors can bring their own food or buy cheese and chips onsite.

2

Heaters and mulled wine are available during colder months.

3

There are various seating options throughout the vineyard.

08
Sayville Bait & Tackle image 1

Nautical decor and a big bar create a lively, seaside pub vibe perfect for families with a kid-friendly outdoor deck. Food arrives hot and fast with generous portions that impress every time. Live music adds to the welcoming atmosphere that draws crowds late into the night.

Food comes out hot and fast, even late at night on Sundays. Portions are generous and consistently amazing every time.

People are saying

"You have to try the shrimp poboy, it's massive and fantastic."

"The bar's atmosphere was great and lively."

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $1 or $2 off drinks, but is less extensive than other bars.

2

Live music and food specials are available on Saturday nights.

3

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday, making the atmosphere lively.

09
Aegean Cafe image 1
Greek restaurant

Small space with authentic Greek decor offers a casual, family-friendly vibe. Menu is huge with vegetarian options and reliable Greek dishes. Gyro platter is a solid example of traditional flavors, perfect for lunch or dinner.

Greek dishes come out authentic and beautifully prepared. The gyro platter stands out as a solid example of traditional flavors done right.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and beautifully prepared."

"The pita bread here is so good, never dry."

"I found the Greek food here to be authentic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Expect a 4% surcharge for credit card payments.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of vegetarian options.

10
Off The Block Kitchen & Meats image 1

Butcher shop offers fresh dry aged selection in a cozy, intimate atmosphere with outdoor seating. Food is mouthwatering and inventive with good portions and reheats well. Service is excellent in a casual, welcoming setting where locals gather.

Food here is mouthwatering and beyond inventive with good portion sizes. It reheats well and pairs with excellent service in a casual setting.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the burgers and wings, is consistently delicious."

"The smoked brisket sandwich with au jus sauce was outstanding."

"The food here is delicious and mouthwatering."

Good to know

1

Fried Chicken Night occurs every Wednesday with limited availability.

2

The restaurant offers a seasonal menu that changes regularly.

3

Reservations are recommended for larger parties, especially on weekends.

11
Blackbirds' Grille image 1

Enjoy incredible flavor and consistent quality in a menu that pairs well with a solid beer selection. The space blends a comfortable bar with inviting decor and a lovely patio for outdoor dining. Atmosphere stays fun and casual but can get loud when busy.

Food here stands out for its incredible flavor and consistent quality. The menu offers excellent choices that pair well with a solid selection of beers.

People are saying

"The food here is super delicious and beautifully presented."

"The food at this bar is outstanding, especially the crab cakes."

"The food and atmosphere here make for great Date Spots."

Good to know

1

Parking is convenient and available on-site.

2

Expect a wait if visiting during peak hours, particularly on weekends.

3

The restaurant had no wait at 7 pm on a Saturday.

12
Parlor House Grill image 1

Oversized living room style dining area with fireplace and wood floors offers a warm, welcoming vibe like Grandma's kitchen. Food arrives fresh and hot with outstanding service. Noise rises when full, with both indoor and outdoor seating available.

Food comes out fresh, hot, and well prepared with a menu offering plenty of options for different tastes. Service is outstanding, complementing the delicious and satisfying meals.

People are saying

"The food here is always done well, making it a great spot for date night."

"You have to try the baked clams; they're the best around."

"The food here is so fresh and tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

The restaurant offers a vast menu with options for everyone.

3

Prices are reasonable, with meals averaging around $15-20.

13
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails image 1

Bistro-style spot shines with delicious food and unique cocktails like Watermelon Margaritas. Dark, lively vibe with soft lighting and a private room with fireplace offers cozy charm. Photo booth by the bar adds fun to the vibrant social scene.

Food here is consistently delicious and often nicely plated. Dishes offer great value with flavors that impress across both casual and formal meals.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The bar staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"Planning my party here was so easy thanks to Tara."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features seasonal cocktail specials and runs from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Bingo nights occur every Wednesday with prizes and a fun atmosphere.

3

Parking is limited out front, but a larger lot is available at the rear.

14
Ramen Ramen image 1
Ramen restaurant

Ramen spot shines with generous portions and fresh, flavorful ramen. Quick service suits pick-up style, while varied vegetarian options cater to diverse tastes. Bright, warm space feels welcoming despite its compact, storage-like setup.

Food arrives quickly and is well-packaged. Dishes offer exceptional flavor and delicious taste with a focus on Chinese cuisine.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here, especially the ramen, is authentic and flavorful."

"I found the Bao Buns amazing, like little sandwiches."

"The food here is authentic and packed with flavor."

Good to know

1

They have late-night hours, making it a great spot for dinner after work.

2

Ramen Ramen is only available for pick-up at the moment.

3

The restaurant is conveniently located with plenty of parking available.

15
Crosstown Chef image 1
Restaurant

Deli-style spot offers large portions of fresh, flavorful food like the Nashville Chicken sandwich. Casual vibe with clean seating and well-packaged take-away meals makes dining easy. Unique pickle-based options add a tasty twist to the menu.

Food here is consistently delicious, fresh, and served in abundant portions. The quality stands out and many people enjoy the meals.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"The dinner spots here have huge portions and are delicious."

"I found the Egg Sandwich here delicious."

Good to know

1

One meal easily feeds two people, providing great value.

2

The deli offers a weekday breakfast deal worth checking out.

3

Meals are thoughtfully packaged for easy reheating.

16
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville) image 1
Asian fusion restaurant

Asian fusion spot shines with fresh sushi and flavorful Mongolian beef. Spacious seating and a gorgeous bar area set a unique vibe with decorative statues. Atmosphere shifts from quiet dinners to lively crowds, all at reasonable prices with solid service.

Food comes out fresh and delicious with consistent quality. Prices stay very reasonable while service remains solid.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"The Chinese food here, especially the Lo mein, is filling and flavorful."

"The sushi here is so fresh and expertly crafted."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and free for restaurant patrons.

2

Lunch specials offer great value compared to regular menu prices.

3

Expect to pay around $100 for a meal for three with drinks.

17
Friendly's image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant offers large portions and notable ice cream desserts with quick, hot service. Atmosphere shifts from family-friendly calm to lively chaos with kids and teens. Space stays clean and organized throughout.

Food comes out hot and perfectly served with quick service. Ice cream and meals consistently taste great.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was great and cooked to perfection."

"It's a great place to bring the kids without breaking the bank."

"I always loved getting their delicious ice cream."

Good to know

1

Expect no wait times during off-peak hours.

2

Kids' meals include three tenders, fries, and drinks.

3

The estimated wait for food orders is around 19 minutes.

18
Jade Garden image 1
Chinese restaurant

Bright, clean space offers a friendly atmosphere with soothing music. Food is consistently delicious, showing excellent quality and care. Prices are higher than usual, reflecting the premium experience.

Food shows excellent quality and delicious taste consistently. Staff put heart into the dishes, making every meal flavorful and satisfying.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be always delicious and tasty."

"I thought the takeout food here was excellent and fresh."

Good to know

1

Jade Garden offers delivery service for convenient dining at home.

2

Lunch prices are lower, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

Expect to spend a lot of money when dining here.

19
Brownstones Coffee Sayville image 1

Spacious spot with trendy decor offers a cozy, lively vibe. Crowds gather for generous portions of fresh food, especially the French toast bites. Friendly energy and modern style make it a standout choice.

Food stands out for its delicious freshness and generous portions at a reasonable price. French toast bites are especially notable for their flavor and quality.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and affordable."

"Tiffany's positive energy made my breakfast feel like being served by a friend."

"The brunch food here is off the chain, with gourmet flavors."

Good to know

1

Reservations can be made online to avoid long wait times.

2

The parking lot is small and can be difficult to navigate.

3

Expect longer wait times during weekend brunch hours.

20
Beijing Kitchen image 1
Chinese restaurant

Chinese spot delivers hot food with large portions at fair prices. Friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere. Some dishes like hot and sour soup really shine.

Food arrives hot in a thermal bag with generous portions. Dishes are fresh, well-seasoned, and consistently tasty.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"The food for delivery was really good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers large portion sizes for a satisfying meal.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to other local dining options.

3

Food is delivered hot in thermal bags for optimal freshness.

21
Sal's Pizzeria and Catering image 1

Pizza spot offers affordable prices and a simple atmosphere with good seating and soft music. It serves highly rated pizza with quick delivery and shows real passion for customers. Steady crowds prove its strong local appeal.

Food shows consistent great quality and value with a menu that beats many neighborhood spots. Service includes quick delivery and a clear passion for customers and their meals.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent."

"I loved the amazing food, especially the pizza pies."

"This lunch spot has the best pizza I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Sal's Pizzeria and Catering offers a lunch special of 2 slices and any 20 oz drink for $7.

2

Three slices cost around 11 dollars, though I was not sure of the exact amount.

3

The restaurant is located in a no-frills strip mall.

22
High Street Bagels Sayville image 1

Fresh, soft bagels pair with expertly crafted egg sandwiches for a tasty breakfast. Quick service delivers outstanding quality every time. Clean, welcoming space offers seating but favors takeout convenience.

Food comes out fresh and cooked quickly with outstanding quality. The menu offers delicious and great-tasting options consistently.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be fresh and cooked to perfection."

"I found the egg sandwich here to be one of the most delicious I've had."

"I thought the food was amazing and really good."

Good to know

1

The shop is very clean and well-maintained.

2

They offer a wide variety of bagels and breakfast options.

3

Egg sandwiches can be ordered with bagel or roll options.

23
Brightview image 1
Retirement community

Spacious apartments boast modern design and clean interiors. Residents enjoy a lively atmosphere with outdoor fun like bocce ball and a putting green. Breakfast shines with excellent food quality in a stylish dining room. Dog-friendly spaces encourage socializing.

Breakfast features excellent food quality served in a new dining room with great aesthetics. Food services maintain a high standard throughout.

People are saying

"You can play chess or cards in the outdoor space."

"I loved playing games on the patio on nice days."

"The food here is excellent and the facility has great aesthetics."

Good to know

1

The community offers various activities throughout the day for residents.

2

Brightview is a dog-friendly facility, allowing pets for residents.

3

The facility is clean and well-maintained, both inside and outside.

24
Sayville Falls Mini Golf image 1
Miniature golf course

Mini golf with a river theme offers fun for families and groups. Outdoor beer garden features volleyball and foosball plus big screen TVs. Food truck serves quick, tasty finger food perfect for casual bites.

Food comes out quickly and tastes great. Good finger food options and a food truck add variety, making it a solid choice for families.

People are saying

"The mini golf here is challenging and fun for everyone."

"It's a fun, kid-friendly place for the whole family to hang out."

"The food here is great."

Good to know

1

Mini golf costs $15 per game, with additional charges for igloo rentals.

2

First responder and veteran discounts are available.

3

Expect long wait times, especially on weekends, up to 30 minutes.

25
Koi Sushi image 1
Asian fusion restaurant

Old diner turned Asian fusion spot offers fresh sushi and a family-operated vibe. Food is delicious and staff are patient, creating a relaxing atmosphere with calming music.

Food here is consistently very good and delicious. Staff are patient and enhance the dining experience.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here is always fresh and delicious."

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

"I loved coming here for sushi, it was my favorite spot."

Good to know

1

Koi Sushi removed hibachi from their menu.

2

The portion sizes of vegetables and sides are smaller than in the past.

3

Ordering from Koi Sushi may involve delays and temperature issues.

26
Parkville Deli & Gourmet Caterers image 1

Clean deli buzzes with a busy vibe and serves authentic NY sandwiches like perfect BECs and BLTs. Fresh food shines, especially the eggplant rollatini, making it a hit for events with smooth delivery. Prices reflect a premium experience worth the cost.

Fresh and delicious food draws praise from everyone, with the eggplant rollatini standing out. Delivery and setup at events happen smoothly, even with special exceptions for delivery.

People are saying

"The food here is so fresh and beautifully presented."

"I hit the jackpot with this Deli's French Toast today."

"The salads here are so fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Breakfast sandwiches cost $17 for two.

2

Fries are priced at $5, and extra meat costs $3.

3

Free coffee is included with sandwich orders.

Discover more

Fire Island Pines, Sayville

Area guide
Loading Map...