Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Seafood in Fire Island Pines

Made for those who exclusively seek out menus centered on fresh catches from the water.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The Sayville Inn image 1
The Sayville Inn image 2
The Sayville Inn image 3
View all

Casual spot with a cozy vibe perfect for families and sports fans. Enjoy award-worthy fish and chips with a unique coconut crust. Seafood shines in generous salmon tacos and rich Manhattan clam chowder with tender clams.

Seafood here features generous portions of salmon in tacos and a homemade Manhattan clam chowder with tender clams added after cooking. The fish and chips have a crisp crust with a hint of coconut.

People are saying

"The seafood here is award-worthy, with a hint of coconut."

"It's a laid back, family friendly place."

"The bar staff here is always friendly and fabulous."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups, especially during weekends.

2

Expect a casual atmosphere with a relaxed dress code.

3

Parking is available nearby, but it can fill up quickly during peak hours.

02
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails image 1

Bistro-style spot shines with fish tacos and stuffed fish that taste as good as they look. Dark, lively vibe pairs well with unique cocktails like Watermelon Margaritas. Large private room with velvet chairs and fireplace offers cozy space for groups.

Fish tacos come out great and the stuffed fish impresses with both look and taste. Dishes like little neck clams and fish & chips add variety to the seafood options.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The bar staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"The Seafood here is amazing, and the service is so attentive."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features seasonal cocktail specials and runs from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Bingo nights occur every Wednesday with prizes and a fun atmosphere.

3

Parking is limited out front, but a larger lot is available at the rear.

03
Sayville Bait & Tackle image 1

Lively pub with nautical decor and a big bar offers a kid-friendly outdoor deck for families. Signature fish & chips sandwich and tasty PoBoy shrimp highlight the seafood menu. Live music adds to the fun, making it great for groups and seafood lovers alike.

Fish & chips sandwich stands out as a signature item here. The PoBoy shrimp on a torpedo roll and the calamari with sauce also deliver strong seafood flavors.

People are saying

"You have to try the shrimp poboy, it's massive and fantastic."

"The bar's atmosphere was great and lively."

"The decor at this Local Spot is so appealing and nautical."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $1 or $2 off drinks, but is less extensive than other bars.

2

Live music and food specials are available on Saturday nights.

3

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday, making the atmosphere lively.

04
Texas Taco image 1
Mexican restaurant

Mexican restaurant shines with fresh shrimp tacos and fish tacos for seafood lovers. Southern-themed decor creates a great atmosphere that feels like a hidden gem. Generous portions and very good prices make it a smart choice for tasty meals.

Shrimp tacos stand out with fresh, flavorful fillings. Fish tacos also feature prominently, offering a tasty seafood option alongside other dishes.

People are saying

"I thought the tacos here were some of the best I had ever eaten."

"It's so kid friendly; my daughter loved it here."

"The shrimp tacos here are delicious."

Good to know

1

The menu offers a variety of tacos and burritos at reasonable prices.

2

Portion sizes are generous, especially for the taco salad.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean environment, including the bathrooms.

05
Parlor House Grill image 1

Oversized living room style dining area with fireplace and wood floors offers a warm, welcoming vibe like Grandma's kitchen. Seafood lovers enjoy baked clams in large portions and a rich Seafood Meulinieri with shrimp, scallops, and crab. Seating inside and outside suits any mood.

Seafood dishes feature baked clams, shrimp and mushroom risotto, and a Seafood Meulinieri with shrimp, scallops, and crab over linguini. The baked clams come in large portions and include reheating tips from the owner.

People are saying

"The food here is always done well, making it a great spot for date night."

"You have to try the baked clams; they're the best around."

"I loved the family owned atmosphere and their heart and soul."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

The restaurant offers a vast menu with options for everyone.

3

Prices are reasonable, with meals averaging around $15-20.

06
Blackbirds' Grille image 1

Enjoy fresh clams and spicy jambalaya in a casual, fun atmosphere with spacious seating. The outdoor patio offers a lovely spot to dine, though it can get loud when busy. Perfect for seafood lovers seeking a welcoming vibe.

Seafood dishes feature fresh clams, shrimp, and mussels with strong flavors. Specials like seafood fra Diablo and jambalaya stand out alongside shrimp and grits and gumbo.

People are saying

"The food here is super delicious and beautifully presented."

"The food at this bar is outstanding, especially the crab cakes."

"I loved the seafood fra Diablo; it was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking is convenient and available on-site.

2

Expect a wait if visiting during peak hours, particularly on weekends.

3

The restaurant had no wait at 7 pm on a Saturday.

07
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville) image 1
Asian fusion restaurant

Asian fusion spot shines with fresh sashimi and spicy Yellowtail Jalapeno that excite seafood lovers. Spacious seating and a gorgeous bar area set a unique vibe for both quiet dinners and lively nights. Innovative dishes like Mongolian beef showcase bold flavors and artful presentation.

Fresh sashimi melts in your mouth, paired with spicy Yellowtail Jalapeno that lifts the delicate fish flavors. The Hawaiian Poke Bowl offers a mix of textures and perfectly marinated fish, while shrimp tempura rolls and General Tso shrimp add variety.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"The Chinese food here, especially the Lo mein, is filling and flavorful."

"The seafood here is so fresh, it just melts in your mouth."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and free for restaurant patrons.

2

Lunch specials offer great value compared to regular menu prices.

3

Expect to pay around $100 for a meal for three with drinks.

08
Ramen Ramen image 1
Ramen restaurant

Ramen spot offers generous portions and a bright, warm vibe despite its small, pick-up only space. Fresh seafood shines with crispy shrimp tempura and ramen topped with baby shrimp. Vegetarian choices are varied and flavorful, making it a solid pick for all tastes.

Shrimp tempura stays crispy even after delivery and has a light, flavorful batter. Ramen includes four baby shrimp with tails on, adding a fresh seafood touch.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here, especially the ramen, is authentic and flavorful."

"I found the Bao Buns amazing, like little sandwiches."

"The shrimp tempura was light, flavorful, and delicious."

Good to know

1

They have late-night hours, making it a great spot for dinner after work.

2

Ramen Ramen is only available for pick-up at the moment.

3

The restaurant is conveniently located with plenty of parking available.

Discover more

Fire Island Pines, Sayville

Area guide
Loading Map...