Fire Island Pines

Explore over 300 places in Fire Island Pines, Sayville for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED MAY 15, 2026

Best lists

Made for those who view every meal as an essential part of their daily experience.

26 curated spots

You need a space that accommodates your children without requiring you to sacrifice your own plans.

19 curated spots

Made for those who seek out environments specifically designed to help them decompress.

18 curated spots

Bright, airy cat café with rustic charm, featuring a spacious, kid-friendly environment and adoptable cats.

Cozy, family-friendly sports bar with a laid-back, classic Northeast seaside vibe and a hometown feel.

Inviting restaurant featuring beautiful fall decor, a cozy fireplace, and spacious seating for a welcoming atmosphere.

Butcher shop and eatery featuring super fresh dry-aged meats, with a cozy, intimate dining area and warm atmosphere.

Charming eatery with authentic Greek decor and a huge menu selection featuring quality ingredients.