Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Fire Island Pines

Dinner spots

The day is winding down and the kitchen is the last place anyone wants to be. A sit-down dinner is the only way to end the evening.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Crosstown Chef image 1
Crosstown Chef image 2
Crosstown Chef image 3
View all
Restaurant

Deli-style spot offers large portions with flavorful sandwiches like Nashville Chicken and unique pickles. Dinner includes meat loaf and mashed potatoes with friendly staff enhancing the casual vibe. Well-packaged take-away meals make reheating easy and convenient.

Meat loaf, mashed potatoes, and string beans feature in the dinner options. Sandwiches and daily dinner specials also appear on the menu. Employees contribute to a positive dining experience.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"The dinner spots here have huge portions and are delicious."

"I found the Egg Sandwich here delicious."

Good to know

1

One meal easily feeds two people, providing great value.

2

The deli offers a weekday breakfast deal worth checking out.

3

Meals are thoughtfully packaged for easy reheating.

02
The Sayville Inn image 1

Casual spot with a cozy vibe perfect for family dinners and sports gatherings. Known for award-worthy fish and chips with a unique coconut crust. Separate cottage area hosts rehearsal dinners, making it ideal for early dinners and special events.

Early dinners and brunches happen in a cozy setting with family-friendly vibes. Hosting events like rehearsal dinners takes place in a separate cottage area.

People are saying

"The seafood here is award-worthy, with a hint of coconut."

"It's a laid back, family friendly place."

"The food at these dinner spots is delicious and top-notch."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups, especially during weekends.

2

Expect a casual atmosphere with a relaxed dress code.

3

Parking is available nearby, but it can fill up quickly during peak hours.

03
Metros on Main image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers cozy atmosphere with live music that energizes without overwhelming. Dinner shines with friendly service and meals that satisfy groups. Stylish bar and shiplap walls add charm to this lively spot.

Dinner features friendly service and consistently excellent meals. Options satisfy groups, making it a solid spot for family dinners.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the meatballs."

"The bar staff here is so welcoming and remembers your name is remembered."

"The dinner spots here have such welcoming staff, you'll feel right at home."

Good to know

1

Live music and DJ sets happen on weekends, creating a lively atmosphere.

2

Thursday night features ladies night with acoustic music from 7 to 10 PM.

3

Karaoke starts late on Thursdays, and drinks are available at the bar.

04
Redefine Meals image 1
Health food restaurant

Offers healthy meals with great value pricing in a clean atmosphere. Dinner options are convenient and perfect for easy planning. Ideal for quick, fresh meals and weekly orders to go.

Meals come healthy and convenient with options for dinner that take the guesswork out of planning. Weekly orders make dinners to go easy and consistently delicious.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

"I found the healthy food options here to be delicious and convenient."

"The dinner spots here are healthy and delicious."

Good to know

1

Redefine Meals offers a variety of healthy meal options for busy schedules.

2

Pricing is considered good value for the quality of meals provided.

3

The location is convenient for those working nearby.

05
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails image 1

Bistro-style spot shines with unique cocktails like Watermelon Margaritas and espresso martinis, creating a lively vibe. Dinner suits families and couples, with excellent server recommendations and consistently delicious food. Cozy private room with velvet chairs and fireplace adds charm.

Sit-down dinners suit families and couples of all ages. Servers offer excellent recommendations on appetizers, drinks, dinner, and dessert. Guests find the food consistently delicious across courses.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The bar staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"The dinner spots here are great for private parties and events."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features seasonal cocktail specials and runs from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Bingo nights occur every Wednesday with prizes and a fun atmosphere.

3

Parking is limited out front, but a larger lot is available at the rear.

06
Off The Block Kitchen & Meats image 1

Enjoy fresh dry aged meats in a cozy, intimate setting perfect for dinner. Outdoor seating adds charm while locals appreciate the warm atmosphere. Noise stays moderate, making it a casual yet inviting spot for a great meal.

Dinner feels cozy and intimate in the back area. Both lunch and dinner offer an exceptional experience with consistently excellent food.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the burgers and wings, is consistently delicious."

"The smoked brisket sandwich with au jus sauce was outstanding."

"The dinner spots here have inventive, delicious menus that change seasonally."

Good to know

1

Fried Chicken Night occurs every Wednesday with limited availability.

2

The restaurant offers a seasonal menu that changes regularly.

3

Reservations are recommended for larger parties, especially on weekends.

07
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville) image 1
Asian fusion restaurant

Asian fusion spot shines with fresh sushi and Mongolian beef. Spacious seating and a gorgeous bar set a unique vibe with Buddha and dollar statues. Ambience fits both quiet dinners and lively groups, making it great for Christmas meals.

Ambience suits both quiet dinners and group outings with thoughtful decoration. Christmas dinners show consistent improvement over the years.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"The Chinese food here, especially the Lo mein, is filling and flavorful."

"The food at this dinner spot was impressive and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and free for restaurant patrons.

2

Lunch specials offer great value compared to regular menu prices.

3

Expect to pay around $100 for a meal for three with drinks.

08
Aegean Cafe image 1
Greek restaurant

Small space with authentic Greek decor offers a casual, family-friendly vibe. Dinner features classic lamb shank and fresh Greek salad. Huge menu with vegetarian options ensures reliable, traditional flavors for lunch or dinner.

Dinner includes lamb shank, Greek salad, and pita bread. The food is reliable and sticks to classic Greek flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and beautifully prepared."

"The pita bread here is so good, never dry."

"I found great Greek food for dinner here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Expect a 4% surcharge for credit card payments.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of vegetarian options.

09
Sayville Bait & Tackle image 1

Nautical decor and a big bar create a lively, seaside pub vibe perfect for casual dinners and date nights. A kid-friendly outdoor deck and live music make it welcoming for families and groups. Quiet back patio suits relaxed evenings with friends.

Dinner here works well for groups or quiet evenings on the back patio. The spot suits casual dinners and date nights with friends.

People are saying

"You have to try the shrimp poboy, it's massive and fantastic."

"The bar's atmosphere was great and lively."

"The calamari and clam chowder at these dinner spots are delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $1 or $2 off drinks, but is less extensive than other bars.

2

Live music and food specials are available on Saturday nights.

3

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday, making the atmosphere lively.

10
Blackbirds' Grille image 1

Restaurant combines comfortable bar area with beautiful, inviting decor and spaciously spread tables. Atmosphere feels fun, casual, and welcoming but can get loud when busy. Outdoor dining offers a lovely patio setting before occasional disturbances.

People are saying

"The food here is super delicious and beautifully presented."

"The food at this bar is outstanding, especially the crab cakes."

"The food at these dinner spots is delicious and cooked perfectly."

Good to know

1

Parking is convenient and available on-site.

2

Expect a wait if visiting during peak hours, particularly on weekends.

3

The restaurant had no wait at 7 pm on a Saturday.

Discover more

Fire Island Pines, Sayville

Area guide
Loading Map...