Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Fire Island Pines

Sandwich spots

Made for those who value the efficiency and portability of a well-made sandwich.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Sayville Athletic Club image 1
Sayville Athletic Club image 2
Sayville Athletic Club image 3
View all

Small space with a lodge vibe and animal heads on the wall creates a cozy, quirky dive bar atmosphere. The crowd stays mild-mannered and chill, making the mood peaceful and respectful. Local pride shows in the strong community energy and casual, no-frills setting.

Pub food stands out with great flavor and strong local energy. Service comes from regular bartenders who keep the vibe casual and welcoming.

Pastrami sandwiches come piled high and ridiculously flavorful. Brisket sandwiches are smoky and stacked, while fried chicken sandwiches rank among the best. Pulled pork sandwiches come with fries and coleslaw.

People are saying

"The bar's pastrami sandwich is piled high and ridiculously flavorful."

"I thought the food here was really good."

"This pastrami sandwich is ridiculously flavorful and piled high."

Good to know

1

The club is family-friendly, offering high chairs and a kids menu.

2

Local owners take pride in their craft and care about patrons.

3

Expect a casual atmosphere with great food and strong local energy.

02
Sayville Sandwich image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop features a brand new, immaculate interior with clean floors and an organized layout. Atmosphere feels friendly but cold due to low temperature inside. Offers a large, customizable menu with sandwiches that are consistently well-regarded and often packed with customers.

Food here stays consistently good with excellent quality and great taste. Hospitality complements the awesome food experience.

Sandwiches come in great portions that are easy to eat without mess. Prices stay better than local spots and the staff is consistently friendly and welcoming.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and excellent."

"I thought their sandwiches were the best all around."

"I found the breakfast sandwich delicious and satisfying."

Good to know

1

This deli offers a variety of sandwich options to customize your meal.

2

Prices are competitive compared to other local delis.

3

Ordering in person is recommended for the best experience.

03
Aegean Cafe image 1
Greek restaurant

Small space decorated with authentic Greek decor creates a pleasant traditional atmosphere. Busy with a huge menu selection and vegetarian options, it draws those seeking reliable Greek cuisine. The vibe is casual and family-friendly, suitable for lunch or dinner.

Greek dishes come out authentic and beautifully prepared. The gyro platter stands out as a solid example of traditional flavors done right.

Sandwiches come overstuffed with salad and fillings. Options include chicken souvlaki, Greek sausage, and gyro, all served in pita.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and beautifully prepared."

"The pita bread here is so good, never dry."

"You have to try their overstuffed sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Expect a 4% surcharge for credit card payments.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of vegetarian options.

04
Crosstown Chef image 1
Restaurant

Deli-style restaurant with clean seating and a display of prepared chicken, salads, and bagels. Atmosphere feels cool and casual, with well-packaged take-away meals that simplify reheating. Portions are large and flavorful, especially sandwiches like the Nashville Chicken and unique pickle-based options.

Food here is consistently delicious, fresh, and served in abundant portions. The quality stands out and many people enjoy the meals.

Large, tasty sandwiches stand out here, including unique options like a pickle sandwich and solid egg sandwiches served quickly. Potato salad often accompanies the sandwiches, adding a nice touch.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"The dinner spots here have huge portions and are delicious."

"I found the sandwiches here to be delicious and large."

Good to know

1

One meal easily feeds two people, providing great value.

2

The deli offers a weekday breakfast deal worth checking out.

3

Meals are thoughtfully packaged for easy reheating.

05
Off The Block Kitchen & Meats image 1

Butcher shop with fresh dry aged selection offers a cozy, intimate atmosphere inside and outdoor seating options. Moderate noise level supports a casual yet inviting vibe where locals gather. Dining area provides a warm, welcoming experience distinct from the exterior.

Food here is mouthwatering and beyond inventive with good portion sizes. It reheats well and pairs with excellent service in a casual setting.

Smoked brisket and Korean chicken stand out with bold flavors. Pastrami Reuben, burger, and steak sandwiches also deliver rich, satisfying tastes.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the burgers and wings, is consistently delicious."

"The smoked brisket sandwich with au jus sauce was outstanding."

"The food here is delicious and mouthwatering."

Good to know

1

Fried Chicken Night occurs every Wednesday with limited availability.

2

The restaurant offers a seasonal menu that changes regularly.

3

Reservations are recommended for larger parties, especially on weekends.

06
Blackbirds' Grille image 1

Restaurant combines comfortable bar area with beautiful, inviting decor and spaciously spread tables. Atmosphere feels fun, casual, and welcoming but can get loud when busy. Outdoor dining offers a lovely patio setting before occasional disturbances.

Food here stands out for its incredible flavor and consistent quality. The menu offers excellent choices that pair well with a solid selection of beers.

Steak sandwiches stand out for their perfect tenderness and are often paired with gorgonzola. The menu also features a shrimp po' boy and a Philly Grille sandwich, both noted for their flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is super delicious and beautifully presented."

"The food at this bar is outstanding, especially the crab cakes."

"The steak sandwich here is so tender and perfectly cooked."

Good to know

1

Parking is convenient and available on-site.

2

Expect a wait if visiting during peak hours, particularly on weekends.

3

The restaurant had no wait at 7 pm on a Saturday.

07
High Street Bagels Sayville image 1

Bagel shop offers fresh, soft bagels with expertly crafted egg sandwiches that avoid common texture issues. Clean environment supports a welcoming atmosphere with seating but favors takeout. Variety includes unique bagel flavors and breakfast options beyond typical delis.

Food comes out fresh and cooked quickly with outstanding quality. The menu offers delicious and great-tasting options consistently.

Egg sandwiches come out perfectly cooked, never rubbery or overdone. Bagels stay soft enough to hold fillings without squeezing out, showing clear skillful preparation and balanced texture.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be fresh and cooked to perfection."

"I thought the food was amazing and really good."

"I found the breakfast sandwich to be delicious."

Good to know

1

The shop is very clean and well-maintained.

2

They offer a wide variety of bagels and breakfast options.

3

Egg sandwiches can be ordered with bagel or roll options.

08
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails image 1

Bistro-style restaurant with dark, lively atmosphere and soft lighting that opens to the street. Space includes a large private room with velvet chairs and fireplace and a photo booth by the bar. Bar offers unique cocktails like Watermelon Margaritas and espresso martinis, creating a vibrant social vibe.

Food here is consistently delicious and often nicely plated. Dishes offer great value with flavors that impress across both casual and formal meals.

Steak sandwiches feature well-cooked steak that holds together well and delivers a solid bite. Chicken sandwiches vary, with some having thicker chicken and others coming as a soggy, processed patty.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The bar staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"I had a steak sandwich and it was excellent."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features seasonal cocktail specials and runs from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Bingo nights occur every Wednesday with prizes and a fun atmosphere.

3

Parking is limited out front, but a larger lot is available at the rear.

09
Sayville Bait & Tackle image 1

Nautical decor and a big bar create a lively, seaside pub vibe with a kid-friendly outdoor deck. Music performances add to the welcoming atmosphere that suits families and groups. The space fills up, especially late, reflecting its popularity.

Food comes out hot and fast, even late at night on Sundays. Portions are generous and consistently amazing every time.

The fish & chips sandwich stands out with its crispy texture. The crispy chicken sandwich comes with hot sauce on the side for adjustable spice. The steak sandwich costs $23 but is dry and overcooked on garlic bread.

People are saying

"You have to try the shrimp poboy, it's massive and fantastic."

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"The service for my sandwich was quick and attentive."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $1 or $2 off drinks, but is less extensive than other bars.

2

Live music and food specials are available on Saturday nights.

3

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday, making the atmosphere lively.

Discover more

Fire Island Pines, Sayville

Area guide
Loading Map...