Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Milkshake and pizza

A pizza and milkshake pairing that respects the integrity of the pie while still delivering a drink that is more than just melted ice cream.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Sheikhs N Burgers image 1
Sheikhs N Burgers image 2
Sheikhs N Burgers image 3
View all
Halal restaurant

Large dining area with modern design and warm lighting creates a welcoming atmosphere. The space feels clean and bright, encouraging guests to relax and enjoy their meal. Friendly energy and familiar faces add to the comfortable vibe.

Oreo milkshake stands out as a favorite. Milkshakes serve as a perfect sweet treat after meals.

Mulberry pizza returns with a delicious taste. Buffalo chicken pizza offers a balanced flavor without overpowering. Grandma pizza also stands out as very tasty.

People are saying

"I found their burgers to be delicious and well-seasoned."

"Their pizza and burgers are a must-try."

"I thought the burgers were phenomenal."

Good to know

1

The restaurant specializes in burgers, fried foods, and pizza.

2

Everything served is Zabiha Halal.

3

Ample parking is available right off the highway.

02
Elements Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant features cool decor with a motorcycle mounted on the wall and bright, clean atmosphere. Music plays loudly, creating an energetic vibe. Seating includes power outlets, attracting a lively crowd who enjoy unique pizza flavors and draft beer.

Milkshakes come in vanilla and strawberry flavors. They pair well with the food and often hit the spot.

Pizzas feature a crisp-meets-puffy crust with perfectly cooked toppings like BBQ chicken, Fun Guy, Cheese, and Pepperoni. The Margherita pizza stands out with its delicious flavor, and food arrives faster than most other pizza places.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be the best I ever had."

"I loved the craft beer selection on tap."

"I found the milkshakes to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Elements offers weekly pizza specials.

2

The price of $3.50 for a slice is reasonable for the quality.

3

At 2:30pm on a Saturday, the pizzeria was busy but lines moved well.

03
Pizza Shack image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers outdoor seating and table games like Jenga and chess, creating a chill vibe with good music. The atmosphere is welcoming and kid friendly, attracting groups looking for fun while eating. Pizza stands out as amazing and delicious, often described as elite and satisfying.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch milkshakes stand out as a unique and flavorful option. Milkshakes here range from innovative to simply good, with some additions being recent.

Pizza here stands out for its delicious flavors like white pepperoni and grandma slices. Service is both friendly and fast, and the spot also features a unique ice cream bar alongside the pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was a great blend of crunchy and soft textures."

"I thought the milkshakes were innovative and amazing."

"The vibe here is really cool, especially with the table games."

Good to know

1

They charge $1.60 for cheese slices if you pay with a card.

2

The restaurant had a discount on their pizza, $1.50 for a plain slice.

3

This pizza takeout spot offers huge individual slices at a great price.

04
Pies Rโ€™ Us image 1
Pizza restaurant

Open kitchen showcases fresh ingredients and customizable personal pies. Atmosphere stays clean and welcoming, with a focus on Zabihah Halal options. Wait times reflect pizzas made fresh to order, creating a relaxed but attentive pace.

Milkshakes come in strawberry cheesecake flavor and taste delicious. They pair well with simple pies and pizza.

Freshly made pizzas come with generous toppings and a good-sized portion. The baked chicken pizza and fire pizza stand out for their tasty, delicious flavor.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be really fresh and tasty."

"I found the food here to be really delicious."

"The pizzas are freshly made and tasty."

Good to know

1

The personal pies are affordable, priced around $10-11 each.

2

Expect a bit of a wait for pizzas as they are made fresh.

3

Whole wheat dough is available as a choice for personal pies.

05
Carve Cafe & Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy spot offers delicious pizza with unique toppings like pork-free sausage. Pastry counter serves rich milkshakes perfect with a bacon cheeseburger combo. Friendly vibe and luxurious atmosphere make it a great place to relax and enjoy.

Milkshakes come from a pastry counter that also serves frozen drinks. The bacon cheeseburger and milkshake combo stands out as a solid choice.

Pizza here stands out for its really delicious taste and variety, including sausage and pepperoni slices without pork. The menu also features calzones and sweets, all served with great service.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The breakfast service here is incredibly friendly and helpful."

"I found the milkshake to be great."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to take out food during busy times.

2

They let you use the restroom anytime.

3

Coffee and bagel cost $3.50 at the Carve Cafe.

06
Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Lower Manhattan image 1

Smaller theaters create an intimate atmosphere with comfortable, reclining seats that invite relaxation. A bar area offers a casual spot to unwind before screenings, while food and drink service enhances the movie experience. The space feels clean and cozy, though some rooms may feel cramped.

Milkshakes come in classic and spiked versions. The Oreo milkshake stands out as top notch and consistently good.

Pizza comes in a crispy, easy-to-eat style that works well in a dark theater. Options include a broccoli goat cheese variety and a buffalo pizza that was once available and highly regarded.

People are saying

"I loved the in-theater food service during the movies."

"I thought the Oreo milkshake was top notch."

"I enjoyed the personal pizzas at the cinema."

Good to know

1

Tickets are $10.99 all day on Tuesdays, making it a great deal.

2

Karaoke night occurs during a 9 pm movie show on Thursdays.

3

Arrive 30 minutes early to enjoy preshow content related to the movie.

07
Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Brooklyn image 1

Spacious movie theater combines leather reclining chairs with food service at seats and a bar area for drinks. Atmosphere mixes vintage film clips before movies with occasional talking and phone use during screenings. Seating shows wear but overall environment stays clean and cozy.

Whiskey banana and salted caramel milkshakes stand out for their rich flavors. Cold brew milkshakes also complement the food well, making the milkshake selection consistently good.

Flatbread pizzas stand out with their crisp texture and flavor. Vegan pizza offers a solid plant-based option. The menu includes pizza, popcorn, and a variety of drinks for a casual meal.

People are saying

"The seats here are so comfortable for watching movies."

"You have to try the whiskey milkshake; it's exceptionally good."

"I thought the pizza was amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays before 5, movies are $11 total with tax.

2

The restaurant offers movie-specific specials for food and drinks.

3

You cannot be late to the movie, nor can you pull out your phone during the movie.

08
Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Staten Island image 1

Movie theater offers modern design with reclining seats and individual tables for dining. Atmosphere combines intimate bar space featuring themed decor with spacious, comfortable auditoriums. Sound and video quality are excellent, enhancing the overall viewing experience.

Chocolate milkshakes stand out with rich flavor and smooth texture. Milkshakes overall match the high-quality standard of the menu.

Pizza arrives piping hot and tastes high-quality. It stands out among other menu items like wings and burgers with a gluten-free bun.

People are saying

"The seats were so comfortable, especially the armchair style ones."

"I tried the pepperoni pizza and it was delicious."

"I really enjoyed the fantastic peppermint milkshake."

Good to know

1

The theatre does not allow late admissions.

2

Trivia night is on Wednesday at 7:30 PM.

3

Discount movies are available on Tuesdays.

09
Max Brenner New York image 1

Chocolate aroma fills the air in a cozy space with close seating and chocolate-themed decor. Cocktails like chocolate martinis and desserts with toasted marshmallows create a lively vibe. Groups gather around spacious areas while enjoying unique chocolate experiences.

Salted caramel and pistachio milkshakes stand out for their rich flavors and thick texture. The EIGHTIES milkshake offers a unique taste, and the milkshakes are generally not overly sweet.

Chocolate pizza stands out as a unique and popular choice, often topped with extra ingredients for added flavor. The dessert pizza with peanut butter, chocolate, and marshmallow is a favorite, while the loaded savory pizzas also get strong mentions.

People are saying

"It's a great Kid Friendly spot for family celebrations and birthdays."

"You have to try their signature chocolate pizza, it's loaded with toppings."

"You have to try the 80's Milkshake; it's really good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended because it can get very crowded.

2

The establishment closes at 12:20 AM, not 2 AM as listed online.

3

Customers must buy food to sit at a table; coffee alone is not enough.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...