Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Milkshake and pizza

A pizza and milkshake pairing that respects the integrity of the pie while still delivering a drink that is more than just melted ice cream.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Elements Pizzeria image 1
Elements Pizzeria image 2
Elements Pizzeria image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant features cool decor with a motorcycle mounted on the wall and bright, clean atmosphere. Music plays loudly, creating an energetic vibe. Seating includes power outlets, attracting a lively crowd who enjoy unique pizza flavors and draft beer.

Milkshakes come in vanilla and strawberry flavors. They pair well with the food and often hit the spot.

Pizzas feature a crisp-meets-puffy crust with perfectly cooked toppings like BBQ chicken, Fun Guy, Cheese, and Pepperoni. The Margherita pizza stands out with its delicious flavor, and food arrives faster than most other pizza places.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be the best I ever had."

"I loved the craft beer selection on tap."

"I found the milkshakes to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Elements offers weekly pizza specials.

2

The price of $3.50 for a slice is reasonable for the quality.

3

At 2:30pm on a Saturday, the pizzeria was busy but lines moved well.

02
Pizza Shack image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers outdoor seating and table games like Jenga and chess, creating a chill vibe with good music. The atmosphere is welcoming and kid friendly, attracting groups looking for fun while eating. Pizza stands out as amazing and delicious, often described as elite and satisfying.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch milkshakes stand out as a unique and flavorful option. Milkshakes here range from innovative to simply good, with some additions being recent.

Pizza here stands out for its delicious flavors like white pepperoni and grandma slices. Service is both friendly and fast, and the spot also features a unique ice cream bar alongside the pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was a great blend of crunchy and soft textures."

"I thought the milkshakes were innovative and amazing."

"The vibe here is really cool, especially with the table games."

Good to know

1

They charge $1.60 for cheese slices if you pay with a card.

2

The restaurant had a discount on their pizza, $1.50 for a plain slice.

3

This pizza takeout spot offers huge individual slices at a great price.

03
Carve Cafe & Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy spot offers delicious pizza with unique toppings like pork-free sausage. Pastry counter serves rich milkshakes perfect with a bacon cheeseburger combo. Friendly vibe and luxurious atmosphere make it a great place to relax and enjoy.

Milkshakes come from a pastry counter that also serves frozen drinks. The bacon cheeseburger and milkshake combo stands out as a solid choice.

Pizza here stands out for its really delicious taste and variety, including sausage and pepperoni slices without pork. The menu also features calzones and sweets, all served with great service.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The breakfast service here is incredibly friendly and helpful."

"I found the milkshake to be great."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to take out food during busy times.

2

They let you use the restroom anytime.

3

Coffee and bagel cost $3.50 at the Carve Cafe.

04
Cafe Tealicious image 1

Cozy, classic cafรฉ with a clean, modern vibe and stylish, inviting interior. Atmosphere feels like a peaceful European spot, perfect for catching up with friends. Known for delicious pizza and fresh ice cream, it offers a quiet escape with affordable prices.

Fruity Pebbles milkshakes come out fast and taste really good. Both the speedy preparation and flavor stand out.

Pizza comes fresh to order with a crispy crust and tasty toppings like spinach. The Mixed Greens Pizza stands out for its flavor and texture.

People are saying

"The bubble tea here is so refreshing and flavorful."

"The pizza here is so delicious and crispy."

"The fruity pebbles milkshake was really good."

Good to know

1

Cafe Tealicious does not accept phone orders for takeout.

2

The cafe is suitable for both takeout and dine-in options.

3

Prices at Cafe Tealicious are affordable for most visitors.

05
Elite Cafe image 1
Kosher restaurant

Large, spacious kosher restaurant with a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere and warm, inviting energy. Renovations give it a fresh look despite its urban setting. Offers unique amenities like a s'mores tray and free internet, creating a relaxed dining experience.

Chocolate milkshakes stand out as delicious and tasty. Drinks like iced coffee, iced latte, and fruit smoothies also offer a heavenly experience.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"The creamy pastas here are exceptional and bursting with flavor."

"I thought the milkshake was delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant charges an 18% service fee that is not mentioned on the menu.

2

You should check your bill for the service fee to avoid double tipping.

3

Parking can be a challenge; consider looking around the block.

06
Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Staten Island image 1

Movie theater offers modern design with reclining seats and individual tables for dining. Atmosphere combines intimate bar space featuring themed decor with spacious, comfortable auditoriums. Sound and video quality are excellent, enhancing the overall viewing experience.

Chocolate milkshakes stand out with rich flavor and smooth texture. Milkshakes overall match the high-quality standard of the menu.

Pizza arrives piping hot and tastes high-quality. It stands out among other menu items like wings and burgers with a gluten-free bun.

People are saying

"The seats were so comfortable, especially the armchair style ones."

"I tried the pepperoni pizza and it was delicious."

"I really enjoyed the fantastic peppermint milkshake."

Good to know

1

The theatre does not allow late admissions.

2

Trivia night is on Wednesday at 7:30 PM.

3

Discount movies are available on Tuesdays.

07
Roll N Roaster image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food restaurant with a retro 1950s atmosphere and high ceilings that create a spacious feel. Loud and lively environment with oldies music and a birthday coin wheel game adding to the nostalgic vibe. Seating is ample and clean, supporting quick turnover despite busy periods.

Chocolate milkshake stands out as a classic finish to meals here. Milkshakes have a rich, creamy texture and pair well with savory dishes like roast beef and fries with cheese.

People are saying

"I thought the roast beef sandwich was one of the best in town."

"It's got that old school Brooklyn vibe, like stepping back in time."

"I thought the milkshake was one of the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Spend $40 to get a free pizza pie.

2

On your birthday, get a free spin to win up to $45 towards food.

3

Spend over $75 to receive a free pizza.

08
Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Lower Manhattan image 1

Smaller theaters create an intimate atmosphere with comfortable, reclining seats that invite relaxation. A bar area offers a casual spot to unwind before screenings, while food and drink service enhances the movie experience. The space feels clean and cozy, though some rooms may feel cramped.

Milkshakes come in classic and spiked versions. The Oreo milkshake stands out as top notch and consistently good.

Pizza comes in a crispy, easy-to-eat style that works well in a dark theater. Options include a broccoli goat cheese variety and a buffalo pizza that was once available and highly regarded.

People are saying

"I loved the in-theater food service during the movies."

"I thought the Oreo milkshake was top notch."

"I enjoyed the personal pizzas at the cinema."

Good to know

1

Tickets are $10.99 all day on Tuesdays, making it a great deal.

2

Karaoke night occurs during a 9 pm movie show on Thursdays.

3

Arrive 30 minutes early to enjoy preshow content related to the movie.

09
Lucky Strike Queens image 1
Bowling alley

Bowling alley combines neon lights, jumbo TVs, and a lively atmosphere with a spacious arcade area. The vibe is energetic and welcoming, filled with kids, teens, and adults enjoying music and games. Crowds and long wait times are common, especially during peak hours.

Oreo milkshake stands out for its flavor, prompting repeat orders. Milkshakes come in kid-friendly sizes and generally receive positive remarks, though wait times can reach up to 40 minutes.

Pizza party events happen here, making it a fun spot for groups. The veggie and cheese pizzas stand out, and the pizza tastes surprisingly good for a bowling alley setting.

People are saying

"The food and service here were amazing from start to finish."

"This place made our party feel special with amazing, attentive service."

"The pizza here was surprisingly good."

Good to know

1

Call ahead for reservations if your group has 10 or more people.

2

The venue offers birthday packages that include unlimited pizza and drinks.

3

Expect a long wait if you don't make a reservation.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...