Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Pizza pie spots

You are looking for a place that treats the pie as a craft rather than a quick convenience.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Little Charli image 1
Little Charli image 2
Little Charli image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Tiny, cozy space centers on wood-burning brick oven pizzas with a smoky flavor. Dim lighting and intimate atmosphere create a chill vibe suited for quiet evenings. Open bay windows add fresh air, while stylish decor complements the relaxed setting.

Incredible pizza shines here with unique options like the Diablo and s'mores pizza. Gluten free and vegetarian pizzas get special attention, making the menu diverse and accommodating.

Nutella s'mores pie stands out as a rich dessert option. Diablo and white pies offer notable pizza flavors that satisfy two people comfortably.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"You have to try the s'mores dessert pizza; it's amazing."

"You have to try the Nutella s'mores pie; it's heavenly."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for weekend classes, so book in advance.

2

The pizza-making class lasts about 45 minutes, including cooking and eating.

3

The class is suitable for all skill levels; no prior cooking experience needed.

02
Zaros Cafe image 1
Greek restaurant

Family-owned Greek restaurant with a cozy dining room and white privacy curtains creates a comfortable, community-oriented atmosphere. Known for authentic gyros and fresh salads, it balances takeout convenience with a welcoming space to eat in.

Gyro pizza stands out with its perfect cooking and delicious flavor. Small pizzas offer a tasty option alongside pastas and gyros.

Spinach pie comes right out of the oven with the flakiest coating. It stands out as an unbeatable choice compared to other falafel or spinach pies.

People are saying

"I thought the gyros here were the best I've ever had."

"The gyro pizza was delicious and cooked to perfection."

"I believed this place offered some of the best Greek food I ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer 2 Gyro sandwiches for the price of one on Wednesday and Thursday.

2

Zaros Cafe is mainly a takeout place with some tables for dine-in.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is recommended for quick takeout.

03
The Pizza Professor image 1
Kosher restaurant

Tiny space creates a cozy atmosphere filled with lively energy from high school kids, young couples, and college students. The spot stays open late, making it a popular late-night choice. Known for exceptional kosher personal pizzas, it draws a diverse crowd seeking fresh, flavorful pies.

Made to order pizzas come out fast with excellent flavors like the MVP with pesto and vodka sauce. This spot offers free pizza on birthdays and serves as a reliable choice for late-night or daytime slices.

Personal pies come in a wide selection with options like Mac & Cheese Pie and 3 cheese pie. Dessert pies, including a s'mores pie, offer unique flavors, and a free pie is given on birthdays.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be awesome and tasty."

"I loved the dessert pies; they were unlike anything I ever had."

"I loved coming here for late night Kosher pizza runs."

Good to know

1

The pizza place is fully kosher.

2

You need to provide a picture of the kid's birth certificate to get free pizza on their birthday.

3

Dining space is fairly limited, so consider takeout.

04
Nonnas 1977 image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant with rock and roll decor and live jazz and rock music creates a nostalgic, chill vibe. Indoor and outdoor seating support a fun, music-focused atmosphere. The place stands out for its unique memorabilia and themed design.

Fresh ingredients create very good pizza with classic styles like the Proud Mary pepperoni featuring small, cupped slices. The vodka and pepperoni slice with hot honey stands out, and delivery keeps pizzas from getting soggy.

Exceptional crust and fresh ingredients define the pies here. The Proud Mary pie with added pepperoni stands out, while the Veronica pizza offers a vegan option and many pies can be made gluten-free.

People are saying

"The pie's ingredients tasted so fresh, especially the homemade mozzarella."

"I loved the unique options and interesting ingredient combinations."

"I found the pizza here to be absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

The price for a regular slice is $5.

2

You can stop in for a slice or order delivery.

3

Parking is available on the street nearby.

05
Gravesend Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza restaurant offers cramped indoor seating with just two tables and ample outdoor space featuring bistro and folding chairs. Atmosphere stays lively and energetic with enjoyable music creating a warm, family-friendly vibe.

Pizza features 100% homemade tomato sauce and a New York style that stands out. The margarita slice is a notable choice, with flavors considered excellent and delicious.

The pies feature colorful vegetables and rich flavors. The Grandma pie stands out for its taste, alongside the vodka pie and meatlover options.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing."

"The food here is really good and delicious."

"This pizza is the best slice I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The lunch time special is available from 2:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m.

2

The 2pm-5pm special includes 2 slices and a soda for 5 bucks.

3

Bring cash as they charge a fee for credit cards.

06
Mum Feteer فطير image 1
Egyptian restaurant

Glass window shows feteer being made fresh, creating an authentic Egyptian vibe. Space divides into a cozy dining area with a fireplace and a separate hookah lounge in the back. Music and prayer mats add to the cultural atmosphere, while the open layout feels inviting.

Freshly made to order, the Egyptian feteer pizza offers both savory and sweet pies. Varieties include beef with vegetables and combinations like sausage, pastrami, and cheese.

Pies here are light and flaky with generous portions that can feed two. The pastrami meat pie and sausage pie stand out for their fresh, savory flavors and authentic Egyptian style.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"The pies here are crispy, cheesy, and packed with flavor."

"The pastrami feteer pizza had great flavor and wasn't greasy."

Good to know

1

There is a mandatory 15% service charge on everything.

2

Customers have to pay in cash, even though there is a terminal for payment by card.

3

The restaurant has a $20 minimum for dine-in and take-out.

07
Nowon Bushwick image 1
Korean restaurant

Spacious Korean restaurant with neon lights and hip-hop music videos projected on the walls creates a lively, cozy vibe. Music features hip-hop and 2000s RnB, often with a DJ, setting a chill, energetic atmosphere. Outdoor seating and tiger motif decor add unique touches to the stylish space.

Brick oven cooking gives the pizza a distinct flavor and texture. Cooks handle both pizza and burgers with skill, making the pizza consistently exceptional.

Sweet potato pie stands out with its unique flavor and consistent quality. Desserts like crème brûlée also offer distinctive tastes alongside the pie.

People are saying

"I thought the burger was amazing, truly legendary."

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and the best I had."

"You have to try the sweet potato pie; it's so delicious."

Good to know

1

Make sure you get a reservation, especially on busy weekend nights.

2

The restaurant has a happy hour with great deals.

3

Reservations are recommended as it gets busy quickly.

08
SPICES & SLICES image 1
Pizza restaurant

Black-owned Caribbean pizza spot with island-inspired energy and warm, welcoming vibes. Music stays at a comfortable volume, creating a relaxed atmosphere. Offers vegan and veggie options alongside unique toppings like jerk chicken and oxtail.

Pizzas feature a Caribbean spice blend with fresh toppings and a perfect crust. Vegan and saltfish options stand out for their bold flavors.

Succulent brown stew oxtail fills the pies with incredibly tender, well-seasoned meat. Presentation and flavors stay sharp, especially in the Oxtail Pie and Saltfish Buljol Pie.

People are saying

"The pizza here is fresh, full of flavor, and amazing."

"The oxtail pie was so tender and well-seasoned."

"The saltfish buljol pie was delicious and slapped."

Good to know

1

Oxtail slices cost $8.50, while pies are priced at $28.

2

The pizza turnover is about ten minutes.

3

There are a few tables available for in-house dining.

09
The Naked Pig image 1

Bar space buzzes with lively atmosphere fueled by multiple TVs and a stellar DJ. Prosciutto truffle pizza offers a rich, savory flavor that stands out. Shepherd's pie delivers consistent quality, while apple pie a la mode rounds out the meal with a solid dessert choice.

Prosciutto truffle pizza stands out as a favorite with a rich, savory flavor. The truffle pizza is a go-to choice, offering a unique and enjoyable taste experience.

Shepherd's pie stands out with consistent praise for its rich flavor and quality. The apple pie a la mode offers a solid dessert option that complements the savory dishes well.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the nachos, is amazing."

"I loved the truffle prosciutto pizza; it's a perfect 10."

"I thought the shepherd's pie was exceptional."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals are available every day from 4-7pm and 10pm-close.

2

Weekend reservations are a must for boozy brunch.

3

Expect a 90-minute limit on unlimited brunch drinks.

10
Kensington Pies image 1

Small bakery offers authentic British pies with flaky, flavorful crusts and savory fillings. Atmosphere recalls an English pub with a nostalgic, quiet vibe. Affordable pizza slices add variety, making it a unique spot for traditional British fare and casual eats.

Freshness stands out with the margarita pizza offering a delicious taste worth its $15 price. Slices cost less than $2.00, dropping to $1.50 after 9 p.m., making the pizza both tasty and affordable.

British pies feature flaky, crispy crusts and rich fillings like lamb, steak and onion, and chicken dinner. Options include authentic savory pies, pasties, and sausage rolls, available fresh or frozen for takeout.

People are saying

"I loved the British pies, especially the steak and ale."

"The food here, especially the pies, is simply great."

"I thought the pizza here was simply great and delicious."

Good to know

1

Kensington Pies offers both savory and sweet options.

2

They sell refrigerated and frozen pies for takeout.

3

Parking is limited out front and across from a petrol station.

11
Super Nice Coffee and Bakery image 1

Walk-up window with takeaway-only service and a small bench defines the space. Atmosphere feels warm and cozy, offering friendly neighborhood vibes despite limited seating. Dog-friendly touches and unique, highly praised donuts add to its charm.

Pizza here features a notable quality that stands out. It pairs well with the coffee and donuts available, creating a solid food experience.

Golden crusts wrap pies filled with spinach and creamy feta or bacon, egg, and cheese. Hand pies pair well with iced coffee and offer a tasty, savory option alongside biscuits.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee was perfectly satisfying."

"I found the pizza here to be excellent."

"This spinach and feta pie's filling was expertly seasoned."

Good to know

1

Get there early on weekends as popular donuts sell out fast.

2

This is a take-out only spot with no seating available.

3

Order at the window and navigate stairs to pick up your food.

12
O'Toole's Way image 1
Irish restaurant

Irish bar with live music and modern sleek bars offers a warm, lively atmosphere. Outdoor seating under an elevated park creates a quiet, charming space. TVs are well-placed for viewing sports without channel changes.

Soft and chewy dough meets a super crispy bottom for great texture. The margherita pizza works well for one, while the prosciutto and short rib pies stand out with rich toppings.

Short rib cottage pie offers a unique and exceptional twist. Key lime pie balances tartness and sweetness with whipped cream, crunchy coconut, and graham cracker crust. Goat cheese and prosciutto bar pie delivers a savory punch.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and arrived very quickly."

"I couldn't stop taking pictures of this amazing pizza."

"You have to try the short rib cottage pie; it's perfect for a cold day."

Good to know

1

Customers must order dinner food before being seated.

2

Outdoor seating is available for lunch.

3

The place sometimes gets busy and has a wait.

13
Wild image 1
Gluten-free restaurant

Small restaurant with cozy indoor and heated outdoor seating creates a beautiful, relaxed atmosphere ideal for gluten-free dining. Tables are tightly spaced, which may feel cramped for taller guests. Outdoor patio offers pleasant sidewalk seating with heat lamps that keep the space warm even in cooler weather.

Gluten-free options include a thin crust that holds up well and tastes great. The burrata prosciutto pizza features fresh ingredients and a perfectly baked crust. Vegan and cheese halves can be combined on one pizza.

Creamy, tart key lime pie features a gluten-free graham-like crust. Peanut butter chocolate pie stands out with its rich flavor.

People are saying

"I found the gluten-free food here to be amazing."

"I thought their gluten-free pizza was the best in Manhattan."

"I was surprised by how lovely the peanut butter chocolate pie was."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is fully gluten-free, which is a key aspect.

2

The restaurant does not honor reservations.

3

Happy hours are from Monday to Friday, 12-7 pm, with $5 off any drink.

14
Urban Vegan Kitchen image 1

Graffiti art and colorful decor create an edgy, vibrant atmosphere with a relaxed vibe. Music ranges from old school tracks to live DJ sets, setting a lively tone without overwhelming noise. Outdoor seating and a small stage add to the creative, urban feel.

Hollywood Pizza features a salty, savory flavor with seitan and a bit too much sauce. Vegan options include BBQ pizza and sandwiches, all served in small but satisfying portions.

Mud pie stands out with its rich chocolate flavor and pairs well with vanilla ice cream or almond vanilla ice cream for a satisfying, comforting dessert.

People are saying

"The vegan food here is delicious and healthy."

"The pizza here is delicious and satisfying."

"I was obsessed with their chocolate mud pie."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended on weekends to avoid long waits.

3

All transactions must be conducted through your phone.

15
The Pieman VC & Italian Catering image 1

Pizza restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with a quirky pizza art decor and nostalgic 1980's style tables. Music from a jukebox and live Friday performances create a fun, local vibe that is lively but not overwhelming. An immaculate outdoor patio provides a clean, intimate space for gatherings.

Super thin crust with crispy texture defines the pizza here. Toppings like sausage and spicy pepper add strong flavor, making the pies addicting and well-balanced.

Pies come in high quality and are well seasoned with options like Korean BBQ and veggie varieties. Some pies arrive lukewarm after delivery, but the focus stays on the flavor and seasoning rather than atmosphere.

People are saying

"I found the thin crust pizza to be amazing and perfectly made."

"I found the pizza here to be top-notch and flavorful."

"I found the pie to be amazing and well seasoned."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens regularly, providing a fun atmosphere for guests.

2

The restaurant has outdoor seating where well-behaved dogs are welcome.

3

Parking is plentiful in the lot, making it easy to visit.

16
Sean's Bar & Kitchen image 1

Spacious bar and grill with multiple large screens for sports viewing and a lively atmosphere filled with energy. Frequented by soccer fans, it offers ample seating including a long bar and high tables, creating a welcoming environment. The space features a sunroof dining area and a bustling vibe that encourages people watching and socializing.

Margherita pizza stands out with its wonderful flavor. Pizza tastes best when served very hot, offering a good but sometimes uneven experience.

Chicken pot pie features a creamy filling with veggies cooked beyond al dente, not crispy. Shepherd's pie offers an authentic taste reminiscent of Dublin and is both delicious and filling.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the Irish classics."

"They have a huge beer selection, including Guinness and Harp."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Gratuity is already added on the check at this restaurant.

2

House beers are only $7.

3

A 20 percent service charge is automatically charged to the bar bill.

17
Lucia Pizza Of Avenue X image 1
Pizza restaurant

Vintage pizzeria with small indoor space and climate-controlled indoor and outdoor seating offers a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. Loud music contrasts with moments of quiet, attracting a mix of locals and hipsters. The place combines modern, rustic design with a clean, stylish layout.

Fantastic pizza stands out with consistently amazing flavor and quality. The spinach pizza is especially notable, often considered the best in the area.

Creative and classic pizza pies include Signature Vodka Pie, clam pie, shrimp pie, and Salsiccia with ricotta and sausage. Clam pie tastes like baked clams, and whole pies are recommended over slices.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best."

"I loved the old-school slice shop feel and amazing pizza."

"The spinach pie filling was smooth and tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is having a Grand Opening with special offerings.

2

Expect a clam pie and 28-day aged burger on weekends.

3

The margarita pie costs $30 with two drinks.

18
Antonio's Pizzeria New York-Kensington Pies image 1

Small space feels very hot inside with a casual, no-frills vibe. Affordable prices stand out, especially for pizza and British pot pies that offer generous portions and crispy crusts. Late hours attract a steady flow of locals seeking quick, budget-friendly meals.

Fresh, flavorful pizza pies arrive consistently, including vegetable options and a cauliflower crust choice. Large pizzas come at a low price, around $10, making it a solid pick for events or family meals.

British pies stand out with great crusts and a fantastic variety including cottage, Shepard's, and beef and bacon. Buffalo chicken and chicken pot pies offer solid comfort food with large portions.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be fresh and flavorful."

"I loved the British pies; they were a total surprise and the highlight."

"The prices were great and affordable."

Good to know

1

The restaurant stays open later than other shops in the area.

2

A large pizza costs only $10.

3

Prices are significantly cheaper compared to the average pizzeria.

19
The Grape Leaf image 1
Halal restaurant

Authentic Middle Eastern architecture shapes a comfy, quiet space with open windows and beautifully painted plates. Arabic music plays softly, enhancing a vibe that recalls Lebanon in Brooklyn. The place offers a large vegan selection and is known for amazing falafel and shawarma.

The laghmagen offers a tasty take on Armenian, Turkish, and Lebanese pizza styles. The chicken pizza fills you up and stands out as a solid choice.

Lots of fresh baked breads and spinach and meat pies fill the menu. The spinach pie resembles a calzone with a fresh, tasty crust.

People are saying

"I loved the Mediterranean falafel sandwich; it made my heart happy."

"I tried the Armenian Pizza, and it was spot on tasty."

"The pie here is awesome and the staff is friendly."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 10 PM, not 10:30 PM as advertised.

2

The chicken shawarma pita costs $20.

3

Parking is hard to find, but there is paid street parking available.

20
Chrissy’s Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small walk-up spot with cozy vintage decor and 90s nostalgia including VHS tapes and old movie posters. Atmosphere feels warm and casual, evoking memories of old neighborhood pizzerias without kitsch. Space offers limited standing room with high tables, creating an intimate, laid-back vibe.

Pizza here stands out for its crispy and sizzling crust and excellent dough. The cheese is reference grade 10/10, and toppings like pepperoni with jalapeños offer a spicy, savory balance.

Best pie in NYC stands out with every slice. Waiting early pays off for a fresh, top-quality pie that many find unmatched in the city.

People are saying

"This pizza is the best I've had in New York."

"I thought the pizza was amazing and mouth-wateringly good."

"The pizza here is divine and has a unique flavor."

Good to know

1

Monday is the best day to visit for the shortest wait time.

2

The restaurant charges up to $40 for a 16” pizza.

3

They typically sell out by 8pm, so arrive early.

21
Cooper's Tavern image 1

Renovated space offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with cozy decor and a lit fireplace. The bar fills with a lively crowd even on typically slow nights, creating a pleasant and energetic vibe. Valet parking supports a busy scene where owners engage directly with guests.

Flatbread pizzas stand out, especially the Bee Sting with its unique flavor. Thin crust options deliver a good, crisp bite and the overall pizza quality is solid.

Chicken pot pie stands out as a solid choice with a rich filling and flaky crust. Shepherd's pie is absent, but a Guinness pot pie with beef and puff pastry offers a hearty alternative.

People are saying

"Their French Onion Soup and Chicken Pot Pie were incredible."

"I thought the pizza here was awesome."

"The chicken pot pie here is incredible."

Good to know

1

Valet parking is required due to limited self-parking, which can be inconvenient.

2

Prices are reasonable, allowing for multiple rounds of drinks and shared plates for under $250.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere on Tuesday evenings, especially around 5:30 PM.

22
Au Za'atar - Midtown East image 1
Lebanese restaurant

Outdoor and indoor spaces feature heated terraces and table-side shawarma burners that offer a unique dining experience. The atmosphere combines nostalgic Arabic music with a warm, inviting vibe, though noise levels can be high. The setting balances a fancy, renovated interior with casual, interactive elements like self-cooking stations.

Small pizzas without cheese deliver a mindblowing taste. The Falafel Pizza features rich cheese and falafel that tastes like meat despite being vegetarian. Sujuk pizza offers a simply delicious flavor.

Small pies come out fresh with bread straight from the oven. Lamb meat pie and Halawet El Jibn stand out as mouthwatering fatayer options.

People are saying

"I found the food to be delicious and amazing."

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and delicious."

"The spicy lame ajin pie with cheese has a distinct, not overwhelming flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to ensure a table, especially on weekends.

2

Expect some dishes to cost over $150, making it a pricey dining option.

3

Table side shawarma takes 30 to 60 minutes to serve, so order early.

23
Dragos Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Long, narrow space with a cozy, homey vibe and friendly atmosphere. Music and TV add to the lively, welcoming energy. Known for affordable, delicious pizza and unique specialty slices like the tri color slice.

Pizza features tasty sauce and perfectly balanced cheese with a quality that stands out. Both regular pies and Sicilian slices come out delicious and excellent.

Pickle pie stands out with a unique flavor. Some pies taste greasy and garlicky, showing inconsistency. Rushing the baking affects the pie quality.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza was the best I ever had."

"I have many good memories of the Italian food here from my younger days."

"I found the buffalo chicken slice to be incredibly delicious."

Good to know

1

Takeout is the primary service; it's not a sit-down restaurant.

2

Dragos Pizza offers a unique tri-color slice not found elsewhere.

3

Prices are considered high, with some items like soda being overpriced.

24
Aragvi image 1
Georgian restaurant

Georgian restaurant shines with authentic decor and a warm vibe perfect for dates or groups. Unique pizza features minced meat and Georgian cheese on bread like Neapolitan style. Steaming Adjaruli pie with egg yolk and rich spinach pie add hearty flavors.

Bread resembles Neapolitan pizza but includes minced meat, Georgian-style cheese, and sauce for a unique twist. Kamcha root serves as a pizza bread with spinach, often dipped in bean lobio for added flavor.

Steaming hot Adjaruli pie features a visible egg yolk and butter on top. Spinach pie stands out with its rich, fresh flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and wonderfully prepared."

"You have to try their pizza bread with spinach and cheese."

"The Chef's Khinkali were so good, I ordered more."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended for special events like graduation dinners.

3

Free parking is available for restaurant guests.

25
PARK AVE KITCHEN BY DAVID BURKE image 1

Beautiful interior with Himalayan sea salt decor and lots of windows creates a classy, charming atmosphere. The vibe feels like an old neighbor, offering a unique and welcoming experience. A grab-and-go area adds convenience for those on the run.

Pizzas come in good size with flavorful meats and unique toppings like salmon and avocado. They pair well with wine and include options like the Angry Butcher for lunch to go.

Key lime pie stands out with its mild sourness and comes with fruit and raspberry sauce on the side. Portions are on the smaller side but the flavor is solid.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and packed with flavor."

"I'm already dreaming about that delicious margarita pizza."

"The key lime pie was delicious and served with fruit."

Good to know

1

The happy hour at Park Avenue Kitchen is every day from 4pm until 7pm.

2

The menu has limited options for those with shellfish allergies.

3

The restaurant offers a creative and innovative menu during restaurant week.

26
abc kitchen image 1
Restaurant

Dining room combines intimate lighting with a crowded, loud atmosphere under a low ceiling. Space blends white and rustic wood decor creating an upscale, elegant vibe. Guests often encounter a vibrant energy that can make conversation challenging.

Pizzas feature irregular shapes and light homemade whole wheat dough. Mushroom pizzas stand out with juicy toppings, melted cheese, and a farm egg in the center.

Cherry and blueberry pies serve as sweet finishes to meals. Mini pies offer a crisp texture that stands out.

People are saying

"The service here is casual yet impeccable."

"I thought the truffle pizza was perfect."

"The service here is impeccable, never hovering."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the Sunday brunch due to high demand.

2

The restaurant offers a three-course Prix Fixe menu for $60 during restaurant week.

3

Happy hour features discounted drinks and appetizers, typically from 4-6pm.

27
Double Chicken Please image 1

Small, Japan-inspired bar splits into two distinct rooms: dark, refined backroom with craft cocktails and lively front room offering draft drinks and casual bites. Atmosphere feels chic and sexy, with innovative cocktails and standout chicken dishes drawing a dedicated crowd despite long waits.

Cocktails mimic pizza flavors, including a pizza-flavored cocktail that tastes like a margherita slice. The menu features drinks inspired by dishes like carbonara and main courses in a glass.

A standout is the key lime pie cocktail with a flavor that mimics the dessert. The menu features creative drinks that taste like food, including this pie-inspired option.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are inventive and unlike anything I've tried."

"You have to try the key lime pie; it's a standout dessert."

"You have to try the cold pizza; it's unique."

Good to know

1

Reservations are definitely needed, as they sell out quickly.

2

Be prepared to wait outside for at least an hour on weekends.

3

The wait time for the coop side can be 3-4 hours.

28
La Lanterna di Vittorio image 1
Italian restaurant

Historic brownstone hosts a cozy Italian restaurant with low lighting and an intimate atmosphere. A garden oasis and covered outdoor patio add unique charm. The space feels both spacious and intimate with high ceilings and quiet corners.

Thin crust supports the goat cheese and arugula pizza with fresh, balanced toppings. The margarita pizza offers classic, fresh flavors alongside other Italian dishes like lasagna and pasta.

Many pies come with blueberry crumb and pecan varieties standing out. The apple pie is perfectly made and pairs well with espresso drinks.

People are saying

"The lasagna flight was playful and comforting, offering a range of flavors."

"The pizza here is crispy, flavorful, and delicious."

"You have to try the blueberry and pecan pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for the garden room seating.

2

The restaurant features live jazz on select nights.

3

Valentine’s Day fixed menu includes a glass of champagne and dessert.

29
Ci Siamo image 1
Italian restaurant

Open kitchen with visible ovens and chefs creates an engaging atmosphere. Lounge-like setting combines comfortable seating, complimentary wine elevator, and a private outdoor terrace. Energy ranges from intimate and warm to lively and touristy, with friendly staff enhancing the experience.

Salty and bright flavors stand out in the anchovy white pizza. The pizza bianca features delicious sauce and toppings that complement each other well.

Savory pies here shine with the Caramelized Onion Torta, a creamy, flavorful dish that tastes like French onion soup in pie form with a buttery flaky crust. The Lemon Torta offers a smooth curd and meringue topping, delivering a tartness similar to Key Lime Pie.

People are saying

"The rigatoni alla Gricia was perfect, the best pasta I've ever had!"

"The pizza here is outstanding; I highly recommend it."

"This onion pie is creamy, full of flavor, and totally delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for brunch and dinner.

2

Claim a spot by 5pm to avoid long wait times.

3

Happy hour is lively and popular, especially leading into dinner.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...