Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Scones and seafood in New York

You appreciate the versatility of a menu that serves both a classic scone and fresh seafood, regardless of the time of day.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Rosie’s Amagansett image 1
Rosie’s Amagansett image 2
Rosie’s Amagansett image 3
View all

Disco balls and jazz trio music create a lively, Miami-inspired vibe with a fresh, fun atmosphere. Sophisticated yet cozy decor blends modern style with seasonal changes, including a large outdoor seating area. Cocktails and food offer inventive, standout flavors amid a dog-friendly setting.

Freshly baked scones arrive early and often sell out quickly. They stay moist and have a phenomenal flavor that makes them worth returning for.

A trio of seafood ceviche offers distinct, flavorful versions. Whole fried fish and baked shrimp stand out as solid main dishes.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the indulgent mac and cheese."

"The seafood ceviche here is distinct and absolutely delicious."

"I found the scones to be phenomenal and they didn't dry out."

Good to know

1

Brunch specials are only available on Fridays, not weekends.

2

Expect high prices, with pancakes at $20 and egg sandwiches at $16.

3

Arrive early as scones often sell out quickly.

02
Dutch Baby Bakery image 1

Spacious bakery with warm, welcoming atmosphere and live jazz music on weekends. It attracts families and offers comfortable seating including outdoor options. Attention to detail shows in fresh flowers and a lovely interior design.

Scones come in a variety with standout options like the feta scallion and ginger cream. The feta scallion scone is moist and packed with scallions, while the ginger cream scone offers a unique, rich flavor.

Shrimp and grits stand out with excellent flavor and texture. The seafood pairs well with other menu items like the burger.

People are saying

"The biscuits here are flaky, buttery, and seriously delicious."

"I found the scones to be buttery and perfectly savory."

"I found the seafood here to be creamy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch as it is a neighborhood favorite.

2

Trivia night happens every Tuesday with fun and engaging questions.

3

Winning trivia rounds earns you a free treat like a drink or dessert.

03
Evelina image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers beautiful indoor and outdoor seating with heated patio and gelato cart. Atmosphere feels refined and romantic, with phenomenal decor reminiscent of Milan. Cocktails and fresh pasta stand out amid a buzzing, friendly vibe.

Freshly baked lemon scones come with butter and lemon curd. The lemon custard and cream add a delicious, rich flavor that stands out.

Shrimp and lobster come in generous portions and are expertly cooked. The Hamachi and Shrimp Ceviche offers a perfect blend of avocado, jalapenos, and leche de tigre. Charred Octopus is cooked until incredibly tender and full of flavor.

People are saying

"The pasta here is divine, truly out of this world."

"The squid ink spaghetti was a great mix of seafood."

"You have to try the lemon scone with the sharp lemon custard."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially during busy hours.

2

The restaurant switches from brunch to lunch menu at 11:45 AM.

3

Expect to wait 1-2 hours if you don't have a reservation.

04
The Lonesome Club image 1
Cocktail bar

Space combines modern UK-style chophouse decor with plenty of natural light and outdoor seating. Atmosphere balances chic and cozy, suited for intimate dinners, though noise levels can rise with live Irish band performances. Cocktails and classic drinks receive consistent praise for quality and craftsmanship.

Scones come out cozy and comforting, fitting well with the elevated food style. They pair nicely with coffee and sit alongside other hearty options like soda bread.

Fish and chips come with light, crispy fish and hand-cut fries, served alongside tartar and malt vinegar. Clams taste clean and sharp, softened by a creamy sauce, while raw oysters make a delicious starter.

People are saying

"I loved the hearty Irish breakfast and bottomless mimosas at brunch."

"Their fish and chips are amazing, served with great fries."

"The fish and chips were light, crispy, and not over-the-top delicious."

Good to know

1

Bottomless mimosas are available on Sundays.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekend brunch.

3

The restaurant does not list allergens on the menu.

05
Majorelle image 1
Haute French restaurant

Stylish interior blends Christian Dior décor with natural flower arrangements creating an elegant, calm atmosphere. The space feels like an intimate garden oasis with meticulous attention to detail. Guests enjoy a refined, leisurely experience marked by classic French elegance.

Warm scones arrive after desserts, leaving space for all the jams and cream. Served with Devonshire Cream on Dior bespoke porcelain, they feel comforting and perfectly baked.

Oysters stand out as excellent here. Fish dishes come with whole fish presentation, but they do not de-bone it table side.

People are saying

"The tea here feels like a quaint escape to Paris."

"The warm scones with clotted cream were the highlight."

"The grilled brazino with eggplant caviar was exquisite."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the high tea experience, especially during the holidays.

2

The high tea experience costs around $500 for two people, including drinks.

3

Formal attire is highly recommended for dining at the restaurant.

06
Katie's Cottage image 1
Bar & grill

Traditional Irish decor with warm lighting creates a cozy and inviting atmosphere. The place maintains a relaxed vibe with a well-chosen playlist enhancing a homelike feel. It draws a crowd seeking an authentic Irish experience with expertly poured Guinness and standout dishes like corned beef and chili wings.

Warm, moist scones arrive at every table, often served small with butter before the main menu. Bread shares the same scrumptious quality, making it a consistent starter.

Fish and chips come with a crispy outside and tender inside when cooked well. Some fish meals appear undercooked or raw.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and extremely good."

"The fish and chips here are perfectly cooked and crispy."

"The scone here feels so cozy and relaxed."

Good to know

1

There is street parking and a nearby lot available.

2

Prices are very reasonable, around $20 each plus tip.

3

Brunch entrées come with a complementary mimosa or bloody Mary.

07
Empire Diner image 1

Diner combines 1950s splendor with a contemporary upgrade in décor, creating a visually striking space. Outdoor seating in a weather-protected hut with heaters offers a quieter, comfortable atmosphere. The vibe is calm and friendly, with lively music that sometimes challenges conversation.

Scones come in apricot ginger, peach and ginger with crème fraiche, and herb varieties. They pair well with coffee and have a consistently delicious, enjoyable flavor.

Fish and chips feature tender fish with an amazing crispy outside. This dish stands out as a great choice among the seafood options.

People are saying

"The diner food here is delicious, especially the mac & cheese."

"The fish and chips here are so good, I wanted more."

"I enjoyed the apricot ginger scone with crème fraiche."

Good to know

1

The diner is open late until 11pm.

2

Expect a wait longer than indicated during peak hours.

3

The diner does not take reservations, so plan to queue.

08
Prince Tea House Ktown | Dessert Spot at Fifth Ave image 1

Space features high ceilings and French-inspired decor with warm colors and quirky animal sculptures creating a whimsical, elegant atmosphere. It feels cozy and spacious, suitable for afternoon tea and special occasions with a prestigious vibe. The setting encourages relaxing social gatherings and romantic encounters.

Scones come out warm and soft with a moist texture and a nice sugar crust. They pair well with clotted cream and peach preserves or jam, making the afternoon tea set classic and satisfying.

Shrimp lollipops and takoyaki stand out as flavorful seafood options. Afternoon tea features crab and shrimp tea sandwiches and salads that satisfy seafood lovers.

People are saying

"I found the tea here to be super yummy and delicious."

"The scones were outstanding, especially with jam and cream."

"The shrimp lollipops and crab salads are so refreshing."

Good to know

1

Afternoon tea includes unlimited tea for 1.5 hours.

2

A full teapot costs $10 and serves more than 4 teacups.

3

The afternoon set for two includes finger sandwiches, pastry, and scone for $88.

09
Bar Blondeau image 1

Rooftop bar offers stunning Manhattan skyline views through floor-to-ceiling windows and a large outdoor patio. Atmosphere features live jazz music and a trendy, ritzy vibe that suits dates and social evenings. Seating includes both indoor and outdoor options with blankets provided nearby.

Scones come out moist and light, never dry or heavy. They arrive with homemade jam that complements their flavor well.

Oysters stand out as excellent and worth ordering twice. Shrimp come with a spicy American-style red pepper flavor, while croquettes include mushrooms and shrimp, with the latter less notable.

People are saying

"This bar has incredible vibes and amazing city views."

"The scones were delicious, not dry, and served with homemade jam."

"The seafood, especially the oysters, were excellent."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for sunset hours to secure a good view.

2

Happy Hour is available on weekdays at the bar with reasonable drink prices.

3

The best time to visit is at 5 pm during summer or autumn for sunset views.

10
BG image 1
American restaurant

Elegant dining room offers breathtaking views of Central Park and beautiful green accents. Atmosphere stays welcoming and luxurious, with unique water glasses and attentive service. Popular spot for people watching and fashion, especially when seated by the window.

Scones come with clotted cream and jams, offering a texture that rivals British versions. They pair well with excellent tea and have a crispy, freshly baked feel distinct from sponge cake.

Truffled tuna fish stands out as a unique offering. The menu features pasta and seafood dishes, with anything involving fish tasting good.

People are saying

"It's so elegant and visually impressive inside."

"The service here is fantastic and attentive."

"The seafood, like salmon and tuna poke, was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times, especially for afternoon tea.

2

High tea costs $75 per person and includes sandwiches, scones, and dessert.

3

The tea service is priced at $100 per person.

11
Lafayette Grand Café & Bakery image 1

Large, open French brasserie with beautiful interior and European outdoor seating creates a lively atmosphere. Bakery section draws long lines for exceptional pastries, especially the Pistachio Supreme Croissant. Bar offers notable cocktails like a well-made penicillin and fresh mimosas.

Onion scones stand out with a savory French onion flavor that many find memorable. These scones offer a delicious, rich taste that pairs well with other bakery items like almond croissants.

Massachusetts sourced oysters stand out for their insanely fresh quality. The Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail also delivers a solid seafood option.

People are saying

"You have to try their French Food, especially the flaky, creamy pastries."

"The oysters were insanely fresh seafood."

"The pistachio Suprême croissant lived up to the hype."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait an hour or more to get in during peak times.

2

Reservations are necessary to avoid long wait times for brunch.

3

The bakery releases their famous croissants at 8am, 12pm, and 4pm.

12
The Commerce Inn image 1
American restaurant

Colonial-era and Shaker decor create a cozy, homey atmosphere with a classic American vibe. The space feels romantic and intimate despite challenging acoustics that bring diners close together. Signature milk punch cocktails and original American dishes add to the distinctive experience.

Flaky scones arrive warm, served with butter and jam. They stand out alongside pancakes as a solid food choice.

Fried oysters and pickled oysters stand out as starters. The potted shrimp offers a unique and flavorful option alongside roast fish and pork chop.

People are saying

"These pancakes are so fluffy they melt in your mouth."

"The fried oysters here are delicious, especially with the pickled ones."

"The scones here are good, especially the fluffy buttermilk ones with buttermilk."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand.

2

Brunch ends at 3 PM, so plan accordingly.

3

Expect high prices, with salads around $19 and soups at $33.

13
Tea & Sympathy image 1
British restaurant

Small dining space offers a cozy, authentic British ambiance with traditional tea service and vintage decor. Outdoor seating in a charming greenhouse-style patio provides a quieter, more spacious option. The atmosphere balances intimate and lively energy, making it personable and quaint.

Scones come out light and fresh, paired with clotted cream that adds a creamy, sweet touch. They sit alongside a gorgeous array of cakes and finger sandwiches, all made with care.

Fish and chips here have a traditional British style and a consistent quality that recalls European meals. The dish pairs well with other classic items like pot pie and Victorian sponge cake.

People are saying

"The afternoon tea spread, especially the sandwiches and scones, was delicious."

"The scones here are perfect, buttery, and fall-apart."

"The seafood here is authentic and charmingly British."

Good to know

1

Reservations are definitely recommended due to limited seating.

2

The cost for an afternoon tea set is $60 per person.

3

Credit cards have an upcharge of 2%+, so use cash or debit.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...