Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Unique Vanilla Ice Cream in New York

Vanilla ice cream that manages to be distinct and memorable without relying on a dozen distracting toppings.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Craveology image 1
Craveology image 2
Craveology image 3
View all
Dessert shop

Dessert shop offers clean, modern design with a cozy, welcoming vibe. The space feels spacious and well lit, creating an enjoyable atmosphere. Unique dessert presentations and a variety of options set it apart from typical spots.

Soft serve stands out with its creamy texture and pairs well with desserts like lava cake. Vanilla ice cream appears in treats topped with gooey marshmallows, rich chocolate drizzle, and whipped cream swirls.

Amazing desserts feature unique presentation and flavors. Dishes stand out with distinctive creativity and delicious combinations.

People are saying

"The desserts here are so sweet and the staff is incredibly friendly."

"I found the desserts here to be unique and delicious."

"The vanilla ice cream soft serve was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Craveology offers a variety of desserts including crepes, shakes, and coffee.

2

Craveology has late hours to satisfy late-night cravings.

3

Prices at Craveology are reasonable for the quality of desserts offered.

02
Don Don Korean BBQ image 1
Korean barbecue restaurant

Small space with retro Korea vibe and open kitchen creates an authentic meat market atmosphere. Tables feature vented tabletop grills and seats with hidden storage to reduce BBQ smell. Loud music and smoky air make it lively but not suited for quiet conversation.

Airy texture defines the vanilla ice cream here. It often comes with black sesame powder or as a complimentary sesame vanilla scoop to finish the meal.

Offers a unique Korean BBQ focused solely on pork with a bar/KBBQ vibe inspired by Korea. Features unique bowls, plates, and glass cups alongside distinctive banchans in a comfy atmosphere.

People are saying

"The Korean food here, especially the stews and side dishes, is delicious."

"It's unique how they only serve pork, especially the dry-aged kind."

"You have to try the airy vanilla ice cream."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only serves pork for the BBQ meats.

2

The price for one serving of pork belly is $35.

3

A ssam (veggie) platter costs $7.

03
YuanYang Dessert鸳鸯糖水铺 image 1

Wooden architecture and modern-traditional decor create a cozy, authentic atmosphere with warm seating. Small space fills with an energetic vibe as customers enjoy a variety of classic Chinese desserts. Self-ordering machines add convenience for takeout.

Coffee starts strong then softens as it blends with vanilla ice cream in the dessert. The vanilla rice ball and colorful cereal topping add visual appeal, while hot coffee poured over the pudding intensifies flavors.

Pineapple beef skewers blend sweetness with savory in a way that stands out. Desserts offer unique flavors like milk custard resembling white egg tart centers, paired with a pleasant atmosphere that feels different from typical spots.

People are saying

"I found YuanYang Dessert to be my favorite Asian dessert place."

"The desserts here are so unique, with fresh ingredients and distinct flavors."

"The vanilla ice cream with coffee egg pudding was surprisingly pleasing."

Good to know

1

All payment methods are accepted, including mobile payments.

2

The menu features unique dessert options like Roasted Pears with Peach gum.

3

Orders are prepared quickly when placed at the kiosk.

04
Duo Cafe image 1
Tea house

Small tea house blends traditional and modern influences with warm lighting and painted brick walls. Atmosphere feels cozy and intimate, suited for quiet chats or solo study. Narrow aisles and backless chairs shape a compact, lively space.

Caramelized and brûléed sweet potatoes pair with vanilla ice cream to create a rich, unexpected combo. Presentation feels like works of art with careful attention to detail.

Tea selection includes traditional classics and unique options with a chance to smell loose leaves before choosing. Desserts feature unique flavors like taro basque cheesecake and osmanthus flower accents.

People are saying

"The desserts here are impressive, well-balanced, and beautifully presented."

"It's such a cute and cozy spot to unwind."

"The sweet potato with vanilla ice cream is excellent."

Good to know

1

Duo Café offers a special menu and decorations for the Lunar New Year through mid-February.

2

The tea set for $39 includes a big cookie, two almond cookies, two tangerines, and a yam.

3

The basic tea set costs $42, and $52 includes a cake and ice cream.

05
Lemongrass Brooklyn image 1
Thai restaurant

Thai restaurant with tropical decor and beautiful aesthetics creates a lively atmosphere filled with techno-pop music. Outdoor seating is available but heaters provide limited warmth. Drinks include tropical cocktails served in unique presentations like pineapple bowls.

Vanilla ice cream here is super velvety and served with desserts like lava cake. It also appears as fried vanilla ice cream, adding a crispy twist to the creamy texture.

Fried ice cream and tom yum ramen offer unique flavors not commonly found elsewhere. The lychee shrimp balances sweetness and savory in a way that stands out, while the atmosphere feels like a vacation vibe.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the crab rangoon."

"I loved their unique Thai ramen and fried shrimp dishes."

"The vanilla ice cream here is super velvety."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials are available Monday to Friday, including a spring roll and an entree.

2

The restaurant gets packed quickly, so making reservations is recommended.

3

They do not accept Apple Pay; credit cards are preferred.

06
Kesté Pizza e Vino image 1
Pizza restaurant

Separate kitchen and oven ensure safe gluten-free options with pizza that folds without breaking. Seating is cramped indoors but complemented by a large outdoor patio suitable for groups. Atmosphere feels homey and lively without being noisy, with visible pizza-making adding to the experience.

Angioletti served with vanilla ice cream and Nutella stands out as a spectacular dessert. This combination creates a finest dish experience.

Pizzas feature a beautiful selection of unique toppings with distinct and authentic flavors. The Montanara Genovese stands out for its unique taste among a variety of vibrant options.

People are saying

"The gluten-free crust here tastes exactly like regular pizza."

"You have to try the calzone; it's safe for celiacs."

"The pizzas here have a unique, authentic flavor."

Good to know

1

Happy hour lasts until 7:00 PM with great deals on drinks and appetizers.

2

The restaurant does not accept reservations; arrive early to secure a table.

3

All menu items can be made gluten-free, including their popular pizza.

07
Elio's image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with wide variety of flavors and unique donut toppings offers a friendly, welcoming atmosphere and fun interior design. Retro Pac-Man game adds a nostalgic touch while customers enjoy their treats. Space includes a separate area to relax and savor ice cream and milkshakes.

Vanilla ice cream comes with a dark chocolate drizzle that enhances desserts like the brownie delight and Nutella peanut doughnut. It also appeals to dogs, making it a versatile treat.

Desserts feature donut and ice cream with color-changing spoons adding a playful touch. Flavors stay unique and fun throughout the sweets.

People are saying

"The ice cream staff here are so friendly and welcoming."

"I found the ice cream flavors here to be so unique and fun."

"The dark chocolate drizzle on the vanilla ice cream looked really nice."

Good to know

1

The dessert spot is open until 2AM on the weekend.

2

John Depp ice cream is 21+ only.

3

The ice cream sandwich costs $15.00.

08
Little Maven image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers an elegant, 80s-inspired decor with meticulously maximal design and carefully curated lighting. Atmosphere balances a lively yet not too loud vibe with great music, including DJ sets. Guests find a thoughtful bar program featuring well-crafted cocktails and knowledgeable sommelier recommendations.

Homemade soft serve vanilla ice cream comes with an aftertaste of banana. It pairs with out-of-the-oven chocolate chip cookies for a classic finish.

Dishes like butternut squash agnolotti, tempura squash with stracciatella, and celery root pasta offer unique textures and flavors. Shareable plates come with creative twists that stand out.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and wonderful."

"The dishes here are unique and always delicious."

"You have to try the homemade soft serve vanilla ice cream with the cookies."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant offers a $55 special three-course prix fixe menu.

3

Happy hour deals include discounted drinks and appetizers.

09
Hello, Yam! image 1
Dessert shop

Small dessert shop with bright, clean ambiance and limited seating focuses on Japanese-imported sweet potato desserts. The atmosphere stays calm and cool, attracting a diverse crowd. Desserts balance unique flavors with a creative presentation.

Parfaits combine vanilla ice cream with warm yellow yam, sweet potatoes, and corn flakes. Simple desserts layer one scoop of vanilla ice cream with corn flakes and regular sweet potato.

Desserts feature unique flavors and textures that stand out. The creative dessert shop offers a distinctive hojicha latte and treats that feel unlike anything else.

People are saying

"The yam desserts here are surprisingly light and totally unique."

"The vanilla ice cream with warm yam and crispy cornflakes is delightful."

"I was surprised so many items were vegetarian or could be made vegetarian."

Good to know

1

Many of the items can be made vegan.

2

There are not many places to sit, so it’s more of a pick up dessert place.

3

The dessert shop is unique and creative.

10
Grace Street Coffee & Desserts image 1

Loud, crowded space with high noise levels and self-service setup shapes the experience. Seating is roomy but uncomfortable, with bare, peeling walls giving an unfinished feel. Energy stays lively, making calm conversation difficult.

Crispy, cinnamony donuts come with sweet and creamy vanilla ice cream in the middle. Fluffy cinnamon pastries like Ho-Dduk and hotteok pair well with the vanilla ice cream.

Honey toast with boba comes with condensed milk to pour on top. The menu offers unique shaved snow and desserts with a twist on traditional Korean flavors.

People are saying

"The matcha latte here is one of the best I've ever had."

"I found a unique dessert with a creamy texture and fun mix of textures."

"The hotteok paired perfectly with the sweet and creamy vanilla ice cream."

Good to know

1

You need to order at the front entrance counter.

2

Expect to spend almost $20 per person for a full dessert.

3

There is no way to reserve a table at this place.

11
Museum of Ice Cream image 1

Fourteen interactive rooms offer colorful, Instagrammable spaces with free ice cream at multiple stations. Loud music and many children create a lively, energetic atmosphere. Creative exhibits include a sprinkle pool and a massive slide, making the experience playful and immersive.

The pink vanilla ice cream stands out with a unique flavor. Regular vanilla ice cream also offers a rich, creamy taste.

Visitors find a magical and fun experience with generous ice cream servings and unique flavors. The outing appeals especially to families and ice cream lovers seeking something different.

People are saying

"It's a fun, colorful, and interactive experience that kids will love."

"Each room was unique, colorful, and provided great photo opportunities."

"The pink vanilla ice cream here is unbelievably delicious."

Good to know

1

You should reserve your tickets in advance.

2

The cost is $60 per person.

3

Tickets must be purchased ahead of time and online.

12
COTE Flatiron image 1
Steak house

Modern space with high ceilings and artwork by renowned artists creates a chic atmosphere. Loud music and dim lighting make conversation difficult, while grilling meat at the table offers an interactive dining experience. A basement bar provides a casual spot to relax before meals.

Creamy vanilla ice cream comes with a soy caramel sauce or caramel syrup. It offers a sweet ending to meals.

Grilling offers an interactive experience with each course featuring unique flavors inspired by Korean soul food. Dishes include house-made sauces and soju bottles, plus a soft serve with soy sauce caramel that stands out.

People are saying

"The Korean food's marinated galbi is the best dish here."

"The quality of the food and the unique blend of traditions make it worth the investment."

"The vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce is a perfect sweet ending."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for weekend dining.

2

Expect to pay around $225 per person for the full experience.

3

COTE is the only Michelin-starred Korean BBQ in the world.

13
Softside image 1
Ice cream shop

Soft serve ice cream shop with clean, modern vibe and abundant outdoor seating including sidewalk tables. Atmosphere is Instagrammable and cute, attracting those who enjoy visually appealing treats. Lactaid pills are available for lactose intolerance, adding a practical touch to the experience.

Vanilla ice cream comes with a honey, olive oil, and sea salt topping that stands out. It also appears with a crispy chocolate coating, though sometimes the ice cream melts quickly.

Soft serve features a unique twist with an olive oil addition that blends surprisingly well with the sweet flavor. The ice cream offers a familiar yet distinct taste not commonly found in Korea.

People are saying

"The matcha ice cream here is worth the hype."

"You have to try the unique olive oil and sea salt topping on the ice cream."

"The vanilla ice cream with honey, olive oil, and sea salt is incredible."

Good to know

1

The establishment only accepts cash in 2024.

2

The soft serve costs $9.

3

They sell lactaid pills for those who are lactose intolerant.

14
Lexington Candy Shop image 1

Small diner with retro American atmosphere and handmade soda fountain service creates a nostalgic vibe. Crowded space filled with classic 1920s Americana details and an authentic luncheonette feel. Regulars enjoy old-fashioned cokes and traditional breakfast dishes in a compact, lively setting.

Coca-Cola served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream creates a classic float. The drink is prepared by hand and served in a tall glass, offering a nostalgic and delicious taste.

Vintage decor and a soda fountain counter create a cozy atmosphere that feels like stepping back in time. Hand mixed sodas and a Coca-Cola with ice cream offer unique flavors not found elsewhere.

People are saying

"You have to try the diner's Coke, mixed the old-fashioned way."

"It's a unique step back in time with that classic Coca-Cola taste."

"I tried the Coca-Cola with vanilla ice cream, and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Breakfast time is recommended to avoid queues at lunchtime.

2

On the weekends, there’s a line that stretches around the block.

3

Be prepared for a wait; it’s all part of the experience.

15
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain image 1

Old-school soda fountain and vintage pharmacy decor create a nostalgic atmosphere filled with knickknacks and collectibles. Seating is available both indoors and outdoors, with board games and picture books adding to a relaxed vibe. Unique offerings include adult ice cream floats featuring beer or rose.

Creamy vanilla ice cream appears in the black and white milkshake with chocolate syrup swirls and in the broken dreams sundae topped with hot fudge and pretzel salt. The vanilla ice cream is pleasant but not exceptional.

Old-school pharmacy decor creates a vintage ambiance with cozy tables and board games. Shakes, floats, and sundaes come with a fun, unique twist that fits the dark academia vibe.

People are saying

"The ice cream and sundaes here are delicious and worth every calorie."

"It felt like stepping back in time with all the charming vintage decor."

"The vanilla ice cream here feels like a trip back in time."

Good to know

1

Customers need to order inside and find a table or seat outside.

2

The restaurant has limited seating for two, which can be an issue.

3

The place gets pretty busy at night.

16
Margot image 1
Restaurant

Open kitchen and stylish decor create a welcoming, relaxed atmosphere with easy conversation noise levels. Cocktails stand out as a highlight, crafted by skilled bartenders. The space feels cool in temperature, and servers wear a hip, elevated style.

Cuisine features unique tastes like nettle green pesto, offering a refreshing alternative to regular pesto. Wines by the glass and cocktails also stand out for their unique selections and flavors.

People are saying

"I loved the great wine selection and knowledge here."

"The cocktails here are expertly made and top-quality."

"The cocktails here are creative and unique."

Good to know

1

There is a surprise 3% kitchen fee added to the bill without warning.

2

The restaurant can prepare gluten-free meals without cross-contamination.

3

Check your receipts as the bill may have higher prices than listed.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...