Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of South Setauket

Sandwiches

A handheld meal that is easy to eat on the go.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bella's Bagels and Deli image 1
Bella's Bagels and Deli image 2
Bella's Bagels and Deli image 3
View all

Bagel shop offers fresh, bouncy bagels and flavorful breakfast sandwiches like the Hungry Man Breakfast Hero. Enjoy home fries by default with sandwiches in a clean, organized space. Friendly service and affordable prices add to the old school vibe and family feel.

Breakfast sandwiches feature bacon and egg with a satisfying, flavorful taste. Bagel sandwiches and croissants come out delicious and well-made, with options like the Hungry Man Breakfast Hero including home fries by default.

People are saying

"This breakfast sandwich is satisfying and flavorful."

"The bagels here are fresh and hot."

"I always went there for a good, tasty breakfast."

Good to know

1

The sandwich comes with home fries by default.

2

Prices are affordable for most menu items.

3

The shop is clean and organized for a pleasant visit.

02
Mangiamo Italian Market & Deli image 1

Market shines with gorgeous decor and a pristine interior that creates a wonderful atmosphere. Sandwiches are overstuffed with quality ingredients, following an old world philosophy for authentic Italian flavors. Pricing stays fair and affordable, perfect for those seeking quality deli options.

Sandwiches come overstuffed with quality ingredients and follow an old world philosophy that values more filling. Options include heroes, ciabattas, and customized Italian sandwiches that maintain affordability and strong flavor.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are huge, fresh, and delicious."

"I found the leg of lamb, meats, and salads to be authentic and good."

"The Italian market and deli have authentic imported selections."

Good to know

1

The market offers a large variety of authentic Italian specialty products.

2

Prices are competitive compared to other delis in the area.

3

Expect some food items to be expired or not properly rotated.

03
Centereach Deli image 1

Old school deli offers a homestyle vibe with bacon, eggs, and coffee aromas. Breakfast sandwiches shine, especially the bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel. Lunch features a buffalo chicken cold cut sandwich with fresh toppings and Boar's Head meat.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel and a strong reputation for being delicious. Lunch options include a buffalo chicken cold cut sandwich with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles on a roll, alongside other sandwiches and salads.

People are saying

"This deli's breakfast sandwiches with crispy bacon and melted cheese are incredible."

"The food here is delicious, especially the roast beef heroes."

"Their breakfast sandwiches are incredible, especially the bacon, egg, and cheese."

Good to know

1

Catering services are available with large heroes, pasta trays, and party platters.

2

Expect to pay around $15 for a sandwich, which some find expensive.

3

Everything is prepared quickly, often within 15 minutes.

04
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen image 1
Chicken restaurant

Fast food spot shines with crispy chicken sandwiches and spicy wings. Cozy, clean space favors mobile orders and drive-thru. Prices run high but pair well with sweet iced tea for a quick, tasty meal.

Chicken cutlet sandwiches stand out for their juiciness and crispy texture. They come together quickly and pair well with a cool, sweet iced tea.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and hot."

"I found the fast food chicken sandwich to be the juiciest and crispiest."

"Their chicken sandwich is juicy and crispy."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Mobile orders and drive-thru service are prioritized over dine-in customers.

3

Parking is ample and easily accessible.

05
Poppyseeds Bagels image 1

Fresh handmade bagels shine with New York-style quality and generous toppings. Egg sandwiches are solid but pricey at $10 plus 15% fee and may take up to 20 minutes. Seating is ample and space stays impeccably clean despite occasional waits.

Egg sandwiches come with great bagels and taste consistent. Expect a $10 price plus a 15% card fee. Wait times can reach 20 minutes and orders may sometimes be incorrect.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be the best I ever tasted."

"I thought the food here was always great and fresh."

"I found their egg sandwich to be the most perfect every single time."

Good to know

1

Orders are prepared in less than ten minutes.

2

The spot is popular, so there can be a wait at times.

3

The sandwich costs $10 plus a 15% fee for using a card.

06
Jejojo Bagels Inc image 1

Old-fashioned bagel shop shines with soft fresh bagels and quick service. Sandwiches feature super thin ham slices but fillings can be sparse. Family-run spot offers reasonable prices and a clean, consistent vibe.

Breakfast sandwiches come with super thin ham slices and vary in filling size. Some sandwiches like the Hungry Man have just a literal piece of bacon and no home fries, while others have barely anything on them.

People are saying

"These bagels are huge and fluffy."

"The staff here is super friendly and competent."

"I love their breakfast sandwiches; they're better than ever."

Good to know

1

Jejojo Bagels Inc. opens from 5 am till 2 pm.

2

Expect long wait times during busy morning hours.

3

The prices for bagels are reasonable, with a bagel and cream cheese costing $3.61.

07
Bonchon Centereach - Centereach Mall image 1

Space feels compact with Japanese-themed decor and a peaceful vibe. Chicken sandwich packs strong flavor but can be greasy. Friendly staff and kiosk ordering keep service quick in a busy spot.

Chicken sandwich offers a strong flavor and comes with fries at a reasonable price. Some find it greasy and heavy due to the fried batter, which can be overwhelming.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and cooked to perfection."

"I found the fried chicken to be exceptionally crispy and flavorful."

"I found the chicken sandwich to be really good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; orders must be placed online only.

2

Some menu items may be unavailable, especially during peak hours.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean and sanitary environment.

08
German Doner Kebab image 1
German restaurant

Modern space offers a unique meat slicing view and a family-friendly vibe with friendly staff. Original sandwich packs bold flavor and comes with a free sauce flight to enhance taste.

Original sandwich comes stuffed with flavor and toppings. Sauce is always included free, often with a flight of three small sauces.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and super fresh."

"The bread here is soft, warm, and has just the right crisp."

"The Original sandwich is huge, overflowing with flavor and toppings."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of around 50 minutes during peak hours.

2

The restaurant has limited seating, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

It's a counter-service restaurant, so order at the counter.

Discover more

South Setauket, Centereach

Area guide
Loading Map...