Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Sandwich spots in Commack

Made for those who prefer a portable, handheld meal and have high standards for how a proper sandwich should be constructed.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The Rolling Spring Roll (Commack) image 1
The Rolling Spring Roll (Commack) image 2
The Rolling Spring Roll (Commack) image 3
View all

Small, simple space with a clean and quiet atmosphere suits takeout well. Energy stays low, making it good for conversation and enjoying authentic Vietnamese dishes. Known for fresh spring rolls, handmade Banh Mi, and soul-warming pho that reflect traditional flavors.

Food here is authentic Vietnamese and consistently fresh. Dishes come with great service and a homemade feel.

Classic pork Banh Mi sandwiches feature savory fillings and a tangy sauce inside a crisp, homemade baguette. They taste very fresh and highlight traditional, handcrafted cuisine.

People are saying

"I always come here for a comforting bowl of Vietnamese Food."

"I always came here for a comforting bowl of beef pho."

"I really enjoyed the fresh, savory banh mi sandwich."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has some vegetarian and vegan options.

2

I appreciated the QR code ordering system.

3

The prices were reasonable.

02
Simplygreekexpress image 1
Greek restaurant

Small space with thoughtful decor and an open kitchen creates a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Energy feels welcoming and relaxed, with a focus on authentic Greek hospitality. Seating is limited but recently expanded to accommodate more guests.

Food here is consistently excellent and fresh, with a focus on Greek dishes that stand out for their wonderful flavors.

Gyro sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and come with salad and a side. Chicken options like the gyro and souvlaki sandwiches offer delicious, savory taste.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic Greek, with flavorful spices and fresh ingredients."

"I loved the Gyro sandwiches and dinner plates; they were huge."

"The gyro sandwich here is authentically delicious and huge."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers large portion sizes for a reasonable price.

2

Expect little to no wait for food during peak hours.

3

The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness throughout.

03
Shahโ€™s Halal Commack image 1

Halal restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with warm hospitality and a clean, welcoming environment. It attracts those seeking quick, tasty, and affordable meals with generous portions. The vibe suits casual dining and hanging out with friends or family.

Halal food here stands out for its excellent quality and amazing flavor. The food consistently pairs well with attentive service, making meals satisfying and reliable.

Spicy Chicken sandwich cooks well and tastes good. The Philly cheesesteak sandwich sometimes lacks peppers and onions and can have dried out meat. Gyro sandwiches are often overstuffed with cubed meat that falls out easily.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

"It's a great late night spot for quick and tasty food."

"I found the chicken sandwich here to be very good."

Good to know

1

Parking is available right in front of the restaurant.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

3

Prices at Shahโ€™s Halal Commack are very reasonable.

04
Pastrami N Friends image 1

Old school kosher deli atmosphere fills the space with vintage decor and relaxing lighting. Crowds gather around for authentic pastrami sandwiches and classic Jewish deli aromas. The vibe is casual and friendly, with a clean and comfortable setting.

Food comes out hot and fresh with a wide assortment of delicious kosher deli options. The flavors are delicious and comforting, reminiscent of home cooking.

Pastrami and corned beef combo sandwiches come tender and moist, served in a perfectly sized portion. Rye bread with Russian dressing and coleslaw adds a classic touch to these consistently good sandwiches.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be excellent and delicious."

"I loved their creamy coleslaw; it was the best I ever had."

"I thought the pastrami sandwich was the best on the island."

Good to know

1

Parking is available and shared within the area.

2

The menu at Pastrami N Friends is Kosher.

3

Expect smaller portion sizes compared to larger delis.

05
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks of Commack image 1

Flat screens and throwback food truck vibe create a fun, classic sandwich counter atmosphere. The place draws people looking for light, perfectly cooked cheesesteaks and amazing empanadas. Prices vary, but the setup and charm stand out in a strip mall setting.

Food arrives hot and ready quickly with consistently great and tasty flavors. The menu features cheesesteaks that stand out for their quality and taste.

Steak sandwiches feature melted cheese at the bottom blending with steak juices for rich flavor. The original Philly cheesesteak stands out as a classic choice with a nostalgic sandwich counter vibe.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and tasty."

"I found the cheesesteak sandwiches here to be amazing."

"I found the empanadas to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the strip mall where the restaurant is located.

2

Online ordering is user-friendly and recommended for takeout.

3

The dining area is small, making takeout a better option.

06
Commack Bagels Deli Market image 1

Bagel shop offers fresh bagels and excellent egg sandwiches with a significant menu that suits hearty appetites. Atmosphere feels family-owned and welcoming, adding a nice touch to the community. Prices lean toward the higher side, reflecting the quality and selection available.

Food stays fresh and good with a significant menu that offers great portions at fair prices. Meals are consistently delicious and remarkable.

Sandwiches here have small portions of meat, often just one slice of turkey and cheese. The egg and cheese and cowboy sandwiches stand out, but prices near $15 feel high for the quality.

People are saying

"These bagels are so fresh, they feel like they just came out of the oven."

"I found the deli food here to be always good and fresh."

"The food here is great and always fresh."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $15 for a sandwich.

2

Bagels cost over $4 each.

3

Portion sizes for meat on sandwiches may be smaller than expected.

07
Everything Bagel image 1

Bagel shop feels super crowded and crammed, making waiting in line uncomfortable. Energy stays busy and lively with steady flow and enough staff to handle volume. Known for fresh, delicious bagels and huge egg sandwiches that stand out in the area.

Food stays consistently fresh and delicious with top notch quality every time. Dishes look appealing and taste great, making the overall food experience amazing.

Egg sandwiches stand out for being huge, cheap, and delicious. The combination of bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel creates a flavorful sandwich that reflects strong craftsmanship.

People are saying

"I loved the Everything Bagel; it was perfectly baked."

"Their egg sandwiches are huge, cheap, and delicious."

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a line during peak hours, but it moves quickly.

2

They offer a promotion: buy 12 bagels and get 6 free.

3

Prices for a dozen bagels are higher on holidays.

08
QuickChek image 1
Convenience store

Gas station with 24-hour service and well-lit pumps stays open late with all pumps working. Store offers clean, well-stocked aisles featuring fresh sandwiches and a variety of snacks. Atmosphere is straightforward and convenient for quick stops.

Food stays consistently fresh and offers great value. Quick service makes it easy to grab a meal or drink, though wait times can reach up to 40 minutes.

Sandwiches match the pictures on the window and taste very delicious. Friendly staff prepare them, making it a nice spot for coffee and sandwiches.

People are saying

"This gas station is a lifesaver, always open when you need it."

"I loved my sandwich; it looked just like the picture."

"The food here is great and a good value."

Good to know

1

QuickChek is the only 24-hour gas station in the area.

2

All gas pumps at QuickChek are well lit and operational at all hours.

3

The store is clean and well stocked with a variety of items.

09
MAYFAIR BAGEL CAFE image 1

Bright, modern bagel shop with a spacious, spotless dining area and welcoming atmosphere. Offers fresh, high-quality ingredients and stands out as a halal breakfast option. Energy is calm and cozy, suitable for family breakfasts.

Food features delicious bagels and consistently great taste. Service complements the good food well.

Breakfast sandwiches come wrapped and cut in half for easy handling. Bagels serve as a solid base, and meals include plasticware and ample napkins for convenience.

People are saying

"The food here is incredibly fresh and delicious."

"The owner's personal touch makes breakfast feel so thoughtful."

"The breakfast sandwiches here are fantastic and fresh."

Good to know

1

The price for a bagel sandwich is $13, including a pickle and a side salad.

2

The cafรฉ is known for being the only halal breakfast option in the area.

3

Prices are generally considered reasonable for the quality of food offered.

Discover more

Commack, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...