Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Sandwiches in East Islip

You want a sandwich that is built with intention and quality ingredients rather than just something to fill the gap.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Riley Fibbers image 1
Riley Fibbers image 2
Riley Fibbers image 3
View all

Old, rustic building offers a casual vibe with open layout and loud music. Reuben sandwiches stand out with top-rated wings and unique pub food like Bender Fries. Wide drink selection keeps a diverse crowd happy late into the night.

Reuben sandwiches rank among the best here, alongside a solid steak sandwich and a smoked turkey sandwich. The skirt steak sandwich comes without onion and mashed potatoes by default.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be amazing."

"I love their great beer selection."

"I had one of the top three Reuben sandwiches ever."

Good to know

1

Riley Fibbers has a late night kitchen for food after hours.

2

Expect large portions for both food and drinks.

3

The restaurant is family-friendly and welcomes kids.

02
A/S Pork Store & Italian Fine Foods of East Islip image 1

Italian grocery store shines with authentic deli meats and in-house aged beef. Sandwiches boast exceptional taste and quality ingredients that appeal to all ages. Atmosphere bursts with personality and authenticity for true food lovers.

Offers carefully crafted heroes and sandwiches with a beautifully curated selection that appeals to all ages. The sandwiches stand out for their exceptional taste and quality ingredients.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"I had the best sandwiches I ever tasted here."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of imported Italian products.

2

Aged beef selections are available, ensuring high quality.

3

Customer service is noted for being friendly and helpful.

03
Burger Break image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Old school burger joint offers a casual, nostalgic atmosphere with outdoor picnic tables. Chicken sandwiches are crispy and fresh, while cheeseburgers come with classic sides like fries and onion rings. Quick service and good prices make it lively and inviting.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with a crispy fried texture and fresh taste. Burgers come with cheeseburgers and classic sides like fries and onion rings, served quickly at a good price.

People are saying

"I thought the American food, especially the burgers and hot dogs, was delicious."

"I found the chicken sandwich to be fresh, hot, and delicious."

"I found the chicken sandwich to be especially great."

Good to know

1

On Mondays, there's a buy one get one free deal for shakes.

2

The service time from order to pickup window is between 7-10 minutes.

3

There is ample accessible parking right out front.

04
BlueLineDeli&Bagels image 1

Islanders-themed decor creates a casual vibe. Toasted bagels and crispy bacon draw steady crowds despite slightly higher prices. Egg sandwiches are delicious and affordable. Staff offer kind, helpful service with extras like free coffee.

Egg sandwiches stand out for being delicious and affordable. Staff show kindness and offer helpful service, often including extras like free coffee.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were great and delicious."

"The staff here are the nicest people, making my breakfast easier."

"I found the egg sandwiches to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Prices are generally $1 to $1.50 higher than other local delis.

3

The deli maintains a clean environment for customers.

05
South Shore Deli image 1

Old school pork store style creates a homey atmosphere with clean, organized space. Breakfast sandwiches with egg and brisket shine. Quick service makes it a solid choice for a morning meal before work.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with egg and brisket options. Quick service makes it a solid choice for a morning meal before work.

People are saying

"I thought the BBQ here was incredible."

"This lunch spot has awesome staff and delicious homemade food."

"I always come here for the breakfast sandwiches."

Good to know

1

South Shore Deli offers a wide variety of deli items on its menu.

2

Prices at South Shore Deli are very reasonable for the portion sizes.

3

The establishment is clean and organized, providing a pleasant dining experience.

06
Buttermilk's Chicken image 1
Chicken restaurant

Cozy seating and homely decor create a warm, inviting space with pleasant music. Crispy buttermilk fried chicken shines with homemade sauces that make sandwiches like the Kickinโ€™ Chicken stand out. Limited hours add to its small-business charm.

Chicken sandwiches come fresh made with homemade sauces and are huge in size. They stand out compared to chain options and include varieties like the Kickinโ€™ Chicken.

People are saying

"The fried chicken here is impossibly delectable and spicy."

"I thought the onion rings were battered perfectly and so crispy."

"The chicken sandwich here is huge and amazing."

Good to know

1

Buttermilk's Chicken closes early at 7pm on the days they are open.

2

They operate only a few days each week, so check ahead.

3

Expect larger portion sizes, which include bread with the meal.

07
Subway image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwiches are made with clean handling and perfect prep. Quick service keeps lines moving in a functional setup. Regulars value efficiency over ambiance here.

Sandwiches come out with perfect preparation and the right add ons. Staff change gloves for each sandwich, ensuring clean handling and precise customization.

People are saying

"I found the sandwich here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, particularly on Friday nights.

3

Parking is limited; consider using public transport or rideshare services.

08
Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille image 1

Open outdoor seating with firepits and a dog-friendly patio creates a lively, family-friendly vibe. Inside, a buzzing bar offers loud music and energy. Sandwiches shine with a cornflakes crusted fried chicken and an off-the-charts steak sandwich.

Fried chicken sandwich features a cornflakes crust and chipotle sauce with two thin cutlets. Large lobster sandwich called Lobster Bomb comes smothered in lobster bisque on a big bun. Steak sandwich stands out as off the charts. Panini and chicken sandwiches stay tender and moist.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the lobster rolls, is amazing."

"You have to try the lobster grilled cheese at this Lunch Spot."

"The lobster sandwich was smothered in bisque and delicious."

Good to know

1

Taco Tuesday offers $3 tacos and $6 margaritas every Tuesday.

2

Reservations are recommended to avoid a 30-45 minute wait for a table.

3

Happy hour prices are available in the dining room during specified hours.

Discover more

East Islip, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...