Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Farmingdale

Seafood dinner spots

A seafood dinner that feels like a proper night out rather than a quick trip to a fish counter.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Palmer's American Grille image 1
Palmer's American Grille image 2
Palmer's American Grille image 3
View all
Continental restaurant

Spacious dining room with a golf theme creates a comfortable and tasteful setting. Live band plays 80s and 90s tunes in the bar, adding lively entertainment. Noise level can be high when crowded, making conversation difficult.

Dinner features delicious food and outstanding service. Prix fixe dinners offer excellent value for celebrations and special occasions.

Seafood dishes feature tender, flaky fish prepared to order, including a stuffed Mediterranean white fish and stuffed shrimp. The seafood crepes stand out as a favorite, alongside tasty shrimp served in various styles.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here have large portions and great flavor."

"The seafood crepes and stuffed whitefish were excellent."

"The Caesar salad is delicious with fresh lettuce and cheese."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is one of the few excellent options remaining on Long Island.

2

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

3

The restaurant offers an affordable three-course prix fixe menu.

02
Grexicana image 1
Restaurant

Colorful murals and hand-painted artwork create an eye-catching decor that energizes the space. The atmosphere shifts from cozy and inviting on quiet days to loud and lively during busy nights. Outdoor seating adds a relaxed option, while the crowd often waits for tables, indicating strong popularity.

Dinner features a Lamb Shank and Risotto that stands out. The menu includes a quirky Girl Dinner option for special occasions. Families often choose this spot for birthday dinners.

Shrimp tostada and fish tacos stand out with flavorful seafood. Birria tacos and shrimp and grits join a menu featuring diverse seafood dishes alongside elote, saganaki, and haloumi.

People are saying

"I thought the food and drinks here were outstanding."

"The shrimp tacos and fish tacos were amazing fusion."

"The food at these dinner spots was amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

On Saturday nights, Grexicana offers live music at 9 pm.

2

Tuesdayโ€™s all-you-can-eat tacos with a margarita for $35 is a great deal.

3

Brunch on Saturdays and Sundays includes bottomless mimosas or margaritas for 90 minutes.

03
Gino's Of Farmingdale - Pizzeria & Restaurant image 1

Traditional style pizzeria with beautiful interior design and comfortable seating inside and out. Casual, family-style atmosphere with pleasant country music creating a welcoming vibe. Known for exceptional pizza including thin crust options not found nearby.

Dinner features pleasant country music that enhances the meal. The food is amazing and portions can be generous enough to share.

Seafood appears mainly in pasta dishes with shrimp, mussels, and clams. Options include shrimp parm and seafood pasta with rigatoni or spaghetti. Soup with clams also features on the menu.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was one of the best I could find."

"The seafood pasta had shrimp, mussels, and clams."

"I thought the pizza here was great."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has plenty of seats inside and outside.

2

There is little to no wait time during most visits.

3

The VIP meal deal provides enough food for at least four people.

04
Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant image 1

Old school Italian restaurant with wood paneling, fireplaces, and brick decor creates a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Live accordion music circulates on weekends, adding an authentic touch. A central bar area complements the warm, welcoming vibe.

Fresh and delicious appetizers and dinners make this spot great for dinner. Rigatoni al forno stands out as an excellent choice for family occasions, romantic dinners, or gatherings with friends.

Seafood shines with bisques, stuffed shrimp, and calamari appetizers. Filet of sole and shrimp dishes come with rich, spicy cream sauces.

People are saying

"I found the Italian food here to be amazing and authentic."

"The dinner entrees here are amazing, especially the bolognese."

"The seafood here is amazing, especially the shrimp in spicy cream sauce."

Good to know

1

The lunch menu prices are cheaper than the dinner menu prices.

2

The restaurant has a parking lot available for guests.

3

Expect longer wait times for food during busy hours.

05
CaraCara Mexican Grill image 1
Mexican restaurant

Large Mexican restaurant with Frida Kahlo inspired portraits and an inviting bar scene featuring high chairs and booths. Atmosphere is cozy and inviting but can be dimly lit and noisy, suitable for conversations over dinner or appetizers. Known for excellent margaritas and a phenomenal guacamole cart.

Cozy and inviting atmosphere suits both family dinners and casual outings. Great food supports easy conversations over dinner or appetizers.

Shrimp stands out with perfectly cooked texture and flavor. The Pollo and Shrimp Quesadilla and Quesadillas Con Queso with shrimp offer hearty portions that work well as entrรฉes.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and packed with vibrant spices."

"These dinner spots have delicious, flavorful tacos and bold, fresh flavors."

"The Pollo and Shrimp Quesadilla was very good."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available at the bar, offering discounted drinks.

2

Parking is available behind the restaurant, but front parking is often closed.

3

Expect to pay around $13 for two empanadas.

06
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Farmingdale) image 1
Asian fusion restaurant

Asian fusion restaurant offers a beautifully lit and decorated space with private rooms and charming outdoor seating featuring a bubbling fountain. Atmosphere varies from warm and lively to noisy, with occasional loud music and active children. Sushi and sashimi stand out for their freshness and presentation.

Dinner features fresh sashimi served with shredded radish and shiso leaves on ice, alongside dishes like pineapple shrimp and fried rice. Seating is available quickly even during dinner hours.

Rock shrimp stands out as a popular choice, often ordered alongside the TOA roll. Appetizers like tuna tataki and shrimp tempura rolls also feature prominently on the menu.

People are saying

"The food here is so fresh and delicious."

"You have to try their rock shrimp; it's amazing."

"I can't believe they stopped serving the salmon teriyaki for dinner."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

A 20% service charge is automatically added to all bills.

07
The Barnyard image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Cozy space with colorful artwork and comfortable lounge chairs creates a warm, inviting vibe. Live DJ and Caribbean music fill the air, adding vibrant energy. Open kitchen design lets aromas mingle with the lively atmosphere.

Dinners here bring a family-friendly atmosphere with consistently enjoyable meals. The setting suits both couples and groups looking for a relaxed evening.

Seafood dishes feature well-seasoned, soft fish and perfectly cooked shrimp. Highlights include coconut shrimp with mango sauce and shrimp and grits with balanced seasoning.

People are saying

"The food, especially the mac and cheese, was excellent."

"The coconut shrimp with mango sauce did not disappoint."

"The dinner spots here have delicious food and great portions."

Good to know

1

Make reservations as seating space is limited.

2

Brunch on Sunday features a live DJ.

3

Expect long wait times for drinks and orders, especially on busy nights.

08
Vico: Costiera Amalfitana image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space combines cozy intimacy with a lively, bustling atmosphere that can get noisy. Indoor and outdoor seating create a Positano-inspired vibe with fresh herbs nearby. Drinks include espresso martinis and Italian beer, complementing authentic regional Italian dishes.

Dinner here offers a memorable atmosphere with attentive service that enhances the evening. It suits intimate dinners and special occasions well.

Spaghetti with clams varies here, sometimes cooked to perfection with tender clams full of flavor, other times lacking sauce and garlic taste. Fresh-made pasta and amazing fish also feature on the menu.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is delicious and fantastic."

"The dinner spots here make you feel truly welcomed and cared for."

"The seafood here is perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

The family meal special costs $30 and serves four people.

2

Live music is available on select evenings.

3

The Sunday family takeout special is $25, down from $35.

09
Verona Ristorante image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers old world charm with classy yet comfortable ambiance and live music enhancing the experience. Tables come set with wine and linens, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of dining in Italy.

Dinner arrives promptly with a gluten free menu available. The spot suits both regular family dinners and special occasions like memorials and holidays.

Clams paso stands out as a favorite appetizer. Shrimp oreganata offers a succulent bite with perfectly seasoned garlic and breadcrumbs. Fish dishes come out especially excellent.

People are saying

"The food and service here are excellent."

"The pasta here is unique and flavorful, especially the squid linguine."

"The seafood here is cooked to perfection, tender and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for private events to ensure availability.

2

The restaurant can accommodate large groups, making it suitable for events.

3

Parking is convenient for guests attending events.

Discover more

Farmingdale, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...