Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Farmingdale

Italian food spots

Italian cooking that feels like a genuine kitchen effort rather than a mass-produced plate.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bellagio Pizzeria image 1
Bellagio Pizzeria image 2
Bellagio Pizzeria image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant combines cozy atmosphere with modern design featuring concrete floors and metal furniture. Space welcomes families with games like Connect 4 and seating suited for groups. Menu offers halal options and large portions, appealing to diverse tastes.

Halal Italian-American comfort dishes stand out here, offering classic flavors rarely found with halal options. The food is consistently delicious and served with genuine hospitality in a warm, family-owned setting.

Pasta dishes stand out with creamy Vodka sauce and rich flavors. Options like Lobster Ravioli with Asparagus and Shrimp and Rigatoni Florentine offer variety beyond the speciality pizzas.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be so good and amazing."

"The food here is amazing, especially the Chicken Francese."

"It's amazing Italian food because every single item is halal."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers halal options, including halal pepperoni and chicken.

2

Parking is available at the restaurant for customers.

3

Expect a plain slice of pizza to cost around $4.00.

02
Sapori Del Vallo image 1
Grocery store

Small space with wood-fired pizza and fresh baked bread creates a welcoming ambiance filled with authentic Italian atmosphere. Live Italian music and bilingual conversations add lively cultural energy. Offers genuine Italian groceries and simple, unpretentious dining.

Freshly made dishes follow family recipes from Italy, offering authentic Italian cuisine with a small, focused menu. Breads come out fresh and the food tastes like home cooking.

Fresh pasta dishes and wood-fired pizzas come made to order with quality ingredients. The selection includes authentic imported meats, cheese, and olive oil, plus breads and sweets made on site like tiramisu.

People are saying

"The pasta here is made fresh to order by Italians using family recipes."

"The pizza here is made in a wood fire oven, just like in Naples."

"I found the food here to be authentically Italian."

Good to know

1

The store closes at 5:00 PM.

2

All products are from Italy or made on premises.

3

The pizza is offered at a great price.

03
DGM Food Truck image 1
Restaurant

Food truck offers freshly made meals with a clean seating area nearby. Owners run operations personally, ensuring high-quality ingredients and careful service. Menu features standout items like Philly cheesesteaks and shrimp po'boy sandwiches that attract regulars.

Food here is homemade and gourmet, offering satisfying quick meals with fresh preparation. Specials like chopped cheese and dishes such as corned beef and cabbage stand out, served alongside a clean seating area by the truck.

An extensive menu features pastas like penne alla vodka, which arrives ready to finish at home. The chicken pesto panini adds variety beyond traditional Italian dishes.

People are saying

"The food here is so fresh and delicious."

"I loved the food trucks; their chicken parmesan was to die for."

"The Italian food here, especially the heroes, is really good."

Good to know

1

Call ahead to place your order 20-25 minutes in advance.

2

They offer different specials every day.

3

DGM Catering provides soft drinks, water, plates, utensils, and napkins.

04
Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant image 1

Old school Italian restaurant with wood paneling, fireplaces, and brick decor creates a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Live accordion music circulates on weekends, adding an authentic touch. A central bar area complements the warm, welcoming vibe.

Meals feature fried zucchini, stuffed artichoke, chicken francese, and a stuffed veal chop. Food and service both stand out as exceptional and consistently deliver a terrific dining experience.

Entrees feature bolognese sauce with farfalle, a special with chicken, sausage, and artichoke in wine and lemon sauce, and penne with vodka sauce. Grilled salmon comes with vegetables and pasta as sides.

People are saying

"I found the Italian food here to be amazing and authentic."

"The dinner entrees here are amazing, especially the bolognese."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

The lunch menu prices are cheaper than the dinner menu prices.

2

The restaurant has a parking lot available for guests.

3

Expect longer wait times for food during busy hours.

05
Vico: Costiera Amalfitana image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space combines cozy intimacy with a lively, bustling atmosphere that can get noisy. Indoor and outdoor seating create a Positano-inspired vibe with fresh herbs nearby. Drinks include espresso martinis and Italian beer, complementing authentic regional Italian dishes.

Food here tastes like authentic Italian made with fresh, real ingredients. Every dish feels handmade and delivers a delicious, genuine experience.

Fresh pasta and sauces taste like they come straight from Italy. Dishes like Rigatoni ai Funghi and Spaghetti with Clams offer well-balanced, authentic flavors. The pizza, including Pizza 83, and the biscotti stand out as well.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is delicious and fantastic."

"The authentic Italian food tastes like it's straight from Italy."

"The food here is delicious and fantastic."

Good to know

1

The family meal special costs $30 and serves four people.

2

Live music is available on select evenings.

3

The Sunday family takeout special is $25, down from $35.

06
The Empanada Spot image 1

Small restaurant with freshly made empanadas offers a wide variety of flavors and affordable prices. Atmosphere is clean and casual with limited indoor and outdoor seating. Customers often order by phone to avoid third-party fees.

Food arrives hot with crispy fried meals and fresh, flavorful dishes. Portion sizes stay perfect and the Colombian offerings stand out.

Pasta dishes come in various styles including Chicken Scarp Pasta and fried lasagna. The menu also features Fritto Bombs and fried pizza, all noted for their strong flavors.

People are saying

"These empanadas are fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked."

"The pasta dishes were delicious and traveled well for takeout."

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

The empanadas cost $3 each.

2

There is limited free parking on the premises and street parking available.

3

All items are made fresh to order, and they accept phone orders.

07
Tasting Room Kitchen + Cocktails image 1

Cozy space with low lighting and a modern vibe creates an inviting, stylish atmosphere. Guests enjoy a relaxed yet elevated energy suitable for casual or special occasions. Frequented for its unique cocktails and standout dishes, it balances comfort with an upscale feel.

Creative dishes combine great taste with appealing presentation. Cocktails are made perfectly and pair well with a flight of wines that complements the food.

Fresh pasta shines in the Lemon Pesto Pasta with well-blended flavors. The Tri-Color Lasagna and fried lasagna offer rich, standout options.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and exceeded my expectations."

"The Italian food here, especially the tri-colored lasagna, is amazing."

"The food here was delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for busy weekend nights to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant offers a complimentary bottle of wine for birthday celebrations.

3

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

08
Piazzetta of East Farmingdale image 1

Pizza restaurant offers best pizza in Farmingdale with a welcoming atmosphere and super clean environment. The menu includes impressive variety with standout dishes like meatballs and chicken parmesan. Plenty of parking and group accommodations make it convenient for visits.

Food arrives hot and fresh with a solid selection that tastes really good. The dishes consistently deliver amazing flavor and come out on time.

Pasta dishes like veal cutlet Parm over spaghetti, penne a la vodka, and Bolognese stand out for their taste and portion size. The menu also features pizza, lasagna, and shrimp fra diolo, with stuffed rigatoni options including chicken.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"I thought their pizza was delicious and worth every penny."

"The pasta here is so tasty, especially the rigatoni."

Good to know

1

The pizza costs around $60 for four guests.

2

There is plenty of parking available nearby.

3

Reservations are recommended for larger groups.

09
Gino's Of Farmingdale - Pizzeria & Restaurant image 1

Traditional style pizzeria with beautiful interior design and comfortable seating inside and out. Casual, family-style atmosphere with pleasant country music creating a welcoming vibe. Known for exceptional pizza including thin crust options not found nearby.

Food features amazing taste and consistent quality across visits. Service is fast and friendly, enhancing the dining experience.

Fresh pastas stand out with dishes like fettuccine Bolognese and eggplant chicken pasta offering quality and flavor. The menu includes penne ala vodka with a rich sauce, lasagna, and garlic knots, all served in generous portions.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was one of the best I could find."

"I found the food here to be fantastic and amazing."

"I thought the pizza here was the best around."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has plenty of seats inside and outside.

2

There is little to no wait time during most visits.

3

The VIP meal deal provides enough food for at least four people.

10
The Villager Farmingdale image 1

Small indoor space centers on a long bar with multiple TVs and a projector, while outdoor seating shines with a covered tent, string lights, and a lively beer garden. Atmosphere blends pub-like coziness with live music and heated tents in winter, creating a family-friendly vibe. Music volume can be high, making conversation challenging at times.

Food features sweet potato tots with fluff and a menu that leans pricey but offers great late-night options. The dishes come with friendly, efficient service and drink pairings that match well.

Fried mozzarella comes out hot and crispy, served with a vodka sauce. Drunken Fried Chicken features a Parmesan crust, vodka sauce, burrata, prosciutto, pesto emulsion, and arugula on garlic ciabatta.

People are saying

"The burgers here are amazing, perfectly cooked and deliciously cooked."

"The food here, especially the burgers, is cooked perfectly."

"The Italian food here, especially the fried mozzarella, is amazing and hot."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with themed drinks on Witchy Wednesdays.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups, to guarantee a table.

3

The kitchen stays open late, serving food until 2:00 a.m.

11
Verona Ristorante image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers old world charm with classy yet comfortable ambiance and live music enhancing the experience. Tables come set with wine and linens, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of dining in Italy.

Food offers authentic flavors and tastes consistently delicious. Dishes deliver a great balance of quality and freshness.

Classic Italian dishes come with perfectly cooked pasta and unique flavors like squid linguine and penne alla vodka with chicken. Vegan options stand out for their quality and variety, all served with authentic Italian style.

People are saying

"The food and service here are excellent."

"The food here was delicious and met our expectations."

"The Italian food here is outstanding, especially the veal Parmesan."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for private events to ensure availability.

2

The restaurant can accommodate large groups, making it suitable for events.

3

Parking is convenient for guests attending events.

Discover more

Farmingdale, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...