Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Seafood spots in Garden City

Made for those who prioritize sourcing their meals directly from the water and won't compromise on the origin of their seafood.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Plancha image 1
Plancha image 2
Plancha image 3
View all
Tapas bar

Small, intimate tapas bar offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with rustic decor and an open kitchen. Seafood lovers enjoy garlic shrimp and octopus paired with flavorful sides. Chill vibe and great playlist make it perfect for relaxed evenings or date nights.

Garlic shrimp stands out as a favorite dish, paired often with boquerones and a Spanish Board featuring tapas like Pan con Boquerรณn, Patatas bravas, and octopus. Other seafood highlights include shrimp polenta and octopus, served alongside flavorful sides.

People are saying

"The wine selection here is massive and spectacular."

"The tapas and small plates here are perfect for sharing."

"The garlic shrimp and boquerones are unforgettable seafood."

Good to know

1

They offer free parking, which makes the experience more convenient.

2

The menu at Plancha changes often, so check it before you go.

3

They offered a happy hour before 6pm with good wines at decent prices.

02
Tony's Tacos Garden City image 1

Bright, spacious spot offers experimental tacos with standout shrimp mango and salmon options. Strong, delicious margaritas complement the fresh seafood. Welcoming vibe suits dates and groups, with clean, appealing decor enhancing the fun atmosphere.

Shrimp tacos come in several varieties like fire shrimp and shrimp mango, both packed with flavor. Other seafood options include salmon tacos and cod tacos, all served quickly and tasty from start to finish.

People are saying

"I found the tacos to be amazing and freshly made."

"This casual spot has terrific, high-quality ingredients."

"The seafood tacos were pretty tasty and of good quality."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with $5 drinks.

2

On Tuesdays, margaritas cost $5, but not the $2 at other locations.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere during happy hour, especially on Wednesdays.

03
Nomiya image 1
Japanese restaurant

Small Japanese spot shines with rock shrimp tempura and fresh seafood dishes. Striking oakwood decor creates a calm, elevated vibe. Bar offers Japanese whiskey and craft cocktails, while outdoor seating and karaoke add casual fun.

Rock shrimp tempura stands out as a favorite, often praised for its flavor and freshness. Japanese-style fish and chips and shrimp teriyaki offer tasty options with fresh fish and shrimp.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"Paola's service made the Japanese food experience feel truly welcome."

"The seafood, especially the shrimp tempura, was incredible."

Good to know

1

Happy hour at Nomiya is from Monday to Friday, 4-7 pm.

2

You must sit at the bar area to order from the happy hour menu.

3

Most dips are very spicy, especially the 'hot oil' dip.

04
bartaco image 1
Taco restaurant

Enjoy crunchy fish tacos with bold chile-lime shrimp and ahi tuna tatako. Relax in a beach vibe setting with stylish decor and lively tropical energy. Sip on margaritas and tropical cocktails that perfectly complement the fresh seafood flavors.

Shrimp and cod ceviche come with fresh guacamole and salsa. Fish tacos stand out for their crunchiness and bold flavors like chile-lime shrimp and ahi tuna tatako.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be excellent and delicious."

"The Mexican food here, especially the tacos, has unique and amazing flavors."

"The shrimp and fish tacos were fantastic and left you wanting more."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

The kids menu features affordable options suitable for children.

3

Online orders can be picked up at the restaurant without waiting.

05
Sushi Ya image 1
Restaurant

Fresh sushi shines with garlic notes boosting flavor. Affordable prices and a clean, relaxing atmosphere make it great for groups. Outdoor seating offers a comfortable family option with inviting music.

Fresh fish stands out with garlic notes enhancing the flavor in the rolls. The seafood consistently tastes delicious and amazing.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here, especially the sushi, is the best I've ever had."

"I found this spot to be a nice lunch spot."

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Sushi Ya charges a non-cash fee for credit card payments.

2

The lunch special offers great value for money.

3

There is plenty of parking available in the back.

06
Poke Frisรฉe image 1

Bright, clean space with a cozy vibe serves fresh poke bowls featuring high quality fish and shrimp tempura made fresh. Offers a huge variety of add-ons and sauces for a healthy, flavorful meal.

Freshness stands out with high quality fish served. The shrimp tempura is made right in front of you, and the ahi tuna poke offers a tasty option even for those who usually avoid raw fish.

People are saying

"The poke here is so fresh and flavorful, I loved it."

"The seafood portions here are super generous for the price."

"The customer service at these Date Spots is so friendly."

Good to know

1

Prices for poke bowls start around $10, with additional charges for toppings.

2

Portion sizes are generally generous, but some customers report smaller servings over time.

3

The restaurant has no air conditioning, which can make it hot while waiting.

07
DJ's International Buffet image 1
Buffet restaurant

Buffet offers large sushi bar and seafood Cajun boil with crab legs and abalone. Dining feels crowded and noisy with close tables and loud celebrations. Decor is old and worn, showing signs of wear and lack of cleanliness.

Seafood options include crab legs, sushi, and a seafood Cajun boil. Both raw and cooked dishes like octopus, coconut shrimp, and steamed flounder appear alongside unique items like abalone and conche.

People are saying

"The sushi and sashimi here are so decent and flavorful."

"I experienced one of the best buffets I have ever had."

"The seafood selection here is mind-blowing, with options like crab legs and oysters."

Good to know

1

The buffet opens at 11:30 AM and closes at 11:00 PM.

2

They start removing food at 9:30 PM, so arrive early.

3

Lunch costs $29 for all-you-can-eat, which is reasonable.

08
Primehouse image 1
Steak house

Steak house blends prime rib with fresh seafood like lobster risotto and perfectly cooked shrimp. Upscale yet warm, it suits romantic dinners and social gatherings. Enjoy a notable cocktail selection in a serene, welcoming space.

Shrimp comes out cooked perfectly and oysters feature in the surf and turf special. Lobster risotto offers a fresh seafood taste with tender lobster, alongside sushi and fish specials.

People are saying

"The desserts here are delicious and cooked perfectly."

"You've got to try the marinated skirt steak; it's great."

"The seafood here is delicious and beautifully presented."

Good to know

1

A service fee is charged for parties of two.

2

Reservations have a two-hour time limit.

3

Dress code ranges from casual to dressy.

09
Kyuramen x TBAAR - Garden City image 1
Authentic Japanese restaurant

Intimate booths with curtains offer private dining in a cozy, beautiful setting. Crispy shrimp tempura and unique fried oysters highlight the seafood menu. Guests enjoy authentic ramen paired with Japanese drinks like soju and sake.

Shrimp tempura stands out with its crispy texture and frequent presence on the menu. Fried oysters offer a unique twist, while fried potato shrimp serves as a solid appetizer option.

People are saying

"I loved the flavorful Japanese food, especially the ramen and takoyaki."

"The ramen here is so flavorful and delicious."

"The shrimp tempura here is amazing and crispy."

Good to know

1

Happy hour discounts on drinks and appetizers are available, making it a great time to visit.

2

Lunch specials are offered alongside happy hour deals.

3

The restaurant accommodates large parties, making it family-friendly.

10
King Bar by David Burke image 1

Dark wood and mood lighting set a swanky atmosphere perfect for relaxed evenings. Fresh oysters and surf and turf options highlight the seafood menu despite some service delays. Great cocktails and knowledgeable service complete the classy, welcoming vibe.

Fresh oysters come with some service delays, arriving in two parts. The menu features surf and turf, including lamb chops and fish dishes.

People are saying

"The Classy food, like the octopus and risotto, is always prepared wonderfully."

"The Hotel staff here always makes you feel so welcome."

"The Seafood here is amazing, and the staff are so attentive."

Good to know

1

Dress code requires no sandals; business casual is preferred.

2

Coat check is mandatory, but staff presence may be inconsistent.

3

Expect limited appetizer options on the menu.

Discover more

Garden City, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...