Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Lake Grove

Jewelry stores

Made for those who refuse to settle for mass-produced accessories and demand pieces with a distinct, personal signature.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Jared Jewelers image 1
Jared Jewelers image 2
Jared Jewelers image 3
View all
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers a comfortable setting with expert help on engagement rings. Staff provide personalized service and next-day ring sizing. Enjoy free food and drinks while getting repairs, resizing, and cleaning for sparkling jewelry.

Engagement rings get special attention, with expert help from CJ. Services include repairs, resizing, and cleaning that keep jewelry sparkling and well-maintained.

People are saying

"CJ was so helpful picking out my perfect engagement ring."

"The staff at this jewelry store is so patient and helpful."

"CJ was so patient helping me find the perfect watch."

Good to know

1

The store closes at 7 pm, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Ask for CJ or Gloria for expert assistance with engagement rings.

3

Jared Jewelers offers a lifetime warranty for jewelry repairs.

02
KAY Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Welcoming store offers stunning jewelry and engagement rings that catch the eye. Staff provide personalized service and expert help with repairs and cleaning. Tools for jewelry care and magnification are top-notch, ensuring pieces stay flawless.

Helpful and informative staff assist with finding engagement rings, earrings, necklaces, and other jewelry. Regular services include ring cleaning and repairs to keep pieces in good condition.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are super friendly and helpful."

"The Ring Store team helped me find my dream ring."

"The staff at this Mall location were so pleasant and nice."

Good to know

1

The selection of engagement rings is extensive and varied.

2

Personalized service is available upon request.

3

The store offers jewelry servicing with a good reputation.

03
Gabriel Alexander Jewelers image 1

Offers personalized service with competitive pricing on high-quality 14k pieces. Staff like Lina, Jade, and Julianna provide clear explanations and help find the right jewelry. Atmosphere feels welcoming with great deals on beautiful items.

Beautiful jewelry with knowledgeable staff like Lina, Jade, and Julianna who help find the right pieces. Offers good prices and great deals on a variety of items.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store offer personalized service and great value."

"You'll get personalized service at this necklace store, especially from Juliana and Jade."

Good to know

1

The store provides personalized service and offers the best value.

2

Juliana and Jade offer prices that beat other stores significantly.

3

Expect great deals on jewelry with competitive pricing.

04
Lovisa image 1
Jewelry store

Bright, clean space offers tarnish-free earrings with clear pricing. Quick, painless ear piercing service is supported by professional staff. Helpful aftercare options ensure easy healing and earring changes.

Clean, organized store offers a beautiful selection of jewelry with tarnish-free earrings priced at 3 pairs for $25. Staff explain the ear piercing process clearly and provide options for changing earrings after healing.

People are saying

"It's so Kid Friendly; they made my daughter feel comfortable and smiling."

"Sadie made the piercing experience so comfortable and friendly."

"Kristen at this jewelry store made my piercing experience comfortable and easy."

Good to know

1

The store offers a quick and painless ear piercing process.

2

Earrings are available at 3 pairs for $25, and they are tarnish-free.

3

An aftercare spray is available for $15, promoting healing in a month or less.

05
Banter by Piercing Pagoda image 1

Relaxed atmosphere and quick piercing ease nerves. Staff like Tyler and Madison offer expert advice on gold and silver pieces. Enjoy promotional deals and clear aftercare instructions for easy healing.

Staff like Tyler, Madison, and Malaika offer helpful and patient service when picking out jewelry. They provide expert piercing and jewelry advice, making it easy to find the right earrings that heal well.

People are saying

"The staff here are so patient and sweet with kids."

"They made me feel so comfortable and calm."

"Nicole was so encouraging and patient with my ear piercing at the Jewelry Store."

Good to know

1

The piercing procedure is quick and generally painless.

2

Aftercare instructions are provided after the piercing.

3

A follow-up appointment is available for aftercare support.

06
Ethan Jordan Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store shines with an amazing selection of gold earrings and kids bracelets. Staff offers friendly service and negotiates prices well. Customers enjoy respectable deals that beat big-name retailers.

An amazing jewelry selection offers a wide range of pieces including gold earrings and kids bracelets. Prices stay competitive while service remains stellar and personalized.

People are saying

"Steve and Amanda helped me find the perfect engagement ring."

"The staff at this jewelry store is so patient and helpful."

Good to know

1

The jewelry selection is amazing with great prices for engagement rings.

2

The total cost for two sterling silver chains and rush service was only a couple hundred dollars.

3

Be cautious when buying engagement rings, as there is a risk of being scammed.

07
Zales image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store shines with personalized assistance from staff like Christine and Wafa. Offers beautiful jewelry and matching sets for special occasions. Occasional discounts make shopping more appealing despite mixed experiences.

Staff like Christine and Wafa provide personalized assistance in selecting engagement rings and matching jewelry sets. The store offers a range of beautiful jewelry pieces suitable for various occasions.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are incredibly helpful and knowledgeable."

"Christine made my jewelry shopping experience amazing and comforting."

"Valerie helped me find the perfect watch."

Good to know

1

Repair charges can be around $60, plus additional fees for services not requested.

2

Discounts of 10% may be available at times.

3

The online store offers pocket watches at 25% off.

Discover more

Lake Grove, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...