Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Montauk

Quiet hotels

You need a hotel where the silence is as much a part of the stay as the bed.

Based on 505 Opinions
+502
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Sunset Montauk image 1
Sunset Montauk image 2
Sunset Montauk image 3
View all

Clean white interiors and immaculate rooms create a cozy, peaceful atmosphere. Outdoor spaces feature lawn games, fire pits, and ample seating, fostering a relaxed, community vibe. Quiet location near the ocean offers easy access to beaches and bike rides around town.

Rooms stay quiet and clean, tucked away from busy areas. The location feels peaceful and far from the hustle.

Rooms feel modern and very clean with a resort-like vibe. Location stays quiet and off the main path, and check-in is efficient with clear info on amenities and nearby spots.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful, making it comfortable."

"The hotel staff was so welcoming and friendly."

"The staff here is so friendly and accommodating."

Good to know

1

The hotel is just a two-minute walk from the beach.

2

Check-in is easy and straightforward.

3

Bicycles are available for quick rides to nearby attractions.

02
Daunt's Albatross Motel image 1

Courtyard features fire pits lit every evening and a clean, inviting pool with plenty of seating. Rooms blend coastal decor with comfortable beds and thoughtful touches like igloos and kitchenettes. Location sits just blocks from beach and downtown, creating a laid-back, relaxed vibe with peaceful common areas.

Rooms stay quiet with minimal noise. Guests keep a friendly and quiet atmosphere throughout the stay.

A family-run motel near the beach offers a friendly, attentive team always ready to help. Guests enjoy a BBQ area, close walk to the beach and town center, plus vouchers for a nearby restaurant.

People are saying

"The beds here are super comfy and you'll sleep well."

"The Hotel staff was so friendly and welcoming during my stay."

"It's the perfect quiet spot, steps from the main street."

Good to know

1

The motel is dog-friendly, allowing pets during your stay.

2

It's just a short walk to the beach, making it convenient for beachgoers.

3

The motel is located near downtown Montauk, close to shops and restaurants.

03
Offshore Montauk image 1

Oceanfront hotel offers modern, elegant rooms with spectacular views and high-end finishes. The atmosphere is calming and inspiring, blending classic and modern beach vibes. Amenities include a quiet pool area, wellness facilities like sauna and cold plunge, and free beach service with chairs and towels.

Offers beach chairs and towels, a rare amenity in the area. Location is central but peaceful with easy access to attractions. Provides everything needed for a beach-front stay with great views and seasonal rates.

People are saying

"This hotel's location right by the water is stunning."

"The luxurious rooms are beautifully designed with high-end finishes."

"The rooms are modern, warm, and spotless."

Good to know

1

Check-in is simple with a door code sent prior to arrival.

2

Expect to pay over $2000 a night on Saturdays in July.

3

The hotel ran out of beach chairs on July 4th.

04
Aqualina Inn Montauk image 1

Modern hotel offers heated salt water pool and well-kept outdoor spaces with balconies and patios for relaxing. Quiet atmosphere in the evenings complements clean, updated rooms with spacious layouts. Location provides easy access to beach and town, all within walking distance.

Rooms stay quiet in the evening with immaculately clean spaces. Outdoor areas are well kept and add to the relaxing atmosphere.

Rooms stay very clean with well kept outdoor spaces. The hotel sits walking distance to the beach and town, offering chairs, umbrellas, and beach towels for guests.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is perfect, walking distance to the beach and town."

"It's just steps to the beach and the main strip."

"It's quiet and relaxing here."

Good to know

1

The beach is right across the street from the hotel.

2

The location is a 45-second walk into town.

3

Beach towels, chairs, and umbrellas are included with the stay.

05
Kenny's Tipperary Inn image 1

Motel offers spacious, clean rooms with an ocean-themed decor and modern upgrades alongside vintage charm. Grounds feature a heated pool, meditation lounge, and beautifully maintained outdoor spaces with plants and fountains. Atmosphere stays quiet and relaxing, even at full capacity, with a cozy, welcoming vibe.

Grounds stay quiet and relaxing even at full capacity. Rooms are clean, spacious, and quiet, making evenings peaceful.

Rooms are very large and spotlessly clean. Location sits within walking distance to the beach, harbor, and many restaurants, right across from the boatyard.

People are saying

"The hotel staff were so nice and accommodating."

"This place is extremely dog friendly; my dog made friends."

"The inn was quiet and relaxing during my visit."

Good to know

1

The rooms are clean and spacious, with fresh linen and towels provided daily.

2

The location is ideal, within walking distance to the harbor and restaurants.

3

Pets are allowed, making it a great option for dog owners.

06
Montauk Blue Hotel image 1

Hotel offers spectacular ocean views with large private balconies right on the beach. Atmosphere ranges from calming sea breeze and waves to occasional noise from long-term guests. Amenities include heated indoor pool and hot tub, plus convenient beach chair and umbrella service.

Rooms stay quiet every night even when fully occupied. Guests keep a friendly and calm atmosphere throughout the hotel.

Rooms offer amazing ocean views right on the beach. Location sits within walking distance to town, restaurants, and shops, making it easy to explore.

People are saying

"The Hotel staff went above and beyond to make our stay special."

"You can walk directly onto the beach from here."

"It was a quiet stay, even when the hotel was full."

Good to know

1

The hotel is right on the beach, providing easy access to the ocean.

2

Rooms are clean and well-maintained, ensuring a comfortable stay.

3

The hotel is within walking distance to restaurants and shops.

07
Montauk Manor image 1

Hotel offers gorgeous views and spacious rooms with unique layouts. Grounds resemble a luxury Caribbean resort with meticulously maintained landscapes. Lobby features a fireplace creating a cozy, inviting atmosphere.

Beautiful, secluded, and quiet property offers a mature atmosphere. Shuttle service provides easy access around town, excluding Gurney's.

A stunning, classy, and timeless hotel with flawless amenities like tennis courts and pools. The on-site restaurant and bar add convenience, and the staff, including the manager, provide helpful support.

People are saying

"This historic hotel is beautiful and the rooms are clean."

"The scenic views from the room were amazing."

"It's so quiet and secluded, you'll love the privacy."

Good to know

1

Murder Mystery weekends are popular and require advance reservations.

2

Oktoberfest events feature fireworks and are held annually.

3

Dinner service is available after obtaining a liquor license.

08
Wavecrest Resort image 1
Resort hotel

Oceanfront setting offers breathtaking views and a quiet, peaceful beach with no busy roads nearby. The atmosphere stays relaxed and tranquil, with complimentary lounges and umbrellas enhancing comfort. Fire pits and an onsite food truck add unique touches to the experience.

A private beach offers a quiet stretch ideal for relaxing. The resort stays comfortable and calm, close enough to town but still feeling private.

Located right on the beach with no busy road to cross, the resort offers complimentary lounges and best views and sounds of the ocean. It maintains a very clean environment and accommodates various needs, making it suitable for families and those camping nearby.

People are saying

"I loved the stunning ocean views from my room."

"This hotel's beach views are stunning, with whales and dolphins often visible."

"It's so quiet here, right on the beach away from crowds."

Good to know

1

Wavecrest offers complimentary umbrellas and lounges for guests.

2

The resort is located on a secluded section of beach adjacent to a state park.

3

The rooms are clean and comfortable with stunning ocean views.

09
Breakers Montauk image 1

Retro motel converted into a quasi high-end spot with spectacular beach views and quiet, peaceful vibe. Guests relax by a clean, inviting pool and enjoy free bike rentals while being just steps from the beach and town. Balconies add charm, and a bonfire area enhances the outdoor experience.

Cabins offer quiet seclusion with a peaceful vibe. Ideal for those seeking peace and quiet before heading out.

Close proximity to the beach and downtown stands out. The hotel offers a clean, peaceful atmosphere with complimentary amenities like water and shower gel. A retro motel converted into a boutique spot adds unique charm.

People are saying

"It's just steps from the beach, super convenient."

"This hotel is perfectly placed right across from the beach."

"It's so quiet, perfect for a little peace before going out."

Good to know

1

The hotel is right across from the beach, just a short walk into a trail leading to the beach.

2

Parking can be challenging, especially if your room is on the far side.

3

The property is within walking distance to the beach and downtown.

10
Marram image 1
Hotel

Oceanfront setting offers stunning views and quiet, serene atmosphere with cozy secluded spots for relaxation. Heated pool near the beach and fire pits with complimentary s'mores create a relaxing outdoor experience. Yoga sessions and bicycle rentals add to the calm, retreat-like vibe.

Quiet and serene atmosphere lets you enjoy the peacefulness of waves crashing on the beach. Rooms can be assigned for quiet sleep, making it a relaxing getaway spot.

Design impresses with its perfect execution and attention to detail. Staff provide a warm welcome that stands out. Amenities include morning yoga and free bicycle rentals.

People are saying

"It's a truly relaxing spot, quiet and in harmony with nature."

"The hotel staff here felt like family, so welcoming and kind."

"It's a quiet, serene atmosphere perfect for a getaway."

Good to know

1

The resort charges a daily resort fee of $182.60 per accommodation.

2

The hotel offers daily activities like yoga and creative workshops.

3

Nightly bonfires with s'mores are hosted for guests.

Discover more

Montauk, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...