Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Bay Ridge's best

Bakeries

A bakery that treats every pastry as a fresh, individual creation rather than a stale, mass-produced item.

Based on 469 Opinions
+466
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Al Reef Bakery and Restaurant image 1
Al Reef Bakery and Restaurant image 2
Al Reef Bakery and Restaurant image 3
View all

Halal restaurant offers a warm vibe with fresh bread and delicious falafel. Pastries are fresh and tasty, perfect for breakfast or takeout. Bakery items shine with solid quality and satisfying flavors at very affordable prices.

Pastries come out delicious and fresh. Options include breakfast pastries and bread available for takeout.

Great bakery items stand out with fresh flavors and solid quality. Breakfast options offer a satisfying start with a variety of choices.

People are saying

"The bakery's fresh bread is warm, soft, and made in-house."

"The pastry here is friendly and attentive."

"The bakery items are just as delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers breakfast, lunch, dinner, pastries, and bread for takeout.

2

Prices are very fair and affordable for all menu items.

3

The bakery is known for its friendly and kind staff.

02
Healing Bean Cafe | Arts and Coffee image 1
Healing Bean Cafe | Arts and Coffee image 2
Healing Bean Cafe | Arts and Coffee image 3
View all

Enjoy fresh pastries and delicious bakery items that pair perfectly with coffee or iced coffee. The space feels magical and charming with larger-than-life flowers and cozy seating for work or chat. Free Wi-Fi and a small flower shop add to the unique vibe.

Pastries come fresh and tasty, pairing well with coffee and iced coffee options. The selection includes a variety of desserts that complement the drinks nicely.

Fresh, delicious bakery items pair well with the coffee. The bakery section offers a nice variety of great drinks and baked goods.

People are saying

"The pastries here are fresh out of the oven and amazing."

"The pastries are fresh and taste amazing."

"I love the coffee and pastries here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for private events, so check in advance.

2

Expect a loud atmosphere; bring headphones if you prefer quiet.

3

Wi-Fi is available but may be unreliable.

03
Brooklyn Baklava image 1
Brooklyn Baklava image 2
Brooklyn Baklava image 3
View all

Bakery offers a wide assortment of baklava and Turkish delight with fresh, aromatic smells. Friendly staff serve homemade-style Lebanese American dishes in a family-run setting. Exceptional pistachio baklava highlights traditional ingredients without shortcuts.

Baklava stands out with its rich nuts and delicate pastry. The pastries offer a variety of flavors and a fresh, aromatic smell that excites those familiar with Middle Eastern treats.

Offers a wide assortment of baklava, Turkish delight, and kunafa. Known for its diverse and interesting bakery selections.

People are saying

"These Middle Eastern pastries are the best I've ever had."

"These pastries are the best Middle Eastern treats around."

"These Middle Eastern pastries from the bakery are the best."

Good to know

1

You should pre-order the knafeh to ensure availability.

2

The prices for the pastries are very reasonable given their high quality.

3

They charge a credit card fee for transactions.

04
Bay Ridge Bakery image 1
Bay Ridge Bakery image 2
Bay Ridge Bakery image 3
View all

Greek-themed bakery shines with fresh pastries like bougatsa and cannolis. Gluten-free and halal options add variety. Staff offers custom cakes with precise lettering in a clean environment. Prices range from moderate to high but match the quality.

Fresh pastries include Greek and Italian American varieties with cannolis among the options. Quality remains consistently good across cakes, cookies, and other pastries.

Clean environment and delicious baked goods stand out here. Custom cakes come with on-the-spot lettering to ensure accuracy, and the staff is consistently attentive and helpful.

People are saying

"The owners and staff at this bakery are so kind and welcoming."

"I love the bakery’s vibe and tasty treats."

"The owners put so much heart into their pastries; you can taste the care."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers numerous baked goods regardless of reason or season.

2

The selection of cookies includes pignoli, rainbow, biscotti, and shortbread cookies.

3

One piece of galaktobouriko is normally priced at $4; a triangle is $5.

05
Mandato Bakery image 1
Mandato Bakery image 2
Mandato Bakery image 3
View all

Bakery shines with freshly baked pastries like conchas and croissants, offering a quiet, heavenly atmosphere perfect for relaxing. Breakfast tacos feature soft, tasty bread and fresh flavors. Small seating with benches invites guests to enjoy sweet treats in a clean, inviting space.

Pastries come out freshly baked with a well-balanced sweetness and butteriness. Mexican classics like conchas and pan de canela sit alongside croissants that rival fancier bakeries.

Breakfast tacos stand out with fresh, delicious flavors and soft, tasty bread. The bakery offers a variety of sweet treats and cakes in a clean, hygienic setting.

People are saying

"It's the best Mexican bakery around here."

"You have to try this pastry; it was asked about multiple times."

"I considered this the best Mexican bakery in NYC."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers real Mexican bakery items and a variety of breads.

2

Tortilla chips are gluten-free unless flour tortillas are requested.

3

Prices are affordable, but pickup orders may cost more than shelf prices.

06
Maison De Viennoiserie image 1
Maison De Viennoiserie image 2
Maison De Viennoiserie image 3
View all

Bakery offers cozy seating with both indoor and outdoor options and fast Wi-Fi suitable for remote work. Loud early 2000s Rotana music plays, creating a lively but noisy atmosphere. Pastries range from high-quality French-style to some less refined items, attracting a mostly Arab/Berber clientele.

Authentic French pastries include beautifully presented tarts, éclairs, and mille-feuille called Napoleon. Pastries are fresh, properly crispy, and offer a variety that includes an unbelievable apple pastry.

Authentic French pastries stand out with consistent quality and appealing presentation. The bakery pairs these with well-crafted coffee in a cozy setting that invites relaxed family visits.

People are saying

"These French pastries are so authentic and delicious."

"I love how fresh and tasty the pastries are."

"I found the bakery's French pastries to be the best around."

Good to know

1

Customers must order a drink and dessert to sit at the restaurant.

2

The place closes at 8:35 PM.

3

Prices are reasonable and more affordable than most spots in Brooklyn.

07
Paneantico Bakery Cafe Inc image 1
Paneantico Bakery Cafe Inc image 2
Paneantico Bakery Cafe Inc image 3
View all

Brick oven baking fills the air with an irresistible aroma around a bustling space featuring pretty tile work and a top notch coffee bar. Locals pack the cafe day and night, creating a warm neighborhood vibe with outdoor dining and wait service that invites lingering.

Offers a wide range of traditional Italian-American pastries that are fresh and tasty. The selection includes Sicilian pastries, breads, and desserts, all known for their quality and flavor.

Extensive deli cases showcase Italian breads, Sicilian pastries, and bakery items that capture the feel of old-style Brooklyn bakeries. This spot offers a nostalgic experience with a wide range of Italian salads and hot foods alongside its baked goods.

People are saying

"The bakery has a cozy vibe with tasty treats."

"I love how fresh and varied the pastries are."

"I loved their chocolate bread and many of their pastries."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 9 PM according to the information provided.

2

This bakery does NOT offer self seating; it has table service only.

3

Paneantico offers a variety of options including coffee, tea, pastries, cake, and sandwiches.

08
Omonia Cafe image 1
Omonia Cafe image 2
Omonia Cafe image 3
View all

Cafe offers spacious seating inside and in a beautiful outdoor patio with trees and vines overhead. Atmosphere feels relaxed and cozy with a Greek vibe, suitable for both romantic and family visits. Music and energy vary, creating a lively yet comfortable environment.

Offers a rich variety of pastries blending traditional and modern flavors. Pastries stay fresh and pair well with coffee like cappuccino.

Wide variety of sweets, pastries, cookies, cakes, and baklava fills the bakery counter. The berry berry napoleon cake tastes close to a well-known bakery version. A warm and cozy bakery-diner style atmosphere adds to the experience.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be exceptional and delicious."

"The pastries are fresh and tasty with lots of choices."

"The pastries taste amazing with a perfect mix of flavors."

Good to know

1

Breakfast starts at 9:30am, but the restaurant opens at 8am.

2

Customers pay extra for potatoes with their meals.

3

The place is family-friendly, so you can bring the kids.

09
II Fornaretto Bakery image 1
II Fornaretto Bakery image 2
II Fornaretto Bakery image 3
View all

Modern bakery with attractively displayed goods and a welcoming atmosphere. Offers hard crusted bread and traditional French and Brick Oven loaves that stand out locally. Maintains a clean, renovated space that invites quick snacks or breakfast.

Freshness stands out with fresh and delicious pastries including Pazki and donuts. The selection is limited but very good, featuring amazing bread, rolls, and cookies.

Breads feature hard crusts and include French and Brick Oven loaves that recall traditional styles. Donuts and cookies stand out, and the bakery offers pleasant service with a modern, clean look and attractive displays.

People are saying

"The bread at this bakery is the best I've ever had."

"I've loved this bakery and its bread for years."

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery is under new ownership and has changed its name to Il Fornaretto.

2

You have to come in early to get the breads and rolls, as they usually sell out quickly.

3

The price of a donut is $5.

Discover more

Bay Ridge, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...